Until the last few weeks never really understood shading, i am an old man now and tried painting many times over the years with poor results, watching you talk and paint with shading starting before the actual painting has given me one last thought to try and at least one more time to do one painting that might be of average ability , thanks Joni. Love your Paintings

Love the way you do the tree in black. The only think that looses me just a bit is the willow foliage that makes it past fall enough to get to a snowy day. Mine turn to stringy barren vines until spring.

Truly beautiful. Im so glad the tree trunk got some speckles of snow as on my phone it looked a bit smooth though im sure it looks different when bigger. So grateful for you sharing to help us beginners. Thankyou.❤🎉❤🎉❤🎉❤🎉

abolutely spell binding, looks just like fairyland. thank you.

Absolutely beautiful❤. I love the calm, whimsical feel of this piece and the splash of colour just adds a touch of magic. ❤

I truly appreciate your way of painting. It’s so beautiful and your voice is so soothing not demanding or harsh. It makes it easier for me to follow along with you. You remind me so much of a female Bob Ross. Thank you 🙏🏻

Beautiful. It was gorgeous as is, but that little wash of color brought it even more to light. I love this technique.

Beautiful with just the black and white... Absolutely stunning

Beautiful! Love watching you paint - helps that you’re left-handed - gives us a clear view of the canvas! Thank you❤️

I love all your works they are all magnificent and very passionate they seen so real that we have the feeling of being part The blet fascinates me it is for me a mystery Wich intrigues me and at the same time marvels me.❤❤❤❤

I love, LOVE your free style of painting and I'm going to try some of them.. TY so much for sharing your knowledge and talent... We are so lucky to have you sharing with us ❤️👌🙏

This is so beautiful. I'm just starting to paint and doing black and white Season themes

I love this, it feels as though you could walk right into it.

Love it.

Beautiful

You are blessed for such a great gift from the master❣️

I love it you inspire me to try 💗 you are a great teacher I'm confined to bed due to a car accident . Maybe I can get someone to get me supplies .. just watching is so relaxing ty 💪💗

Looks magical

Stunning. I have a feeling I could walk into this scene, so beautiful ❤️

Simply GORGEOUS !!!!

Such a mysterious and atmospheric scene. Awesome job.

A truly good looking painting. Mysterious.

Awesome painting dear friend

I really love this painting with only the use of black and white. I’m inspired I just order my paint kit, going to start practice as soon as it comes. Thank you very much

love your painting it standsout thumbs up thankyou

Love it!

The black and white were perfect

Just mesmerizing to look at.!! 👏👏👏👏

Beautiful painting 💐💕🇵🇰

Beautiful, so, so beautiful!!!! I'm so glad I was able to see you paint this live!!! You are so inspiring to watch, thank you for another amazing tutorial!!!

It is gorgeous so enjoyable to watch,!, thank you.

Wow… amazing ❤

Very amazing painting, I like how you stroke the brush on the canvas. thanks for tutorial

Oh so beautiful ! Makes me ready for winter.

Un très beau paysage de neige, j'aime beaucoup!👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽❤❤❤❤❤

You just keep getting better and better! I can't wait to paint this one!

Really pretty 😊, love snow scenery 🎨 paintings.

Can't wait to paint this one Joni, what a beautiful painting you've created and shared with all of us !

Wonderful, beautiful,thanks for sharing your art 🖼 👌👌👌

Another beauty! Oh, I took your suggestion and purchased the makeup/mop brushes from Amazon. Can't wait to get to try them on this painting. Thanks for everything you inspire.

Oh wow it's awesome I love your works

Bonjour , il est sublime , bravo, merci

Fantastic, thank you.

vraiment magnifique 🎉🎉❤❤

Oh my ! This is so beautiful

Bonjour Joni, c'est magnifique splendide, merci pour ce tutoriel très bon !👍

Simple beautiful

Bon courage

So beautiful! Thank you!

I think this is fab, definitely going to do this next

Love your paintings ❤

Soooooo BEAUTIFUL!!! 😍 ❤

another good one joni

😍😍i love it 💓💓 snow too ❣️❣️

That is a really beautiful piece, little lady!!!

Браво, невероятно красиво❤

Thanks!

Wow So Beautiful painting using colours are most Amazing, Wishing you more and more Success,🍇🌴🌼🌺

❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

Thank you, it is beautiful 😍

Congratulations Joni, it's wonderful !

Stunning!🥰

Looking at the finished product its intimidating to try these, I'm still a beginner I've only painted like less than 10 things but art runs strong in my family so sometimes I feel I can take on more advanced things. I dont want to mess this one up cuz i want to give it as a gift. Do you think, in your professional opinion, that a beginner can do this painting and it would come out okay?

Mashallah lovely

Magical!😍

Ich finde deine Bilder einfach toll! Liebe Grüße aus Germany

This is absolutely stunning 🤩 thank you so much 🙏🏻💜 I’m definitely going to give this a go 😍

Gorgeous

Wonderful.

Gotta do this one!

WOW, this is a spectacular beauty. Loving it 💖❤️

Wow...fantastic painting..congratulation Joni....😉🙋‍♀️🌺

C'est jolie !

Wow 1 question how did you learn that’s amazing I’m learning but to get to your finish is not easy so many details beautiful

Hi das ist soo schön. Dankeschön für das schöne Video und hab eine gute Zeit 😊LG Tina

💛this

Can I use any black for this piece such as Carbon Black or Mars Black?

Magnifique ! Dommage que je ne comprennes pas l'anglais !

Hi Joni if I paint this am I allowed to sell it at a craft show?

Beautiful