Please pin me I like pain

Hiccup: *shoots Toothless’s left tail off* Toothless: *bites Hiccup left leg off* Also Toothless: *get nae naed*

So toothless didn't betray him he just accidentally pulled off his foot.

I never really thought about how he lost his leg, I was just like "Oh, he lost his leg..... well that's rough!" But you do make a very good point.

Her:Toothless is responsible for his leg Me:He is responsible for Hiccup surviving 😂

Notice how in each movie he lost smth each movie 1 his leg 2 his dad 3 his dragon 4 I cried

Honestly that picture in the thumbnail is terrifying

Wait he's not a traitor he just tried to save him as fast as he can

Toothless: *yanks off hiccup’s foot to save hiccup* Me: was it delicious?

What Toothless eats: •Fish •Hiccup's leg •Eel •Hiccup's Sweat(licking his face) •Hiccup's prosthetic leg.

What I've always thought is this: Pretty much same as you said, as they fell, Toothless grabbed the part of Hiccup he could reach - his leg. But I believe he had his teeth retracted. If he didn't, there's a chance he would bite it off and he wouldn't be able to hold on to Hiccup that way. So, I think with teeth retracted, he chomped down on the leg and held tight. So tight that he crushed Hiccup's leg. Unintentionally, of course. But the leg was crushed beyond repair, Gobber saw right away that they would have no choice but to amputate it.

Wait people thought his leg was burnt off? I already knew from the beginning that Toothless bit Hiccup's leg off so he could pull him closer and protect him

Hiccup : “ i lost my leg when me and toothless fought the red death ! “ Zuko: “ thats rough buddy “

Yeah duhh hiccup even says in the second film. "Actually i shot him down oh but he got me back soo PEG LEG"

*Lets all put ourselves in Hiccup's shoes.* (Pun included)

These are good points, but if Toothless had bit off the leg completely, Hiccup would have kept falling and turned into charcoal; yet he has hardly any burns, implying that his dragon caught him successfully. We see Toothless reaching out before entering the fire, so I always thought that he wrapped his claws around (or in) the leg in a hurry and yanked Hiccup into his wings. The claw wounds + force of crashing into the ground at a weird angle caused a sort of amputation in itself. Though that's just my personal headcanon

video thumbnail: hoW hICcuP ReAllY lOsT hIs Leg!!! TOOTHLESS IS A TRAITOR!!! actual video: na mate he was just doin' his best

So......he bit his leg off by accident trying to save him? That's basically what you are 'trying' to say right?!

:toothless you shot off my tail so i ate your leg :hiccup ...

Theory : toothless sacrificed his leg to save him. Thumbnail : TrAiToR

Like she said Toothless didn’t mean to hurt Hiccup, it was either Hiccup loses a leg or he DIES. That doesn’t make Toothless a traitor it makes him a hero.

1. Toothless bites off hiccups leg on accident. 2. Toothless kills hiccups dad on accident. What's next?

Um, this wouldn’t be a betrayal. There would be no point in going after Hiccup just to eat his leg. Plus, his goal was to save him anyway. Although, the moral of this is that you’ve been Click baited...

He unintentionally saved Gobber from losing his other delicious leg by losing his own.

“ the third and last one” Homecoming: “ am I a joke to you?”

Gobber: "Hiccup, were is your leg!?" Toothless: *nom nom nom* Hiccup: "I haven't the foggiest idea."

*How Hiccup REALLY lost his leg* COUGH COUGH: FOOT

This video: exists Me: *thinks of how Toothless lost one of his tail flukes Also me: Hiccup basically hot KARMA

No one: Alteori: The third and last one. Homecoming: EXCUSE ME?!?

Ok.. but how tf does that make him a traitor

At least Hippcup is alive and toothless I mean.... I want How to train your dragon 3 and 4 like if you agree P.S you don't have to like

Yeah... you make a great point in that car analogy. Toothless wasn't moving in the opposite direction though but getting chomped and pulled would still totally make you lose a limb. Man... Such a great movie.

I thought everyone new that when toothless grabbed hiccup he bite hiccup leg

What happened to hiccup How to train you dragon 1- Lost his leg😢😢😢😢😢😢 Httyd 2- Lost his father😢😢😢😢😢😢 Htyyd 3 (hidden world) - Left his dragon😢😢😢😢😢

1st how to train your dragon my childhood 2nd was growing up already 3rd im all grown up now :')

This just makes me love their relationship even more❤️❤️

Love that you are a HTTYD fan! Hiccup is my spirit animal and one of my role models! I'm not ashamed!

I thought Toothless didn't fully envelop him at first and so Hiccup's leg stuck out in the fire during the fall. Toothless's wings probably fully covered him by the time they hit the ground, but not in time to save his leg. Your theory could work; however, if Toothless ripped Hiccup's leg clean off, Hiccup would just have kept falling, and wouldn't have been saved. Maybe it was a mixture of the dragon bite and the fire, who knows.

His leg got yeeted end of the story

Though this is a theory I've had since watching the clips on KZfaq (I was too young to notice when I watched the movie), there really are a handful of other things that could've happened. I doubt it was burnt because the rest of his leg is fine and as you said, it would be his hair if anything. Also, they did have quite the fall, and Toothless did seem to at least partly land on Hiccup, so it could've been broken pretty bad and, considering that these are vikings, maybe unfixable with their current technology.

In movie 3, the detachable leg saved his life. During the falling scene at the end, the villain was holding his leg, and Hiccup detached just in time for the light fury (Toothless' girlfriend) to catch him while letting the villain keep falling.

Tbh I just thought/think toothless didn’t manage to cover one of his legs with his wings, like you know when your foot is hanging out of the bed. That’s the situation I thought was here.

I thought this was obvious...in HTTYD2 Hiccup jokingly said Toothless"got even" with him

Toothless: I NEED TO SAVE HIM and his leg look good and tasty

So A couple weeks ago my mom got surgery and when we were driving back home this dude infront of us had his leg out the window, my dad said something close to "you think surgery is bad? imagine your leg getting ripped of"

He lost his leg because the WiFi went out

U dare call toothless a traitor 😾

Hiccup: shoots toothlesses tail off Toothless: rips leg off Me: now their even or MAYBE HICCUPS LEG JUST BURNED OFF

Why does everybody think Toothless is a traitor? Toothless is the fastest dragon in existence being an Night fury, and Hiccup was falling fast. He had no other choices by grabbing his leg and ripping it off to save him. If Toothless didn't rip Hiccups leg off, he would've died in the fire in the matter of seconds, you're hearing this from a HTTYD nerd and super fan.

I mean ur not wrong but why does the picture say traitor?

This appears to be one of the only possible conclusions that make any sense. After watching this movie nearly 13 times already, Hiccup just wouldn't be able to survive any other way. Toothless' forelegs were far to short to catch Hiccup and pull him in, furthermore Toothless' arms and foreclaws aren't exactly meant for grabbing. Even if he had managed to grab him and pull him in, I doubt Hiccup's leg would take to kindly to Dragon claws digging into it to pull him up. Impact causing the injury seens exceedingly unlikely just due to how the two fell together, with Toothless taking the brunt of the landing. Lastly Gobber within the one of the final scenes states that Toothless saved "most" if Hiccup, implying he lost his leg after they had hit the ground. Whilst this theory is solid and has quite a bit if evidence backing it, I still have one question in mind; the video itself states a multitude of times that the injury was most likely unintentional on Toothless' end. So why bother hinting at it beung intentional by putting "Traitor!" within the title, whist not discussing the plausibility of the injury being intentional? Just seems like a cheap method to get views, however that is just my opinion

Obviously, she is kidding Toothless may have pulled off his leg or something but that doesn't make him a traitor

Toothless: im gonna pull whats called a pro gamer move

I thought you’re going to say he ate his leg looking at the thumbnail. Am I just the violent imaginator?

It's a darn DreamWorks movie it doesn't have to be perfect

Thank you soooooo much for describing the results of that traffic accident, the leg. Queasy.

No toothless had to get even my guy- since hiccup shot one of his tail wings- And toothless ate his leg-

I just thought it happened. no details. his leg just fell off.

Hiccup lost his leg because Toothless tried to save him. ME: **Cough** or he just got revenge for Hiccup shooting him down **COUGH** **COUGH COUGH COUGH** Coronavirus

I always thought it was the fire that made hiccup lose his leg but after watching this video I have to agree with you on the fact that toothless was the one that severed his leg.

also toothless: oh balls hes gonna die if he goes into the fire utube channels: TOOTHLESS IS A TRAITOR DEATH TO THE DRAGONS

In the dreamwork series hiccup said "i shoot his tail and he bite my foot"

I would say there is another option: A couple tons of dragon, landing directly on his lower leg, as they crash to the ground. Bones crushed beyond recovery with viking 'medicine', so amputation became the choice, to prevent future pain. Even using his mouth with retracted teeth, he wouldn't NEED to hold Hiccup, just grab and tug to slow him down and catch him with his claws. As far as the forces, YES, Hiccup would be pulled upwards toward Toothless, but the change in velocity isn't that much. Toothless is moving FASTER than he is, to be able to catch up to him, so he only has to slow Hiccup down ENOUGH to overtake him fully. Its a few mph slower, as opposed to a dead stop in mid air. You as a person could probably pull with the same force on someone's leg and not do too much damage. And Toothless getting him back could still just apply to the fact that he was involved in damaging the leg and the result of it.

Yes and the fact in homecoming zephyr said how did you lose your leg because she was talking about dragons being dangerous and hiccup was like uhh umm

I always assumed he lost his leg from the fire

Atleast he saved him

I agree what your theory is. I had the thought as well. In a ironic way Toothless did get back at Hiccup back. I think Hiccup notes it in the 2nd movie. .. "You couldn't save all of me"

he wasn't a traitor...he just accidentally ripped of his leg

Hiccup even talked about toothless being the reason that his leg is gone

Toothless ate his leg Toothless had a great lunch

I always just though it was burned off by the fire because that part was exposed and not protected by toothless' fire proof scales, but then when it got to a certain point toothless could cover it thereby putting it out.

She is so well thought out. It makes perfect sense. Holy shit, this movie still surprises me years later.

There’s a difference between “Traitor” and “Accident”

Probably from a spike. It was an accident you know that. Hes not a traitor

So, it's not at all possible that Toothless grabbed him but while falling, didn't manage to fully envelope him until after the burn damage was so bad it had to be amputated? Considering their level of technology, the odds of Hiccup surviving an amputation of burned flesh are *MUCH* higher than the odds of him surviving infection from the bite, what with the saliva which contains billions of dragon bacteria, not to mention fish and whatever the hell else has been in his mouth. If it were the latter, I'd put his odds at a little under 1/1000000. In addition, when Hiccup is getting out of bed after the injury, Toothless sniffs and inspects the new prosthetic with caution and skepticism. This makes little sense if he bit off the leg himself *but* if the last time Toothless saw him, he did have his leg (albeit charred and blackened), he'd be surprised by it being missing. A prosthetic in and of itself wouldn't surprise him as he's seen others (and has one himself). And also, wouldn't there be part of a leg somewhere? All in all, while there isn't concrete evidence one way or the other, it seems the odds are greatly stacked in the favour of it being burn damage as opposed to dismemberment.

Has anyone thought about the fact that Toothless could have caught up, wrapped his wings around Hiccup, but Hiccup slipped past him, at least enough for his leg to get burned?

Toothless is always protecting Hiccup In worst Situations

*Toothless after biting hiccup leg * :You Just Got Victored

Toothless tried grabbing hiccups leg but he accidentally rips it off. But. Hiccup kept falling so toothless ducked his wings and when they were about to hit the ground toothless caught hiccup with his wings and held him tight. when stoick held hiccup and carried him home, Gobber must of fixed his leg bc it was all broken. u may like if u agree, u do not have to. if u can pls pin me.

I mean it’s not really a traitor if Toothless grabbed Hiccup’s leg to save his life..

Incase you actually couldn't tell at 3:05 you can see toothless reaching out to grab him with his paws/claws. He probably didn't BITE his legs off, like you've said. He also could've wrapped Hiccup up without realizing his leg was still exposed, there are other ways to look at this- We never actually see the leg after this has happen so if he bit hiccups it off, there would've been a lot of blood. It could've just been severely burnt (like I said before) so they had to cut it off.

I would think the when Toothless wrapped his body around him, but the impact of hitting the ground injured his leg, and the doctors had to cut it off as it was to injured to fix or something

A eye for a eye or in case a leg for a tail.

"Couldn't save all of me so he just had to make it even." Quote from hiccup HTTYD 2

He aint a traitor,he just tried to save him as fast as possible,thats what i call bonding.

This makes sense. I like your theory of opposite velocity and your mother is one brave woman! If that was the case, Toothless did indeed need to lock unto Hiccup and change direction very quickly. I thought he wasn’t able to cover all of him in the explosion, so his leg was blasted. The biggest hint for me that Toothless was remorseful, was his somber expression when Hiccup’s father came. If he was fully successful he would have been exuberant. Thanks for the video!

at 1:22 does anyone else see a dragon figure in the flames on the right?

some people thing that Toothless did it on purpose knowing that hiccup had shot him down causing him to loose his tail, y'know "an eye for an eye"

I've always assumed Hiccup's leg was badly broken from the collision with the Red Death and couldn't be salvaged. If you look at his legs when he's falling, the left one (the one he loses) does seem to be at a slightly weird angle but of course, the film itself isn't going to show a mangled, irreparable leg since it wouldn't be family-friendly. Toothless also reaches out to him with his limbs and wings first but I suppose Toothless taking off Hiccup's leg would mirror Hiccup taking off Toothless's tail fin.

Toothless just wanted to be even with Hiccup.

toothless: i can't grab him with my legs hiccup: falling faster toothless: oh wait i have a mouth

3:46 Imagine that head collision scene from the movie "Deathproof"

I think your theory is correct! It was such a clean amputation, and no burn marks or anything have ever been seen on Hiccup's leg.

Who else already at least had an idea that's what happened

Hiccup: falling Toothless: left leg, wait new left tail nom nom nom nom Toothless:damn it still no tail

I like how you call toothless a traitor when it was hiccup who got toothless’ tail ripped in half

Oh my God this is terrifying but it also makes perfect sense. I'm torn between the feeling of watching a gory horror movie and the feeling of understanding and gratitude that Toothless did everything possible to save Hiccup. 5:00 SO YOU'RE TELLING ME HE MEANT THAT LITERALLY. IT ALL MAKE SENSE NOW.

Now that I think about it, Toothless brings his wings in to give less air resistance to slow him down. He grabs Hiccup’s foot, then has to re-open his wings to pull Hiccup in. That would give Toothless just barely enough time to cover Hiccup from the fire... But this still leaves me with another question... How did Hiccup end up with his head by Toothless’ head? There couldn’t have been enough time to flip Hiccup like that if it was his foot that was grabbed... Hiccup would’ve had to do a flip... Followed by Toothless falling and pulling Hiccup in... Help...?

I think hiccup was wrapped up in toothless’s wings, but one of the legs were stuck out and was burnt off of him

Not leg a foot for his life be grateful hiccup “lol”