Head-to-head comparison of woodworking rasps

Рет қаралды 3,689

Practical Clubmaker

20 күн бұрын

A comparison of woodworking rasps including Iwasaki, Liogier, Shinto and Narex.

Пікірлер: 24

@PikkaBird 16 күн бұрын

That joke about Japanese hammers was A+!

@davidclark9086 14 күн бұрын

A well made and super informative video.

@gregorymacneil2836 13 күн бұрын

I really like Farrier’s rasps because they have a good weight and are a great length. I'm particularly fond of the new Cody James Dymondback Rasp. I highly recommend trying the Cody James Rasp, even if you're not a fan of Farrier’s rasps in general, the handles for Farrier’s rasps are superb!

@richardcook555 15 күн бұрын

I paid stupid money for a rounded Iwasaki............teeth jam up with wood immediately. Very hard to clean. Tried chalking it, but no help. Love the Shinto.

@practicalclubmaker6152 14 күн бұрын

The Iwasakis do clog with pine and other high resin woods. No issue with clogging with hardwoods. If there is a buildup with hardwoods, I tap end of the rasp on my bench and the shavings fall out. But for pine, I often need a card file/brush to clean it.

@bigoldgrizzly 14 күн бұрын

@@practicalclubmaker6152 and give them a clean out as soon as some clogging becomes evident ... it only takes a second or two. - don't wait till it clogs up solid.

@michaelsaxman 14 күн бұрын

I use the shinto for large sculpture. I got the offset handle version so that I can use it like a plane. Mostly I just use it without the handle at all now, works good sideways like a spokeshave, too.

@practicalclubmaker6152 13 күн бұрын

@@michaelsaxman Good tip on using the Shinto like a spokeshave. That would come in handy where the grain direction switches compared to using a traditional spokeshave. Kind of like using a toothing plane instead of a traditional plane.

@wadepatton2433 16 күн бұрын

I've used most all of them on hardwood. One I like but you didn't include is a farriers rasp--the big one. It's SUPER coarse on one side and medium coarse on the other. They'll hog off wood quickly, but be mindful of the ruts being cut. Another favorite of mine is a soft-materials file -like your Iwasaki shown. I don't know where I got it or what the specs are, but it's fantastic for wood, horn, and plastic. It cuts smoother than any rasp. I also use rasps and the Shinto. I have one machine-made rasp and also a hand-stitched rasp (mia-but I'll find it someday). Also I'm a fan of the draw-knife and spoke shave. More tools, more options for what the grain is doing today.

@practicalclubmaker6152 16 күн бұрын

@@wadepatton2433 Good point on the hoof rasps. Somebody else I know mentioned that so, thanks, I will have to give that a try. Any particular brand of farrier's rasp that you like?

@wadepatton2433 16 күн бұрын

@@practicalclubmaker6152 Nah, just whatever the local farm store has. They're a good bit cheaper than rasps, but only good for rough shaping. Reverse directions as needed for a "smoother" cut, they can get nasty when fighting the grain.

@bigoldgrizzly 14 күн бұрын

Absolutely ! I use a Heller Excel Legend and it eats wood at speed. Rasp on one side and a medium single cut file on the other. The cutting edge angles are excellent for wood Only con is that don't make a half round. ps I also use a Sandvik Oberg fine rasp - 25 years so far of regular use and it is a sharp as day one. Sandvik no longer make files and rasps but if you see a good secondhand one, grab it What ever you buy, look after it well and keep the blade in a sheath. Never use any of these on metals of any sort - you will quickly destroy them.

@gregorymacneil2836 13 күн бұрын

I think Farrier's rasps are great but the handles for Farrier's rasps are amazing - much more comfortable and workable in the hand. Try the Heller Red Tang if you want to start experimenting and make sure you buy a Farrier's rasp handle.

@bigoldgrizzly 13 күн бұрын

@@gregorymacneil2836 Hopefully your post will help someone else considering a farriers rasp. I have made all my tool handles for over 50 years and have long since found the shapes that fit my hand for different tools, so I'll pass on this one thanks