I personally love the appearance of the half nightmare half siegfried in soul caliber 2.

Honestly SC3 Nightmare is S Tier for me, so simple but it's amazing

Soulcalibur 3 P2 is actually quite a popular design among Siegfried players I've talked to. I too think it's better than crap, but in general - as a long time Siegfried player myself - I agree with almost all your rankings of the designs.

SC2 nightmare is such an iconic design have been working on a cosplay for it

I feel like both of Sieg's SC3 Designs were great honestly.

Siegfried's P1 design from Soul Calibur is my favorite of the series. I love the subtle gold accents and engravings, but it still feels grounded in its roots as Germanic gothic plate armor. SC 1 & 2 in general had a more grounded and somber tone, and stuck a little closer to the historical and cultural influences for the characters. They still had stylized anime vibes, but they felt more balanced with the historical setting. SC3 and onward just went so, so far into over the top anime territory with their aesthetics and story. If 3 were the last of the series, then it would've felt like an appropriate energy for a finale to have, but 4 & 5 completely lost their identity. Felt more like Final Fantasy than Soul Calibur. 6 has tried to bring it back to its roots, and I appreciate that a lot, but it's still not quite what it was. This is evident in Siegfried's design. It doesn't look at all like any historical plate armor. It just looks like something out of WoW. It's so chunky and awkward looking. Poor Sieg just gets completely lost in it. Like he's wearing his dad's clothes. Oh, also SC5 Nightmare is hideous. It's like SC2 redesigned by someone with no concept of what makes that design so beloved. SC4 Nightmare I sort of respect for being so buttfuck over the top and stupid, but SC5 is TRYING to be classier and just failing miserably.

I loved the SC4 design personally

I'm gonna disagree with most of the nightmare costume ratings bro, I actually like the designs.

SC1 Siegfried's black armor reminds me of the Berserker armor probably because it was referencing Guts

Sc3 p2 Siegfried is my all time favorite design. The artwork for it too is 🔥 imo

Love the video, and I have to admit I was taken quite by surprise at the out of nowhere DBGT Baby theme @15:45 😂

SC3 Siegfried 2P is godlike. I really liked the video, ALTHOUGH I found the audio just a little bit low.

I love the SC2 Siegfried secondary outfit, THAT IS NOT DAMNED!!!!!!

Nightmare's default hairstyle in 5 is actually Raphael but u can replace it with either Gelled Back Long or Long Straight and of course removing Dumas mask is a mod that you have to put into a byte code

I’m sorry but bronze siegfried and regular clothes Siegfried are a fuckload worse then SC4 Nightmare

Mid transformation siegfried/nightmare from sc2 was a childhood crush so i was devastated at him being dragged so hard ;^;

2p version of his Requiem is simply great, much better than his default one.

Kinda disagree Sc2's take, I think SC2's 3rd Nightmare outfit is good enough to picture a realistic Knight of Soul's world and since he got a identity too, so I think that armor suits him.

I actually find the first nightmare (and subsequently, red-armor Siegfried) to be pretty alright. Not as good as what we got in SC2, or even the first SC, but it was a decent starting off point for a character we didn't know too much about yet. I find it kinda charming in it's antiquity.

The fuck you just say about SC3 Sig's P2 outfit? Put that shit up in God-Tier where it belongs. Right next to SC2 Nightmare.

SC2 Nightmare is my favorite Fighting Game Character design in the entire franchise.

I love me some Nightmare and that's why I like all of his designs Edit: 18:46 HOW DARE YOU THREE MOCK THIS SICK AF DESIGN FOR NIGHTMARE 😠

I only disagre for Siegfried outfits from SC 4, both of them are Superior tier, especialy the crystalline armor, it makes him so unique, it gave so much prestige, it was the exactly opposite of Nightmare, the Holy and the Unholy. I agree with the rest. SC series have so much potential but as long as the moron Harada is team leader, we will never see any improvemnt, only hardcore content with awful graphics and nothing more. Thats why I stoped at SC4. I hope someday both swords Soul Calibur and Soul Edge thrust into that bastard's Harada heart and kill him for good so the game will become phenomenal (Same with Tekken)

Nightmare SC2 and SC5 God Tier for Me

Loved Nightmares design in 2. Absolutely iconic look for him. 3's Siegfried was also absolutely perfect. I hated what they did with Soul Calibur and Soul Edge in 4 though. Those costumes and weapons were abominations

Thanks for video! For SC3 main version of Nightmare is the best!

Yo a voldo and/or astaroth tier list would be super sick brotha

so yall were saying all of soul calibur's 5 budget went into nightmare's arm

It’s been a year since you did this. Would love to see you make it into a series with other characters in the future.

Soul Calibur 3 2p is his best design lol

oh god this hurts

Nightmare Soul Blade: Looks very blocky due to the PS1 graphics Soul Calibur: 1-Looks alright. 2-Looks like he’s trying to be Griffith from Berserk Soul Calibur 2: 1-Best of the bunch and very iconic. 2-a good look for Siegfried when he was Nightmare although his hair could have been red. Soul Calibur 3: 1-Looks good but his armor in Soul Calibur 2 is a bit better. 2- Looks like Patrick Star’s demonic cousin Soul Calibur 4: 1-Trying way too hard to be evil looking. 2-looks like Megatron from the 2007 Transformers movie. Soul Calibur 5: 1-A great comparison to his Soul Calibur 2 design. 2-Looks like a rejected Doom/Diablo/Dragon Age/Dark Siders/World of Warcraft/Legacy of Kain monsters Soul Calibur 6: A great update from his Soul Calibur 1 design Siegfried Soul Blade: 1-Looks ok for a 16 year old knight. 2-Just a boy in armor. 3-more looks like a squire Soul Calibur 1: 1-Good so far. 2-Great addition of the German Hunting knife. 3-Alright Soul Calibur 2: Looks good even though he’s just a 3rd costume for Nightmare Soul Calibur 3: 1-Best design so far. 2-Looks a lot like Cloud Strife if he became a knight. Soul Calibur 4: Looks kinda ridiculous in that Crystal armor. 2-Meh Soul Calibur 5: 1- Looks ok for a guy who’s 40 but his armor looks like it belongs in either World of Warcraft or Warhammer. 2-Makes him look like a farmer if he decided to retire and start a family of his own. Soul Calibur 6: Looks good so far.

The best for me is 1p SC2 too cool

soul calibur 2 and 6 best skins ever

SC2 Is goated

5:28 is that from a comic or can made ?

Soul Calibur ost tier list?

Thanks for the Warning about Unpopular Opinions. These Opinions are Harsh.

Few minutes in and I already hate this video

These guys hate siegfried lmao

Wow.... the shittiest of tastes.