@@Maria-zk2sb oh wow. TARA destroyer fans. :(

Ur just jealous it's not her fault !!

@@Maria-zk2sb not her fault? LMAO. Where are you when the truth came out? Lollll

@@Maria-zk2sb cant you just read the fuckin truth ? She is the one who make t-ara popularity get down.

@@Maria-zk2sb Idiot do your research before comment bitch, this twins are snake they're destroyed T ara and MBK entertainment career stfu.

@Evie Samora nothing much. Just rumours.

@@sayit2198 a female staff revealed the truth years later, her photos of the chat were confirmed as real and hyoyoungs agency admitted to her actions...yeah sounds like 'rumors' to me 🤔 If you have no clue then keep your mouth shut, shouldn't you know that from this scandal, hyoyoung had no clue yet she opened that mouth of hers, very wide ¯\_( ͡° _ ͡° )_/¯ and then that ended up biting her back On top of that you're spreading misinformation to people who don't know about it

@Evie Samora I wanted to post a link but somehow KZfaq doesn't let me You can just search up hyoyoung scandal and there should be plenty articles My explanation is, basically hwayoung one of the twins used to be in a kpop group called Tara but they had to disband due to a scandal that hwayoung was getting bullied, and it was also hwayoung herself who exposed that. However it was never 100% confirmed so it was unsure whether she was telling the truth or lying. Then years later the twins went on this show and talked about it as the victims, an old staff member of Tara saw that and revealed the whole truth in which hwayoung was actually acting really selfish all the time which on one occasion led to 80 people working 6 hours more than they were supposed to. The members were upset about her selfishness so they posted something about will indirectly saying that hwayoung doesn't seem to have the same will to work as hard as everyone else in the group. Hwayoung told that to her sister hyoyoung who then texted and threatened the youngest member in the group to scratch up her face etc. Hyoyoungs company came forward admitting to it and explaining that hyoyoung reacted emotionally about the fact that hwayoung was upset but didn't have other motives

@@aribanahonarukas1641 your right but I'm talking about the scandal and hyo young joining in was bad choice from her.

@@sayit2198 fact not rumors, the real two snake

She didn't ruin T-ara. Why do you accuse her of that when you don't know what really happened? You are simply repeating what others have written without taking the trouble to find out for yourself. T-ara's problems were caused by people doing the same as you have done here. I have done the work to find out the truth and written the full story. The True Story of the T-ara Bullying Scandal t-ara-and-hwayoung.blogspot.com

@@nightjaronthegate she didn't do anything to enter to T-ara only her rich father helped her. She was a lazy snake, she didn't deserve to enter into the group. She ruined T-ara career.

@@estefaninicolebenavente2535 Adding Hwayoung to T-ara was a decision made by the management and the claim that it was influenced by her father is just a lie made up by lazy snakes trying to make excuses for T-ara's actions. KKS was quite capable of making debatable decisions on his own - he even chose to put Dani in the group when saw her in the street. T-ara don't need excuses and never did. They needed their fans to support Hwayoung as they asked when they admitted their mistakes and apologized, which was the day after Hwayoung made her statement saying the bullying rumours were not true and asking her fans to support T-ara. Two days ago Arin from Oh My Girl ruined the other members' lives by pulling out of their performance on M Countdown with muscle pain. It was just a bit of pain and obviously wasn't anything serious because she was back on stage the next day. Jiyeon wouldn't have let it stop her. Sorry, it seems Oh My Girl's lives have not been ruined. Why is that? Because they didn't write comments about her on Twitter that made the fans suspicious.

@@nightjaronthegate Well, it's your opinion🤷.

@No name yet Hwayoung had the public's sympathy but that was a result of the way she was treated by CCM and the fact that she never blamed the other members for what happened to her (edit: and the silly belief that she was bullied, which she never supported). She did say she wasn't bullied and T-ara's fans accused of doing it to make herself look good by appearing to be someone who forgave her bullies, so after that she generally avoided talking about the subject of bullying and limited herself to positive comments about T-ara and gestures of support. What do you think would have happened if she had kept talking about not being bullied? The fans would have kept moaning about her bringing up the bullying issue, just like they did after Taxi when she didn't even mention it. They never wanted a denial of the bullying rumours; what they wanted was a confession that it was all her fault and an apology for all the things they wrongly accuse her of doing.

Franco Lee ye

Woojin Join too

@@albertus8474 yeahhh

If you want the others to join in it would have to be from Shin Jimin's record label FNC Entertainment Cnblue Jonghyun and FtIsland Jonghoon

April join too

So that's why rumours started accoring. It's because she left to pursue acting..............

Because she's chaebol kid. If she want, her parents grants everything

Bcause she already bad from inside

lmao... didnt shannon williams blast MBK? n she left... they did poorly to give shannon williams a career not to mention alot of their groups flopped... i doubt they destroyed t-ara in general... alot of the artist chose to not resign with the company alot of ppl left to other companies aswell hyoyoung stayed with mbk 4 years after the incident happened with her sister.. n then she filed a lawsuit n forced mbk to terminate her contract... most kpop groups suffers from the 7 year rule anyways t-ara basically achieved that... so was bound to happen n alot of the members of t-ara still gets work

@@joshualee6765 if you are t-ara fans you would know that this two had caused a huge trouble for t-ara that added fuel to their disbandment.

@@nicapika7970 yep i get it... but who is getting more work nowadays despite of the scandal they admitted to? apparently the entertainment industry acknowledges her talent n keeps hiring her

@@joshualee6765 Thats why both of them sucks....They cause someones career to go down and made them suffer the knetz harsh comments... Yet here they are still being active in entertainment world. The world is really unfair. Besides those two were rumored to have a strong connection to someone with a high status in the industry....Thats why Hwayoung was easily added to T-ara despite being odd for t-ara is a successful group already during those times.

It’s been years get over it

They didn't do that and T-ara didn't bully Hwayoung. Read this: The True Story of the T-ara Bullying Scandal t-ara-and-hwayoung.blogspot.com

I don’t believe in hating others and destroying their lives in the name of karma, but I seriously can’t help but hater her after knowing the details !

@@k-poppersince0951 I don't think you do know the details. I have done the work to find out what really happened and there is no reason to hate Hwayoung or any of the other members. Click the link in my reply above to read the full story. This is the part about the Taxi interview: 4) Taxi There is a very common belief that when Hwayoung appeared on Taxi, she talked about being bullied by T-ara and said that she had terrible time as a member. She did not. She said absolutely nothing about bullying and only a few words about her time in the group. This is the section of the interview that was given such a bad reception, copied from the English subtitles, www.kcon.tv/media/SJ0BmT0_Ol but unfortunately the video is not available because www.kcon.tv no longer exists. _I heard Hwayoung was more determined to become a singer._ That's true. It was disappointing, but if you think about it things can happen among girls. Members were immature back then. I'm including myself; I was a minor then. _You were young_ I poured everything into singing, so I didn't get to experience the socialization process. I regret that. _You gave up your dream. Didn't it hurt?_ You know, it really hurts. _Did you cry by yourself?_ Many times. _In front of your sister?_ No, alone in my room. _Aww...poor Hwayoung..._ There was a time when I lost a lot of weight. Unni told me to stop losing weight. I weighed 40kg back then. There was nothing I could do. _But you're an extrovert by nature...But it's your dream... Your sister sacrificed herself for that dream. How did you feel watching her, Hyoyoung?_ Yeah, during that incident she'd turn on TV and just stare at other singers (At this point we see that Hwayoung has turned her head and is looking through the window.) That's when my heart ached. (Now we see that Hwayoung's eyes are filling with tears.) Compare Hwayoung on Taxi with Eunjung on The Beatle2 Code and T-ara in their apology letter reproduced in Section 3. Eunjung: “It was our fault because we were careless and immature.” T-ara Apologize - KZfaq Hwayoung: “Things can happen among girls. Members were immature then. I'm including myself.” That is all Hwayoung said on Taxi about the problems that occurred within T-ara. Why should T-ara fans be angry when what she said matches what Eunjung had said previously? They should not, but the Hwayoung haters were incandescent with rage. Some people have interpreted this as an attempt to blame T-ara for the problems, because she says “members” first, but that is ridiculous because she was one of the members and she adds “I'm including myself” immediately to emphasize that. The truth is that it's an attempt to take the pressure off T-ara. If Hwayoung could dismiss the whole thing as something that happened because of immaturity and poor communication, then there was no reason for anyone to continue campaigning against T-ara. The interpretation of the ex-staffer who leaked Hyoyoung story was that when Hwayoung said “things can happen among girls” she was referring to the threat, but that is very unlikely. Hwayoung was talking about the problems between herself and the other T-ara members. The Hyoyoung story was not known to the public and none of the people involved wanted it to come out, so why would Hwayoung talk about that? Hwayoung haters also object to her crying in the interview, which did not happen until her sister was talking about how she felt watching Hwayoung going through such a hard time, and even object to her saying that she cried after she was fired. I don't know how many of them think she meant that she cried while she was a member of T-ara, but anyone who thinks that has not watched the video of the interview carefully. The crying is what I would expect from anyone in her position. She had been kicked out of T-ara after working very hard and giving great performances. She was shocked, she was depressed, she was grieving, and that was because she wanted to stay in T-ara. She should have the sympathy of the fans, but they reacted with fury and vile abuse. Hwayoung has shown concern and sympathy for T-ara throughout the years, but her haters don't seem to have genuinely considered her feelings at all. Earlier in the interview there is something interesting. For a while I thought this might be something that had stimulated some anger, but it seems to have gone unnoticed. When the twins are asked about the differences between them, Hyoyoung says that Hwayoung doesn't hold grudges. T-ara fans might have thought the intention was to suggest that a grudge would be justified and to portray T-ara as villains, while presenting Hwayoung as a kind and forgiving person, when she really wants to gain sympathy and publicity for herself while taking revenge on T-ara. And there you have it; Hwayoung, in a few words spoken by someone else, simultaneously “playing the victim” and “taking the high road”, as the angry ex-staffer put it, but that would be the wrong way to take it. If Hyoyoung's mention of Hwayoung not holding grudges was an intentional, planned reference to T-ara, then surely it was aimed not at them, but at their haters. If Hwayoung has no grudge against T-ara, then there is really no reason for anyone else to hate them. There is another possible meaning though, which I think is far more convincing. Hyoyoung is talking about Hwayoung not holding a grudge against her. It was Hyoyoung's shocking texts to Areum, probably written while drunk, that scuppered Hwayoung's reconciliation with Ta-ara. The next day Hyoyoung would have thought, “Oh no, what have I done? Hwayoung will never forgive me.” It must have been difficult for Hwayoung, knowing that her sister destroyed any chance she still had of remaining in the group, but she was able to forgive her. Now it all makes sense; Hyoyoung holding Hwayoung's hand so tight, Hwayoung saying "I want to reveal some truths," Hyoyoung saying, "Until here is good. Say more, it'll be a disaster." Angry T-ara fans will not believe that "Hwasnake" is someone who can forgive others for any wrongs they have done her, because, in their view, they are the good people and Hwayoung is a snake. That means that Hyoyoung has to be lying, and Hwayoung really does hold grudges, so the reason for saying that has to be to make people think that she has a reason to have a grudge, and that T-ara bullied her. The reality, though, is that it is not a lie, but absolutely, undeniably true. That's why Hwayoung has remained so close to Hyoyoung, and why she has always supported T-ara despite being angry at first. It is ironic that the story which turned the scandal around and made Hwayoung so hated is one which actually proves her to be a far more loving and forgiving person than all those who call her a snake or a bitch, and hold her responsible for all T-ara's troubles. They now loudly proclaim their triumph, but fail to realize that it shows them for the vicious bullies they really are, and that it proves nothing either way about the other T-ara members. I have no doubt about T-ara; there was never any serious case against them.

@@nightjaronthegate bullshit!

@@mungyatheishokwungnao1438 "bullshit!" is not a valid argument. My history of the scandal is thorough, fair and truthful. All the parts of the story fit together perfectly and T-ara's reputation would not be affected if everyone believed it. Read it and think carefully.

What they look soo alike

@@momosgf725 Identical twins never look exactly the same; they are genetically identical because they started as a single embryo which split in two.

identical twins have the same face but their face can slightly change and differ from each other while growing up due to external factor such as environment, stress and diet..theory that one probably have cosmetic enhancement which slightly change her face should also be included..

Well one us with makeup 💄 and the other is with none

Acting can be learned but good attitude is not. I hope she can still eat and sleep well after destroying T-ara’s success. An imposter.

True

Why what happened??

joanna ryan people should forget about the past

I'm curious as to what happened

@@nurulhudaafrina4278 It's true that past is past, but that doesn't mean people should forget about the terrible thing that she and her sister did to T-ara. T-ara had huge potential as a group, and she and her sister ruined their careers, and they deserve the backlash that they are getting. It's punishment for their wrongdoings, and they ARE in the wrong. I can't believe people like you think they should just be let go with no backlash from the public. They RUINED all of the T-ara members' careers, yet all they have gotten is benefit from their lies. You think people should just forget something like this because "past is just past?" Ridiculous. Do people "forget" the incidents of 9/11 because it's "just past?" Do people "forget" the actions of Hitler or Stalin because "it's just past?" I can't believe you people with your unbelievable double standards. If anything, the sisters deserve this and people should forgive WITH TIME but NOT forget. This is incredibly disrespectful to T-ara who worked hard for their success, only for Hwayoung (who got in without as much hard work as the other members) to ruin it all for them. I hope you can seriously reconsider what you just said.

update , mina is the crazy btch all along HAHAHAHA

Mejor dicho los supuestos fans que no creyeron en ellas y dejaron de seguirlas. Hay mucho drama dentro de la verdadera historia, la cuál nadie sabe a ciencia cierta. Siempre hay dos versiones y cada una se cuenta a complacencia o se transforman con el paso del tiempo. Que flojera estar odiando a alguien que no conocen, no las defiendo porque seguramente inocentes palomitas no fueron.

@@velascomich dude wtf, realmente sus fans no tienen mucho que ver, en los años en que sucedió el escándalo con T-ara, lo que más importaba era la reputación de un kgroup en Corea del Sur, así que incluso con un montón de fans internacionales, si les cerraban las puertas en su país de hecho ya perdían muchísimas oportunidades de seguir creciendo como grupo. Las pruebas sobre lo que hizo Hwayoung ya salieron y más clara no puede ser la situación. Entró al grupo por mero nepotismo, y como solamente le interesaba hacerse popular para luego ser actriz, nunca colaboró con las demás integrantes, y las saboteó en programas y conciertos. T-ara también hablaron numerosas veces de lo que sucedió con Hwayoung y de manera super honesta, nadie se está haciendo la santa paloma ni insinúa que lo son. No por eso le vamos a restar importancia a lo que Hwayoung provocó 😉 Also, nadie la odia como persona jajaj, sino por sus malas actitudes y el daño que causó por hacerse un espacio en la industria. No es necesario conocerla para criticar su mala conducta en público🤡

@@yoongisflacko9473 La empresa las explotaba a las miembros, no creyeron en su esguince para forzarla actuar, se peleo con las miembros que supuestamente deberian estar de su lado y no criticarla por twitter, esto no lo causo solamente ella. Que el rumor de bullying fue creado por haters y fans de otros grupos ya que eran muy exitosas, esto causo que muchos fans de Tara creyeran en el rumor que Hwayoung habia dicho que no paso.

Yes

Those who follow them from the start know how their attitudes and characteristics really are. members are always reprimanded by people because of the way they talk between members, who are younger to the elderly just like the same age but that's how they are close to the present. they are like brothers and sisters, brothers who have no limit. the problem that you said before is even worse than Jiyeon but no one calls it bullied. The umbrella issue you mentioned was indeed broken from the start, why just touched it a little is broken right away !? are you not weird ! Please make more sense. You only see the cut and edited video without seeing the whole, you can see it here: -kzfaq.info/get/bejne/rNhojbeBrtOyhGQ.html -kzfaq.info/get/bejne/g76jqLKkmtPekYE.html -kzfaq.info/get/bejne/fdyogblz37ilYqM.html I did not mind the bulli problem that made me angry earlier than that how she pretended to be sick so she could rest ! Don't always excuse sickness or worry too much that is your reason, even doctors in Korea and in Japan say it's okay. Come on she is not just 1 or 2 months in T-ara but more than 1 year and within that time several members were injured. If she is there, the other members will understand, they are kindly and sweet people. But this ? Nail art? And finally trending on naver. Ok, she got it. Even in KBS music she even slams her crutches. And many more complaints from staff about her bad attitude. I understand that in a group there will always be differences, and there will always be one or two people who become troublemakers and in t-ara, she is a troublemaker. Sorry to say this, even though the other members love each other I only regret the attitude of the Hwa who caused the problem. Besides that she cannot adjust to other members, he is always a little difficult to interact, maybe she realizes that other members have many talents with a beautiful face and also has an inner beauty

@@kimrinaaa6147 You seem to have replied to the wrong person.

she ruined t-ara career playing the victim abt being bullied

she was rude even to the staff

Yup bener

T-ara is more popular when they were active. Recent years several of them are least active in the industry. Some are married, some decided to retired from the industry and some established other businesses. Ryu sisters have more appearances because they continue their careers and signed new contracts with other companies.

both of them?

Trio if Shin Jimin 😡🤬🐿🤮🐍🤢💀👿is added. Height wise the twins are taller than Shin Jimin 168cm vs 161 cm Shin Jimin

carolinamtz13 (sorry for my bad english) Hwayoung is the former member of t-ara. T-ara was originally had 6members but after 4years t-ara gained popularity and became best girl group after snsd, their company added hwayoung into t-ara, which exactly a total mistake. She manipulated the situation and made people/knetz believed that she was being bullied by t-ara members. T-ara is getting a ton of backlash because of her. The major damage has been done. T-ara saved the kpop industry but hwayoung ruined t-ara career. She ruined everything. She also made ahreum left t-ara too. So now when people said “her acting is good” lol ofcourse. Her acting skill can ruins other people careers. She is such a snake. 🐍 Why would i praised her acting skill if i could’nt forget what she did to t-ara even she’s already “apologised”. You can get many info about them > “The Worst Entertainment Companies : MBK” on youtube.

​@@firstwz That is wrong. Hwayoung did not make people believe she was bullied and said she was not. Fans became suspicious because of T-ara's tweets and when the company dismissed Hwayoung they made it worse. She supported T-ara and they supported her but the fans took sides and made the scandal go on for years. She didn't ruin anything and Areum didn't leave because of anything she did. I have researched this very carefully and written the true story. Please read it. The True Story of the T-ara Bullying Scandal t-ara-and-hwayoung.blogspot.com

Nightjar on the gate nah i’ve searched about this so many times too. this was the last vid that i found about them kzfaq.info/get/bejne/p86Fm5NiqZm0qKM.html then i watched again “proof t-ara bullying hwayoung” vids and it’s so obvious that hwayoung play victim

Sonima Sankar Hwa Young is a former member of the girl group called T-ara.She and her sister once told on a TV program that she was bullied by the other members and because of her the group was hated by Koreans and disbanded.They were very popular in many countries and in Korea before that bully scandal.Two years ago,the truth came out that no one bullied her and she was lazy in the group and just pretended to be bullied.She’s a liar. Excuse my English.

Sonima Sankar also her sister hyo young threatened one of the members that she would cut her face with a knife and those kind of stuffs because that member was the new to the group.She had to quit from the groups because of those black mails.

@@stellachen2511 Ooh... OK... Never expected that..

@@stellachen2511 Thank you replying... 😊

You shouldn't thank Khine Zar Thwe for lying to you. I have written a fair and truthful examination of this case which will help you understand what really happened. The True Story of the T-ara Bullying Scandal t-ara-and-hwayoung.blogspot.com

Thats the first thing i noticed about hwayoung just by watching her in a sports show. She didnt do anything bad or speak anything bad but i felt like just by looking at her she looked arrogant in some way but who know what she’s like in real life

Itu lah yg bikin menjengkel kan ya mbk? Padahal Hwayoung gk pernah bilang di bully tp netizen yg ber ekspektasi Tp yg menjengkel kan kenapa status nya Hwayoung seolah2 dia sedang di tekan jadi fans nya tambah jadi ngebully t ara sampai 5thn pas performance Tara di teriaki babi mati aja Membernya Tara jiyeon sama enjung sampai depresi datang ke psikiater parah pokok nya aku liat di yg Kenapa pas netizen begitu hwayong gk memberi bantahan bahwa dia gk di bully jadi kan fans nya Tara gk akan membenci dia Coba aja dulu di klarifikasi sama hwayong klw dia gk di bully Sekarang hwayong di benci kasian juga si apalagi suka acting nya dia

@@novivita4628 kasihan? Lebih kasihan bertahun" T-ara d diskriminasi. Seharusnya dia bisa ngomong ke media kalau Itu salah paham. Dengan diamnya dia Itu malah membuat keadaan memburuk

@@jeshl7714 ya itu dia knp hwayong gk bilang ke media malah diam aja menggiring knet untuk ber ekspektasi sendiri seolah2 emang bener t Ara membuli nya Maksut nya kasian apa ya?

@@novivita4628 d internet dah banyak berita ka. Coba Cari Aja. D situ kan Host nyinggung masalah T-ara bully hwayoung. Padahal nggak. D situ dia bilang kalau dia sudah memaafkan mereka sambil nanges 🤦 seolah" membenarkan rumor. Yang salah sebenarnya media. Tapi dengan diamnya hwayoung. T-ara suffering 5 tahun. Kena tuduhan bully. D jauhin banyak idol grup. Bahkan sampai nggak d kasih tempat duduk d SBS gayo. Parahlah. Benci bat sama hwayoung

@@novivita4628 padahal dia jugak masuk setelah T-ara sukses. Member tambahan tapi Kena star sindrom kata menejer T-ara. Malas latihan alasan cidera padahal perawatan kuku dia. His Huh tenang..... D lanjutin takut jadi koran

Yes, but she's a fucking bitch

Kris Aven but ugly personality

Hwayoung is shit

Hwa💩💩💩

Hwayoung🖤

@@raizasilva2918 you don't need to insult

Hwayoung is shit

No , they are not cute they are disgusting

bukan begitu, mereka sudah menghancurkan karir dan hidup 6 orang sekaligus dan tidak pernh meminta maaf. Apa itu pantas disebut kemanusiaan?. Mereka tidk pernah mencoba untuk menjadi lebih baik. Setidaknya mulai lah dari meminta maaf pada semua member T-ara dan fans yang sudah mereka hancurkan.

Dia minta maaf ngak?

@@sasukkura kalo berubah lebih baik mah pasti setiap manusia juga bisa sih.. masalah nya sama fans nya / yang ngehujatnya,kalo misalkan dia / mereka tetep minta maaf juga,fans nya bakal tetep ngehujat,sama kayak aoa jimin

Noooo

Not all twins are super identical though. But one thing sure is the same about them they are the bullies and snake of the group T-ara. Good thing this Twins got exposed, they had been thriving and using the victim card way too long while the real victims got cancelled.

Parem com esse ódio por favor, hwayoung não é minha bias e sim Hyomin, mas poxa, atualmente ela pode ter se arrependido pelo erro cometido . Deveríamos nos concentrar apenas em apoiar o t-ara