When you see that Winter is ranked 5th in vocals out of a 7 member group, that’s how you know this group got phenomenal singers

Taeyeon and Wendy are just vocal queens. It’s crazy how taeyeon sang that high note with such ease and no stiffness

Idc about seulgi being the last in visual ranks. The fact that she's broke the korean standard by debuted as a monolid girl and not so fair skin is already make me proud 😁

Hyo was a body double for Boa when she was just a trainee and also Jenet Jackson's backup dancer, not to forget she can do almost all dance forms.. And if you focus in the dance break she does not skip a beat unlike the other two.. I am not bringing down anyone imo every girl in this group are queens but I just hate when anyone questions hyo's talent because for her whole career she has never been appreciated more and finally when she is getting what she deserves everyone is still trying to bring her down.

It's insane because my favorite visuals are Seulgi, Hyoyeon, and BoA! Hyoyeon's look is particularly my favorite. I have total opposite standards than most people who rank these.

wendy literally the hidden main rapper in rv lol she did the rappers part on icc and many more

When it comes to vocal, wendy and Taeyeon are so close to each other like at this point they are 1 and 2 for me. Two of my all time fav female vocalists together, i can die peacefully now… Same here goes with hyo and boa, their dance, j can’t rank btw them two, both are tooo good. This group is full of talented queens. I am so excited to see what they have in store in the future!

seulgi is actually so insane ranking 4 and 3 in dancing, also why the heck is she 7th visually...she has the most Korean fans along with irene so I don't think this is base on korean beauty standards

Lead Vocalist - BoA, Seulgi, Winter Main - Wendy, Taeyeon Lead Dancer - Karina, Seulgi Main - HYO, BoA Lead Rapper - Karina, (Wendy) Rapper - BoA, Winter Main - HYO

Even Hyoyeon and Karina have incredible vocals 🤭

Wendy is such an underrated dancer.. she hits heavy choreo so hard.

For anyone doubting Wendy's Ranking in "rap" just listen to her rap break in "taste" red velvet' b-side im the rbb album.

Seulgi natural visuals....perfect dancer

GOT made me realize just what a dance glow-up Wendy had. I still often remember her as being a stiff and pretty bad dancer but her improvement has been insane and she holds her ground with the rest of the group even without relying on her amazing vocals. Seulgi will forever be red velvets ace to me but Wendy has become such an allrounder and I'm just in awe of her because of how hard she must have worked - especially considering her recent extreme injury!

I can say this group is one of the most completed groups that have been exist in kpop history

When Seulgi can legitimate and understandingly be ranked 4th for vocals and 3rd for dance ability, you just have to accept this group is a force to be reckoned with.

This is just confirming that Wendy is an incredibly talented idol.

Boa is the ACE of the grup, i love that .

I really agree with your vocal ranking but when i see you comment Winter is a better vocalist than Seulgi, imo seulgi is a better vocalist hehe, Cause i think she can do falsetto and high note better please don't hate me 🗿🙏🏻

For me Hyo and Seulgi have the most attractive look. In my opinion they are the best visuals and also best dancers. 😍❤💕

Seulgi is 7th visually no way

They're all visual killers, but if I should rank them, HYO would be the FIRST to me, Wendy would be second, and Seulgi definitely wouldn't be the last . . It's interesting how HyoTae are number 1 in their respective field, and being the last at the opposite field 😄 Taeyeon: best vocalist from 2nd gen Hyoyeon: best dancer from 2nd gen Legendary, and they're all still in the game 😎😎

wendy, boa and karina are so talented it's insane

I believe BoA is the strongest dancer overall, if we're going to pull out dancing from the archives and not from this comeback alone. Hyoyeon has swag, but BoA be walking upside down in Woman, moonwalking through The Face, vibrating from foot to head (My Name), in-sync with thunder and lightning (The Shadow), and over-killing a dance-off (GOT/Moto), dreamy and edgy in Only One... Hyoyeon just don't take the same risks and go beyond her comfort zone to show her range of skill enough. She has one standard style, which is great, but she doesn't often take it to that next level. BoA is far more creative and fluid with her movements.

It feels good to see people appreciating Hyoyeon. She's the best dancer. And she's soooooo talented. Never got the hype. I hope she earns her well deserved Stans now.

My top 4 in each category: Vocals: 1. Taeyeon 2. Wendy 3. Boa 4. Seulgi Dance: 1. Hyoyeon 2. Boa 3. Seulgi 4. Karina Rap 1. Hyoyeon 2. Karina Haven’t heard much from others so i dunno Edit: For people asking for Winter. This is just my top 4. While she’s a talented singer and dancer, in comparison to seniors then, this is my unbiased conclusion. If it makes y’all feel better, she’s actually top 5 for me at both of vocals and dance.

You know this is an elite squad, when Seulgi is ranked last, in terms of visuals. The handsome bear. ʕ•ᴥ•ʔ

Vocal wendy, visual wendy

Positions in my opinion: Boa: Leader, Main Dancer, Lead Vocalist, Rapper Taeyeon: Main Vocalist Hyo: Main Dancer, Main Rapper Seulgi: Main Dancer, Lead Vocalist Wendy: Main Vocalist, Rapper Karina: Lead Dancer, Lead Rapper, Vocalist, Visual Winter: Lead Vocalist, Lead Dancer, Visual, Maknae

Wendy Is Personally my favorite vocalist, an underrated rapper, a Good energetic dancer and good at freestyle and is a visual. If she did not get plastic surgery on her Jaw, she would be the prettiest one here

(According to this song, not overall) Vocal: Taeyeon/Wendy Dance: BoA Rap: Hyoyeon (Karina was insane too) visual: *all of them are number one* ✨

Yes karina visual is no joke

Vocal 1.taeyeon/boa/wendy 2.winter/seulgi 3.karina 4.hyoyeon Rapper 1.hyoyeon 2.karina 3.wendy 4.winter Dance 1.boa/Hyoyeon/seulgi/karina 2.winter 3.wendy 4.taeyeon Visual 1.winter 2.karina/taeyeon 3.wendy/seulgi/boa/Hyoyeon

Dance 1.Hyoyeon 2.BoA 3.Karina/Seulgi 4.Wendy(she has improved a lot in dance) 5.Winter 6.Taeyeon

Karina is my favorite♡︎

The visuals ranking is totally insane

I think Taeyeon is the visual

Seulgi, Hyo and Karina are the top 3 visuals for me

I love them all for a variety of reasons, but my ultimate bias is Hyoyeon. She's a frickin amazing dancer, the songs she releases are catchy and within her vocal range and she performs them well, and she's so hot. I think she appeals to a Western audience for a reason, and not only because she's into EDM either. It's not surprising to me she's not very popular in Korea itself but well loved outside of it.

Having the most experience in the kpop industry and being a soloist for 20+ years, BoA is definitely an all rounder !!

thank u for appreciating Wendy's rap, she's amazing

BoA is total queen

Taeyeon's vocals are really one of a kind

Dance : Hyoyeon Vocal : Taeyeon (Really Taeyeon have better high note and control than Wendy but close the gap is close) Rap : Hyoyeon Visual : Karina

Vocal 1. Taeyeon/ Wendy 2. Boa 3. Winter/Seulgi 4. Karina 5.Hyoyeon Dance 1. Hyoyeon/ Boa/ Seulgi 2. Karina 3. Winter 4. Wendy 5. Taeyeon Rap 1. Wendy/Hyoyeon Sm doesn't have real rapper except giselle/amber but Wendy's really good she can be main rapper here 2. Karina 3. Seulgi 4. Winter 5. Taeyeon Visual They are all pretty in their own way Stage presence 1. Hyoyeon 2. Boa 3. Seulgi 4. Wendy 5. Taeyeon 6. Karina 7. Winter

I think Winter's vocal is better that Seulgi's....

if anything the ranking in this video (visuals aside) is facts!! best one I've seen

Taeyeon is just amazing she has everything

Hyo has the best visual to me! She is stunning, her voice is unique too!😍🥰

My no 1 in eash category Vocal: Taeyeon Rap: Karina Dance: Boa Visual: Karina

Seulgi 7 visual rank? The only one that is probably not all plasticized, besides being in the rank of the most beautiful in the world since 2016 ... I don't agree hahaha

here's how i'd rank them (more of in step back era, not based on their positions) eventho no one cares *vocals :* 1. wendy [her vocals here are just so heavenly i can't even describe it with other words T____T] 2. taeyeon [hers too. i feel like she can hit the high notes rlly effortlessly] 3. boa [eventho she doesn't sing much highnotes i think she rlly shined in this era as the only 1st gen idol] 4. winter [her vocal range is so wide and i like the way she pronounce words] 5. seulgi [eventho i think in got the beat she doesn't get the vocalist position, i still think she sings nicely without effort] 6. karina [would like to hear more of her singing bc her vocals in aespa is sooo nice] 7. hyoyeon [just like karina, i want to hear more of her singing bc i think she has a unique voice] *rap :* 1. hyoyeon [her rap here is just beautiful] 2. karina [just like hyoyeon, main rapper material] 3. wendy [i can't necessarily say tht she deserves a rapper position here but in rv she gets it so ...] 4/5. winter/boa [their vocal range is wide so i think they could also give it a go and get decent in rap] 6. seulgi [same like wendy] 7. taeyeon [i rarely hear her rap but who knows? maybe she'll get a rap lines in future cbs?] *dance :* 1. karina [her dance is just so smooth and precise in step back, and she also has godly musicality] 2/3. hyoyeon/boa [main dancer material that just has sooo much experience] 4. seulgi [her dance is also very precise, and even some moves i think only seulgi can perform it right] 5. wendy [a hidden all rounder, she tried in this era i think it was pretty good] 6. winter [so sadly i think she can do better, where's the winter in black mamba era?] 7. taeyeon [she's good if she tries, and it's not the case here T0T] *visual :* 1. karina [she literally looks virtual. literally just like a goddess tht just fell from the skies] 2. wendy [idk but i love her hereee she looks so fresh and her hair??? i'm in love] 3. winter [she looks so tiny and small but she fits will the outfits in this concept] 4. taeyeon [her silver-grayish hair compliments her overall pretty look so much] 5. hyoyeon [her pink hair is rlly nice eventho it doesn't rlly fit the concept, but the make up and the outfits we're chef's kiss] 6. boa [the outfit tht was picked for her looked very nice, and all the bling on it fits her so well] 7. seulgi [just like boa, her look wasn't rlly outstanding from the other members but it made her look so good] this is just how i'd rank them imo, u can freely have ur own opinions but here's mine personally. anyways each of them shined so nicely in this era. each has so much potential and are queens in their own way

dance ranking 1-boA 2-hyoyeon 3-seulgi

Seulgi my bias 💛

Timestamps: 0:00 - Intro 0:13 - Vocal Ranking 2:44 - Rap Ranking 4:30 - Dance Ranking 6:27 - Visual Ranking 7:10 - Outro

YES! Rapper WanD represented!!

mine ( base on technique) Vocal 1.Taeyeon 2.Wendy 3.Boa 4.Winter 5.Seulgi 6.Karina 7.Hyoyeon (my bias)

The positions in my opinion: Taeyeon: leader, main vocalist, visual Boa: lead vocalist, main dancer Hyoyeon: main dancer, Main rapper Seulgi: main/lead dancer, lead vicalist Wendy: main vocalist, lead/sub rapper Karina: lead dancer, lead/main rapper, visual Winter: lead vocalist, visual (You understand their dance skills when seulgi could be a lead dancer instead of main)

i think wendys a better dancer than winter. just me .?

THIS IS SOOOO ACCURATE OH MY GOSH!

For me, Wendy should be 1st on vocal category but nonetheless, thank you for the effort 🤎

To me visual 1.Karina🖤 2.Winter💜 3.Taeyeon❤️ 4.Wendy💙 5.Seulgi💚 6.Boa💛 7.Hyeoyon🧡

My favorite: Karina Positions: Boa: Lead Vocalist, Lead Dancer, Sub Rapper Taeyeon: Main Vocalist, Leader, Face of the Group Hyoyeon: Sub Vocalist, Main Rapper, Main Dancer Seulgi: Lead Vocalist, Lead Dancer Wendy: Main Vocalist, Sub Rapper Karina: Lead Rapper, Sub Vocalist, Face of the Group Winter: Sub Vocalist, Sub Rapper, Visual

For me Vocal : 1. Taeyeon 2. Wendy 3. BoA 4. Seulgi 5. Winter 6. Karina 7. Hyoyeon Dance 1. Hyoyeon 2. Seulgi 3. BoA 4. Karina 5. Winter 6. Wendy 7. Taeyeon Visual 1. Seulgi 2. Karina 3. Taeyeon 4. Winter 5. Wendy 6. BoA 7. Hyoyeon Ekspresif + charismatic 1. Seulgi 2. Wendy 3. Hyoyeon 4. Karina 5. BoA 6. Taeyeon 7. Winter Rap : 1. Karina 2. Hyoyeon 3. Wendy 4. Winter 5. Seulgi 6. BoA 7. Taeyeon

Taeyeon's voice is untouchable to be honest, it's insane

Vocal:taeyeon Dance:boa Rap:hyoyeon Visual:karina and winter

I only wanna say, im proud being sone cause i couldn't agree more with ur list. It shown to people that second generation is multitalented cause even time goes by with many group coming, their still able ranked top above those new comer which which more popular in most of mainstream compare to snsd at these days. But i love all the list and i love this song so much

Positions Boa - Main Dancer, Lead Vocalist, Rapper Taeyeon - Main Vocalist Hyoyeon - Main Dancer, Vocalist, Main Rapper Wendy - Main Vocalist Seulgi - Lead Dancer, Lead Vocalist, Rapper Karina - Lead Dancer, Sub Vocalist, Main/Lead Rapper Winter - (Lead?) Vocalist, Lead Rapper

Aespa barely sings live, we can’t say Winter is better than Seulgi since Winter herself isn’t showcasing her skills. Seulgi has a really good lower range, she can support up to B4 (although she doesn’t produce resonance) and her falsetto is somewhat stable (but her higher register is very unexplored so there’s not much to judge) Winter so far has showcased a really steady vibrato and controlled vibrato (something that Seulgi sometimes doesn’t have), but since Aespa almost never sings live, it’s hard to see exactly where Winter’s supported range starts and ends. Some people said she can support up to B4 too, but i haven’t seen that. She has good pitch as expected, but SM has failed to allow her and her group members to explore their voices live. Who knows, if they truly sang live i believe Winter could be idk supporting her C#5s in Savage.

If the korean visual standards, then Seulgi may be the last because of her monolid eyes. However, I really like Seulgi’s beauty and charm, I’ve fallen for her

In this kind of rankings is the only I fully agreed😁✨

positions imo boa - center, main dancer, lead vocalist, lead rapper taeyeon - leader, main vocalist, sub rapper hyoyeon - main rapper, lead dancer, sub vocalist seulgi - main dancer, lead vocalist wendy - main vocalist, sub rapper karina - face, main rapper, lead dancer, sub vocalist winter - lead vocalist, sub rapper, maknae

Ranking the girls always gonna be unfair most of all in visuals cuz Is strictly subjective, I think Hyo Wendy and Seulgi are 1,2 and 3 for me, maybe we should stop ranking them and just enjoy this insanely talented group!! All Queens!!

La visual es karina que cumple con todos los estándares

Wendy can do all queen👑💅

It's incredible how hyoyeon is underrated! She can do everything but nobody's talk about her. Your rap in step back was fantastic and nobody talk so much about it, It's really sad

This group is full of legendary vocalist

Visual : 1. Karina 2. Winter 3. Taeyeon 4. Hyoyeon 5. BoA 6. Wendy 7. Seulgi Dance : 1. Hyoyeon 2. BoA 3. Seulgi 4. Karina ( just watch their latest step back performance u will know that this rank is so low on this talent ) 5. Winter / wendy 6. Taeyeon Rap : 1. Hyoyeon / karina 2. Wendy 3. BoA 4. Winter 5. Taeyeon 6. Seulgi Vocal : 1. Taeyeon ( obv ) 2. Wendy 3. BoA 4. Seulgi 5. Winter 6. Karina 7. Hyoyeon

In my opinion,karina should get no.1 in rap

Best vocal and rapper is actually Wendy

SEULGI IN THE 7TH RANK!? EXCUSE ME!? Bro, I'm feel so offended She is a visual queen *don't changed my mind*

Hunny, BoA will not be BoA for her to rank second in dancing. Hyo is a great dancer but BoA is just unbeatable and on another level.. Queen of Kpop indeed.

Visual 1.Winter you heaters For Winter

My opinion Visual 7taehyeon 6boa 5seulgi 4wendy 3winter 2hyohyeon 1karina

No but really, Wendys and Taeyeons vocals r no Joke😬💟

Lets do this: Vocals: 1-Taeyeon 2-Wendy 3-Boa 4-Winter 5-Seulgi 6-Karina 7-Hyoyeon Rap: 1-Wendy 2-Karina 3-Hyoyeon 4-Winter 5-Boa 6-Taeyeon 7-SeulGi Dance: 1-Hyoyeon 2-Boa 3-Seulgi 4-Karina 5-Wendy 6-Winter 7-Taeyeon

Taeyeon 😍😍 Yeahh she all-rounded 💯 perfect idol indeed

BoA - Main Dancer, Lead Vocal e Center Tayeon - Main Vocal e Leader Hyoyeon - Main Dancer e Main-rapper Wendy - Main-vocal, Sub-rapper e Sub-dancer Seulgui - Main-vocal e Main-dancer Karina - Visual, Lead-rapper, sub-vocal e Lead-dancer Winter - Visual, Main-vocal, Sub-rapper e Maknae My opinion!!💞

Vocal 1st: Taeyeon 2nd: Wendy 3rd: Boa 4th: Seulgi 5th: Winter 6th: Karina 7th: Hyoyeon Dance 1st: Hyoyeon 2nd: Boa 3rd: Seulgi 4th: Karina 5th: Winter 6th: Taeyeon 7th: Wendy Rap 1st: Karina 2nd: Hyoyeon 3rd: Winter 4th: Boa 5th: Wendy 6th: Taeyeon 7th: Seulgi Visual 1st: Karina 2nd: Taeyeon 3rd: Seulgi 4th: Winter 5th:Hyoyeon 6th: Wendy 7th: Boa

so the visual ranking is based on how much procedure they've done to their faces?? 🙊 coz seulgi is definitely last in this 🙈

Wendy vocal isn’t a joke

Seulgi is the most talented idol omg

Karina : dancer, rapper, and visual. Undeniable.

Vocals 1-taeyeon 2-wendy 3-winter 4-seulgi 5-boa +karina 6-hyoyeon

Heres my opinion Main Vocalist - Taeyeon, Wendy Lead Vocalist - BoA, Seulgi, Winter Sub Vocalist - Hyoyeon, Karina Main Rapper - Hyoyeon Lead Rapper - Karina Sub Rapper - Winter, BoA Main Dancer - Hyoyeon, BoA Lead Dancer - Seulgi, Karina Visual - All (i can't choose)

My opinion 7 Hyoyeon 6 Karina 5 Winter 4 BoA 3 Seulgi 2 Wendy 1 TAEYEON Rap 7 Seulgi 6 Winter 5 Taeyeon 4 Wendy 3 BoA 2 Karina 1 HYOYEON Dance 7 Wendy 6 Taeyeon 5 Winter 4 Karina 3 Seulgi 2 Hyoyeon 1 BOA Bias 7 Hyoyeon 6 BoA 5 Winter 4 Taeyeon 3 Wendy 2 Karina 1 Seulgi

Eh I personally think Karina should be placed first with rapping. She’s not the best either but she executes it so well and she has so much potential to be a good rapper.

when it comes to vocals, winter is definitely a better singer than seulgi, however seulgi has a way of singing that makes you extremely attracted to her voice. She is a good singer, and the way she sings can fool u into thinking she is a better singer than winter.

this is how I'd rank for vocal

Vocal: 1:Taeyeon (A-) 2:Wendy (^B+) 3:Boa (^B) 4:Seulgi(B) 5:Winter (C) 6:Karina (C-) 7:Hyoyeon (F-) Rap: 1:Hyoyeon 2:Karina 3:Wendy 4:Boa 5:Winter 6:Taeyeon 7:Seulgi Dance: 1:Hyoyeon 2:Karina 3:Seulgi 4:Boa 5:Wendy 6:Winter 7:Taeyeon Visual: 1:Karina 2:Winter 3:Taeyeon 4:Wendy 5:Seulgi 6:Hyoyeon 7:Boa Stage Presence: 1:Boa 2:Seulgi 3:Karina 4:Wendy 5:Taeyeon 6:Hyoyeon 7:Winter My Bias: 1:Winter 2:Karina 3:Wendy 4:Seulgi 5:Taeyeon 6:Boa 7:Hyoyeon