سیدنا علی نے نبی پاک کے حکم کے مطابق تحریر محمد رسول اللہ نہیں مٹایا حق کس کے ساتھ؟ سیدہ فاطمہ اور علی المرتضی کا اختلاف ہوا کہ علی نے شادی کا اردہ کیا حق کس کے ساتھ؟ علی و عباس کا اختلاف ہوا حق کس کے ساتھ؟ حسن و علی اختلاف میں حق کس کے ساتھ؟

Hazart Ali he 4 sal hokomat Chali hu. kysy hukomat kaim nhe hue? bachon wali batain

Beshak

Ameen

Proof?

Hume yah baat pata hai par 1400 phlae Muslamno ko yah baat nahi pata thi. Hamari lslam ki samag too Sahabh sae bhi bhar gi.

JazakAllah

Faisla qayamat me Allah karein ge

Sary Pakistani have no mind 😂😂😂😂😂

Usman RA ko Shahid kia GIA Kyu? qatil kon wo ik khalifa the

Truly written brother. God bless you....!!

We are not sunni we are muslim of our caliph abu bakr umar usman Ali muwaviya hasan (ra)

you're right

सही

I am also Sunni But hazrat ali r a par hum quraban jaye wo hamare imaan ka hissa hai

yahan motadil ka matlab hy k dono ko sahe kaha jaey aur sb khush rahen ashra mubashra k hoty, aur umr (ra) jnka boht kehty hein jo keh gaey k mei apny bad en 6 k ilawa kisi ko ehl nahe pata abu bakr (ra) tu munkreen e zakat k khilaf bhe alam buland karen aur jaiz rahen aur ali (as) baghyo ko maren aur MOTADiL view ki bat ki jaey yani just WAH

Seedha seedha sahih hadees ki mukhalifat men tareekh ki zaeef riwayaat ka sahara lekar bani ummayah ko protect kar raha hai, unke jaraim par parda daal raha hai. Yeh shaks jab bhi ahlebait ki baat aati hai hadees ko chor kar Taarikh ki baat karta hai. Mene aik video men suna tha k yeh imam Mahdi (as) ka bhi munkir hai jis ke baarey takreeban Abu Daood men 12 sahih ahadees mojood hen. How he just manage to throw all the ahadees in the bin so easily and leave people in wah wah. Just wow!

@@mjasyed So Allah SWT made a mistake and forgot to mention about Imam Mehdi in Quran. Also kindly give one authentic hadeeth where Huzoor Paak SAW named Imam Mehdi and said he will come back. For god sake stop following kesay khani or stories and make them religion.

بہت خوب۔

@@mjasyed mje ye baten ap k yahan kn c tareekh biyan ki gai or ap kis sahih hadees ki bat kar ry hn ap paish kren phr karty hn debate

Jeo

Wo sirf ikhtalaf tha Hazrat Muawiya b Sahabi e Rasool thay

Beshak hq sach

بھائ مولا کا کیا مطلب ہے

Mashallah

Ghamidi sab ke lye dono mauqif thik hai logical hain inki raye asi he hoti jiski wjh se tum inko sunte ho

Beshak!

Mashallah May Allaha blesing you bro forum Pakistan

@@hasnainabbas51 me

Ji bilkul 25 Saal tk ❤❤❤❤

Haan bhai yahi to khn rhn ghamidhi sahab....Ali Sa ko logon ne chuna or yahi sahi tha ...

Hazret Hussain ko katel karney ki Swedish kid nay ki .

سیدنا علی چوتھے خلیفہ راشد تھے اور اسکا انکار کوئی بھی نہیں کر سکتا ہے۔ جہاں تک بات قاتلین عثمان کی ہے تو ان سے اکثر جنگوں میں ہی مارے گئے اور ان میں سے ایک یعنی محمد بن ابی بکر کو بھی مصر جاتے ہوئے قتل کر دیا گیا۔ لہذا تقریبا وہ سب لوگ مارے جا چکے تھے جنہوں نے سیدنا عثمان کو قتل کیا۔

And many other ahadees

It's explicitly said in hadith of bukhari and Muslim that Ammar will be martyred by transgressing group. Ghamdi intentionally skipped this Hadith to save Muavia. This isn't first time that so called scholars hide historical facts

jo uss daur ko behtreen keh gaey un sy ap kuch aur tawqu na rakhen Bukhari 4108, Muslim 4776 behtreen daur k bary hy - lakin esko be zaeef kahen gy ye mohtram

Kia ap ye bata skty ammar ibin yasirra ko jb shaheed kia gya to mugheera bin suba b mojod thy wo baityrizwan waly sahabi hn jin ki shan mn allah ka quran utra to mugheera bin shuba ko jahanumi kho nauzubiilah or quran ki ayat k munkir hojao

Very good question… I would suggest you to do your own research because if you ask sunnies they will put it on Saba’iyyah rebels who also killed hazrat Usman ra and the other side will claim group that had support of hazrat ayesha ra to be responsible for his murder…

Yes karbala is one of the consequences

Who cares if you don't agree. Listen to him again you'll find your answer

Jab musalman kaum ke sar mein khota lag jaye tou unki assiciate krne ku quaat kho jaati hai aur in ke brain free ghoomna shuru kr dete hein. Ya phir aisi suspenseful cheezein ejaad kr ke woh apne dil ko sukoon dete hein.

Wah

Ameen

Ameen

Sach kia hay arabic history

yeah and sahaba dont remember those hadith ?

Tmare dilo se mirza nikly ga to kitab ki baat smaj ay gi na

he said Muawiya won during the face off, when Imam Hasan out of not wanting war and his love for Ummah decided to step aside as Khalifa. He never said Muawiya won from Sayyiduna Ali.

Hassan withdrew in best interest of Muslims. Is Only this sentence not enough that who was thinking about Muslims welfare and who for personal gains.

Haha ap sawal chana ka jawaaab gandum de rhy o

So if hazrat Ali ( rA) could be decieved then atleast we should not called mushkil kasha .

so u dont know the reason behind that war after watching this vedio aswell

YOU ARE QUITE WRONG,HE HAS TO TELL THE FACTS AND NOT HIDE THE FACTS,SAY THE UNSAID,TELL THE UNTOLD AND,Was Ali elected or selected by some 200 or 400 as blamed by Javed Ahmed Ghamadi and Ameer Muawiya had millions of people who wanted to have him the caliph but according to which rules of business.He did not reply the answer but defended his like minded like a funded project and did not tell the nation why he selected the most corrupt boy on buying and forced initiatives and the same did with the Hussain and his family. How long our religious leaders and the scholars would lie and hide the facts and who are the ultimate beneficiaries of such projects?

Al-Quran Surah 2 - Al-Baqara - Ayah 134 أَعـوذُ بِاللهِ مِنَ الشَّيْـطانِ الرَّجيـم بِسْمِ اللّٰهِ الرَّحْمٰنِ الرَّحِيْمِ تِلۡكَ اُمَّةٌ قَدۡ خَلَتۡ‌ۚ لَهَا مَا كَسَبَتۡ وَلَـكُمۡ مَّا كَسَبۡتُمۡ‌ۚ وَلَا تُسۡئَـلُوۡنَ عَمَّا كَانُوۡا يَعۡمَلُوۡنَ ۞ Translation: They were a people who passed away; they shall receive the reward of what they earned and you shall have the reward of what you will earn; and you will not be questioned as to what they did.

He is not here to convince you but to state how it was.

Bro. Those time were tough . Both parties point of view was right. One wanted speedy justice other wanted to delay for stability reasons. Syeeduna Muavia was ready to took oath of allegiance of Syeeduna Ali but after taking revange of blood of Syeeduna Ustman

But brother, Ghamdi is denying khilafat of Maula Ali a.s saying that Ali a.s khilafat was not prevailed and penetrated in the area but by his virtues he is khalifa just like first one and 2nd one. I have said in my comments that ghamdi is a scholar just like those ones who were living with Yazid lanti.

Saahaabaa kee list bataaeñ jinho ne sayadana ali r.a. par be,at kee+sayadana maawiyaa ke haath par be,at karne waale saahaabaa kiraam kee bhee list bataen,kioñ ke hizbullah kee central commettee ko hee khalifaa banaane kaa akhtiar thaa naa ke baghioñ ko?!!!

Sahi Bukhari 2812

Wait for next episode

Ghamdi haramzada hai

no hadees is bigger than Quran

Imam Hassan do Musalmaan groho k darmiyaan sulaah kaim kary gy (mafhoom of Hadith)

See Face of program evil agenda against Sahaba inshallah.

Dear sahaba ka maqam koye nhi chuh sakta but Jo ustime hua wo bayaan karna kounsi Galt baat hai

Hazrat Ali alehi salam Ahadees Mai likha hai alahi salam Baad k molvi kha Gaye hain

@@rizwanhabib3491 kisne bola aisa wahi aayi thi ya time travel kar ke muhadaseen se mil kar aaye ho tum ya kisi ke aandhe muqalid jisne bol diya ki maulvi kha gaye aur tumne man liya

​@@danish_mohammedjab darood me AS parhty Hain sab to naam k sath AS q nahi? Is se Bari bhi koi daleel Chahiye mery Bhai ko?

As usual ghamidi saab forsake and put aside all the clear sahih ahadees about the issue. I don't understand his problem. Why he gives his understanding of issues priority over the verdict we can derive from the word of the prophet (s). I mean he's trying to defend ameer e shaam making excuse of distance. It was made very clear to him by Ali (ra) before any war occurred between them! There was a constant exchange of letters between Ali and Muawiyah. And shame on you for saying Ali was chosen by the rebels. Madina had only rebels in it??? Madina had thousands of sahaba who fought in badr, uhad, Ahzab, khyber and hunain. Didn't they pledged their allegiance to Ali (ra)?? Along with them Makkah didn't have problem with it, Kufa, basra, Egypt and all along the islamic states pledged. In war of siffeen have you ever seen the people with Ali (ra)? Who were they?? Were they sahaba or were they rebels?? Why Muawiyah couldn't see thousands of sahaba with Ali?? Why he went against the jaamat of Muhajireen wal Ansaar? *The only reason was the old hatred of Bani Hashim! *He couldn't stand the fact that the man who killed their kafir forefathers in badr and Uhad to become khalifa. *He didn't wanted Ali in power who he had to answer for all the plundering of bait ul maal they've been doing for years under Hazrat Usman's nose. Who is ghamidi to tell me I can't call Muawiyah a baghi when my prophet called him baghi in the hadees of Martyrdom of Ammar bin Yasir??? I have a question: ok for instance Muawiyah was not clear as he claims. Didn't the hadees about Ammar made clear to him that he was wrong. Why didn't he stopped fighting and give his bayyah when everything became crystal clear. Instead he chose to fool his army by saying Ali brought Ammar in war so Ali is responsible for his martyrdom! What?! If prophet brought Hamza in Uhad so will you hold account prophet for killing of Hamza? What a twisting of truth? Muawiyah made it clear in the hadees of Abdullah ibn Umar (ra) that he had nothing to do with shahadat e Usman but he wanted power because he thought he deserved it. Allah knows on what grounds! So ghamidi saab stop making your own theories. Everything is very clear in books of ahadees. It's your old habit to jump to your conclusions without considering the account of clear ahadees on any issue. This makes you a 'Munkar e Hadees' blatantly.

bahut achi dua hai

❤️❤️

and he intentionally skipped Hadith about Ammar to save Muavia

O bhai jinhn ny katal kia tha ap ksi rawayat sy sabit kar do k wo kn kn log thy or ameer muavia k door mn wo zinda thy or unhn ny bdla ni lia unhn ny to sb sy ziada dunia mn islam ka ghalba kia jihad k zariye to usman k katilo ko kahan chorna tha unhn

Most of them was already killed in previous 3 wars and after sullah of hassan(ra) there was no need for capturing murderers

بھائی جان حضرت امیر معاویہ رض نے خلافت سنبھالنے کے بعد قاتلین عثمان کو چن چن کر قتل کیا۔ بعض کو تو حضرت علی رض کی خلافت کے دوران ہی مارا گیا ۔ کسی تاریخی کتاب کا مطالعہ کرنے کے بعد ہی کمنٹ کیا کریں

@@maniop9540 agar pehle 3 jango main zadatar quatilin e usman(as) mare jachuke the aur sulah Hasan k bad unhe capture karne ki zarurat nahi thi, to fir muawiya(ra) ne hazrat Hasan(as) ki bait kiu nahi kiya? Muawiya to usman(as) ki quatal ka kisas chahate the our agar quatilin mar chuka tha to hazrat Hasan(as) ke khilaf kyu Gaye? Iske piche maqsad kay tha? Thora aqal ka use v krlo.

Ameen

ھم قرآنی مومن لوگ حضرت ابو بکر صدیقِ علیہ السلام حضرت عمر علیہ السلام حضرت عثمانؓ علیہ السلام حضرت عمر بن عبدالعزیز علیہ السلام کو اپناامام معصُوم مانتے ہیں جنگ صفین مین شامل دو نون فر یق کو ھم لوگ نھیں مانتے ہیں

​@@Matamvlogs512 AAMEEN

yahan baat kiya ho rae or tum kiya keh rahay ya sari jo apnay bayan ke kiya HAZRAT HASSAN AS ko nai pata tha 1400 saal pechay jakar socho 21 saadi nai the

Sdo I think 🤔 😕 😅 😌

Right

@@videogamerzworld6468 hazrat hassan ny sula hi ki thi ba sir....sula allah k nabi ny kafiro k sath b ki hui ha us pr kia kahygy aaap???

​@@masoodshuja5479 sula nhi baait kar li thi

آمین یا رب العالمین

Most wonderful reasoning,

مشورہ ہوا مشورے میں اختلاف ہوا پھر ایک گروہ بر سر اقتدار آئےتو اسکی حکومت جائز ہو گئ

Bilkul bhi jaaiz nahi

jazbat ko side per rakhen munkreen e zakat tu muslim thy phr kesy unky khialf abu bakar (ra) ny jang ki ? agar uss amal ko ye kaha jaey k vo maal k gharz sy the tu ??

deene islam poetry se samjh nahi aata , facts neutral ho kar research karni parti ha emotions k saat nahi

Jahil log quran se hat kr poetry wgera se logic dhondty hain

Speak Truth r the Truth will Speak.Diference between H.Ali and Muaawia.?

بے بنیاد کہانی سنا رہا ہے یہ جیدا غامدی

Beshak ❤️

It was all a power struggle between tribes ... like it happens today as well in tribal areas .... kon samjhaye in logon ko ... they don't think and use their minds ... just believe what baba sitting on the mimbar is blabbering....just do research from non-religious sources and you will find the truth.

Emotions k bghr to janwar b nae HOTA .. Khuda gharat kry so-called truth phailany walon ko ..

@@rajaaliahmadhussain6591 Kya baat hai Ali Ahmad bhai !!!

لوگوں کے لئے یہ اہم تھا کہ علی کیسے حُکمران تھے۔

In Islam people decide who they want to choose and give there opinion. It’s a not about Blood. It’s about what Allah and his prophet (PBUH) has told us. Blood has nothing to do with Islam. As ghamdi said Muslims will know on day of judgement the truth. I hope all good Muslims no matter what there sect be granted Jannah.

@Mohsin Abbas..... belittle karna to aapka shak-o-shubah he, kaun kissika parallel hosakta he ? Rashidoon ka parallel kahin mila he aapko ? Bughz-e-Muawiyyah mein aap extremism ka parallel hosakte hein...! Khuda-na -Khuwastah.

Hazrat Moaviya Razi Allah Anho was a great Sahabi. Nobody can degrade him. Let shia say anything against him, they will ultimately know on the Day of Judgement.

Mohsin sb only blood line is elegibility ? .... Please recall about PBUH uncles.

exactly, shadeed ikhtelaf hy mujhy en k ess nuqat.e.nazar sy so sad to see k ye kaisy haqaiq ko manipulate kar gaey aur na ye beyan kea gya k jin sharait per sulah ki ameer.e.sham ny un ki kitni pasadari ki gae

اے کاش کے یہ معاملہ اج بھی عالمی عدالت میں آے

Wah ullama zameer naqvi kay shagird......wah

💯 percent true

Yes, but fault on basis of unjust reasons. Wanting the revange of Syeeduna Ustman was their just right

Proof?

@@whiteholeeducationcenter why muawia didnt take revenge in his rule? 🤨😂

@@meeretalk Because he already took it during Ali's rule. Muawiyah killed Muhammad ibn Abi Bakr, Malik Al Ashtat and Abdur rahman ibn uwais who were perpetrators in killing of usman.

Yes

You cannot judge history.. we can only learn from History..

You should first become better than people you are judging.

Shia ki jhooti hadith

🖐️🖐️

Dear Ibrahim, majority of us are so hard-wired to our biases, mental-conditioning and old beliefs that it has become extremely difficult to accept new truths. Only the wise can do that not the masses. But hope slow and steady, truth will find its own ways to reveal upon all.

جناب کی بات سن کر ایسا لگتا ہے جیسے مرا نہیں زندہ ہے، بہت افسوس کی بات ہے

How about you learn another language? Instead of expecting everyone to speak English

I second that

@@ahmadhabibkhan8213 I don't think he meant any offence. The fact is there are many misconceptions being expounded in the English language and it would be nice to have someone like him speak English, or at least, provide subtitles which, thankfully, they seem to be doing now.

Very good points, nice

Mu'tadil? Really? Tell Allah that! k ya Allah aik sajda hi to nahi kiya. chorden! Mu'tadil banen! O bhae jab haq o batil aamne saamne hoon to beech ka koi raasta nahi hota. Yahi baat aap hazrat Abu bakr aur jo maani'een e zakat k baarey men keh saktey hen. K dono achey thy dono apni jaga durust thy. Mu'tadil rehna chahiye. Bas Ali ki bari men ietidaal rakhna hota hai?? Hazrat Abu bakr ki jangon par Huzoor ki koi hadees mojood nahi phir bhi aap unko haq pey kehtey hen Ali ki jangon k liye to Bukhari aur Muslim men chapters k chapters hen ahadees k jin men Huzoor ney clearly hazrat Ali ko haq pey kaha aur unke mukhalifeen ko baaghi aur khawarij kaha. Magar nahi! saari ahadees gayi khadey men. Mu'tadil hona chahiye. Well done! Mehshar men Huzoor k bajaye ghamidi saab se shafa'at karwana kyun k tum Huzoor k bajaye ghamidi k mu'tadil islam ko maantey rahey ho.

@@mjasyed محترم مرجان شاہ صاحب آپ نے غامدی صاحب کی باتیں یقیناً تعصب سے سنی ہیں۔۔ اگر بغور سنا ہوتا تو اتنے جھوٹے فتوے لگانے کی چنداں ضرورت پیش نہ اتی۔۔ برائے مہربانی غور سے تمام لیکچر سنیں امید ہے آپ بھی اعتدال کا راستہ اپنائیں گے۔ سرور کونین خاتم النبیین حضرت محمد صلی اللّہ علیہ وسلم اور حضرت علی کرم اللہ وجہہ الکریم سے میں بھی اتنی ہی محبت کرتا ہوں جتنی جناب کرتے ہیں۔۔ اس لئے گزارش ہے کے جذبات سے ہٹ کر حقائق کو پیش نظر رکھا کریں۔۔ اور زندگی میں اگر محبت نہیں بانٹ سکتے تو برائے مہربانی نفرتیں بھی نہ پھیلائیں۔۔ جزاک اللّہ خیر

Ahadees ye bhi kehti hain ke Hazrat Zubair bin Awam aur Talha bin Ubaidullah Ashra Mubashshara mai Shamil hain, In donon ko Jnage Jamal mai Hazrat Ali kay sipahion nay shaheed kia. Un kay Qatleen kia jahanmi nahi honge?

Thank You God

Coz u r shea, out of total Muslims shea r not more than 10,15 percent, so the rest don't agree to ur argument