Here I am binge watching your old videos ❤

I never understood why companies even sell onion sets, my first year of gardening, I purchased sets, and I found out the hard way that sets do not grow decent onions. I now start seed indoors every February and most of my onion are softball size or better. I grow kalsae, and Alisa Craig, and walla walla. Zone 5a Wisconsin. I nevertop them, just run a string between rows, that way the neck doesn’t bend and the full leaves are still intact to absorb the sun.

Thank you! All my onions have fallen over and I couldn’t figure out why, nothing on the web other than they were ready to harvest, when they definitely weren’t. Live and learn for next year!

I discovered this channel 2 weeks ago and have been watching a few hours worth of MIgardener videos a day! I picked up a bundle of slab wood from the local Amish sawmill for $15 , and i am building several raised beds out of those. would have been close to $200 for the lumber so i am building them for basically $3 a piece. Just wanted to say thanks to MIgardener for inspiring me to get my hands dirty and help provide for my family! Also to try and eat healthier and get some exercise while we are stuck at home during these crazy times we are in! Always wanted to garden and now at 40 years old i'm diving in head first! Thanks Luke and family for the inspiration!

A topic that doesn't change much over time. Thanks for the summary, grown a lot of things but new to onions.

Luke, thank you so much for the time you and your family put into helping us grow our food. We so appreciate every moment.

Hey Luke - great videos. Would you consider doing a video on how to harvest, cure & store onions similar to the one you did for garlic recently? Appreciate all your hard work. Alison from Canada (Zone 4B)

Great info! But don't just discard those pinched off greens. Those are my favorite part of the onion. 😋 I snip them into little rings that go in all kinds of salads, soups, casseroles, eggs...

I agree on avoiding sets, however I also avoid seeds. The easiest way to get big onions is to go to dixondale farms, pick a variety, order onion transplants, put in your zip code. They send the onions the week you should plant for your zone. I spaced mine at 8 inches and just harvested about 250 softball sized onions. Red zeplin and yellow Spanish. My largest are bigger than what you see in the store. The key is green transplants, spaced 8 inches and most importantly planted on the date for your zone which is going to be an early date. The onions nearest my irrigation stayed green longer and got larger but I only irrigate 30 min a day so it's light.

Took your advice and planted 4, 72 cell trays with 3 different onions and a Carentan leek. Started on the winter solstice, so most plants are a couple few inches tall already, looking for larger transplants in the spring as well. My potting mix is very similar to yours, 40%sifted aged compost, 40% sifted leaf mold and 20% aged worm castings. Next time I water, will start using compost and worm casting extracts as feed. Going to try using all home made fertilizers this year. I have 2, 5 gallon buckets of comfrey/borage tea from last fall and plenty compost and worm castings for making teas and extracts. Enjoy your videos. Stay well!!!

Thank you from UK. I have spent so much money buying sets of all colours and sizes and never produced a single onion worth talking about. This video is very helpful and identifies the problems. Hopefully next year I will grow some decent onions. Thanks. Really appreciate your vegetable growing videos.

I have watched a number of your videos for years and I appreciate how sincere you are and try to give accurate information. You even admit when you get things wrong.

I have to admit Luke, I had no idea about long day and short day varieties! This was a great teaching video! I've only grown green onions, but I want to start growing many different varieties soon. This is going to help out a lot! Thank you so much for all this great information! Nothing beats fresh grown produce right in our own backyards!! I love how much beauty nature has to offer, right at the tips of our fingers🍃🐝

Only just started to watch your channel and have found that you can teach a very old dog new tricks.

Fun fact, onions (and other bulbs) need nitrogen not phosphorus because bulbs AREN'T roots, they are modified leaves #TheMoreYouKnow

I binge watch new and old videos. I appreciate all of the time you put into these.

Watched this and kinda put it in the back of my mind. Local farm stand here in Eastern PA, Poconos had sets. Red, White and Spanish. I bought a flat of each for a raised bed. Stuck them in early and let them go. I came back to this vid a while later and I'v topped and weeded my box. Nothing but compost and eggshells crushed and a we bit of time release lime at the start. I'm pulling 2 or 3 each week for my salads and they are banging ! Big bulbs. I think the farm stand was selling appropriate sets for the zone. The weeding and topping has made a huge difference. Other gardeners in my community garden are seeing poor results. Care and attention are my best friends. Thanks for the vids..... You Rock Dude ! ! ! ! !

😊 thank you so much for reviewing this again. I have epically failed at growing onions. That being said, I did little research and bought sets with no knowledge of long day short day. My husband just came out of his office and giggled as I am watching your video and said “so your trying onions again I take it?” My response right before you talked about. I bought sets and the store doesn’t say long day or short day. So I was doomed before I started. 😂 This year is my year!!

Thank you for putting these videos out, even if repeat! Much appreciates!

I'm gardening for the first time and i felt mildly called out,,, but! this was super helpful! I took lots of notes!

I appreciate you going threw the chemicals in the fertilizer and what they do for the plant. For YEARS I've been gardening and they just won't stick in my head. I wish there was a fertilizer for the brain :( Thank you for the video.

Now I’m going to try onions from seed next year!

Long/short day has always frustrated me haha, on my street I’m above 32* latitude. But my neighbor is south of it! Right on the line.

Hi Luke, in your opening comments you spoke about watching your older videos, I watch everything that you produce. You are the best source of information for gardening anywhere!!! 😃 You are my first go to for everything. Thank you and Cindy and your team so very much for providing all this free source material for gardening. That being said, do you have a video on Core Gardening? I would like to find out how to do that and apply it to my beds. I am in zone 9B, South Houston Texas. 🇨🇱 A lot different than Michigan. LOL. Again, thank you for all the great material. I wouldn’t have very much success if I hadn’t watched all of your videos. God bless and thanks 🙏🏽

Thanks for info..I truely appreciate it. You know you are one of the few channels I watch the whole video. .Blessings

Thanks for another well researched and presented video. I am growing onions in the sub-tropics (Brisbane Australia) so can only grow short day onions but finding out which varieties available here are short day onions is very hard. The seed packets don't specify. I now have found a couple of varieties and they are growing well. I will harvest them in October/ November ( our late spring). I dehydrate the onion leaves and grind them into a powder to use in my cooking. It is much better than the onion powder from the supermarket.

How do you take a vacation? Like I mean, what prep do you do before & do you have someone come water/weed for you? Would be interested in a video on that please. Thank you for your videos!

I'm from the future and I can say that I definitely have been watching the old videos. Ive been watching gardening videos since April of 2021 and keep getting deeper and deeper into gardening youtube lol

I plant Onions in the Winter and pick them in July . I just pulled few out a couple days ago and the largest are the size of Tennis balls .

Hello Luke, first of all I love your videos, honesty and passion you have for gardening. You’ve mentioned that you don’t water your raised beds because you do core gardening. My question is, would this apply to my beds being that I live in Southern California? In the San Fernando Valley to be exact, where the summer temps can be over 100 degrees, and we don’t get any rain like you guys in MI. Thanks in advance and keep up the great job! 👍😊

Good info. I 100% agree about onions sets. One option that you didn't mention is buying onion plants. Browns of Omaha or Dixondale are good places to buy plants. They ship when you want them and offer a good selection of varieties and the more you buy the cheaper they are. I usually order for a bunch for the neighbors also. So much easier than starting from seed. Long day onions are very frost tolerant. I planted mine on April 4th and had two heavy snows after that. (I am west of you and another MI gardener) Only the cippolinis (Italian flat) wanted to flower. Cheers.

First!!! I bought onion seeds from your store online Alisa Craig onions. And this is my first year to have BIG onions. I will definitely buy onions seeds again next season. I live in new Jersey.

Glad I saw this video because my onion tops are so long. Tomorrow I'll give them a haircut!! This Florida gardener loves your videos. Go Big Or Go Home. Love it!!

I go back and watch your old videos all the time. I even watch ones ive already watched to refresh my memory haha. God bless!

Great tips! I’m resurrecting an old garden bed that my parents used and I used several years ago, hopefully it will yield a good crop for me! Hugs and love from Texas! Zone 8

Zone 8 and my onions are doing great it’s my first garden short day onions and I just ringed them and wow so excited to start harvest when I get the 13th leaves they seem to be growing in different stages but that’s ok I can’t eat all 75 at one time lol going to be eating fresh and dehydrating for filling my powdered onion jar along with premade season packages I use for fast cooking

Thank you so much Luke! I tried onions for the first time last year, and they didn't get much bigger than the sets I started with. ☹️ I thought I just won't bother with onions anymore, but you have reinvigorated my resolve to try again. I did everything wrong, starting with the sets. 😝

Thanks for the video. A few questions when starting from seed...approximately what date do you start the seed, do you provide bottom heat when doing so, roughly when do you transplant outside, and when does harvest occur? I'm struggling to find a tutorial that actually hits on approximate dates when starting from seed and subsequently transplanting and harvesting (I'm in NC...gonna try my hand at growing Red Creole [short day] onions in calendar 2023). Thanks in advance, and keep up the great videos!

My onions were not very large but I am super excited that I was able to grow what I did in a couple pots. Hoping for more and better next year.

I'm growing sets, and their turning out great.

Thank for this video!! I’m a newbie at onion and garlic growing but this video taught me a lot for next year to top off, spacing and grow from seed in the variety for long day onions! I got quite a few small golf size onions this year just winging it so happy they grew at all!

I truly love your video's . I just planed my onion seeds today

Great video Luke! It answered a lot of questions for me. Can you also do another growing guide on shallots?

Luke: I just want to help you grow an onion larger than a ping pong ball. Me: shows a picture of an onion slightly bigger than a ping pong ball. Cue angle music Luke: my life is complete 😂😂😂

Thank you, I found it. I found your video on the core gardening that you produced sometime ago. Take care guys❌⭕️♥️ 🐰

Very good and most interesting as usual! You Yanks are so enthusiastic, which is very refreshing. We Brits are naturally a bit on the gloomy side! Keep up the good work and thankyou. Vic in South Oxfordshire, UK.

Well I learned something new todaythank you very much I always thought those onions came from Vidalia Texas I had no clue that they came from Vidalia thank you for educating me

I am brand new sub. I picked out 4 videos I really needed to watch and now as I am doing some chores I am going down the lines to watch all of them or at least I will watch 95% I bet. You would be surprised at some golden nugget bit of info you really needed found in some previous videos. Learn from others!!!!

Thanks. I'm going to try topping. Never done that. I had done sets, but next time I'll try the seeds.

I love binge-watching all your informative videos

I used your advice and grew the biggest onions I’ve ever grown! I’m setting an alarm for next winter to get my onion seeds started. Never using onion sets again.

You always give amazing and clear advice. I have learned so much from you I almost feel like I need to pay you for your time haha. How can novice gardeners like myself support you? I have just over three months of Gardening experience and have feel in LOVE with this stuff. From Oregon, thank you.

Luke! You are using 32⁰ as the cut off for short day onions. I'm just shy of 35⁰. I have struggled to grow onions for years. 😅 I've been planting short day onions. You just blew my mind.

learned a lot , thanks. This year I will try seeds and trim the tops.

I love growing green onions!! You have such great tips about so many different plants. Thank you for clarifying how they grow! I can't wait to have an onion bed like yours!

WOW! I had no idea I needed to top my onions. Thank you!!

Thanks for clearing up about the 32 degrees for I knew nothing about that and I am planning to grow huge onions and at least pingball size and much like yours and larger. Last season I did have a bigger than my head size 16.5 lbs canolope hybrid from Gurneys Seed and they said often between 10 - 20 lbs.

I've been growing onions a for decades and the best tip I can give is to grow from seed and never buy onion sets. Made a world of difference for me and I have tried sets again.

Please talk about the difference between onion sets and small onion plants, I think these are often confused.

Luke thank you for doing this again! I just pulled out my garden journal and took notes while you spoke. I never knew that topping the onions could help. Or that you need high nitrogen.

I really enjoy how knowledgeable your videos are. They are full of tons of useful information. I also love your seed store and prices. The only thing I get hung up on in your videos is how much you tend to ramble at the beginning. Only 2 minutes of it in this video so actually not too bad. I have ADHD so its hard for me to remain tuned in long enough to get to the information I am here for. Again, I am a subscriber and a fan and I appreciate your knowledgeable videos...just a little input from the peanut gallery.

Great information.Really enjoyed viewing it.

The rain knocked down all my onions!!! I am SO bummed. I'm glad to hear this because I'll concentrate on this next year!!!

At the start you mentioned that you hadn't watered those onions and they turned out great. A little later in the video you mentioned the more water (within reason) the larger the onion. I was researching how to water onions and was a little confused by those two statements. Many thanks.

Thanks for the info. I just located the 32nd parallel on the map. I was terribly surprised that it was so far South. I’m in East Tn and I just assumed it was North of us. It’s a good distance South. I’ve always grown short day onions with good success here. The Walla Walla and the Georgia Sweets primarily. Great info I will start using in my bed this summer.

Luke your onions amaze me and this year I tried my hardest to get there. I did have a success as they grew well the failure is that I kept picking them because they were so tasty. Will plant more next year and try to keep away. Thank you for all your information.

Man you have the most beautiful plants

Thank you for the great video on onions. I am a little despondent that the sets I just planted may not produce the amazing onions I have imagined. Seeds next time!!

well, i failed onion seeds this summer, so bought garlic and onion bulbs at lowes for fall planting. i see now that was a mistake, but it's done, so i will plan to retry seeds in the spring! sooner or later i'll get it right!!!

Great info, I always wondered how to get BIG onions. First time last year growing onions from seed(winter sow method) which germinated wonderfully but it was such a busy year they suffered. I have seeded some onion seeds in the fall, curious to seed if they will germinate and grow(zone 3). I will definitely put your advice to the test this year! Had no idea to top the leaves which makes alot of sense. Thank you for this video, it is very helpful.

onion greens are just as good as the actual onion itself. I use them endlessly!

my onions were grown from starts, and I noticed they have all bent and fallen over. I didn't know that mean the onion was done growing until watching this video. Thank you for the tip, and for helping free up some space in my beginners garden.

Both onion sets I bought this year were dried up or rotted. I’ve learned my lesson! Thanks for the info!

Debbie here,,you explained that very well, thank you

I enjoy your garden videos. Very informative. This year my young onion leaves are curling after transplanting as if someone gave them a perm. There seems to be some deformity. This is with more than one variety. I'm in zone 7a in Virginia growing in a raised bed. Any advice you may offer will be very much appreciated. Thank You, Red

Vidalia, Georgia is about ten miles north of the 32 degrees latitude line. Pretty close to right on.

Thanks! This helped me alot! I'm growing one onion in a container and its top was about to bend down so, I topped it off. The top of the onion tasted yummy!! I do have nitrogen soil in with my compost and it's doing great. I'm brand new at this. I have started a container garden on my lanai.

I learned a ton. THANKS

Thanks for the information. Last year was the first time I planted onions. Very helpful video!

Always interesting...never knew any of this!

Thanks for another great video. I think I have made every mistake anyone could ever make!

I always knew onions were biennials, but for some reason it never dawned on me that the reason my sets were flowering the first year was because of that... I feel dumb now. BUT I ordered my seeds so I can get them started the right way. Thank you!

I never knew the importance of keeping onion plants from getting top heavy so thank you for that. You mentioned your raised beds all have a Core. I recall in past videos you mentioned a need to prepare the core by wetting it. How do you decide how much water to give the core, especially for *un-rotten* straw? If I were to put a moisture into the soil of a raised bed with a core, what is the ideal reading at 6” into the soil (dry, moist or wet)?

I just found out about long/short day after 40 years of gardening just last month. Lowe's had only long day when I went in yesterday. We are in SC. 😞 I've only ever gotten little onions because of this.

great looking onions

If I can't seed start indoors when can I sow seeds outside? Thanks for your channel. I learn so much from you.

Thanks, Luke!

Awesome thank you I’m planting onions this year for my canned salsa!

Thank you Luke!

What I find with old videos that the vlogger will learn more and the newer videos provide much more updated & experienced information so I'm glad you are speaking on this topic again. This was great info. When you recommend a product (like Trifecta +) could you put it below in your notes? Often it's really difficult to understand exactly what the product name is. Do you have a suggestion of how to cure onions when one doesn't have a basement? I put them under deep shade under trees (where they can still get good circulation) but it does still get warm during mid-day.

Thanks for another GREAT video! I always thought I needed to add a lot of phosphorus so I was gonna load up on Bone meal. But now I will add some Blood meal to my trifecta + application. Thanks again Luke!

Loved the video! I'm planting sets from a big box store now- I know, I know, but I'm a beginner and wanting to learn. Hey, I was just wondering, when you talk about pruning the onion tops, it made a lot of sense, but was wondering. What if you constructed a slat of fencing that would lay horizontally above the bulbs about 10 inches high or so. Could that maybe help support the leaves so they remain upright and reduce the need to prune? I only ask because as a former grower/harvester, it was always hotly debated whether pruning hurt or helped, because it forces the plant to heal, and also to grow new shoots. But as you say, creating new shoots may in fact add to the bulb size. This is something I may experiment with in the future and let you know if I have any success. Thanks a lot for the great info!

Thank you I watched the old video before an honestly forgot th basics. It like a refresher course.

Can you share more specifics about digging a trench and putting something on the bed so you don’t have to water??

Thanks for great information, answered questions I didn't even know I had.

Thank you, great tips! My onions look beautiful this year but they have a crazy amount of leaves and I was wondering if I needed to top them. Now I know!

Storage storage storage! Once we are successful and have all this amazing produce we need to know how to store it all. I’m interested to know what things I do cool storage that does not involve canning, fermenting, etc. (I’ll do that too but want fresh supplies throughout the winter 🙂🙂)

Awesome video! I learned a lot! I just set out a bunch of seedlings without knowing whether they are short or long day variety…. I guess I will find out! Next year I will be more careful on selection!

Whenever Green Thumb Luke does a video in shorts, I know it's gonna be good.

Luke great tip on cutting the extra greens off the top of the onions.