Guan Video观视频工作室 只有选举，没有选择就是美式民主！

HongKongers should join the Dalai Lama cliques in India. Very free country where you can pee and shit every where. Freedom, Democracy, free speech and opium is everywhere and cheap.

jimmy poo

Shut the music and re-upload this video.

Guan Video观视频工作室 你这几乎是一天0.1万的订阅量啊，赞👍加油

i agree totally , HK depends on China for its food / water and economy ..hasn't even got its own army . the nearest is the police force which they keep bashing !!!

He is so WRONG!! The reason why Hong Kong was prosperous was not of China!! It was because Hong Kong’s location and got very awesome transportation. People around the world could travel through Flights and Ships easily to Hong Kong. Hong Kong was prosperous since the mid 1970s. At that time, ICAC was found for Anti-Corruption and business people around the world believed that they could put in their trust in Hong Kong. Even in terms of entertainment / fashion industry, Hong Kong got influenced from Japan, Britain and the United States. Hong Kong people could enjoy Sushi a lot earlier than the people in Mainland China. China’s prosperous time was in 2000s. But before that, Hong Kong had donated a lot of clothes, food and money to China after China experienced catastrophes (such as earthquakes and floods). Most people in Hong Kong feel that the Hong Kong is doing a poor job is because it’s packed everywhere including hospitals, it’s pharmacies and jewelry shops everywhere when Hong Kong government allows too much visitors from Mainland. And it’s getting harder for the young people to get a house and they notice the new immigrants from China could actually own the houses much sooner so they feel hopeless. I want to explain that sometimes it’s just the Hong Kong people are seeing the HK government’s doing terrible job so they protest by walking and ask the governors to step down. Sometimes it has nothing to do with China’s government or people living in China. So people in China really don’t have to be over-sensitive whenever they protest.

@@ivyonic very good analysis but it is also true that hkong's market could be diversified as china gains more economic power worldwide. The fact that china is now the NO 2 in terms of GDP opens more markets to hkong. Consider this point as well although i agree with what you said.

@@jackyyoyo2005 for sure hong kong wouldnt be free at least 50 yrs.🤣🤣🤣🤣

@@ivyonic lol u didn't graduate high school did u ?

bz2316 是的，英國🇬🇧是沒有給香港人很多民主自由，但是香港有保持社會廉潔的廉正公署，所有人都不需有任何避忌去講或批評任何東西（包括香港政府），如果你自己去看看google images search for “Hong Kong June Fourth Protest”, 以前香港人因為看了天安門的大學生只是為了「反貪污」就已經被坦克車處理掉了，香港人遊行示威為平反六四和有音樂會紀念捐款活動都可以和平的進行，警察和平的維持秩序，以前香港人常常遊行抗議加價，政府人員是會出來收信的，警察真的和新紥師兄的梁潮偉一樣廉潔自律受歡迎可信賴的。其實你可以看到香港人有不斷的捐款救災的，很愛中國的，只是對共產制度有些憂慮，不竟香港有很多從中國偷渡來的，以往中國有很多批鬥而令有些失去親人、藝術作品、財產 - 見過鬼是會怕黑的會有陰影的， 他們清楚知道言論無自由和有自由的分別。你看看現在2014的雨傘運動和今次為要求撤回送中法案的遊行，他們只是害怕失去言論自由，那些遊行示威者極大部分都只是穿著黑衣拿著雨傘行行企企和靜坐，你看看政府已經説他們是暴徒，夾雜在中間的警察已經放橡膠子彈和催淚彈去鎮壓示威者了，警察已經不理是記者或老人家或女人或只是經過的都很無理的暴力對待了。其實香港人也看去中國玩、做生意的，但是中國沒有KZfaq,Facebook,言論自由，就算大灣區有多漂亮，很多香港人也不願去。其實很多香港人並不是想要港獨，有些只是要求香港政府體量一下，讓他們繼續有言論自由到2046年，而不是什麼也不願面對，只是找警察甚至白衫的黑社會人士去打壓他們！

He is so WRONG!! The reason why Hong Kong was prosperous was not of China!! It was because Hong Kong’s location and got very awesome transportation. People around the world could travel through Flights and Ships easily to Hong Kong. Hong Kong was prosperous since the mid 1970s. At that time, ICAC was found for Anti-Corruption and business people around the world believed that they could put in their trust in Hong Kong. Even in terms of entertainment / fashion industry, Hong Kong got influenced from Japan, Britain and the United States. Hong Kong people could enjoy Sushi a lot earlier than the people in Mainland China. China’s prosperous time was in 2000s. But before that, Hong Kong had donated a lot of clothes, food and money to China after China experienced catastrophes (such as earthquakes and floods). Most people in Hong Kong feel that the Hong Kong is doing a poor job is because it’s packed everywhere including hospitals, it’s pharmacies and jewelry shops everywhere when Hong Kong government allows too much visitors from Mainland. And it’s getting harder for the young people to get a house and they notice the new immigrants from China could actually own the houses much sooner so they feel hopeless. I want to explain that sometimes it’s just the Hong Kong people are seeing the HK government’s doing terrible job so they protest by walking and ask the governors to step down. Sometimes it has nothing to do with China’s government or people living in China. So people in China really don’t have to be over-sensitive whenever they protest.

I am also one of the 60s, I second your opinion.

SFresident omg..here comes the experts.

@@ivyonic 你说的六四坦克车碾压学生，这是谣言。现代社会谣言更容易蛊惑很多不明真相的人。请在获得确凿的证据前不要随便发表评论。香港现在是“高度自治”，人民的权利比英国统治时期要好得多。如果按当初回归时中国政府的承诺：保持香港现有的制度不变，那就应该民主，选举权不给香港人，总督由大陆任命（像当年英国一样）。那样香港可能就不会有今天这么乱了，因为香港人只能当顺民了。大陆给了香港那么多优越条件，可是香港天天在攻击，抱怨大陆。很多香港人骨子里就不认自己的祖国。就拿送中条例来说，中国与世界许多国家都有引渡条例，这是国际惯例。罪犯须满足在香港和中国都是犯罪，才可引渡。这是非常合情合理的事情。可是香港人却产生那么大反弹，宁可让罪犯在香港逍遥法外，也不愿引渡中国。骨子里就是反中。

He is so WRONG!! The reason why Hong Kong was prosperous was not of China!! It was because Hong Kong’s location and got very awesome transportation. People around the world could travel through Flights and Ships easily to Hong Kong. Hong Kong was prosperous since the mid 1970s. At that time, ICAC was found for Anti-Corruption and business people around the world believed that they could put in their trust in Hong Kong. Even in terms of entertainment / fashion industry, Hong Kong got influenced from Japan, Britain and the United States. Hong Kong people could enjoy Sushi a lot earlier than the people in Mainland China. China’s prosperous time was in 2000s. But before that, Hong Kong had donated a lot of clothes, food and money to China after China experienced catastrophes (such as earthquakes and floods). Most people in Hong Kong feel that the Hong Kong is doing a poor job is because it’s packed everywhere including hospitals, it’s pharmacies and jewelry shops everywhere when Hong Kong government allows too much visitors from Mainland. And it’s getting harder for the young people to get a house and they notice the new immigrants from China could actually own the houses much sooner so they feel hopeless. I want to explain that sometimes it’s just the Hong Kong people are seeing the HK government’s doing terrible job so they protest by walking and ask the governors to step down. Sometimes it has nothing to do with China’s government or people living in China. So people in China really don’t have to be over-sensitive whenever they protest.

@@ivyonic If he is so wrong and you are so right, and Hongkong's prosperous is attributed to the good location and awesome transportation, Hong Kong should be still developing very fast. Cause the good location never changed. And I don't think the Hong Kong government was intended to slow down its economy, right?

Martin Jacques is the author of When China Rules the World, which explains the historical reason for China's rise. The book is not an advocacy of Chinese authoritarianism, but rather an explanation of why the authoritarian political system worked in developing countries like China. It provides a unique aspect that is totally different from the mainstream media. Good to read.

Dramastone thanks for the information! I look forward to reading his book.

kzfaq.info/get/bejne/n9OYiNB92dK-oKs.html One on TED, impressive.

rightful insight

对，有点喧宾夺主

战狼声声吓唬你

是的

请您听一下背景的噪音，制作人用这个音乐应该是纯属无奈hhh

Also it takes a foreigner to understand HK more than their locals, HK people should really wake up and see the truth, if China were to abandon HK then it will truly be the end of HK.

and when u said china should start from education. hongkongers come out and protest that china is eliminating hongkongers, their culture and cantonese....

他们都住在一两平米的笼子里，都忙着赚游行的钱，哪有空看这些

@Sigma Geranimo Yeah that assures those like the 'Brexit' bullshit never happens in China.

Explain.Why do you copy the west for more than 30 years now ...and still do. Was Mao better ? The Pol Pot regime you kept alive ?

@@nickiseb8910 I am not sure if you have watched Martin Jacques' series presentation. There are quite a few in KZfaq. If you said Chinese government has learnt a lot from the west, and by that you have to insist it's copying, fine. Martin has explained anyway.

Hong Kong’s been way more advanced and ahead of China for near a century. HK people don’t want to be arrested in the middle of the night because they protested etc. They also don’t want to worry about their economy collapsing if China’s does. China makes some Risky crazy and untried moves w it’s economy. The US nearly collapsed because of real estate and China’s building huge ghost cities where nobody lives to keep up their gdp. That seems super risky to me, somehow eventually things like that can one day catch up to you .

@@kevinodom2918 your ghost town story is debunked already, go visit one of the ghost city now, lol.

I think it’s HK own choice too choose their own transportation like you have nicely put out. I don’t totally agree with what you are saying because not all Chinese provinces and cities are like Shenzhen, Shanghai etc. Martin Jacques explained it well and it’s his point of view what’s his right. But he is mostly talking about the economy. You are all agreeing with him because it’s true to fuel your own thoughts that HK is bad without China. Does anyone brought a solution except integrating the HK people like xinjiang? You can compare the situation with a divorced couple and a kid. What’s the best for kid, it’s like one of the parents is forcing the kid.

I don't agree with the part that Hong Kong would "become" the heaven of criminal. Hong Kong would maintain the status of the heaven of criminal. Apart from this, I mostly agree until 22nd of July, which two groups of people were fighting in the MTR station of Yuen Long. It was shocking to me that the group of people who wore white shirt chases and beat the group of people who wore black shirt. Passengers on the train on Yuen Long station was also beaten up, despite not wearing black shirt and was not involved in the conflict between the group of white-shirts and black-shirts. That is triad act. Mass fighting in public; illegal assemble in public; they commited a lot of crimes. However, insufficient police force arrived to seperate the groups and arrest them. Moreover, some people in other videos claimed that the black-shirts deserve to be beaten up and none of the passengers were injured. However, the claim have not been proved and there were people that was not bewn involved in this conflict injured. Evidences have shown that the white-shirts and the black-shirts are opposite in political views. This, along with the previous events, made me worry that our freedom of speech and freedom of free of fear will be lost. It is not by legal sense, but cyber bullying have got worse.

@@dlareg7201 Sorry to disappoint you but I have nothing to do with the CCP. Try not to jump to conclusion.

@@jasonp500 Haven not heaven.

By luck, fools believe what he said. That unlucky for those fools.

Kamwai Chan Definitely ture. It just indicates the british hypocrisy. Actions should speak louder than words.

I agree, they will always think colonial British rule is always better because they are ignorant to the point of no return. China is the future and the future for the Hong Kong people but too ignorant to understand. Sad...

Very true! Spot on!! I live in UK. It’s in a shamble at the moment. Knife crimes, drugs, homelessness. The rich are getting richer. A mini America, where 100m Americans live pay check to pay check. Looks good on the surface- that’s what democracy is about here. Look close and it is predatory capitalism at work, millionaire or billionaire is not good enough, trillionaire is what some greedy lot aspire to become.

Tan: why don’t you move to China? Guarantee you want . I know media is full of it but China is turning into and really been a police state . A credit system that judges you on your behavior? Sounds nice but who makes the rules and the abuse and insanity that will come of this will not be fun to watch if you live there Uk and America is a mess right now but if I left China would be about a 1000 on my list of places to move to. I hope they’re successful and it all works out but I wouldn’t bet my life on it

thats why... hongkong tycoon can maintain their wealth while the poor getting poorer

我之前也看过

所以言论自由，只是他们的言论才能自由，其他的没有自由。

另一个频道几个星期前发过

民主自由就是最新型的邪教

西方所谓民主：你是民，我是主。

不是不知道是不愿意承认罢了，当年他们瞧不起的内地人已经比他们进步富强这个现实让香港人尤其年轻的人很难接受。他们还活在比内地更接近西方的自我陶醉里。

全世界華人族群最惡劣的就是。。。。你知道我指的是誰！

@@pcstar123 其实大多数香港人还是很好的，主要是些年轻人太容易被蛊惑了。

@@wowotou 脑子问题，救不了

@@wowotou 其實所有族群中絕大多數都是好的，他們就是壞的比其他人多一些！ 我並無抹黑所有人的意思，只是做個比較！

赞同！纯粹没必要的背景音乐，访谈节目，又不是纪录片。

加音乐是为了掩盖噪音的无奈之举，谅解一下吧

😂👍🏼

He is so WRONG!! The reason why Hong Kong was prosperous was not of China!! It was because Hong Kong’s location and got very awesome transportation. People around the world could travel through Flights and Ships easily to Hong Kong. Hong Kong was prosperous since the mid 1970s. At that time, ICAC was found for Anti-Corruption and business people around the world believed that they could put in their trust in Hong Kong. Even in terms of entertainment / fashion industry, Hong Kong got influenced from Japan, Britain and the United States. Hong Kong people could enjoy Sushi a lot earlier than the people in Mainland China. China’s prosperous time was in 2000s. But before that, Hong Kong had donated a lot of clothes, food and money to China after China experienced catastrophes (such as earthquakes and floods). Most people in Hong Kong feel that the Hong Kong is doing a poor job is because it’s packed everywhere including hospitals, it’s pharmacies and jewelry shops everywhere when Hong Kong government allows too much visitors from Mainland. And it’s getting harder for the young people to get a house and they notice the new immigrants from China could actually own the houses much sooner so they feel hopeless. I want to explain that sometimes it’s just the Hong Kong people are seeing the HK government’s doing terrible job so they protest by walking and ask the governors to step down. Sometimes it has nothing to do with China’s government or people living in China. So people in China really don’t have to be over-sensitive whenever they protest. The United Kingdom didn’t give Hong Kong people a lot of democracy and freedom. However, Hong Kong got ICAC (The Anti-Corruption Agency). All people didn’t need to worry about whatever they said and they could criticize on anything (including the Hong Kong Government). If you go to see it yourself, search for “Hong Kong June Fourth Protest” at Google Images. In the past, Hong Kong people had seen the news how the Tiananmen’s College Students (who were just protesting for “Anti-Corruption”, and they were treated by tank cars. The Hong Kong people staged demonstrations to rehabilitate the June 4th peacefully. The police maintained order in peace. In the past, Hong Kong people often marched to protest against fare increases. Government officials came out to receive letters. The police got super good image and got nice recognition around the world. In fact, you can see that Hong Kong people have continued to donate money for disaster relief. They love China very much. They only have some worries about the communist system. In the past, a lot of people from Mainland China was fleeing to Hong Kong because of the Chinese Civil War. A lot of them had some lost their loved ones and masterpieces of art, property. They clearly know the difference of living with or without Freedom of Speech. How about you take a look at the umbrella movement in 2014 and the march to ask for the withdrawal of the bill happening now. They are just afraid of losing their freedom of speech. Most of those demonstrators are only wearing black clothes and holding umbrellas and sitting on the street. You can see the Hong Kong governor has said that they are thugs, the police in the middle have put rubber bullets and tear gas to suppress the demonstrators. The police have ignored the Freedom of Press, pushed and put unreasonable violence against the reporters or the elderly or women. In fact, Hong Kong people enjoy having fun and doing business in China, but China does not have KZfaq, Facebook, freedom of speech, even if the Dawan District is beautiful, many Hong Kong people are not willing to go. In fact, many Hong Kong people do not want Hong Kong independence. Some just ask the Hong Kong government to listen to them and promising that they will continue to have freedom of speech until 2046 as the document signed in 1984. But the Hong Kong governor, Ms. Lam Cheng (who got citizenship in U.K.) just doesn’t want to step down or fix any issues, she just appoints the police or even a white-shirted triad gangster to suppress the residents in Yuen Long.

正確 建制無能，不是好東西.... 三杈分立，没有了英国殖民主子， 運作不了.... 民国1911以来，花旗传教士式的“普世/改造”....沾上了，死路一条

精辟！

​@@ivyonic 这本来是最后的一段，但我还是想把它放到前面来： 其实，你的言论已经证明了一切，口口声声称大陆为“中国”就已经再明白不过地证明：你们根本不把自己当做是中国人。因此，我们14亿中国人需要让你们这些反动者明白一件事情，香港自古以来都是中国不可分割的一部分，就算所有700万香港人都想要独立，也不要忘记中国不止只有香港这700万人，中国还有14亿人，决定国家前途和命运的是所有中国人而不是仅仅700万人就可以做得了主的。台湾问题也是一样，想独立？问过14亿中国人没有？ 想脱离中国，可以，爱去哪去哪儿，我们举双手赞成不愿当中国人甘愿做洋狗的赶紧离开中国的土地，不要占着中国的资源还干着反中国的事情。中国的领土是我们的一代代祖先以无数鲜血和生命留下的基业，是全体中国人的财产。我相信大陆的所有14亿同胞，宁愿香港和台湾变成残垣断壁一片焦土，变成一个了无人烟的荒岛也不会同意中国的任何一寸国土被分割出去。在香港土地上的洋狗们，听清楚了吗？ 你上面这一切的解释太过牵强，而且超级虚伪，充满了历史虚无主义和偷换概念的小聪明。 香港现在失去言论自由了吗？中央政府有任何行动要钳制香港的言论自由吗？在英国殖民时期，你们香港人可以侮辱英女王吗？可以挑战英联邦的统治权威吗？可以做今天游行示威一样的事情吗？也许上面的问题你一个也答不出来，因为从你的言论就可以看出，你对香港的历史要么是一点都不了解，要么就是故意无视香港的历史，刻意美化殖民政府，刻意美化三等公民的生活地位和人权尊严。 如果以上的问题你有答案，那么只需拿出哪怕一例证据出来。不要用还没有发生的你们自己所臆测的事情来当做反华的借口。香港政府从未说过所有游行的人都是暴徒，从暴动发生的第一天起就已经很清楚地向全世界声明那些使用暴力的人才是暴徒。用偷换概念把所有参加和平游行的人都拉进来为你们背书从而为暴徒辩护简直是无耻之极！ 香港历年来对大陆的各种捐款，都是香港的爱国同胞和爱国商人、党政人士对大陆同胞的爱，但是这些人里面绝对不包括那些不把自己当做是中国人的“甘做英国狗”的反动者。你们不要把爱国者的善举也戴到自己的头上，像拉大多数和平游行的人为你们的暴动背书一样，用爱国人士的善举为你们背书。这样的行为太无耻、太卑鄙。 拿六四来说事，一样是你们反华叛国者惯常使用的伎俩。这世界上所有真正花过一点时间了解六四的人，都至少上过Wikipedia，至少看过西方媒体在KZfaq上的长达6个小时的六四全程录像。所有看过以上全程录像和维基百科的人都很清楚六四到底是一个什么事件，其发生的原因和背后的目的与今天的香港暴动和几年前的台湾太阳花运动一模一样。六四是一场针对共产党的颜色革命，是西方势力蛊惑学生、年轻人用最恶毒残忍的手段针对自己同胞的可怕残杀，是中华民族永远的痛，只要是中国人都不愿再回顾再提起这段伤心的往事。看看如今是谁在反复地揭中国人的伤疤就可以很清楚地明白这些人的险恶用心。

司馬閑都 这个SFresident是个脑残。真的到处都是这一段，还觉得自己很厉害。香港要是靠这群脑残，衰落是迟早的。让他们继续把香港搞死吧

殖民害死人，可以看到，一个独立自主的国家是多么重要。 香港格局太小，整体方向性的东西把握不住，只能陷入一种奇怪的漩涡，除非他们自己认识到必须大破大立，不然只会这样沉沦下去。

其实 世界上的 真正的 “道理” 就那么多。 只是人的智商不同，导致了认真的差异，很幸运，你跳出了泥潭。 未来 年入百万 RMB 不是梦

不同，台灣不是殖民政府，經濟發上台灣亦比較全面及獨立。台灣更多是政治上不同意大陸，而香港是自我身份上不認同大陸，覺得自己高人一等，事實是，世界已經變了。

Patrick Ng 台湾的殖民概念并不少…居然还能在岛上给日据时代的殖民者立雕像…而且改教材的课本已然20多年…这些年经过绿营的台独和蓝营独台的轮流洗脑…思想的反智有过之而无不及…台湾唯一拿的出手的也就是台积电了…在上一轮金融风暴的洗劫下…也变成了华尔街控股…好在人才比厂房更有用…吸引掉相关人才…台湾烂的更快

Albert Lin 台湾比起香港还是好不少的，至少台湾经济不是房地产寡头垄断，台湾的工业虽然在萎缩但任然占据经济的大头，说真的台湾2000万人，有一个微电子工业就能喂饱所有人了，同理韩国也一样。

大家可能都忘了幾個月後的RCEP，姓蔡的是絕對簽不到的，到時候他怎麼跟台灣人交代我們等著看：）

英國🇬🇧是沒有給香港人很多民主自由，但是香港有保持社會廉潔的廉正公署，所有人都不需有任何避忌去講或批評任何東西（包括香港政府），如果你自己去看看google images search for “Hong Kong June Fourth Protest”, 以前香港人因為看了天安門的大學生只是為了「反貪污」就已經被坦克車處理掉了，香港人遊行示威為平反六四和有音樂會紀念捐款活動都可以和平的進行，警察和平的維持秩序，以前香港人常常遊行抗議加價，政府人員是會出來收信的，警察真的和新紥師兄的梁潮偉一樣廉潔自律受歡迎可信賴的。其實你可以看到香港人有不斷的捐款救災的，很愛中國的，只是對共產制度有些憂慮，不竟香港有很多從中國偷渡來的，以往中國有很多批鬥而令有些失去親人、藝術作品、財產 - 見過鬼是會怕黑的會有陰影的， 他們清楚知道言論無自由和有自由的分別。你看看現在2014的雨傘運動和今次為要求撤回送中法案的遊行，他們只是害怕失去言論自由，那些遊行示威者極大部分都只是穿著黑衣拿著雨傘行行企企和靜坐，你看看政府已經説他們是暴徒，夾雜在中間的警察已經放橡膠子彈和催淚彈去鎮壓示威者了，警察已經不理是記者或老人家或女人或只是經過的都很無理的暴力對待了。其實香港人也看去中國玩、做生意的，但是中國沒有KZfaq,Facebook,言論自由，就算大灣區有多漂亮，很多香港人也不願去。其實很多香港人並不是想要港獨，有些只是要求香港政府體量一下，讓他們繼續有言論自由到2046年，而不是什麼也不願面對，只是找警察甚至白衫的黑社會人士去打壓他們！

我就知道你的回复区有轮子

@@ivyonic 估计你应该年纪不大，你需要向身边的长者了解下港英政府如何镇压67暴动的港人。你认为中国大陆的人不能上fb youtube ins就是很不自由，我也不多说什么，送你一句话"一道墙有两面，谁在墙里还不一定知道"。还有，fb youtube ins等都是美国平台，舆论战场你懂吗？

@@yeweix9474 应该还不算轮子。

@@ivyonic 还有你说的8964，至今还没看到坦克车碾压学生的视频，youtube也有当年真相的视频，军车被烧，解放军被打被烧。以前我跟你一样觉得64的学生很无辜，但是现在香港正上演一场"港版64"为当年牺牲的军人平反。

By luck, many fools believe what he said.

You were right. But it's not all the editor's fault, because if he doesn't, the leader may think he's not working.

@@pptskills Isn't that wierd so many documentaries from these state run channels have irrelevant music playing in the background. So many good contents are ruined in this way. A fake taste is added into them.

@@charlieq4255 I am a Chinese, I must admit that although we are very good at science and engineering skills, but in the design and other fields there is still a big gap. But things are getting better. It just takes some time.

It tells you something that those protests happened 20 years after the handover. The HK protests are a youth movement, not a people movement. They are mainly led and manned by 20 year olds who read the BBC about how Hong Kong was like before the handover. I have talked to many locals over time, and you can squash every single one of their arguments.

Hong Kong people don’t necessarily want democracy. Like all people, Hong Kongers want to improve their way of life. They want to be able to have a government and chief executive who serves Hong Kong people like other nations. Please read about Legco and how the Hong Kong government merely acts in the interest of business tycoons and mainlanders. If you’re a politician who is not “pro-China”, you are simply expelled from legco.

@@JC-rv6lo oh really? Then how come so many government plans are disrupted and stopped? How come those anti government politicians yelling around every single day? How come those anti government people destroy government buildings repeatedly? Pls look at the mere facts. And stop interfering with Chinese people internal affairs cuz u dunno how the Chinese live.

f k It’s simply because the legislative committee (which makes the laws in Hong Kong) by it’s nature, primarily benefits the business/insurance sector, therefore the chief executive and other politicians in power seek to play the sycophant toward Beijing at the expense of ordinary citizens. Believe it or not, their used to be a large percentage of Hong Kongers during British rule who wanted to expel the British (read 1967 Hong Kong riots). However this percentage substantially decreased when the government introduced policies after the riots which aimed to improve the social welfare of the citizens (reduced corruption for example). There were considerably less protests during the later era of British Hong Kong because there was little reason to protest against the government because they genuinely sought to serve and benefit the livelihoods of the people of Hong Kong. 2 million people don’t protest on the streets for no reason. The Hong Kong government has continually failed to address social issues, and because of the government failing to serve in the interests of the people, unpopular policies (Lantau island land reclamation, Macau Bridge, housing shortage) continue to be placed upon Hong Kong people. A well known example of the Hong Kong government failure is the housing issue. Cage homes are simply an embarrassment for a developed city, but this government fails to make any decisive action regarding the supply of homes because this will upset the business sector who have power in the legco. I will repeat my first comment in a way that you can understand: People in Hong Kong for more than a decade, have been angry at the current Hong Kong government because the government simply doesn’t care about the interests of the people, it’s all about money to Carrie Lam and the rest of the cronies in power. Anyone who has an understanding of the Hong Kong situation knows that it was only a matter of time before a situation like this occurred, because the majority of the population are simply NOT happy.

@@JC-rv6lo I'm sorry but you're not Chinese that's all. If you don't like China, get your ass out of the Chinese land.

英國🇬🇧是沒有給香港人很多民主自由，但是香港有保持社會廉潔的廉正公署，所有人都不需有任何避忌去講或批評任何東西（包括香港政府），如果你自己去看看google images search for “Hong Kong June Fourth Protest”, 以前香港人因為看了天安門的大學生只是為了「反貪污」就已經被坦克車處理掉了，香港人遊行示威為平反六四和有音樂會紀念捐款活動都可以和平的進行，警察和平的維持秩序，以前香港人常常遊行抗議加價，政府人員是會出來收信的，警察真的和新紥師兄的梁潮偉一樣廉潔自律受歡迎可信賴的。其實你可以看到香港人有不斷的捐款救災的，很愛中國的，只是對共產制度有些憂慮，不竟香港有很多從中國偷渡來的，以往中國有很多批鬥而令有些失去親人、藝術作品、財產 - 見過鬼是會怕黑的會有陰影的， 他們清楚知道言論無自由和有自由的分別。你看看現在2014的雨傘運動和今次為要求撤回送中法案的遊行，他們只是害怕失去言論自由，那些遊行示威者極大部分都只是穿著黑衣拿著雨傘行行企企和靜坐，你看看政府已經説他們是暴徒，夾雜在中間的警察已經放橡膠子彈和催淚彈去鎮壓示威者了，警察已經不理是記者或老人家或女人或只是經過的都很無理的暴力對待了。其實香港人也看去中國玩、做生意的，但是中國沒有KZfaq,Facebook,言論自由，就算大灣區有多漂亮，很多香港人也不願去。其實很多香港人並不是想要港獨，有些只是要求香港政府體量一下，讓他們繼續有言論自由到2046年，而不是什麼也不願面對，只是找警察甚至白衫的黑社會人士去打壓他們！ 中國人不應因將仇報

@@ivyonic 不愿意其实就是还不够痛，等到你什么都失去了，不要也得要。

@@ivyonic 言论自由是伪命题，阿桑奇被抓，斯诺登被迫逃离美国，美国拥有言论自由？

@@ivyonic 美国的言论自由是你能骂除了美国以外的国家，一旦说美国的坏话，你会被禁言

@@ivyonic 在美国你能骂总统,是因为政府是资本家的打工仔，但你要是在电影、平台讽刺资本家，你基本就凉了。卓别林拍了一部讽刺资本家，然后他被遣送出美国了。所以言论自由是伪命题

反對派認為這是香港政府的甚麼大白象工程， 將利益輸送給中央的一個借口。 也將這概念輸送給年青一輩， 你說的機會， 他們眼中只是幫中國賺錢而已。 與我何干的！ 他們不稀罕更諻論珍惜了。

他們要 吸大麻 要濫交 機遇發展什麽的 對他們浮雲一樣

其实除了港珠澳大桥 还有中深通道、珠深通道、广深跨海铁路… 将来只少有四条桥跨越珠江口 部分香港人太过自以为是

为了香港，港珠澳大桥，Y型桥，没有深圳出口，深圳的牺牲，香港知道吗？

@@shichangwang888 巨婴们永远不懂。如果深圳没有牺牲，这个桥的利用率就不知道高到哪里去了。

台湾和香港新一代都有深受当地片面教育毒害的影响，台湾的课改让台湾新一代年轻人对中国历史和近代史一知半解，却以自由民主为旗帜反对大陆，污名化大陆释出的善意。台湾内部新一代都有天然独的称号，多数年轻人认为蔡英文在外交上有突出台湾是一个国家而非地区的概念而支持她，香港也一样依然认为香港的自由民主法制社会是仰赖港英政府，缺忽略过去30年中国的包容和优待，特别是教会力量在香港的教育系统内的无声操纵，让很多人在信仰的名义上多了一层反中的色彩。这次香港爆发游行，背后的在港宗教势力绝对不能忽略，特别是大多数港校和教会都有合作或半合作的关系时。

Chen Jeff 日出来的老婆，打出来的孝子，武统唯一正确方式