I'm not a part of the Hebrew Roots movement perse but I still keep the Torah because its God's Laws for His people and at the end of the days we will ALL be responsible to keep it. So did God do away with His Laws just to cause the nations to keep it at the end? There is no way around it. 2 And it shall come to pass in the last days, that the mountain of the Lord's house shall be established in the top of the mountains, and shall be exalted above the hills; and all nations shall flow unto it. 3 And many people shall go and say, Come ye, and let us go up to the mountain of the Lord, to the house of the God of Jacob; and he will teach us of his ways, and we will walk in his paths: for out of Zion shall go forth the Torah, and the word of the Lord from Jerusalem. - Isaiah 2:2-3

I dont abide by the torah to be justified by the legalistic word "law," but rather to respect Fathers statutes. And live with faith.

Thank you for sharing your story, Kathrine. I love that you are doing this! It's so important for others to hear your perspective. Blessings, Rob

“If you love me keep my commandments.”

Hi Sis, I too used to be in the Hebrew roots movement a decade ago or so and was in it for three yrs.But I got out of it when Abba showed me Galatians 5:4 that we can fall from grace if we try to be justified by the law. Thank you for the video! Love, Ginger

Hi dear, I understand your dilemma about the Hebrew roots movement, I am a follower of Yashua Messiah He is my salvation, but I do have to say that Yah gave His instructions (Torah)to Israel, a nation He chose for they were to share with the other nations around them, us Gentiles, Gods laws and instructions that we are all to live by. People mention the 613 laws, they are not for everyone, if you look into them they are for different job titles, priests, parents, children etc. He gave us His commandments, and we should be obedient to Him including keeping the Sabbath and we also believe in keeping the feast days because we learn from them. The spring Feasts (His first coming-is His Redemption) His dying on the cross for us. Then The Fall Feasts (His second coming-His Restoration) to restore all things. There are many rabbinic things being done that shouldn’t be done, Yah said do not add to or take away from His word. I pray you continue to keep His instructions, the 10 commandment, Loving Yah above all things and loving your neighbor as yourself, the Fall Feasts are about His return and people are not ready nor prepared for His return. As you know there are some tough times coming as Yeshua said and we need Him to help us to endure to the end. We need Torah! We need Truth. Be strong honey, stay in His Truth. The pagan holidays are not truth. Yah bless you in all that you do!

Katherine, thank you so much for sharing your story. It is so encouraging to listen to others share their experience being involved in this idealogy. My husband and I completely left in Fall of 2021 and since God has lead us to a biblically-solid and loving church. After years of confusion, resentment, and fear, our faith has grown like never before. We pray for those who are still involved.

It’s so sad for me to see so many people judging so hard those within the body. My husband and I have made mistakes forsure and have had to Humble ourselves and apologize to family. The father pushed on me to learn the fruit of the spirit in 2021. And it was such a blessing. Because as we in our faith have grown deeper in our walk by doing feast and sabbath. It’s also helped me to be less judging of others. Instead I’ve seen more people in my life who are seeking to be in Jesus footsteps! I’m seeing more and more people being crushed and chastised. We don’t do Easter or Christmas but I also don’t judge those who do I walk out my faith beside all Abba places in our life! The isolation is so real!

Thank you for sharring. I have family stuck here, and this testimony gives me hope. Praise the Lord!

Good video sister. You nailed it. My wife and I attended one of these places for about a year and a half and saw the levels, and inconsistency even among members. I got into a rather heated conversation one Friday night with a guy who was rather rude and jumped on me because he was talking about the requirements to follow the law trying to force it on me and I objected. He got mad and I pressed him on what happens when a follower of Christ doesn’t follow the Mosaic law and he kept trying to get away from answering and changing the topic. I persisted and finally said those who don’t follow the law will be judged. When he said that he knew he was wrong and he walked away. Thank God Paul covers this extensively in his letters to the churches. So glad you got out of that and I pray God’s richest blessings will be on you.

Thank you for sharing. My husband and I were involved in Hebrew Roots up until 10 years ago. At the time we were shunned by some and attacked with “woe to those who call evil good”. There’s many layers to it but looking back we are glad to be free of it.

I can relate to her in one way, it is very lonely when you begin practicing Messianic Judaism. The lady in the video behaved as though she was lucky to get out alive. I question whether the group she was with didn't have something else going on. Did they add whipping as the new punishment?

I noticed you spoke of different levels in Hebrew Roots and I would point out that those exist in all groups . In most groups you have the ones that are pew sitters and those that show up only on Easter and Christmas and you have teachers and some of them are held in high regard . Then you have the lay preachers another step and then the Pastors. In all churches you have the Spiritual and the ones that just show up because it is a good thing.

Interesting. We “keep” as in observe the feasts/sabbath/dietary laws because we know Jesus didn’t come to abolish the law and prophets but to fill up (fulfill) the law. But for us it’s served to teach us more about our Father and Savior. We firmly believe that faith in Jesus alone leads to salvation. It couldn’t be more clear in scriptures. But the law simply showed His people how to live righteously and set apart lives. It also served as a judge for the nation as they didn’t have a king or ruler (other than God) so needed instruction on what to do when the people sinned. Obviously Jesus is our High Priest, our sacrificial Passover lamb... we have found the feasts much richer and deeper than Christmas and Easter. I’m sorry your experience was so negative. I can see how that can happen very easily and we have to be so careful not to fall into adding to Jesus but also not falling into being of the world and not set apart. God bless you.

That is a very wide term, "Hebrew roots movement." That is saying I belong to Christendom. That hardly nails down all the nuances that entails.

I watched you this morning on R.L. Solbergs channel. Im checking out your videos, but i want to say thank you for your testimony. As a gentile, i was in Messianic Judaism, which parallels closely with Hebrew Roots beliefs, for 25 yrs. Its a long story. But i came out of it 2 yrs ago. I was wrestling with guilt about celebrating Christmas. I had a close friend who is still blinded by HR doctrine, so much so, he doesn't talk to me anymore. I pray for him, but truthfully lost hope in him seeing the truth as he us in very deep. But seeing some of your videos about praying and not giving up has raised my hope. Thank you for your channel and helping people see the truth.

Thank you. This video came up on my KZfaq feed and I will say, that I experienced all of the things you mentioned. My husband and I are at odds now since he still wants to hold onto this mindset (Tzitzit, feasts, kosher, etc) feeling that they are required for righteousness. I will not be put back under these HR teachings. After 5 years, I finally feel free in Christ. Carry on with your journey and God bless you ❤️

I learned a great deal from this guy, Bobby Collier. I still refer to the Messiah as Yeshua. Bobby uses the name Jesus. But his teachings really straightened me out about who, YHWH, Yah, Yahuah, etc... who that actually is. I am so glad for you on the journey out of Hebrew Roots/Sacred Name. Although, there are a great deal of observances we are safe to take note. I still weigh the difference of "traditions of men' as opposed to what is actually in scripture. I believe it is a good practice to test those principles. When a tradition pulls us away from glorifying the Father, then perhaps it's not a good idea. Yeshua manifests the name Father. That's all I needed to see, once again. Elohim wrote Genesis 1 YHWH Elohim wrote Genesis 2:4 So now, I am looking into the Divine Council mentioned in Psalm 82. It has singular Elohim judging plural elohim and a very deep topic. Mike Heiser expounds on this extensively. I can say, that I do not fit any of the modern day churches or movements. Once you take on that name, you take on the whole kit and caboodle. I still say, the Letter J was created in the 1500's and that's when Jesus was created. His mother called him Yeshua. In terms of Old Testament, we need to be careful, because the devil masquerades as God, as an angel of light. But you can see his bad fruit. That's the key. Let Yeshua call the devil out on all his deception. kzfaq.info/get/bejne/Y8uJo5d_ld7PiJ8.html

Very concise and precise! Keep going sister, many will benefit from it. Be blessed 🙌

Thank you for sharing this. I, too, have a family who are in the movement. Blessings to you from our Lord and Savior, Jesus Christ!

I never expected an attack on Torah believers after coming to the truth. But it is written.

Thank you. I found a video by Lex Meyer which made sense. But as I watched more of his videos, the red flags started to go off and I began to distrust this man's teachings. Then I found your video which backs up my gut. Thank you again.

One thing about the law of Moses, you either keep all of them or none of them. Galatians 5 if you're trying to keep the law of Moses you are bound to keep all of them. And try to get justified under the law which is impossible.

Hi Kathrine, I still feel fairly new to the “Whole Bible” Movement, thats what I feel it is to me. Started following/studying December 2018. I’ve mostly watched Bill Cloud out of Chattanooga, TN online in which I’m grateful he & his wife started a fellowship February of 2019. I was living in Metro Atlanta at that time & visited a few fellowships but they didn’t jive with me. I’ve since moved to the south Alabama area & have found a fellowship I’m comfortable with. I do not agree with ALL the things this movement teaches, but add I did not in the Christian church either. I take in the good stuff and spit out the stuff I can’t go for. I Gotta be honest, The Sabbath was not a stretch for me…I loved resting on Saturday’s and not doing anything because I had worked hard through the week & was tired. I always felt guilty for not cleaning or doing this or that… Christmas was always depressing for me. I came from a broken home, and there were NEVER “family” traditions, etc. I would go in debt buying presents & pay them off afterwards. This teaching just makes more sense to me…I do agree with you that I feel they need to be more evangelistic and sharing Yeshua/Jesus with non-believers. Also, I feel the Birth of Yeshua/Jesus needs to be celebrated during The Feast of Tabernacles since from my studies so far, I believe that’s probably when He was born. Why not celebrate it? He birth is documented in the Gospels, so it was pretty important if you look at The “whole Book”. I DO NOT Believe in animal sacrifices, even if there was a Temple, Yeshua paid the price…made the ultimate sacrifice, and yes, God says He has forgotten our sins “as far as the east from the west”, which is to say…they are gone. I do think this movement needs “The Spirit”, The Word says to “worship Him in Spirit and Truth” I truly believe Yeshua is coming back for “one new man” and I feel He is getting us all on the “same page” and that page is not gonna look like modern day Christianity or Messianic Judaism. As we as believers have to choose between the world or God’s ways, I think things are gonna become more clear as He moves us to the “One New Man” God Bless you on your Journey…you are MY SISTER in Yeshua, right where you are😊❤️

I was confused for a while by the hebrew routes too. I really didnt fully understand dispensation back then. I do listen to Mike winger and John MacArthur as well they definitely helped. I would suggest Robert Breaker on KZfaq as well....he is especially good with breaking down the dispensations. I truly understand it now because of his content. Im happy you found your way back...God bless you.

Lev 23 declares th'e feasts are not Jewish they are His, the Creators. I never turn down a feast even if it is Yom Kippur. We do not GOT to do it we GET to do it. Maybe your friends were real fanatics when grace leads one to liberty not licentiousness. Dietary instructions are and never were a salvation issue but rather an emphasis on health. I have never isolated myself from my brothers with there special holidays. You must have fellow-shipped with real sticklers. Torah is always interpreted as instruction and teaching , not law. My group is very inclusive and not at all judgemental or divisive. Remember, the Sabbath was created for man , not vice a versa. We all deserve a rest! Thank you for sharing .

It’s amazing how many scholars don’t know the difference between the word covenant and the word law. Jeremiah talks about a new covenant not a new law. No where do the scriptures state that the law is done away with simply because God accomplishes all His purpose. There is ZERO scripture where God tells people to celebrate Christmas simply because the Word was in the beginning. Got Torah Got Truth

What a great explanation. I have stumbled across this topic and was deeply concerned with those that promote it like Jim Staley and those that spam FB pages and KZfaq channels full of rhetoric and condemnation directed at Gentiles who do not follow the Torah and their teachings. They are every bit a cult and a false belief system. God bless your strength to remove yourself from this group. God will absolutely reward you.

The reason we can eat whatever we want now is not because God wants us to eat unclean foods, it is because Jesus cleaned all the food with His sacrifice. So technically we are no longer being made unclean by food. So it is in fact Hebrew roots who are lawless, because they are denying Jesus' power to clean food, how then can He clean our sin?

Such Shallowness in Truely Understanding Yah’s Scripture..

I'm going to say this again keeping the Sabbath day holy is the fourth Commandment! It's not the people of the Hebrew Roots movement that are telling you to keep the Sabbath its scripture! And no I am not in the Hebrew Roots movement! Sinning isn't supposed to feel good, it sounds to me like it wasn't making you feel good so you needed to separate yourself from it. Sometimes when we are in the middle of being sanctified from our filthy ways Satan loves to come in and make us start doubting. Don't let him win

Pretty accurate! I was in the movement for over 5 years. I’d say most skip that whole first floor all together and instantly think sabbath keeping is a law we are all supposed to keep.

“Because finding fault with them, He says: “Behold, the days are coming, says the Lord, when I will make a new covenant with the house of Israel and with the house of Judah-” ‭‭Hebrews‬ ‭8‬:‭8‬ ‭NKJV‬‬ So if the new covenant was made with Israel which new covenant are you entering into?

I don’t really follow Hebrew roots, but where is the scripture backing up some of their beliefs as wrong? God only called a few sins “abominations” in the Law, one of them being homo sex u a lity(mistyped on purpose) and another eating unclean foods. The church will point at the Law to show homosexuality is a sin but ignore the other abomination in the Law. On top of that, there are words added to the bible(by doing this he declared all foods clean) and Peter’s vision, which had nothing to do with foods according to Peter himself! We only eat unclean foods because they are part of our culture, other unclean foods we would not eat because we were not raised around it such as rats, bats, vultures, all carrying diseases. Finally, how many times are “swine eaters” listed among those being rejected by Christ in future judgement, both in the old and New Testament(Revelation)? We are not saved by works, only by faith. But obedience to the Law, what still applies, is the fruit of that faith.

Once saved always saved

Thank you for sharing your testimony. I also heard your testimony with Prof. Solberg. It was so encouraging and helped shed light on what is behind the mind set that only allows a person to see thru the lens of the Mosaic Law, instead of thru the Spirit and the clear Gospel message in scripture. ✝️

I PRAISE the Lord Jesus the Christ today! This is a disciple of Jesus Christ and a Berean. Thank you for your shining example. Thank "YOU" our Father's grace and peace to you. Thank "YOU"

I can relate to that, had the same journey, I was in it for around two years, teh worst part is that they believe that you have to work out your salvation even after getting saved though Jesus, the blood and the cross, you still have to keep all (yesterday I even found one teache saying you hav eto keep ALL tehj laws not only teh ten commandments9 to keept your salvation . What I have learned blessed me very much and they have a deep understanding for teh scripture when it comes to teh OT and I gained a better understanding for the NT, teh letters and the background of teh gospels and there is a lot in teh OT which is beneficial for us if we apply it but I felt so bound and all these feastst were so foreign to me and I felt so awkward celebrating them so that I dissociated myself from this movement

Can you tell sometime what the tipping point was for you to leave Hebrew Roots? Thank you for sharing your story. I love your gracious loving heart!! I'm praying for that kind of a heart when talking to people I don't agree with.

A red flag for me is when an old Christian friend now kept exclusively referring to God as the Almighty and Jesus as Yeshua.

This whole issue was resolved in Acts Ch 15. My experience with these nutcases is they will try to out Pharisee each other and there will be continuous division and splitting into factions. The other experience is that no matter how much they preach “Torah” it will inevitably end up in Kabbalah ( the Synagogue of Satans witchcraft the Jews practice)

Thank you for your boldness and courage. Please pray in agreement for a woman close to my heart would see the truth and come out of this movement in Jesus name 🙏 Thank you!

As a dog returneth to his vomit, so a fool returneth to his folly. Proverbs 26:11 KJV And I heard another voice from heaven, saying, Come out of her, my people, that ye be not partakers of her sins, and that ye receive not of her plagues. Revelation 18:4 KJV Many will say to me in that day, Lord, Lord, have we not prophesied in thy name? and in thy name have cast out devils? and in thy name done many wonderful works? And then will I profess unto them, I never knew you: depart from me, ye that work iniquity. Matthew 7:22‭-‬23 KJV iniquity=lawlessness If ye love me ( Jesus), keep my commandments. John 14:15 KJV

“Wherefore, beloved, seeing that ye look for such things, be diligent that ye may be found of him in peace, without spot, and blameless. And account that the longsuffering of our Lord is salvation; even as our beloved brother Paul also according to the wisdom given unto him hath written unto you; as also in all his epistles, speaking in them of these things; in which are some things hard to be understood, which they that are unlearned and unstable wrest, as they do also the other scriptures, unto their own destruction. Ye therefore, beloved, seeing ye know these things before, beware lest ye also, being led away with the error of the wicked, fall from your own stedfastness. But grow in grace, and in the knowledge of our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ. To him be glory both now and for ever. Amen.” ‭‭2 Peter‬ ‭3‬:‭14‬-‭18‬ ‭KJV‬‬ Revelation 12:17 And the dragon was wroth with the woman, and went to make war with the remnant of her seed, which keep the commandments of God, and have the testimony of Jesus Christ.

it sounds like you and perhaps your fellowship were stuck in a legalistic mindset. Id like to remind everyone watching this that Jesus did not come to teach lawlessness. We follow Gods commands BECAUSE we are saved, not in order to be saved. Unfortunately most churches are either legalistic with no holy spirit presence or they claim to be full of the spirit and think Jesus did away with the law. They completely disreguard the fact that the holy spirit will cause you to walk in Gods statutes and ordinances.

Excellent video 🙏

Praise God you got out! 🕊️🙏🕊️

Remember that the demons with whom Paul did battle with are the same ones today; they've had 2000 years to perfect their 'art'. So don't feel too bad that you were ensnared. Thank God you were rescued. It's ironic to think that these demons could have specialized in getting pre-Jesus Jews to not keep the Sabbath.

Aahhhhhh ok,John McArthur is teaching lies! Now I understand where you're coming from.

I understand where you are coming from and I am sorry to hear about what you went through. Such can happen when one try to obey the law out of flesh and fear instead of out of love and spirit. Return to ancient part and following HRM is different things and we need to be clear on that otherwise we will easily get trapped to return to the covenant of law. Having say that, with much respect speaking out of love, I think this video can be very misleading to bring a different idea to the viewers .. God bless. .

I’d recommend following Kingdom in context and consider another understanding. Following Gods instructions is simply our discipleship.

Awesome, thank you!

Just subbed because a group I am in has a hrm guy coming in and challenging us to debate to which I don't even want to acknowledge him any more than I would a JDUB, Lds/mormon. Even to listen to these people is dangerous for others and also a waste of time for the steadfast believer, after all WE have a better covenant in JESUS, and the law was only a schoolmaster to bring us to Christ. The law keeping has the same draw it did for Pharasees, a Pride of Superiority.

Sister in Christ, thank you for your test., I agree with you 100 percent, my sister in law practices the Hebrew roots, she believes in Jesus our Savior, she as well misses out on family during Christmas and she partakes in the festivals, the dietary laws , she tries to convince that we are wrong but God forgives us - because we are somewhat ignorant or not as spiritually mature ., She almost had my wife convinced, but she took my advice to read Galatians as other scriptures., We get along great and have get togethers frequently. So glad that you are free and found the truth. GOD BLESS . The Word is a lamp unto my feet and ------- -

Jesus fulfilled the law and the Holy Spirit came. The temple was destroyed 40 years after the cross The mosaic promise also transitioned for 40 years. There is no more temple except true believers. The laws get written in.our hearts.

Oh my! The information about this movement was literally hidden in plain site! I searched for months and could find nothing and then found a plethora of teachings that were there for years…something didn’t want the information found during the years 2017-2021…

Thank you for this heartfelt testimony. I’ve never been part of the HR movement but I have family who is heavily involved. Walking under the law is a dangerous place to be. I have learned in my own walk to have balance. Coming out of the pagan holy days is every bit as important as coming out from under the OT law. Just because we’re not under the OT law doesn’t give us freedom to practice in pagan traditions, so balance is key. Of course these things have to be done with discretion. I don’t think we should shun our family for a Christmas dinner, but submerging ourselves in full pagan custom with all its symbolism is probably not wise either. I used to just love Christmas. I have so many happy memories of it, but after I studied with an honest heart, I couldn’t acknowledge it anymore as a true Christian tradition. “Come out of her” in Revelations absolutely pertains to removing all residue of the old mystery religion (and customs) from our lives. I will be the first to say it was hard for me because we loved this holiday, but once I gave it up, I felt like I had done the right thing. I do not judge or hate anyone who still practices it. I understand them perfectly. I knew for all my life that Jesus was never born in December, but that December 25th was the birth of the sun god. This is fact not theory. To this day, Christmas remains one of the most important “holy days” in the Pagan calendar by their own admission. Something to think on. Satan sprinkles truths in with poison in a complex way to form these cults. That’s why they’re so convincing to even the most sincere and intelligent people. We are notorious for throwing the baby out with the bath water when it comes to truths. The enemy knows this because he has been studying humans for millennia! So what a better place to hide such truths about these pagan holy days than inside a corrupt cult that doesn’t truly honor Christ Jesus (think also JWs 😳), yet they do have lots of truth regarding these holidays. To summarize, each of us have to be led by the Holy Spirit and be in prayer about all things! It’s simple as that. Loving the Lord Jesus and praying for truth (even if we don’t like it) so that we can make the best decisions regarding how we should honor God. The truth will set us free!

Need perhaps a mike. Sound quality not so good.

If you're not keeping sabbath you're not going to heaven Isaiah 66:23-24 Luke 6:22-23 Why would you forsakr your blessing so ypu can break the sabbath and get you angry in god's eyes?

Very excellent message..Thank You 🙏

I really wish I could hear this. There's basically no sound for some reason

2Pe 2:20 For if after they have escaped the pollutions of the world through the knowledge of the Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ, they are again entangled therein, and overcome, the latter end is worse with them than the beginning. 2Pe 2:21 For it had been better for them not to have known the way of righteousness, than, after they have known it, to turn from the holy commandment delivered unto them. 2Pe 2:22 But it is happened unto them according to the true proverb, The dog is turned to his own vomit again; 👉and the sow that was washed to her wallowing in the mire.👈 Proverbs 26 Isa 28:1 Woe to the crown of pride, to the drunkards of 🇺🇸Ephraim, whose glorious beauty is a fading flower, which are on the head of the fat valleys of them that are overcome with wine!

What about the name of God and Jesus. They say that it is supposed to be Yahuah and Yahushua. Is that correct?

Interesting that the presenter says she was in "Hebrew Roots" for two years, but was already "one of the biggest teachers.in my group of the law" (mm 12:30). She was a novice with superficial knowledge of her subject. Characterization of Torah as Old Testament Law replaced by New Testament Grace is as old as Marcion.

Very informative!

Thank you for sharing! I joined a hrm group a little over a year ago with my family. And while I was very straight forward about wanting to learn more about God through the feasts and upfront about not believing sabbath to be "kept", now all of a sudden I am accused of "wanting to sin" because of not believing to need to keep sabbath. Jesus is my sabbath rest, all days are his! I have noticed that along the way I kept more and more to myself. For example, we eat pork (because all foods are permitted) but I would not dare to say. My husband would call the assembly "church" and I would shush him"dont call this church they hate that"....why I didnt want to see how manipulative this group of people is...it feels like being gaslighted. I kinda feel stupid for letting me and my family fall for the lie. They seemed so loving. Untill you don't show progress in your keeping of the law. ....but I'm not sure how to get out of it. We love the people there, but I just can't participate anymore.

Nobody can completely understand the Bible unless they understand the relationship between the Old Covenant given to Moses at Mount Sinai and the New Covenant fulfilled in blood at Calvary. What brings all local churches together into one Body under the blood of Christ? The answer is found below. New Covenant Whole Gospel: Let us now share the Old Testament Gospel found below with the whole world. On the road to Emmaus He said the Old Testament is about Him. He is the very Word of God in John 1:1, 14. Awaken Church to this truth. Jer 31:31 Behold, the days come, saith the LORD, that I will make a new covenant with the house of Israel, and with the house of Judah: Jer 31:32 Not according to the covenant that I made with their fathers in the day that I took them by husband unto them, saith the LORD: Jer 31:33 But this shall be the covenant that I will make with the house of Israel; After those days, saith the LORD, I will put my law in their inward parts, and write it in their hearts; and will be their God, and they shall be my people. Jer 31:34 And they shall teach no more every man his neighbour, and every man his brother, saying, Know the LORD: for they shall all know me, from the least of them unto the greatest of them, saith the LORD: for I will forgive their iniquity, and I will remember their sin no more. Is the most important genealogy in the Bible found in Matthew 1:1 (Gal. 3:16)? Is God's Son the ultimate fulfillment of Israel (John 1:49)? Why has the modern Church done a pitiful job of sharing the Gospel with modern Orthodox Jews? Why would someone tell them they are God's chosen people and then fail to share the Gospel with them? Who is the seed of the woman promised in Genesis 3:15? What did Paul say about Genesis 12:3 in Galatians 3:8? Who is the "son" in Psalm 2? Who is the "suffering servant" of Isaiah 53? Who would fulfill the New Covenant promised in Jeremiah 31:31-34? Who would fulfill the timeline of Daniel chapter 9 before the second temple was destroyed? Why have we not heard this simple Old Testament Gospel preached on Christian television in the United States on a regular basis? Once a person comes to understand the New Covenant promised to Israel and Judah in Jeremiah 31:31-34, which is found fulfilled by Christ during the first century in Hebrews 8:6-13, and Hebrews 10:16-18, and specifically applied to the Church in 2 Corinthians 3:6-8, and Hebrews 12:22-24, man-made Bible doctrines fall apart. Let us now learn to preach the whole Gospel until He comes back. The King of Israel is risen from the dead! (John 1:49, Acts 2:36) We are not come to Mount Sinai in Hebrews 12:18. We are come instead to the New Covenant church of Mount Zion and the blood in Hebrews 12:22-24. 1Jn 3:22 And whatsoever we ask, we receive of him, because we keep his commandments, and do those things that are pleasing in his sight. 1Jn 3:23 And this is his commandment, That we should believe on the name of his Son Jesus Christ, and love one another, as he gave us commandment. 1Jn 3:24 And he that keepeth his commandments dwelleth in him, and he in him. And hereby we know that he abideth in us, by the Spirit which he hath given us. Watch the KZfaq videos “The New Covenant” by David Wilkerson, or Bob George, and David H.J. Gay.

Look up Steve Gregg, he has a video series about Torah observance. Its the most fair and accurate critique I have ever seen!

You seem very sincere, and kind and I appreciate many of your points, however being a former reformed protestant myself there are vast carry over into protestantism from Catholicism. There are many things that are taught by men like you reference that are also not in line with ancient orthodox Christianity. I would encourage you to read the earliest Christians, study the eastern churches and learn what they teach as well as looking into Anabaptist teachings as well. The Eastern churches do keep several festivals, acknowledge that Saturday day is the Sabbath and Oriental Orthodox today have church twice on the weekends the Sabbath (seventh) and what they also call the eighth day and the first day. I am just learning about Hebrew roots after extensive reading of the ancient bishops directly appointed by the Apostles and evangelists who gave us the new testament. Please young lady be careful, the moral law and the ceremonial law are indeed very different one is binding on all people, some exclusive to the Jews. I would be happy to dialogue with you if you have questions. I believe a work called the Apostalic constitutions by Clement of Rome (who like the author of James was a bishop ordained by an apostle) can explain many things you do not yet understand. Again thank you for your warnings about this movement and please consider that apophatic theology is superior to kataphatic theology as drawing the negative space in art helps you to arrive at a better picture, one of course helping to give us a better mental picture of the Invisible GOD than do positive assertions.

Yes this is sooooooo similar to my story

BIG PROBLEM. Hebrew, gentile, geek, means nothing from the moment Jesus said, "man". Man shall live by every word. The Sabbath was made for man. Under grace? Even graceful liars are eligible for salvation. 1John 2:3-4.

I don't know what or who the Hebrews roots is -but Jesus told us over and over if you love me you'll keep my commandments. We all know the catholics changed the Sabbath from Saturday to Sunday as if they know better than God. We know that Jesus and all the disciples were Jews and they preached to the Jews and Paul was a Jew and he was sent to the gentiles. We know that the gentiles were going to Synagogue on the Sabbath. We know that Peter's dream of clean and unclean was referring to gentiles, not food. To be heartbroken over missing Christmas is wild. I understand wanting to spend time with family, but to miss Christmas?? I encourage everyone listening to her to do your own homework. the Bible says God does not change. The laws are not hard to follow. Jesus said he did not come to change even one dot - the tiniest part of the Hebrew letters, so nothing changed. The new covenant simply means Gods covenant is written on our hearts and not on a tablet. Maybe don't get involved in legalistic type of groups and just follow the Bible's teachings.

Now that you have come out of the Hebrew Roots movement, I hope you no longer call the messiah "Yahushua" or "Yahshua". People who know how to read, write and speak Hebrew know that His name was Yeshua. It's just a shame that these HRM cultists don't even bother to learn biblical Hebrew or at the very least modern.

I think Hebrew roots is nessesary but also bears an enormous danger of becoming legalistic and looking view of the salvation through Jesus. I do not agree on all that he says, but I like unlearn yt channel. He teaches mainly Hebrew roots but also clearly says it is not wrong to call Jesus Jesus, since that is the English version of his name, he just preferst to say Yeshua. There is a difference between celebrating Easter as in worshipping the Goddess it is named after or celebrating the resaurection and calling it Easter, because it happens to fall in the same time frame.

There is Hebrew roots pastors on KZfaq teaching polygamy and having multiple wives. Did you see polygamy in your group.

Only two years in the movement? You must not have been taught much or understood certain things, I see you rely and reference feelings and perception quite a bit. Based on two of your links in the description I see two antinominians. What can I say, but go in peace back into what makes you feel good. Sad to lose you 😢.

Well that was disappointing. I was looking forward to hearing about your journey and how it lead you here. Instead, you just spend over 17 minutes describing a lot of "Hebrew Roots" things. Yet you never delved into the Bible to talk about why any of those things are wrong.

Christianity didn't begin in 1517 AD. If Protestantism had the "goods" Protestants wouldn't constantly feel like something is missing. I've been there. Blessings in Christ. ☦️

Good work, however I would say to beware of Calvinism, which is another crutch. It is an easy transition from law-keeping to covenant theology since it allows for the law in its system.

Its good that you came out when you did. Its one thing to be deceived by a false doctrine, its another thing to be a TEACHER of false doctrine. God spared you that greater judgment on teachers. You repented and He is faithful to forgive. May your children be set free by Christ.

Hmmm, my first statement concerning you. A question even if I might say. Which one? God's ways, or man's ways? There ought to be a difference between the two. Is there something wrong with Passover, you know considering Jesus is supposed to be the actual Passover Lamb? Should I go on? What's on the menu of the FDA? Do you know what's in your dog food? Don't remember pink slime in your McDonald's? Is there something wrong with the Sabbath? Wait! Jesus is the whole reason for something I'm wanting to look forward to and have my rest in Him that I can experience that, come that Day. A reminder once a week from the American Dream! I suppose Memorial Day is more holy for you.

Legalism and lies against God’s heart can be found in any direction when you follow people who put rules around rules and say things God never said to you. The root cause is having a Pharisee prideful spirit that needs to be revised, repented of, and renounced. It has less to do with “what” rules around rules and more to do with the fact that you put rules around rules and miss out on the relationship God wants you to have with him through his son and spirit. We are ALL adopted children of God, if redeemed by the perfect blood of the Exodus 12 lamb Jesus (yes, Yeshua in Hebrew). I have zero ties to the Hebrew roots movement, literally zero other than helping people get out of some very strange added teachings of it that caused them harm. Yet, I read my Bible and in my Bible it said celebrate these feast and festivals as a lasting ordinance to teach to our children and we have FUN with that. They all point to Jesus and Sabbath is blessed for rest and a great day to do the work of the Lord in peace. Yet while our family Shabbat Friday evening at sunset, we understand what Jesus meant when he said “sabbath (rest day) was made for man and not man for the Sabbath.” We volunteer at church on Sundays and help family on Saturday, yet we learn from scripture and not corrupt teachers that ignore God’s heart and try to claim you can’t even pull some weeds in the sunshine while playing worship music even if that’s how you find rest. Things like Shavuot is also the day of Acts 2 and a day to focus not on cheesecake or turn into modern political debate, but actually seeking the Lord and being filled with the Holy Spirit and the truth of the basics of scripture as you study and pray over them in unity with others, although there’s nothing wrong with having cheesecake. Yes, the 10 Commandments are the milk that does still need to be had as part of early growth. The big thing is stay away from Hebrew roots teachings, because they are not the teachings of scripture, instead as you read scripture simply do as it says and you’ll be blessed if you do it in the right mindset to the glory of God and to build your relationship with him and not try to fit in or create an identity with a culture that is really a cult of idolatry against him. From what I’ve heard when people repeat Hebrew roots teaching, they knew indoctrination that required twisted scripture. When a Lutheran doesn’t know Jesus would have actually been born in the fall that’s not a sin as they take December 25 to celebrate them, yet it is a sin to try to claim the devil has more ownership over December 25 then God does and create division because of it. When would Jesus have been conceived by the Holy Spirit? What is 9 full months before what is mid to late September? The devil is not a creator, he is a counterfeit and a thief. Don’t empower him in ANY direction. If you want to know what God wants you to avoid pray this prayer. God search my heart, revealed to me what I should give over to you. God forgive me for going to false teachers when Scripture says that if we are your sheep we hear your voice through Jesus your son. Help us to always check what we hear, be at from The spiritual or earthly realm to scripture. Help us not to fall into traps in any direction, Jesus light the way.

I am confused. My understanding is that we are to be (set apart) as (HE is set apart). Why would scripture say not to eat pork (but now it's ok) we are told in scripture (EVERYONE) not just the Jews are to keep Sabbath. I thought The OLD Testiment was VALID for reproof (clearly not). You have invented a new religion. Not just a new Covenant. I agree we should be berians and to be careful in what we preach. But what you are saying is LAWLESSNESS. If we have no law we are lost. And I am stunned at your (no reproof if your Jewish comment) you are missing the whole point of the gospel. To admonish the lost and show them THE TRUE MESSIAH. I pray you will see your error.

I appreciate you sharing your experience. However, i also thonk this is funny. Im not going get into the commentary; just the Lord requires obedience. Increase

we stick to his Word we have the Holy Spirit with discernment and r warned false teachings n false prophets in the end and that is warned over n over again we need to be diligent every lesson learned God has a reason for good video

I live as how I think Yahshua would rule this world. But there is more than 45,000 denominations globally so no one gots it 100% I pray that you would pray for me and I would pray for you not to see how you see or how I see but just see what YHWH wants you to see

Joshua Christ is lord!

Legalism is what kills Hebrew Roots. And a few of the things you talk about are the most heated topics. Its about taking the entire bible as a whole.

I don't know where you're getting the idea that people who are walking with God and are supposed to be going out and spreading the good news are isolating themselves from sinners that's not in Scripture and if those were the kind of people you were hanging out with then they were wrong Jesus sat with Sinners we are supposed to go out and spread the word to everyone especially the Sinners so stop taking what your friends did who may be wrong and misinterpreting what they're supposed to do to turning your back on the whole Bible are we not supposed to fear the lord? We had better be fearing the Lord!

"And it shall come to pass that everyone who is left of all the nations which came against Jerusalem shall go up from year to year to worship the King, the Lord of hosts, and to keep the Feast of Tabernacles. And it shall be that whichever of the families of the earth do not come up to Jerusalem to worship the King, the Lord of hosts, on them there will be no rain. If the family of Egypt will not come up and enter in, they shall have no rain; they shall receive the plague with which the Lord strikes the nations who do not come up to keep the Feast of Tabernacles. This shall be the punishment of Egypt and the punishment of all the nations that do not come up to keep the Feast of Tabernacles." Zechariah 14:16‭-‬19 NKJV The Law was NEVER salvific. If people in the Old Testament could have been saved by following the Law and things like animal sacrifice, they never would have needed a Savior, and Christ would be irrelevant. Therefore it is NOT an offense to the cross when it is resumed under Christ's direction during His millennial reign. There is a FOURTH temple, priests and Levites, and ANIMAL SACRIFICE continually being practiced because it was never an alternative to the work of saving grace, and Christ being the Word in the flesh literally embodies the very laws you hate.

Lady, don't throw away the truth because you had bad experiences. I'll answer all your questions and concerns and show you the error of the Hebrew Roots, but the truth of the Gospel. Please please.

This is what falling away looks like. Rejecting sabbath and the feasts. The spirit was removed from this lady so she had to justify it by speaking against our creator. The covenant is not for all.

Blessings..🙏🙏

If you listened to the debate between Rob Solberg and David Wilbur and decided not to keep the Sabbath any more you can make all the conversions you want David Wilbur crushed Rob with scripture and logic. The Sabbath was made for you to enjoy and bless you. Also Steve Moutri of Torah Family went over Rob's teaching. So you decided on December 24th to get out of it? Any Christmas pressure? lol I've been in your shoes and I know where you are at. This is going to eat at you until you actually get in the bible and study both sides for yourself. Sorry, the Father loves you and this isn't over. Praying for you. Neither Rob or David or kooks, you can trust they are giving you the best of both sides even though I disagree with Rob.

check out dr Micheal brown he is a Jewish believer and teaches against it also and he had a guest also recently who really went with many videos against it

Oh sister. I encourage you to fact check your interpretation of Apostle Shaul Paulos. He never forsook shabbat, nor did he eat pork or permit it. Consider what Galations is refering to throughout the entire letter, is his rebuke of the circumcission group. Circumcision is not done by the hands in the flesh, but by the Holy Spirit/ Ruach Khodesh in our hearts. The law that is (has) passing away is circumcision by the hands and sacrifices. Yeshua is our once and for all sacrifice, reconciling us to the Father. But also consider during the Millennial reign of Yeshua from Yerushalayim when the temple has been rebuilt during Yeshua's reign, that anyone who doesn't go up to the temple to keep the three main feasts do not get rain for the entire year. Can we work unto salvation? No!! No one is righteous unto salvation, & all our works (unto salvation) are as filthy menstrual rags. Yet we are exhorted to work out our salvation in fear and trembeling, and to strive lest we fall short through disobedience. Zechariah and Elizabeth were obedient and blamless in all the Torah and they were called righteous. The epistle of James/ Ya'aqov states faith without action shows your faith to be dead, but faith in action makes your faith complete. The Revelation 12:17; 14:12; 19:10b; 20:4. The accuser/hasatan goes to war with those guarding the commands of Elohim and possing the witness of Yeshua Messiah. Do serious Christians have a witness/ confession of Yeshua? Yes. Do they, guard and keep the commandments? No. Particularly the sabbath. Do orthodox Jew's guard keep the commandments? Yes, and a whole bunch of men made doctrine and dogma to which Yeshua rebuked in Matthew chapter 15. Do orthodox Jew's have a confession of Yeshua? No. If you are not grafted into Yisra'el/ Israel as stated in Galations 3:25-29; 1 Corinthians 7:17-20; Colossians 2:8-15; Acts 15:23-29 & Romans 2:26-29. Some of what you relayed of your experience was not right, and it is sad that you experienced this. But as another brother relayed in a post here, don't take onboard what does not align with scripture. The isolation you spoke of is concerning. However, that does not mean that we participate in pagan festivals such as easter/ishtar & Christmas (which is the worship of the sun god mithros, who's 'birthday' is the 25th December, as are all the sun gods, as they originated frombthe worship of Nimrod from babylon before the disperssion of languages. Mass means sacrifice, and sun god worship involved child sacrifice). As Jeremiah 16:19 says: 19. O יהוה, my strength and my stronghold and my refuge, in the day of distress the nations shall come to You from the ends of the earth and say, “Our fathers have inherited only falsehood, futility, and there is no value in them.” The Scriptures. 2009. 3rd edt. Deuteronomy 12:30-32 30guard yourself that you are not ensnared to follow them, after they are destroyed from before you, and that you do not inquire about their mighty ones, saying, ‘How did these nations serve their mighty ones? And let me do so too.’ 31“Do not do so to יהוה your Elohim, for every abomination which יהוה hates they have done to their mighty ones, for they even burn their sons and daughters in the fire to their mighty ones. 32“All the words I am commanding you, guard to do it-do not add to it nor take away from it. The Scriptures. 2009. 3rd edition. Northriding: Institute for Scripture Research. I believe you would appreciate the work coming out of Benai Emunah Institute, with Dr Miles Jones @ www.writingofgod.com They have over 72 1st century texts, manuscripts, & parchments that show Matthew through to Acts, & Hebrews through to The Revelation were all written originally in Hebrew. These texts, show up the changes instituted by Emperor Constatine and his court scribe Eusebius in the 4th Century to the bible we have today. The narrative is essentially the same, but there have been some harmful 'tweaks' added, as well as showing up simple misstranslations, etc. Of note from historical documentation is that Emperor Constatine declared the Messianic church/ kehilah/ assembly heretic. Consider that. In approx 321AD Constatine calls the original Assembly/ church of Yeshua HaMashiach/ Jesus Christ heretical. I find the most accurate teaching of the word of Elohim from Michael Rood, which you can watch for free on youtube. Or visit www.aroodawakening.tv Or Facebook at Shabbat Night Live. Shalom

You have struggeld with self righousness and roots of judaism. Thats different than hebrew roots😎 sabbath is a part of god and is the 7 day

Maybe, maybe you misunderstood.

Cheryll mac, you wrestled with christmas for a good reason...

Okay, which Commandments do you feel are required? Know what? None of them are. Not one. We have free will. We follow them because that what YHWH and YESHUA said made them feel loved. "If you love me, you'll follow my Commandments" The Torah is the first five books of The Bible, not the list for Shabbat. Our Creator made Saturday Holy (*set apart) as The Shabbat or Sabbath. Are you going to argue with HIM? These anti-Messianic Judaism commercials have been popping up everywhere. Satan is using your love of pork and pagan White traditions. You would rather claim those traditions because they were created by Whites. The NT in Greek? Paul didn't speak or write in Greek! Remember, the doctor Paul asked to accompany him as an interpreter? Yeshua is Hebrew. Jesus is Greek. Yeshua is a Jew. Jesus is half Catholic. Yeshua had hair if wool. Jes-us has a statue next to Ven-us and Ze-us in Rome. I can't speak for you or anyone else, but I feel differently when someone calls me a name they chose, vs the one written in the Book of Life. Yeshua said if it were a direct translation, call HIM the translated name. YESHUA has been called that for ????? The name JESUS 400 yrs ago. I call HIM YESHUA because I love HIM. Its not about whether you have to or not. Its about love for HIM. YHWH said if you love me you'll follow my Commandments. Your Creator shared His given name with you specifically to become closer. Yet, you call Him a generic term, God Lord etc. Corinthians chapter 6 expounds on not Christianizing pagan ANYTHING!