Love both of them, being a vet, would rather carry the M14

“In my not so humble opinion, the M1 Garand is the greatest battle implement ever devised.” - General George S. Patton

Probably the M14 the performance is the same but the loading process seems easier and has more rounds

Can't go wrong with either of these classics

M1 garand vs M1 carabine

M1: Handsome weapon. M14: Functional weapon. Winner: M1 just for lookin' so good!

The box magazine is nice, but that “p’ting!” can’t be beat.

i am a fan of the m14 however at the same time i think both the m1 Garand and the m14 are both winners in my opinion.

Mini-14 vs M1 Carbine

World at War vs Black Ops

Both great rifles. M14 would be the winner for me. Caliber, 20rd box magazine.

I used an M14 when I was in the service. It served me well through a few years of fighting insurgents. I also handled an M1, though not in combat. I have been in armed engagements with rebels who have used the M1 among other weapons against us. Both are equally lethal, although the M14 has more rounds in a single mag load.

Я конечно не являюсь профессиональным коллекционером или любителем оружия, но тем не менее, ваш канал меня очень заинтересовал. Спасибо вам за вашу краткость и простую подачу.

If I had to choose between the M1 Garand and the M14… it’s a draw for me because each rifle has its own favored characteristics. The M1 Garand is the favorite rifle of Ian McCollum from Forgotten Weapons for its history and the M1 being the candid inspiration for the Kalashnikov AK. The M14 on the flip side is what I would use for skirmishes because of the advantage of using the modern detachable magazine therefore not worrying about getting the Garand Thumb in the heat of battle. So it looks like the M14 is the short answer, and with the long answer being both of them good in their own ways.

M14 is the winner to me.

I was in the Italian Armed Forces from '98-00. We used the M-14 as our basic training rifle and for ceremonies. It's a bit heavy, but it's a great, high powered rifle with a lot kick and fairly accurate too

M1 garand vs m1 carbine

M1 vs M14 vs M1A Scout Squad vs M1A SOCOM 16...."Bang"

Question do you think you can do the weapons from the movie Gangster Squad

Simply adding a magazine can take you a long way

M1 Garand: As I am good, my offspring would be better M14 be like: 💀

M1 garand was used by un forces during the korean war and our korean uses it too

I was a Marine from '62--'66. I trained and qualified at PI with the M-14, and later in Fleet. I didn't have to qualify with the M-1, but carried it in ITR at Geiger; no trouble hitting what I aimed at on the "John Wayne" courses. I preferred the M-14, especially when I was an AR man in a fire team; 20 rounds v 8. Big difference.

This guy is definitely good at it if there was an zombie apocalypse

I would say the M1 is the better rifle overall. Officially, the Garand is an inch shorter than the M14 and just so happens to have a longer barrel which is good, but with the flash hider it is even more compact. The lack of a protruding magazine happens to also be a positive if you are trying to store it quickly or crawl with it in a tight spot. The felt recoil is about the same since the M14 is more unbalanced as well. The M14 was such a pos that the war torn Italians made a better version of the M14 out of a modified Garand. Having John Garand help design the "successor" would have helped the rifle to not be shit.

By any chance do you have an extra RSC 1917 clips you'd be willing to sell??

I’ll take the “Band of Brothers” model thank you. Love the empty ping sound.

I would love to see an M-14 vs HK G-3 comparison, and of course a G-3 vs FAL. I have confidence that you probably own both!😂

In combat I would rather have the Garand. I own both. The Garand's balance is more front heavy which I prefer and the enbloc loading design is faster than mag changes.

using both M1 and M14 in my basic training a way long ago. love both and M1 is still my favorite then

Is m1 a good hunting rifles for boars and deer?

I used the M-14 in the Marine Corps but the M-1 would have been so much cooler.

Yo, The 2 weapons looks like Matches on Outside Range for Backyard.

Both amazing 👍🏻

Mauser 98k & Springfield 1903, please

Makes sense considering the m14 is essentially an m1 modified for selectable automatic fire

Hey Dude When Are You Guys Gonna Upload Another Video Of You Guys Shooting The M1 Garand Semi-Automatic Rifle Like I Know You Did Part 1 and Part 2 But When Are You Guys Gonna Make An M1 Garand Shooting In the New Format.

I own both, i love both!!! If i could only chose one if have a nervous break down trying to decide.

They BOTH WON they're both OUTSTANDING weapons.

Apples and oranges there's no comparison. You get the job done with an M14.

I’m always leery of the M1’s potential for “Garand thumb” when inserting the enbloc clip. Plus, the M14 mag is easily topped up via the stripper clip slot. Also, 10-20 rounds vs 8 rounds, no brainer, in my humble opinion.

308 preferred.... good day sammy

can you please make a video about the weapons of the ussr in the second world war

Great rifles!

All m1a front sight wiggles M1 garand sets grooves

They are the same except that M14 magazine load is more convenient. M1 if you are careless in loading you end up with a Garand thumb!

Carried both but really liked the M-1 the best.

Can you put the gun on the table when aiming

Wow

Wouldn’t a better comparison be the BAR vs M14

You'll be best protected by either rifle. Can't get a better battle rifle system.

In my opinion, the only advantage that the m 14 has over the m 1 garand is the magazine capacity

What gets me, is the difference between the Patton quote, and what the feather weight rifle carriers say about them... Guess who's opinion I trust?

Both

They are good guns. The difference is only the impact. M1 garand has a good impact.

The M14. It’s select fire and has a 20 round magazine.

there is a 308 Garand, Italian surplus original not a kit at a local gun dealer, Canadian price 2800.00

They got the same power but the M-14 Armalite Rifle is an automatic rifle unlike the M-1 Garand that is a semi automatic rifle.

Both are winners as was the United States Military for having two outstanding weapons. I am both a M1 Garand fan and owner as well as a M14 fan and owner.

M14 gives me a woody.

You can see the power of m14 in shooting the metal target

THE M1 GARAND!

The one I lucky enough to own.

I think theyre basically the same but aesthetically i like the m14 more

M14 , simply because it has a mag of 20 rds . But both amazing rifles .

M14 but honestly both

I like both tbh.. but I like m14 a lot more.. also ebr style is good too.. 👌 Also tried loading m1 before.. and fucker ate my thumb.. it was old and badly maintained after all.. Lol 😆

Winner 🙄 coin toss. They were both awesome war weapons of their time.

M14 is what the M1 wished it could be. 20 rounds > 8 rounds. Mags are easier to change than the clip and less often. There is a reason why all battle rifles become mag fed vs clip. Gas piston m14> m1 The 30-06 has a negligible edge over the 7.62 nato round. But being ball ammo, their wounding effects are virtually identical. M14 full auto or semi > m1 semi only While the full auto m14 was not comfortable, better to have it and not need it than to need it and not have it.

Why did the army replace the M1 with the M14? There must of been some sort of problem with the M1.

if i ever make a doom mod i wanna use the garand as a weapon in it

I would take the M14 due to capacity. Although, if you want it to convert with a beautiful walnut hunting stock, I would take the M1.

I feel like M14 smacked harder.

I know the US military uses these rifles but do law enforcement like police officers and detectives use these rifles?

M1 garand is a beast

Own both and for fun id pick Garand for fight its M14. M14 can safely use a wider variety of ammo and has larger capacity. M14 also can easily be topped off with strip clips or scoped for longer range.

This is the best rifle of the 2nd World War

Broadning your content! I like it! Look out Ian lol:

I like them both, cuz they e are same 30 caliver

You should shoot an old submachine gun from World War 1

USMC Vet... The M-14 holds 20 rounds and has select fire....in combat , if you are out-numbered , you will thank the Lord that you can go full-auto...and load much faster ...the M-14 is a far better battle rifle ...! Semper Fi...!

Legenda

A bullied kid be browsing reviews

M14 my 2nd gun just next to my Ak47 that i would trust my life to depend😅😅

Finally a new vídeo, what is happening with you guys? You are posting very few vídeos nowadays.

I fired expert with the M1, and also took second place trophy in the Ninth Coast Guard District rifle competition in 1969. Mastering the sling is key to consistent 300 yard plus bullseyes. I have both M1s and M1As in my gun safes…. If I saw leftists coming over the hill, I’d choose the M1.

for me m1 garand win because its save you when you hear the sound ting it means you have to reload

I have Magnum 357 Ruger security six 1970 model saqya usa 38 m special edition Anti-echo is a rare metal

M14, hands down.

m14 has 15 rounds and m1 garand has 8, most of people probably would like to use m14 but i still prefeer m1 garand cuz of it's way to reload is just perfect and the recoil looks easier to hold on than m14. M1 Garand wins

I always hated M1 series iron sights it's really hard to work I think K98 has the best iron sights.

And my taste test winner goes to the M1 Garand !!!

Carried both in USMC M1 was my favorite, although both were reliable. Carrying a clip was more convenient than a magazine.

We use it in Post Bangla war good gun m1 garand

BM59 vs M14 vs M1

I served 17 years in the united states army and I have fired all standard issue weapons of the army. Hands down the M-14 in my opinion is the primary weapon I would want to carry. But I give serious props to the m-1 grand. M-1 carbine was ok but no stopping power as it was .30 caliber.

The winner is both..

M14 weakness is overheating In a long battle garand is the winner

M1 garand vs SKS

M1 garand with telescope is the best use in snipper against enemy of war.. even hunting animals in the mountains etc... M14 is much better use is in battlezone because it has 20 rounds of bullets loaded.. The carbine is always up on them because it has an automatic firing, light weight and easy to maneuver, both the m16 or ar15 is much better because the speed of fire, light weight easy to maneuver and can attach m203... With also telescope can attach... Esp in a close fire battle this are more convenient to handle.. So many differences but still the question is whete to use it.. But if you go to war use drones, your safe🤣🤣