Remove Zambia out of your nonsense...were have you seen a Zambian selling in the streets of Namibia? You want to be relevant with false information

@tkasiam8322 If you moved from Gauteng to KZN/Western Cape you would also be concerned about what happens where you live. Zimbabweans on ZEP permits are affected by decisions made by the Home Affairs that's why people like Mabhena are commenting.

They just want to be legal.You want illegal armed robbery?.

It’s so nauseating 🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮

​@@yllabis yebaba don't take Malema stupid talking points and think u doing something! U are a foreigner there is a big difference between u and a south African moving around south Africa! We won't entertain stupid points like that one ! Why don't u go to Europe and say that stupid thing u have just say and see how they will treat u ?! U Pan-Africans u love lawlessness when it benefits u

Zimbabwe it will be fine dear watch the space t goes around comes round what goes up must come down

@kikipula7967 This is not an emotional things it is 's logical thing. The Home Affairs has given Zimbabweans permits since 2010 also the holders of these permits have been getting less and less. When the project started in 2010 it was called DZP. Then is was renewed and called ZSP and now it was called ZEP. DZP project issued 250 000 permits the ZEP issued 178 000. I'm sure if they renewed there would be less than 100 000 as some Zimbabweans had retired and returned to Zimbabwe have died or moved to other interested especially the UK(England). The point is continuing to renew these visa's is not working for anyone. Its doesn't work for South Africa and well as the Zimbabwean. The Minister is wasting money in court when the solution is very simple. Giving permanent residence to 100 000 Zimbabweans is the only logical solution. This number is less than 1% of total population of South Africa.

It's a person's choice you can also pray for Zimbabwe it will be your own choice.

I'm agree with you kikipupule

Zimbabweans have their own country y do they want to be citizens of another country if their country is not at war

🤣🤣🤣🤣

Mabhena does not have a critical skill, he is a spokesperson of a union of domestic workers who are zimbos so when they leave he should leave cause he won't be having any constituency😂

He must also state what value he himself adds to south africa

⁠@@user-nc4jp9xe1e😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 very interesting

Gqiii didn't the ZEP states that you'll be excluded from qualifying for Permanent Residency 😂....ningazodlala la....blood was shed for this freedom of ours nina nifuna ukuphakelwa on a silver platter....South Africans are unemployed..ama truck drivers used to be a Low skill job which used to feed thousands of disadvantage kids from as far as rural places,manje seyigcele abantu bangaphandle without scare skills ningadlali ngo Buntu bama South Africans nizozisola. Fight and make Change in your Countries and pave way for your future generations ayi nigcale wonke lomhlaba ...our leaders when exile kuma Refugee Camps...to strategies fighting for their country and not other people s entitlements because siyashayiwa...Thina Amabhunu were worse than Zanu Pf but we stayed in out townships and fought....ayi silwe nabantu abasiphe ubuntu....shame guyz.

So you were never in any danger and could always go home

Very true . I alone i know more tha 50 ZEP holders who are now in Europe . So that close to 180 000 number is not valid anymore,, thousands have migrated to other countries across the world

We had a better working economy before you started riding crocodiles coming to our country.

Can't you c south Africans are bizzy solving their problems you're bizzy telling them to give you permanent zep

We will resist as South Africans, go fight for your country

We're done with these cowards

We are busy with GNU, by elections and bona ba mo ka ZEP, ekare dintja that's how selfish and ungrateful

Pray for your Country to be functional and leave our Country

You guys are leaving and SOON.

Theres no better place like home

If SA is causing you to live upside down am sure u know where yo own country is located

They are so entitled and annoying. Theres no war in their country but they are hell bent on fighting our government for their selfish cowardies needs. Such a hopeless and ungrateful nation.

Yes vele that is true

Also a lot passed away ,I know almost over 10 people holder of ZEP passed away

What do you mean by assets to SA😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

Tell me one thing that a Zimbabwean can do that cannot be done by a South African, so we can see how special they are...

Zep holders they don't contribute anything they can even start a decent business, except selling tomatoes and potatoes on the street of south Africa. South African gives them a job Free education Free grant Free medical service Free school Free food They don't do anything they just keeps taking claiming the is a hunger in Zim please wake up Zim people now how to use us.

Thank you for that powerful message I thank you

Remember Zimbabwe is not for a person also you, you can be a Zimbabwean if you choose so.

Then South Africa must seize Zimbabwe's land and incorporate it. As South Africans we hate seeing Zimbabweans fighting our government more than they fight Mnangangwa

South Africans are also scattered abroad

No one was created to stick at one place the earth is for God why can't you ask Helen zille to go where they come from Europe

​@@LeeIELTSCoach hie coach l need your help

And they are now boring🚮🚮🚮

Good Question.

They are so selfish these people. Imagine we are busy trying to settle in a new government and bona ba mo ba busy ka ZEP and court cases ekare dintja!!!

Thank you boss, you raise some valid and important questions and concerns. As a Zimbabwean ZEP holder, I would like to address each of your points thoughtfully. Escape During War or Natural Disaster: The idea that people could easily escape to another country in the event of war or a natural disaster is not as simple as it may seem. Relocating involves numerous challenges, including financial constraints, bureaucratic processes, and the emotional toll of leaving one's home and community behind. Moreover, international laws and border regulations must be respected. Living in Two Countries: Permanent residence in South Africa means that I have committed to making South Africa my primary home, working, paying taxes, and contributing to the South African economy as we have always did without the PR status. While I may maintain cultural and familial ties to Zimbabwe, my primary residence and obligations would be in South Africa. Economic Concerns and Population Growth: The South African economy, like many others, faces challenges, and it is natural to be concerned about job scarcity and population growth. However, immigrants often contribute positively to the economy by bringing skills, starting businesses, and filling gaps in the labor market. Many ZEP holders are productive members of society who help drive economic activity and create employment. Loyalty to Country: Loyalty is not a zero-sum game. Many of us feel a deep sense of loyalty and gratitude to South Africa for providing opportunities and safety. At the same time, we hold a natural connection to our heritage and homeland. This dual sense of belonging enriches our contributions to both countries. Frequent Visits to Zimbabwe: Visiting Zimbabwe occasionally is a way to maintain family ties and cultural connections, much like any expatriate community around the world. It does not diminish our commitment to South Africa. Instead, it fosters a broader perspective and often strengthens our resolve to contribute positively to our host country. Role of ZEP Holders: ZEP holders are individuals who have sought refuge and opportunities in South Africa due to economic and political challenges in Zimbabwe. Many have integrated into South African society, working hard and contributing to the community. We seek to build a future here, support our families, and uphold the values of respect, hard work, and community. We are not in your beautiful country to bring your nation down, or burn your nation to ashes, NO.!! We seek refuge, and we can't afford to make SA suffer, because we suffer more if that so happens. At the end of the day, South Africa did not come what it became today by itself, neighbouring countries like Zimbabwe also assisted in the success of South Africa as a strong nation it is known for today. You don't question your neighbour such questions when his house is falling apart, he or she is still your brother. WE CARE ABOUT YOU AND YOUR NATION MORE THAN YOU WILL EVER KNOW, WE ARE GRATEFUL FOR GIVING US REFUGE.

Population create a demand, a demand create jobs, jobs, jobs create a happy people, if you passed your matric you will understand

​@@simbiromudzingwa Indeed, an increasing population can lead to higher demand for goods and services, which can stimulate economic activity and job creation. However, I would like to remind you that many immigrants, come with diverse skills and a strong work ethic. We contribute to the economy not only as consumers but also as active participants in various sectors, thereby helping to meet the increased demand and foster economic growth. It's also important to recognize the challenges and complexities involved in this dynamic. Effective policies and supportive environments are crucial to ensure that the potential benefits of population growth are realized, leading to job creation and improved living standards for everyone. If you were an independent thinker, open minded, and observer of life and experiences of nations all over the globe, you would understand.. Respectfully

Don't fight the people fight the system which allows the employers to employ foreigners

@@libertydewah9805 at our work place they are firing those who don't have documents

@@libertydewah9805 cheap labour is what you guys are being hired for and nothing else. You ain't better than Sans. You even proud to spew that bile, if i were you I'll be ashamed.

They hate their country with passion.

What are you trying to say?

You don't know what you are talking about 😊

​@@BrianMadzanira-bl7jncos u u wished to be SA mybe to be sotho or tswana cos Zulu called u kwerekweres 😂😂😂

You can say that again.

This is not a voted government, so they will never do good for people, but all is well,no situation is permanent 😢

Soon you're also going to Zimbabwe look what happened to your south Africa is fucked up country now

If it doesn't happen, you will take God to court😂😂😂😂😂

Me too 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

Such hate

😂😂😂😂😂

I make them go up n down for me then once I'm done eating when it's time for a tip. I tell them u are not a SAn so I won't tip u n then I go

Preach

💯 correct ayi lento yabo ye entitlement....bayaphoxa maan

​​@@RaphaelNgwenya-cc1dmnot only ukuphoxa but it's also boring🚮🚮🚮

Never

Correct he must go peruse administrative law ,the judiciary can never take decision over legislators

Athini ama South African na avotile

Dicefe tse diya tena. Ive even lost interest in commenting. I pray PA gets home affairs.

Remember South Africa wasn't built by South African alone, also how do you know if you are really a South African, yet your forefather migrate from North Africa. Think like a wise man, it's only a foolish who did not understand Africa

@@conradfungiro73 yho enough of this story alredy. Those foreigners were working for money, they got paid for the work they dd. So what your point?

We dont owe them anything.

and they call it Pan-Africanism

Please go home.

Nobody called you here kwérèkwérê.Who you blaming?

Yo home in in Zimbabwe

Im sure you came here illegal uze ngecrocodile uzobuyeka bgecrocodile izakubuyisela ezimbabwe

​@@user-cq3tm2gs4cwhat exactly did you contribute to the economy of south Africa

Everything ​@@mataelomokeretla8423

@@mataelomokeretla8423 In so many ways these people work they contribute their labour to the development of S A they spend money in SA shops paying vat which then goes to the betterment of SA and it's citizens They have bank accounts which also brings business to the banks They pay taxes They live in rented houses where they pay so much money to S A landlords hence benefiting the citizens Some of the business people employ South Africans Some of these permit holders are in relationships with the South African ladies whom they are looking after and some of the even have children with these ladies that they are looking after so yaa so many things

😂

😂😂Abawazi Ama South Africans anjani

What do you mean cz I came to South Africa before you were even born​@@RaphaelNgwenya-cc1dm

I support them as well.

​@@boss-js4ffyour foolish entitlement that's what annoys Sans. You'll forever be perpetual runners.

GO AND PLOUGH IN YOUR OWN COUNTRY, WE HAVE ENOUGH UNEMPLOYMENT ISSUES WITH OUR YOUTH. SOUTH AFRICAN MUST STOP GIVING TIPS TO ALL ZIMBABWEAN WORKING IN OUR RESTAURANTS PLEASE

It won't be approved. Motsoaledi is going to follow the correct channels

Khohlwa

Please let's leave God alone. He gave you your birth country, and you guys ran away instead of fighting.Now south Africans must suffer because of you guys.

Amen

​@@DuchessofKuvukinow they are busy praying this hard workers, if it doesn't happen they will take God to court😂😂😂😂😂

No. the message Shud get thru to u Zimbabweans dat yol are not wanted in SA stop being cowards go fight in yo own country Luk at Kenya dey r fighting for rights u Zimbabweans can't do anything but just to remain and want to b in SA

U say there are few Zep wat abt all u illegal Zimbabweans can u show yo faces

Maybe Botswana, Swaziland, Lesotho, Namibia, Tanzania, Kenya. Not Zimbabwe and Nigeria please

Then you go HOME for the holidays hypocrate

We're tired of you

@@boss-js4ff says an international orphan.

Stop lying to yourself,your home is Zimbabwe,be ashamed of claiming another country when you have your own country just boarder across Limpopo

Home, you have a country that needs you more than south africa. Where is your pride?

The next step is to go home Zimbabwe is waiting for you kwerekwere