I own a 2023 MINI Cooper S Convertible, Iconic trim, in nanuq white metallic, which is essentially the same vehicle as the ‘24 model, but a bit less expensive. And of course, the convertible will always be noisier than the coupe because of the canvas roof. Would I change my car for a ‘25 coupe? NO! Even though the coupe looks nicer in the exterior, especially in that ocean wave green, the F56 generation MINI is more ergonomically friendly, I believe because it has knobs, toggle switches, and buttons, which are easier, and safer while driving than the new F66 generation which rely almost exclusively on touching the infotainment screen. Also, I appreciate having the instrument cluster right in front while I’m driving, instead of that pop-up screen that obstructs frontal visibility in the ‘25 model. I also appreciate the fact that in my car I can opt for manipulating a knob to control the infotainment screen instead of exclusively relying on touching the screen in the ‘25 model, and smudging the glass in the process. One thing though that I wish my car had is the adaptive cruise control that is available in the ‘25 model Iconic trim. Although I’ve driven the 2025 MINI Countryman, and I think that I would prefer that vehicle over the ‘24 Countryman- more power, more cargo space, more luxury items.

Damn, not only did MINI neuter the new model by taking away its 'pipes', but it now sounds wimpy when you rev it. 🙁

Great review Anthony. Personally I prefer the 24 for looks and that sweet exhaust note. The both look super fun to drive but too low to the ground for this guy lol 😁 Happy Friday to you and wishing you a great weekend!

+ for new are the powered driver seat and gloss wheel arches and rocker panels (JCW option). - for the exhaust note and dash.

New one sounds like a lawnmower.

You left off important fact that that new mini Cooper 2 door S does not have paddle shifters. That’s a deal breaker for me. While the dual clutch transmission is great I also enjoy manually shifting. That they left off paddle shifters on the two door Cooper S really unbelievable.

2024 for me

Too many aspects of driver involvement have gone with the 2025 model. Gear lever, paddle shifters, handbrake, iDrive controller, toggle switches. And they've taken away the seat extenders and seatback map pockets. I might get used to the exterior rear view but the front is just too plain. Surprised the window sticker shows the engine is from Germany as thought all MINI engines were made at Hams Hall in England. Good comparison Anthony.

in the '25 there are two trims - Signature (Plus) and Iconic - the JCW "trim" is for overseas we'll get a "real" JCW later this fall/winter and it will be (as it should be) it's own model not a trim. MINI has consolidated trims (again) for the current model year ('25) added more content in those trims and actually lowered the prices a bit when compared to the '24 model year if optioned close to what the '25 has.

From the comparison, is it better to spend the money on the new Mini?

2024 hands down! They moved away from the exhaust and the feel of being in a cockpit. There is a difference

I just got a used 2013 I really want a modern one now😂

2024 👍❤

The new mini sounds awful . Like a vacuum cleaner 😅

2024

I'll definitely keep my 2024 mini cooper s. New one looks cheap and the design is bland.

Mini fucked up BIG TIME with the 2025 models. The interior is awful on so many levels. The dash and doors have this nasty abrasive texture that is a dirt and dust magnet and near impossible to clean. Then they put that massive screen in the center that looks like ass. The looks on the outside are mundane and terrible. Just everywhere you look, this thing is a travesty!