earlier today i uploaded this as “unlisted”, but after getting positive feedback from my class (this was a project i did) i decided to make it public since i’m happy with the result :) i have no idea if this will do well since it’s not my usual kind of upload 🙈 and my narration haha.. stay well, everyone!

Honestly Taylor, you’re always a step ahead when it comes to fun facts, but you really outdid yourself here. My dad is a punk musician, and that lineage has played a huge role in who I am as a singer and person. The fact that you managed to sprinkle in key details of the scene while weaving it with K-pop knowledge perfectly illustrates why I love both so much. Thanks for posting this and great job!

That was so well researched and interesting! Since you made this as a final project I dunno if you'll consider doing other vids like this one along with usual a.c.e content but I'd love to see more!

I was raised on punk and I love K-Pop, Rock and K-Pop are my music favorites, hands down.

What a lovely insight on a rare and such a creative topic. I love how you didn't constrict punk in a boxed music genre but showed how it is so fluidly used in influencing not just K-pop songs but also outfits . I love the research and from the video it is totally clear how passionate you were about it! The last A.C.E reference was a cherry on top. This was amazing Taylor 😍😍😍

WOW I LOVE THIS SO MUCH it's so well put together and researched and you are so well spoken (also love how you still managed to sneak A.C.E in there 😂). If this is something you enjoy doing I would LOVE to see more of it and nerd out about kpop music/fashion influences (alongside the usual content of course). 😍😍😍

this is so cooooooooool!!!! I love punk and kpop music so this was super interesting!!! great use of A.C.E too ofc 😉

ahhhh it’s so interesting to hear about all of these songs and music videos through this perspective and learning about all the influences on them!! thank you so much for this video 🥰

wow. this is so well presented. i'm glad you made this and decided to make it public even if it was for a project. edit: coming from someone in both kpop & punk scenes it was very interesting and educational.

oh this is so well thought-out and interesting?? i used to be a semi-fan of punk so this is really interesting to listen to :oo thank you for this video!! i’m only a couple minutes in but this is already really good!!

This is the video that I wanted to watch ever since I first liked kpop about a decade ago. I only listened to rock music and punk was my favorite genre, and when I got into kpop, I always had the feeling that I kind of didn't change the way that I enjoyed music, I felt like everything that I liked before I could find in kpop. I always knew there was punk in kpop but it was really hard for me to put a finger on it. Your research is amazing and I would easily watch an one hour version of this. You truly owned the format and the editing and I'm glad I subscribed long ago to get myself some good content ace edits but now here I am getting an excellent video essay. 🥰 Keep up the great work!

you don't understand how much i love this-- i am That diehard punk lover, it was my entire childhood up to adulthood, while falling devotedly for kpop♡ several years ago has been the most beautiful highlight of my musical life! Block B, Jiyong, Tabi, A.C.E all of these artists i love in a video that starts off with sex pistols?! seeing it in fashion everywhere is one thing but seeing you make note of it's clear effect in music ✨ what a wonderful project!!!

This was so interesting!! You’re very well spoken and used really good examples :))

This was so so interesting! One of the things I love about kpop is how many other music genres are incorporated into the music, but I never really noticed how many punk influences there are. I would definitely love to see more videos like that!!!

This is fantastic, I always love hearing about music history & how it affects musical genres today, and especially with the amount of variety in kpop. I'd love to see more like this!

YASS A.C.E GODSS OF REPRESENTATION

Proof that Choice are intellectuals. Good work here. I'll be sharing this A LOT.👍💕

Great video! It's well done, interesting and entertaining. I love the way you made the connection between the music who took over my teens (punk) and the music that took over my 20's (kpop). I'm definitely would like to see more videos like this :D

Yessssss

your narration voice is really good!~ I would watch this kind of content, it's very informative and interesting ✨ plus using ACE in school projects... that'll give you an A+ for sure

Your narration was flawless and the subject was really interesting! I used to be into a lot of pop punk music...wonder if that's how I got to where I am today :p Hope you get a good grade, it's clear how much work went into this ^^

Ahhh I remember you asked for some good Rock song in kpop 🥺💞 yYu presented this amazing, and I found it quite interesting!!!!

A.C.E gave you reason to cover this as your project if they knew they'd be really happy! it was so cool to see how you put everything in! you put my ults dreamcatcher tysm! a.c.e and dreamcatcher are my ults so yes my insomniachoice heart! this reminds me i still need to finish watching their Savage era showcase! I hope you got good praise for submitting your project! and always delighted when another a.c.e editioned video is made by you! keep it up thank you for loving and supporting our best boys!

I really enjoyed this so much. I always wondered how I ended up liking kpop so much after listening to so much punk rock/pop throughout my teenage years and now I got my answer. If you decide to continue with this type of content from time to time I'd be very happy to watch again^^

nice

Key 'born to shine' performance 😍

really interesting vid, i have watch a lot of kpop stuff on YT but i never saw one related to punk ^^ also how u sneaked a.c.e in there noiceee :3

I know i'm a year late to this video but this was so fun to watch! I remember i was in my "punk phase" when kpop first became known in my country (with the 2gen groups, so around 2009-2010?) i didn't get it then, i thought kpop seemed to "cute" and "manufactured" , but now that i am in my "kpop phase" , and after seeing this i get it totally! kpop, just like punk, is a way of finding a sense of self and belonging to a community outside of what's conventionally popular. It really goes to show that at the end of the day we all have more similarities than differences

👏👏👏

that's so cool and interesting to watch! that would be a great video to show to someone who doesn't know much about kpop ❤️❤️❤️

This is super interesting stuff!! I don't know much about punk history so learning a bit about it is really cool. Thank you Taylor!

as a punk and k-pop fan and i am really thankful you pointed out the similarities AND that k-pop is never gonna be punk. this is really well done

U have the potential to be a TV host/presenter..love your intonation and diction so much...

👍🔥

wow, what a great video, learned a bunch :)

This is an amazing video, you deserve way more likes for this, I hope you do more videos like these! (Only if you want to of course)

7:43 i wasn't expecting this in punk related video :))))

Dang. That must be why I love kpop. Just look at my favorite groups lmao. Dreamcatcher, A.C.E., and BTS. Also kbands. Kbands are love and life, ok?

"I'm married to the music" BG 😏

I love this so much O.o♥

This is a really cool analysis! My family, including extended, grew up on punk and the hard rock scene in both Spanish and English. My emo phase (yikes) was influenced by it as well, so im also a fan of metal, atl., pop-punk, and classic rock. I've been exposed to the areas since I was a baby lol. Im still an avid fan of all of those just as much as I am of bubblegum kpop. So this was a big merge of my worlds. I agree with the punk styling carrying over into more aggressive kpop sound. However, the behavior doesn't seem to. Punk doesn't mean only disrespect, but kinda disruption. I think its ironic that the idol image is so important, but they want to dress them and have them pretend to be delinquents for mvs. The teen age rebellion concept is so overused, yet none of those idols would even dare to look at someone of the opposite gender. Kpop really takes poser punk to a new level. If a song has a second of guitar, the concept immediately means aggressive and scary. Under cover and savage by ace are some of the only ones I've seen that have the sound to back it up. The punk agenda doesn't always mean just music. Genderless clothes are a concept within. so im glad you mentioned ace and their clothes! Punk is going against the norm, which means in almost any way. As well as accepting those that are different and giving anyone who wants it,, a home. i think ace have been doing that well. (thats gushy and off track i love them sorry back to it) Dreamcatcher as well, but ironically they're not styled as such and are more styled to fit a Gothic theme. But to be fair, my girls are probably the closest kpops gonna get to goth anyways. Its So cool to dissect this all, I never would have thought about it This was really well done. I hope you do more analysis in the future! :)

Hobgoblin 💕💕💕💕💕

I kinda shock to see vixx in here tho 😂😂😂

Excuse-me, if someone can ad subtitles to this video, please do! I am really interested in this, but the song with her voice confuses me. It will be easier for me to read so I can understand everything perfectly. It can be in English. Thank you wowson universe for this amazingly well done work!

What about mod influence on K-pop? I wouldn't be surprised if it was a small but significant source of stuff that the companies behind these groups would appropriate. As far as Crass goes, they were actually hippies. They openly said that they were involved in the hippie movement, especially the free festival circuit.

Kpop nggak ada akhlak