Ham Radio Digital Modes Comparison - DMR, DSTAR or YSF? P25 or NXDN?

Рет қаралды 52,540

3 жыл бұрын

Today I connect to a hotspot with the 3 most comment digital modes in Ham Radio, which are DMR, DSTAR and YSF (Yaesu System Fusion) and let you, the audience, listen to each one. We will talk about the differences, my preferences, and my recommendations for you.
★★★ IMPORTANT LINKS★★
✅New MERCH Site!!! - www.shop.hamradio2.com
✅SUBSCRIBE for more Ham Radio videos: hr2.li/9a009
Checkout my WEBSITE: hamradio2.com
✅PATREON: hr2.li/7xziu
✅SUBSCRIBESTAR: hr2.li/f18xr
📜 Be sure to support my sponsors, who make this series possible: 📜
gifts4hams.com
www.randl.com
www.buytwowayradios.com
flexradio.com
👀Check out my Amazon Store, where I make small commissions on some items: www.amazon.com/shop/hamradio2.0
😎 Ham Radio 2.0 Is Now Multi-Platform! 😎
Full30 - hr2.li/o9uok
LinkedIn: hr2.li/uzjn4
Odysee: hr2.li/8qvzv
Rumble: hr2.li/umu9h
★ MORE HAM RADIO ON KZfaq★
Livestreams first and third Sunday evening of each month, check this link for times: hamradio2.com/livestream
★ FIND ME ELSEWHERE ON KZfaq★
How To Make Videos on KZfaq: / @jasonbuildsstuff
DOG Rescuing and Fostering: / @rescuedpups
★ DMR RADIOS★
Anytone D878+ - hr2.li/tl6xm
Anytone D578 Pro - hr2.li/3kjk4
✔ SOURCES ✔
AREDN Mesh Networking Hardware: hr2.li/l3m2q
Get a DMR or NXDN ID: hr2.li/zff8j
ALL About DMR: hr2.li/qze9b
How to write a DMR codeplug: hr2.li/tfr37
**Get your TECHNICIAN License! hr2.li/fgxn3
Upgrade to GENERAL! hr2.li/tm4v8
DMR, DSTAR and YSF Hotspots: hr2.li/7xo4j
Theme and background music courtesy of www.bensound.com
⚑ SUBSCRIBE TO MY CHANNEL ⚑
If you are interested in my videos like this and want to support my efforts, please consider subscribing - hr2.li/9a009
ツ CONNECT WITH ME ツ
Leave a comment on this video and it'll get a response. Or you can connect with me on different social platforms too:
Podcast................► hr2.li/8kksq
iTunes................► hr2.li/cwtaw
Discord.....................► hamradio2.com/discord
Facebook.................►hamradio2.com/facebook
Twitter......................► / hamradio2dot0
Parler......................► hr2.li/kvd3e
Instagram.................► / hamradio2dot0
Gab......................► hr2.li/ha9qz
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mail: 2150 W. Northwest Highway STE114-1163, Grapevine TX 76051
Thanks for watching!
#Hamradio #kc5hwb #hamharder

Пікірлер: 269

@dean-ka0trl980 3 жыл бұрын

Thank You for making these videos. I have been a ham since 1986 but for the last 20 years I have been inactive and now getting back into ham. The hobby has advanced so much since I was in it and I am very ignorant of the new modes. Your videos are teaching me what is new and I thank You.

@MrRobertSpearsJr 3 жыл бұрын

Would love to see a newer video about setting up a DV system in a rural area that doesn't have any repeaters; and why this would be better than just turning up analog.

@joeeisenhour732 Жыл бұрын

I love the DMR, I have a cousin in California and he's been doing the digital for a few years now. I got an AnyTone DMR radio. He told me about P25 and Droidstar for the android. Took me a while to get it working but I did it. I can connect to the PAPA network in southern California. Then he told me about M17. I found it on my Droidstar app and talked to him on M17. I've also made a couple of other contacts on that mode as well. The night he told me about M17 I was able to have it up and running before he did. I think that really surprised him. Now I'm trying to figure out the settings for YSF. I'll keep watching your videos and continue to learn more. I've been a ham for 52 years now. Still have my original call as I didn't see any reason to change it. Got the General in February 4th 1972. Thanks for putting on the videos and hopefully will figure out the settings for the YSF. 73's for now, Joe WB6ELL P.S. I have talked all the way around the world back in 80's when the sun spots were going crazy running 10 watts on 10 meter FM. 73's once again.

@hbryant1971 2 жыл бұрын

"Choose what is closest to you". Excellent advice. However I live in the middle of nowhere in Mindanao, Philippines. There is not even any FM Analog repeaters within 300 miles. However, we do have 50Mbps Fiberoptic Internet. Therefore, the mode closest to me is whatever I program into my Hotspot. To simplify things, I setup two. One with Brandmeister and TGIF and a second with Yaesu System Fusion / WIRES X. No need for cross-mode, which often leads to problems. When I want to talk on DMR, I pick up my Alinco DJ-MD5 or Retevis RT-3S. If I'm in the mood for YSF, I fetch my Yaesu FT5DR. It seems to work well so far.

@caseyschesky3708 3 жыл бұрын

I am a new General and your videos are great. A lot of info in a short package. Very interesting and informative. Thanks I have learned a lot over the last 6 months watching! KE8PFA Casey

@donaldsmith3048 3 жыл бұрын

I got a TGIF HOTSPOT. Not had it but a week and still trying to learn all the things I can do with it. I want to be able to get on some of the different networks. I know that there is a way to do it. One thing I have learned is that in Ham radio there is always something new to learn about!

@jasonritchey8610 3 жыл бұрын

Dstar and System Fusion myself is what I use. Thanks Jason for the video my friend! Keep up the good work. KF5VSM 73!

@W5ERX4911 2 жыл бұрын

I like all these modes for different reasons and they all have something different to offer. My personal favorite is P25. I know it can be a bit daunting to get into but the voice quality is second to none. I would really like to see you do a video on P25 just so folks know what it is about.

@pedrocatalan9814 3 жыл бұрын

Hey Jason. Another great video. You don't touch on the multi mode reflectors, like the Quadnet Array. There are several nets held on there every week. You can use any of the three modes to connect to it, and be heard by all the participants. The cross encoding is done at the server end. There are other multimode reflectors out there too. I have to admit, I find the audio on DSTAR to be much better than DMR. one big problem with DMR, is the varying audio levels depending on the radio the user has. I have a Motorola XPR 6550 and an Anytone 878. You can really tell what radio someone is using just by how loud or soft the audio is. I'm sure you have seen this before. Keep up the great work. 73, VE7LO.

@mossup- 3 жыл бұрын

Great video thankyou, once you have chosen your selected mode, i chose dmr as here where i am in the UK i only have one local dmr repeater tha is too far for my handheld to reach, so i went dmr and got 2 pistar hotspots, one simplex and one duplex, the problem i found is people are spread across many networks like some are on brandmeister and some on pheonix and some on tgif and again some on freedmr, for me there is too many, most local UK repeaters are on pheonix so maybe that is one choice i should go with. either way i am loving dmr so far, had some issues with brandmeister when running 2 hotspots on it, thats when i decided to put the second one on a different network. love your vids, thankyou ♥

@davidg5308 3 жыл бұрын

Thanks Jason! I use DSTAR and YSF. All of the big 3 and more here in the LA area, but just don't feel the need for any more. Go with what you can and enjoy it!

@HamRadio2 3 жыл бұрын

Thanks for sharing

@joeframo3347 Жыл бұрын

Boy you're amazing you came along way brother I still go back to the days when you first yes indeed like I said you came a long way 😎

@dennismarble3591 3 жыл бұрын

I really appreciate and enjoy your videos. Not on yet take my technical exam 3/25. Please keep making videos.

@QRPadventures 3 жыл бұрын

Well, did you pass?

@dennismarble3591 3 жыл бұрын

@@QRPadventures Yep, first to finish and 100% correct. I joined a club and hope to get some Elmer experience soon.

@larrybragg7406 Жыл бұрын

Thank you for sharing. I noticed the sound quality only varies by radio, not by the digital signal. I'm in Bakersfield CA. We have Fusion, DMR and P25. I recently learned how to program a codeplug for DMR. Prior to this, it was confusing but Bridgecom was an excellent resource.

@cbtaylor10 Жыл бұрын

Good reviews. I've been an Icom man since the mid 1980s but since purchasing the Yaesu VX-6R last April I'm impressed with them. That said, I'm digging the Yaesu FT5 for it's robust construction, form factor, and solid Fusion performance. 'Honorable Mention'. N4CBT

@jensvoigt3376 3 жыл бұрын

get one of each D Star, YSF andDMr and using all thank you for your great video

@jackK5FIT Жыл бұрын

There are a couple of D-Star repeaters and a couple of Fusion repeaters in my area. I bought a Yaesu FT70D and a Jumbo Spot to play around with and got everything working and talked a bit on the America Link channel. Signal reports both ways are great. Santa brought me a Radioddity GD77 last Christmas so I could play around with DMR some. No DMR repeaters yet but I understand one is in the works. Looking forward to expanding my digital voice footprint. Thanks for the video! Jack K5FIT

@lawrencecheung73 Жыл бұрын

Thank you for your informational videos !!! I'm a total "newbie" and I am learning so much from you. Just subscribed !!!!

@keithfrost1268 3 жыл бұрын

Fusion was the first I'd heard of. I went D-Star because I wanted to talk with a friend who'd moved out of state. He had an Icom.

@joeblow8593 3 жыл бұрын

DMR sounds really good on your video. I have both D-Star and C4FM Fusion. Never really used either much

@ejrandler 3 жыл бұрын

Jason, as always, thanks for the great content. I appreciate that even though you have a preference, you still showcase other radios/systems/etc. I can't stand people who think that their preference is the only way to go and that everything else is crap. Thanks for not being that guy.

@K3JRZOnTheAir 3 жыл бұрын

When I got into ham radio, my local HRO (yeah, I’m like 20 minutes from the New Castle, DE location) said that System Fusion repeaters we’re popping up in the area and they persuaded my to get a Yaesu FT-1D from a VX-8 (or a model down). There weren’t many YSF repeaters actually up in my very local area, but there were a few 25+ miles away that I was able to hit if I used a better antenna or my 991. Since I couldn’t control the repeaters that I could get to (or they were down more than up) I decide to go with a OpenSpot 1 as my first hotspot. Gave me more freedom to do as I wished. Eventually got a OpenSpot 2. I go to DMR sometimes in my OS2, but haven’t talked to anyone talking through a TG on a local repeater. I usually stay on the System Fusion side of the OS2, switching between the FSC & YSF reflectors.

@jpb5385 3 жыл бұрын

This is great. I appreciate this. I would like to see more on how to use System Fusion. I’m new to the hobby and have an FT3D but know little about the digital side.

@CharlotteCaniac 3 жыл бұрын

I’m new too and have a FT3D. Is it simply a matter of connecting to a Fusion nearby repeater?

@pale_2111 3 жыл бұрын

I've got a FT3D and use in on Wires-X every once in a while because I just got one hotspot. It takes some time to get used to it, but made a few contacts on a few reflectors. I suggest that you make a log before you start because it'll come in handy when you run come across someone again.

@QRPadventures 3 жыл бұрын

@@CharlotteCaniac You can use a Wires-X and a YSF repeater. You can also connect the FT3D to a computer and use it as a hotspot for Wires-X. Lots of youtube videos about it. Good luck and welcome to the hobby.

@madmagrider 3 жыл бұрын

I chose Fusion because I have multiple repeaters near me and because it's easy to use and program a Yaesu radio.

@Jah_Rastafari_ORIG Жыл бұрын

Actually, you can translate any digital mode to any other using DVSwitch. I've also found that voice quality can vary widely, based on radio model, firmware rev and most importantly, whether the user's radio has been properly tuned (not to mention the tuning status of the hotspot/repeater/etc. they're using).

@saltlakecountyares8942 3 жыл бұрын

I run DMR and System Fusion. I like them both and there are repeaters for each close by.

@domgiampietro6005 2 жыл бұрын

Good info; being a "late bloomer" into digital, its great to finally learn the difference btw the various modes, as I dive-in with my new AT578Pro. All your videos are fun to watch too! Thanks. KF7VIB

@Dusty_Ham 3 жыл бұрын

Thank you very much Jason, I'm just about to start looking for my first DMR radio. They are the only repeaters in my country unfortunately. Now I have to search for a decent inexpensive hotspot and HT. My Baofeng isn't working out for me at all unfortunately.

@EvgeniX. 3 ай бұрын

check out OpenGD77 radios such as the tyt 380. really nice! btw only DMR in my country as well :)

@RicSpivey 3 жыл бұрын

I've been using dmr with a lot of help from your channel. A LOT of help lol. But I'm definitely enjoying it. I have one hf radio (g90) but planning on upgrading to something 100w and I was so close to sold on a ic-7300 but I'm seriously considering an ft-991a because I think I may enjoy ysf more than just hf D-star. That'll probably hold me off for a while... Maybe

@proudtex 3 жыл бұрын

Started with D-STAR, but my local club hosts the Texas Patriots room on our Wires-X repeater.

@billcrow5403 3 жыл бұрын

I use DMR because we have numerous repeaters in Oklahoma. Also I have one at the school I teach. Wish Kenwood would come out with a DMR ( ham) radio like the D74

@mac98sho50 3 жыл бұрын

I have both DMR and YSF. I do have repeaters for both near me, but I mainly use hotspots mainly. I have been hanging on Fusion more lately than DMR.

@briankendall1978 Жыл бұрын

I have been keeping my eye on the M17 that open source digital voice protocol. That seems like it could be very cool!!

@johnberry704 3 жыл бұрын

" get one of each ". Perfect response

@forgetyourlife 3 жыл бұрын

Get none of each. The analog response.

2 жыл бұрын

Excellent advice. Here in New England the digital activity is mostly DMR so it's an easy choice here. There are quite a few System Fusion repeaters because of Yaesu's seeding with cheap repeaters, but most are operating in the fixed FM output mode so they're making minimal use of digital capabilities. I suspect that a big reason for DMR dominance here is the New Englanders are cheap, even by ham standards. DMR radios can be bought inexpensively because of the HTs from China.

@jayrogers8255 2 жыл бұрын

Agreed. That being said, I am in New England, & don’t have DMR. I have NXDN, P25, & D-Star. I prefer the audio on P25, but own an NXDN repeater.

@rohnkd4hct260 3 жыл бұрын

I have DMR,DSTAR ,YSF and P-25. I live in area where I have very limited repeaters. Most all my DV ops are over a Hotspot. To me, P-25 sounds the best but , I love DSTAR.

@albing1397 3 жыл бұрын

I have all 3 here in SE Wisconsin, as well as FM. While I programmed repeaters into all my radios (3 DSTAR radios, 2 Fusion radios and 4 DMR - HT, base and mobile), I have mostly reverted to using hotspots. I enjoy DMR (Brandmeister) the most, but only with an RFinder hotspot (still a lot of programming). DSTAR is by far the easiest to program with the hotspot - only program 1 frequency, change reflectors via the DR mode (Openspot 1 & 2). I'm not too worried about using the internet backbone as without the internet, most of these digital repeaters would not be linked anyway. Fusion rooms and Wires X not too active. Many linked FM systems around here via UHF linking. Over 100 repeaters on 2m, 220 and 70 cm in SE Wisconsin. With so many local systems, there is mostly quiet (sandbaggers). In mobile travels east of Mississippi River, most (local) activity is FM, but DV allows you to better reach back home. WA9RYO

@donaldsmith3048 Жыл бұрын

My first radio is a AT 878UVPlus DMR. Ran out of memory for users long ago, but it stil works. I have been thinking about getting a DSTAR but many people are working on ways to put them all together so talking on one goes on all of them.. only local I think but when it is working I can talk to all the digital modes around me. DMR is a programming trouble but sounds best.

@PaulieShortcuts 2 жыл бұрын

Good vid Jason. If I have a Ft3d and open spot 3. Could it communicate with a business band that is encrypted dmr? I’m pretty sure the ft3d wouldn’t even transmit outside licensed frequencies.

@jss672006 3 жыл бұрын

Good video thanks!

@jneale5204 Жыл бұрын

I have one of each. Anytone 878 for DMR, Icom ID-5100 for DSTAR and the Yaesu FTM-400 for YSF. We don't have a DSTAR repeater in the area anymore. I still keep the ID-5100 in my truck because some of the areas I go to for work have DSTAR, We have DMR and Fusion in the area and both work good. I even have the FTM-400 set up as a PDN. With that being said YSF is my favorite mode. KM4NHN

@RodLittle 3 жыл бұрын

DMR works best for me YMMV - so your videos on DMR are much appreciated

@pd3jaghamradio509 3 жыл бұрын

Great video, i love the C4FM WiresX and YSF , but i have them all dmr & Dstar& C4FM 73' from the Netherlands Jason Jan PD3JAG.

@500gwr 2 жыл бұрын

Been using the Anytone 878UVII Plus on the Dallas repeater with a lot of success. Would like a hot spot - looking at the Bridgecom skybridge: waiting for some reviews before I buy.

@dont4450 4 ай бұрын

Great review

@swedesspeedshop2518 Жыл бұрын

So listen to these guys talk and get what you want . Got it 👍

@NorthCountryHam 3 жыл бұрын

I have my AT878 plus, and my 991A w/ C4FM, I have used both, and its a toss up for me, I'm still tweaking my programming on the Anytone . I have to go through my pi-star to connect at home, I don't reach the repeater w/ the HT unless I'm out driving

@dmb3428 3 жыл бұрын

I need to look more into the different varieties, 2m-70cm seems dead here at times so I have a hard time justifying investing in another rig for it so having a d-star option in addition to may make sense

@havok4103 Жыл бұрын

So, good video but what about the features of each? I watched a video showing the dstar can do simplex to a single callsign keeping the signal mute from others, im not aware of the ability for fusion to do that, i think fusion only has groups to join right?

@jamesa4958 Жыл бұрын

Thank you

@jeffreydonaldson3708 2 жыл бұрын

I have a Yaesu FT70 that of course does System Fusion. There are quite a few repeaters in my area that will handle Fusion. Right in my home town probably 2 to 3 miles away is an active DMR repeater. I could hit it with a dummy load. I guess that will be the way to go for digital.

@bluewatermike9249 3 жыл бұрын

Thank you, and had one question. How did you decide on a frequency to use in the hotspot? All the vidoes I watched just pick one and keep moving through the set up. I will be using fusion because I have a Yaesu HT and there is a fusion repeater within reach. I did also get the DMR ID as you suggested in another video, and didn't know if the mode had a bearing on the frequency you choose. Thanks again. KE8RDW

@BennyCFD 2 жыл бұрын

If there no DMR repeaters nearby you can use any frequency you want. Just set low power in the DMR code plug settings.

@tiagoguizzo3876 3 жыл бұрын

I like them all, I think all digital modes have their place but I to my ears system fusion, specially on an FT-70D, has the best audio quality.

@QRPadventures 3 жыл бұрын

Agreed!

@mcdeadsquirrel 3 жыл бұрын

Great video !!!! Thank you !!!! '73

@rjlewis3932 3 жыл бұрын

I've been using digital for about 2 years now. First, I've never bothered programming a digital repeater frequncy into my radios. I only use hot spots. DMR is the least expensive and most active, TG 3100 during the day and 91 any other time. I can bridge to the most popular YSF room, America-Link via TG 31656. YSF and WIRES-X is an expensive mess. I use a Yaesu 70D, but sometimes have issues with WIRES-X connectivity. There are 2 secondary rooms, American Ragchew and Alabama Link which are not very busy. D-Star, even 30C and 1C aren't used nearly as much as they were when I first got in to digital. I also use Blue DV Ambe 3000 server wirelessly on an Android device connected to a Thumb DV plugged into a RPi 3W. With that setup, I can access all 3 modes seamlessly without ANY programming.

@SbrGrendel65 3 жыл бұрын

I’ve got all three around 10-12 miles away around me, but DMR has one 2.4 miles away. So with that being that way I’m leaning to DMR. About to take test real soon...

@K5ORD 2 жыл бұрын

Newbie question… Can saved frequency settings (channels) be saved with alpha-numeric names? If no, which DV HT’s can label channels with alpha characters?

@docmcr1953 3 жыл бұрын

Super video! I applauded for $5.00 👏👏

@HamRadio2 3 жыл бұрын

Thanks!

@N9IBZED 3 жыл бұрын

I am in an area where I need to use a hotspot because I don't have any repeaters in my area that that I can hit reliably I have an AnyTone 878 that I use with my hotspot now but want to try something else out that is easier to program and or if need be change settings from the radio without using programming software so am trying yo choose between dstar and YSG i can only afford to get one radio but can't figure out which yo get which would you get if you wrre in my position and why

@hbryant1971 2 жыл бұрын

P25 was "introduced" in 1994 with Motorola Astro for LAPD. The audio is quite "funky" due to old CODECS. 28 year old technology which is still the public safety standard today.

@Porty1119 10 ай бұрын

Modern P25 radios use the same AMBE vocoder used by DMR. Phase 1 (FDMA) sounds better than DMR, Phase 2 (TDMA) sounds about the same as DMR, but with superior noise cancellation due to the target market.

@Rusty-Williams 3 жыл бұрын

The school system I am retired from went with Kenwood NXDN for our business radio system. I was in charge of all the HT's and used the NXDN software to reprogram them. (I got that simply because I was the only ham operator in the school system and only one who knew anything about radios) I got used to the audio sound and from your video DMR and YSF are the closest in the way they sound. YSF is a "little" better than NXDN and DMR is just a "little" bit worse, but not much. I'm thinking of going digital here, but just checking out all three to see which will be the best fit for me. 73 de KB9TMP

@HamRadioLiveShow Жыл бұрын

Nice video Jason. I have a request for a show with information about various digital modes. I don’t have a repeater I could get locally to show these. I’d like to use your video that very well explain all of these loads. I’ll be sure to present your channel and put a link in the description to your channel. I live in “the desert of digital” lol. Not a lot of repeaters close by to interface with. I appreciate all you do to help advance the knowledge of the Amateur Radio. You put a lot of work in on your channel. Thank you for all the hours of work you put in. All my best to you and your family Jason, Larry

@KC1PDW Жыл бұрын

I FT-3dr running a pi-star raspberry pi zero. i would like to see videos on setting up repeaters for 10 meters and yaesu and dmr for my area. thank you for your videos they help a lot. and HRCC , K8MRD,KM4ACK

@adnassiamarador9547 Жыл бұрын

I have two VHF radios. I live in South Florida. I would like to connect with Jamaica because my brother Shankar Maragh is missing there. I want to know which radio can connect there. I could make contacts on Echolink but recently Jamaica is not logged in.

@rider275 Жыл бұрын

I am new to HAM radio. I located a DSTAR repeater near me. Are there older DSTAR radios that you would recommend? Thank you.

@MrRicksho Жыл бұрын

have a question for you. i have a raspberry pi 4 that i use exclusively for running hamclock. is it possible to use this Pi and build a hotspot to use Digital voice modes for use on my ft5d radio? do u know the steps for building this?

@DineroyvidaenLA 10 ай бұрын

Which system would be better if I am planning to be full time living in an rv traveling throughout the country and going to Alaska, Baja eventually.. thank you

@stacksmasher 3 жыл бұрын

One thing for sure Digital sounds very good!

@earlsimmons5497 Жыл бұрын

I agree with you regarding DMR. I haven't used YSF but have both dstar and DMR and like DMR much better.

@jerry_satcom 2 жыл бұрын

I have at least one radio for all the digital modes (D-Star, Fusion, DMR, P25, and even NXDN), plus a Wires-X node and a bunch of mmdvm’s. (Not to mention a few AllStar nodes too.). Comparing the DV modes isn’t something I really like doing as it’s kind of like comparing oranges and tangerines, but DMR is very cheap to get into (there are many DMR CCR’s), plus if someone new learns DMR first, the other modes will be extremely simple afterwards. Not that DMR is overly complex, but it does involve some simple TDMA multiplexing. Having worked with mux’d supergroup trunks consisting of hundreds of channels before, mux’ing two 6.25 KHz channels (TimeSlots in DMR terminology) is trivial. The downsides to DMR is that there isn’t much dynamic audio range when it’s being funneled through a 6.25 KHz straw. Also, DMR gets its roots from the commercial world in Europe, so using it for amateur use is kind of like putting a square peg into a round hole, same with P25 and NXDN. D-Star and Fusion were created by amateur radio for amateur radio and imo, the reflectors on those modes tend to carry more interesting QSO’s. Try them all out and see which you like. By starting with DMR, if you aren’t sure about Fusion (or P25), you can use crossmode to get a slight feel of their reflectors before investing in an actual radio for them. Yes, there are apps too like DroidStar, but the AQ won’t be as good as a native radio. Also; by having native radios for the modes, you can use them also with just repeaters or even simplex’s. Just because they are digital doesn’t mean they have to be internet linked, it just means they are digital. Have fun and explore them all, but imo, it probably makes most sense to start with DMR if you want to check them all out eventually. I’m now into FreeDV (a HF DV mode).

@Gravelbomber 3 жыл бұрын

DMR is huge in Illinois, especially the Chicago area. You can go pretty much anywhere and be in range of at least 1 DMR repeater...with an HT. I was trying to decide what to get next, and ended up getting the openspot 3, instead of another radio. KC9OSX

@buttyug Жыл бұрын

I’m New to the digital RF concept. Is Wires X the only one that you can gateway into rooms from say 20 miles away if you can be received by the node? Looks like it can be done with C4FM or analog with DTMF codes. I hope this is wrong and can be done at usual repeater distances with other modes as I like dstar mobiles and the DMR Anytone 578. Hotspots just don’t make any sense to me, if I have direct internet access then I already have access encrypted voice calls across multiple platforms 🤷🏽‍♂️

@echo-hotel 2 жыл бұрын

I still have no idea what these are. I’m new waiting on my call sign. Have an ic-705 with d-star or I’m stuck with that for now one repeater near me (10 miles) that I’m not sure I can hit in the mountains of WV

@EricFullwood 3 жыл бұрын

I've had my Extra Class license for about 3 years. Tried everything from AM to FT8. CW is the only thing I find interesting. Talking on the air never really grabbed me. CW SOTA is my passion.

@WillLeingang 2 жыл бұрын

100% sincere in saying you are an inspiration to me!

@swedesspeedshop2518 Жыл бұрын

99% of conversations are small talk . Weather, radio equipment, gardening etc very rarely does it get interesting past that

@spiritzweispirit1st638 3 жыл бұрын

Thank You! Your Sooo Listentoable' and Way Fair!😶👍

@mhpreach 2 жыл бұрын

From my perspective. I would like to see basics of DStar. The Basicsbof Fusion. The basics of P-25. Been on DMR a number of years both as a user and a two radio tech. Would like to try DStar don’t know what rooms reflectors to go try. I have two DStar icoms have used much.

@MrSparks54 3 жыл бұрын

I have DMR, DStar and YSF, personally I like DMR more than the other digital modes but as you say, they are all good.

@TheBluntNinja 3 жыл бұрын

What about DMR do you like that makes it top your list?

@MrSparks54 3 жыл бұрын

@@TheBluntNinja DMR for me is easier to use and seems to be more stable (dgitizes less).

@VintageElectronicsGeek 2 жыл бұрын

Thinking I would learn about these modes...what is it? After watching this video, I still don't know. Was a HAM operator but got out of it shortly after Echolink started, to many operators sounded like CBers....that hasn't changed....just now getting back into it. The search continues.... ~Jack, VEG

@TheNoCodeTech 3 жыл бұрын

#ThNHR #TeamReplay for the win! Great video man.

@billbeam8069 Жыл бұрын

What would you recommend as a setup for someone just getting into DMR? I live in Tulsa, OK and I have a couple of DMR repeaters here in town. Bill kd5qhr

@kg5muc706 3 жыл бұрын

i have all 3. like them all

@N9IBZED 3 жыл бұрын

I am trying to decide which way I want to go I have DMR right now but because of my bad eyesight and the way I need my computer st up in order for me to be able to use it I can’t use the programming software needed to program my Anytone 878 because the software will not work with my computer and I would like to be able to do my own programming without having to depend on someone else to get it done I do have to use my hotspot because there are no repeaters that I can hit in my area from my location and am now trying to decide on either DStar or fusion I can only afford to get one radio and am not sure which way to go for the next radio purchase also I would like to be able o program it from the front panel in case I am out somewhere and run across something I don’t have in my radio yet so any input would be of great help in making my decision as to which way to go thanks and have a great day

@drfrequency Жыл бұрын

What is the HT that you are using third and last to make the listening to DMR?

@mykhal Жыл бұрын

I was curious too. Looked at other videos, and it seems like RFinder B1.

@wcgems 3 жыл бұрын

You may have already done this but should do a comparison between the ZUMSPOT and the TGIF

@greggould4275 5 ай бұрын

COMPLETE Newbie here, wanting to really get into this this year.. I live in a mountain town in Cali. I'm building out a CB station with a President Washington (and will soon get a solarcon a99). I also want to eventually get my HAM license, but, am looking for a good digital HAM radio.. I looked at a map, and the local small airport has a DSTAR repeater (about 1 mile away, maybe less) , and there is an Echolink and Allstar repeaters within 10 miles as well. Is the choice of DSTAR, DMR, etc just settings on a HAM radio, or, would I look for one that specifically can tap into those?

@HamRadio2 5 ай бұрын

You need a DSTAR radio to do DSTAR, DMR radio to do DMR, etc. Find out what is near your location and get a radio for those modes and repeaters.

@TheHonarable1 3 жыл бұрын

Can anyone tell me what repeaters are prevalent in the NY/NJ area?

@bev8200 2 жыл бұрын

Does DMV require the internet? Im looking to make a small network for my neighborhood that can reach out in an emergency situation. I have an analog in place but I want to understand digital and it’s limitations.

@HamRadio2 2 жыл бұрын

Do you mean DMR? No it doesn't *require* internet. You can setup a stand-alone DMR or DSTAR or YSF repeater the same way that you can an analog repeater. You can then *choose* to connect a DMR repeater to the internet to expand its reach, just the same way you can with an analog repeater via Echolink or Allstar. Most people choose to connect the DMR repeater to the internet so that it opens up a whole world of talkgroups (literally) But the mode itself doesn't require internet.

@bev8200 2 жыл бұрын

@@HamRadio2 thank you

@NewZealandAmerican 3 жыл бұрын

In the Chicago area APCO P25 which most AMERICAN public safety uses for choice of digital voice is very popular with many Repeaters. Also another voice mode very popular in the Chicago area is "P26" 🤣

@horaciopetrera4753 3 жыл бұрын

best 73 From LU1BJW, a true D-Star believer.

@rickwaldron3278 2 жыл бұрын

I’m new and still studying. Do you need a hotspot to use any of the modes you are talking about? DMR,DSTAR,YSR

@daveborchard2019 7 ай бұрын

What are the popular and active YSF and DMR networks equivalent to the active RFC030/C, 30 Charlie?

@oldblindsonny8476 3 жыл бұрын

I am using analog mode but thinking of going either d m r or DSTAR

@USAFJUNKIE 3 жыл бұрын

I already decided to use fusion because I like the audio quality and potential for the Group Monitor function if out with friends. Plus, I like that I can use YSF2DMR through my hotspot. That said, I'm curious what mode you'd recommend to someone who travels a lot for work, making the types of repeaters near the user a non-factor.

@whome9936 2 жыл бұрын

Goodness! I'm a technical editor, new to amateur radio, and I need only read the title of this video to know that ham is lost in acronyms. (I'm not blaming this channel; it's everywhere.) Ironically, a hobby centered on communication has a high barrier to entry because it is bad at...wait for it...communication. Jargon is an impediment to meaning.

@HamRadio2 2 жыл бұрын

I suggest you start at the beginning. Not every video I post is for someone who is brand new. Being a technical editor wouldn't help you in any field that has its own jargon, terms and acronyms.

@whome9936 2 жыл бұрын

@@HamRadio2 Yeah. I just edited my comment to indicate I was not blaming your content or channel. Sorry for any ambiguity. I don't claim that being an editor should help me overcome the problem-only recognize it.

@seeyditti Жыл бұрын

How do I know whats around me? Is there a map somewhere?

@n2kto 3 жыл бұрын

I would love to chat with you about a similar type of video but based on what digital mode is best in an Emergency/Disaster. N2KTO

@andrewd4890 3 жыл бұрын

It wasn’t clear initially which mode was being played. The hotspot screen probably showed it but i couldn’t read that at the time. As you were setting out to demonstrate each mode it would have been really helpful if you had announced each mode as it started. Edit: ok after watching again in full screen mode I could read the pistar screen and see what mode was being played. Apart from that, good idea to demo each and your advice to buy whatever suits the local situation is good. Vk1da.

@HamRadio2 3 жыл бұрын

The hotspot screen and the Pi-star dashboard both displayed what mode was being used. I did mention each one also, but not at the beginning, but it was there. Easy to read from the Dashboard also. Additionally, it was obvious which radio I was using for each mode, too.

@neilspector9221 Жыл бұрын

I am in an area that has several DSTAR repeaters.We have one System Fusion and one DMR repeater. So I have one of each radio...

@braintrusts 2 жыл бұрын

Josh, I appreciate your videos, but this review only compares the three digital modes when using a Hot Spot and an HT. You left out repeaters and Simplex. Please do the comparisons on Simplex.

@saddlebrookesilversmithand9493 3 жыл бұрын

Didn't learn as much as I thought I would/should.

@HarryHydro 5 ай бұрын

Ever play with DV 700D mode on hf 14.236? That’s USB, not FM, but I’ve had clean audio - if you call it that - on signals that barely move the needle. I’ve been trying to compare that to DSTAR on HF.

@HamRadio2 5 ай бұрын

Haven't done that, no