아 의외로 슈화양이 먼저 접근을 했군요!

헐 몰랐어요..! 하 진짜 미치것네 예나 우기에 이어 혜원 슈화라니..!! 저는 이 친목 응원합니다

@@theghst5147 제 기억으로 채팅에서 혜원님이 먼저 영통에서 칭해지고 싶은 여돌을 슈화님으로 골랏던 것 같아요 그 후 브이앱에서 슈화가 친해지자거 그랬어요

@@theghst5147 먼저 표시한 쪽은 혜원님이셔요

아하 광배가 또 너 내 동료가 돼라를 시전했군요 ㅋㅋ

ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ아 너무 웃기네요 잇몸이 마르는게 느껴진대 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ사실 저도 건조해서 잇몸 찢어질뻔 했잖아요 ㅋㅋㅋ

추접한 미소ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

ㅋㅋ아 추접한 미소

ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ아 들켰다.. 저도요

Also has less line 🤣

Taste😂

@@airlikname4383 You did not- 💀

@@airlikname4383 fortunately, shuhu got more lines this comeback.

@@airlikname4383 shuhua got more lines now:)

요즘 공중파 예능이 다 죽어서 아이돌들 나갈방송이 없다ㅠ

rly lovely

she is always there for her friends💗

But she’s so right tho haha their bare faces are top notch

She was right I love how she stands up for herself and friends

YESSH🤩🤩

She is the only idol in one of the top GG to reply to fans in IG weibo etc

shes always herself and has such a unique personality

Me too 😭

I hope so our Shuhua is became more mature now i hope to see her in a drama maybe since her beauty is out of this world 😭

I agree with you.

IKR IS THIS HEAVEN BCS I'VE NEVER SEEN TWO GODDESS IN A SAME FRAME BEFORE LOL

진심ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ넘좋음ㅋㅋㅋㅋ

YESSS

Shuhua always treats her friends like this 💕

Yeah. Shuhua is really pure and genuine. She values friendship so much and treats her friends with gentleness and protectiveness which makes us love her more and more. I'm so proud of her for being out there and making new friends.

She’s such a sweetie.

Soojin 😭😭😭

Yea and she stands VERY strong with her ways. How many years has it been since debut and she still refuse to dye hair xD I support

@@xsomili5501 thats what i like about her. and also she's weird like how miyeon said she was the most unique person in the world lol

I don't know about that. From my observation, 2nd Gen is the one that have a lot of friendships outside of group. The main reason is back then the TV and variety show is at their peak so idols group activity always overlap with each other.

Cut-throar environment was 3rd not 2nd. You can see 2nd gen groups together many times on variety shows back then

Part of what changed was that in 1st, 2nd, and even into 3rd gen, companies still didn't allow idols to have cell phones until they had accomplished something pretty major and were several years past debut and in some cases a group without a show win might end their contract and still have never been officially allowed to have their own phones. Managers had a much tighter leash on their artists and were much more controlling of what artists did even in their limited free time. Members might have had a cell phone in secret, but it was kept well hidden from managers as there were still a lot of old school physically and emotionally abusive managers out there who might punish members for breaking rules. Three things have made a big impact since 3rd gen started to debut. First, the prohibition on idols having mobile phones went away, probably at first due to parents insisting that they wouldn't sign contracts if they had to go through an intermediary to speak with their child, and probably as well that mobile devices are so ubiquitous now that if a company tried to seize the devices from trainees or upon debut they would likely have mutinies. Second, there seems to have been a generational shift among many in management that authoritarian styles of management usually backfire. Controlling a group through fear or physical or verbal abuse doesn't work as well as it once did. Finally, the biggest factor is likely the advent of the survival show such as Produce 101, Girls Planet, etc. It used to be that the only people a trainee associated with was fellow trainees at their own company except for a rare few that maybe knew a trainee at another company since childhood. Those survival shows introduced trainees to dozens of other trainees and now with cell phone access once the show was over they could stay in touch. Combine that with managers who were less hardcore about their members never leaving their sight when waiting at a music show or at a festival and people who had become friends on a survival show together were able to actually maintain some of those friendships. For instance right now there is hardly a girl group out there that doesn't have a connection to Produce 48 either in the form of a contestant or a personal friend who was a contestant. This creates an environment where you see a lot more cross-introduction between groups where say two groups have a former Produce member and those two introduce other members that they think might get along well. Those shows broke down a lot of the rigid formality between groups.

@@kagamitaigaz4347 Yep shows like Star King, Strong Heart, Star Golden Bell and others that were at their peak during 2nd gen allowed a lot of groups to meet and socialize, where even the most controlling managers couldn't really prevent it.

i'd say 1st gen was the most cut-throat. On gp999 sunmi and tiffany talked about how wonder girls and snsd were all good but the media kept on flaring up the competition.

she is indeed shy in interviews and etc but hyewon is more of a friend so she's comfy

她根本就沒有輸過🤣

一直以来都很强😻

@@valeriesiu5033 对对对哈哈哈