Gael is actually a decent pundit, I'm quite impressed with him tbh 👌

For what he’s done for them this second stint, they need to at least give him till the end of this year.

Jamie's definitely right that the style of play is a problem because that's what's turning the match going fans off of him. I'm an armchair fan, so my opinion is less important than theirs, and even I struggle to sit through most of our games - even when we win! I can't imagine blocking out countless weekends to travel to and from the match, only to watch us sit deep and counter against every team in the league 🤷 We certainly can't complain about the silverware, I was doing laps of my garden when we won, but it's for the match going fans to decide whether they want to support watching that style every week and whether that discomfort is worth the potential trophy at the end of the season.

Gael is improving as a pundit now, good luck brother .👍 💪

I'm not a West Ham fan but I think they should stick with him for now. I do understand the fans frustration though. As a fan you want one of two things. To play exciting football or get results and obviously doing both is the best case scenario

I like listening to Gael🎉

shake hands and walk away at the end of the season .... getting the manager right is imperative

Moyes rescued us twice from relegation. For that I thank him. For the turgid football, he has to go. Even after spending hundreds of millions we have the smallest and the oldest squad in the league who can’t pass a ball to save their life. Hundreds of millions in exchange for becoming counter attacking set piece merchants. It’s not about us thinking we deserve to be getting better results. It’s about us seeing teams down in the bottom half pass the ball better than us.

to win 1st trophy in 40 odds years. He should have a statue if anything. This guy saved west ham from relegation twice. Fans these days are ungrateful

The academy of football, When Moyes said players under aren't ready for first time. That was it, no one talks about it.

this show is probably the best one sky sports have made. more tactical analysis and the real issues teams have or why they are succeeding . hope they keep it up

They are 8th.... Not 18th

Respect Jamie Jamie gets us. ⚒️

Let the guy finish the season

Just because footballing trends are changing or West Ham are not fighting relegation, it doesn''t mean Moyes should change his style. If anything, his style should become more effective against teams that press with high defensive lines. However, I think one of the few criticisms you could throw at Moyes is signing Phillips and not getting another winger or creative player instead.

Till the end of the season at least for Moyes

If Moyes weren’t at West Ham, where would he be? more than likely a relegation threatened club or championship team

Nah the fans that actually know the club wouldn't get mad at the playstyle. A counter attacking playstyle is fine, it is a type of playstyle for a reason. Even big teams like Real Madrid with all the star players they have, find themselves relying on a last minute goal to find the winner. That is, what their own fans call it, the Real Madrid way. The problem is,what carragher said, the goals being conceded. For a team who has like 2 right backs, 3 CDMs playing in the starting XI, they are conceding way too many goals. The "compact" defence is easily being split by players like Saka and Martinelli. And going to the attacking side of things, for a team who rely on counter attacks and set pieces their not doing well on those either. There's a severe lack of decision making in the final third, where players choose to hold the ball for too long or either take shots from unlikely to score areas or just cross it high into the box for a fairly short Jarrod Bowen to somehow battle against the very likely bigger players of their opponent teams, the centre backs. And set pieces, west ham were on par with arsenal at one point of the season on goals scored from set pieces. But in these recent games they have fallen off massively. James ward-prowse is still a dead ball specialist, but the other players are struggling to find the back of the net from those deliveries. In short, you've got a counter attacking team, whose defence isn't good enough neither is its attack

I wish when Carragher said he's a top premier league manager, he'd been asked "so with Klopp leaving, you wouldn't mind Moyes at Liverpool?"...

Honestly just find some form of stability with results for the remaining reason and I give it a fresh go for next season and bolster the squad with the right players that match their needs. Don’t panic buy and they’ll bounce back. No need to sack him.

No one talking about Declan going to Arsenal? Must have been a blow to WHU’s team moral 🤔

West Ham and Brighton are on the same points. De Zerbi is wanted for his football philosophy and David Moyes is being hounded out. Even although Moyes has arguably achieved more, European Cup and building West Ham up from relegation, fans still don’t want him. Madness.

It’s a disgrace that you can talk about Moyes getting the sack. Everything wrong with football right there these days

10th in the league is not that bad for West Ham all things considered, and pulling up stats about possession is fine but you can't use that as a negative after acknowledging it's not their style of play. I really think this time next month the message will be different.

Well done gael , speaking really well

Sack Moyes and the team will bring in high profile manager after high profile manager and end up nearly relegated. You see it all the time.

Been an awful 2024 for West ham but don't forget he's won them a European trophy their first ever and guided them to European spots. Put some respect on his name

Jose would be perfect for this job.

IMO they need to give him till the end of the season for all that he's accomplished with the club it's the least time he deserves.

Top 7 finish a few seasons ago, currently 8th. Stabilised and made West Ham an established premier league club, and getting them European football, and then won a major trophy last season, a European one at that. Talk about ungrateful fans. Be careful what you wish for.

This debate just goes to show you are totally missing the point. Moyes will not be leaving at the end of the season because of the results or style of play, it will be because he is out of contact and Moyes, Steidten and the club can't agree new terms. Moyes want to carry on as a manager with a lot of overall say, transfers etc. The club and more importantly Steidten want to now hire a coach to run the first team only .

At last someone in the sports media that get what most of us west ham fans feel like. He has spent 500 millon on players, we ha e the smallest squad abd the oldest squad in the league

To quote big Sam, every team wants to play "tippy tappy" football these days. When in reality not every team is capable of doing it. Burnley should not be trying to play out from the back for example. I don't know who West Ham could get in to replace Moyes and could get this current squad getting 50%+ possession every game without a massive overhaul of players. A drastic change in styles could magically backfire on West Ham. Everton did well initially when they brought Martinez but very quickly that lack of a presence without a strong and sensible opinion sent them back down the table quickly. West Hams owners don't exactly have the best track record of making smart decisions prior to Moyes. Does anybody trust the West Ham board to make the smart decisions post Moyes?

Not a massive fan of stats. But for a manger, I take more notice of stats. Motes clearly has done a great job. But it’s time for him to leave. When the fans turn on you, it’s time to go. Leave with his head held high on those stats lad

Tbf to West Ham they have been missing paqueta who is a huge player for them since the draw against Bristol city. However i know him being out is the reason they are conceding

Can't stand Carragher, however I completely agree with him here.

Gael Clichy is (so far) a brilliant pundit. His commentary is concise and insightful.

Very fair analysis

I don’t think there’s any WH fans that expect them to play like Man C and Arsenal. However they want more engaging football. More to that they want the defence to work. They want to use the skills of the creative players in the team that have cost a lot of money. They also want a manger that knows how to turn a game around when things aren’t working. To make incisive substitutions ina timely manner that can impact a game and rescue a point or at least get the team fighting.

He won the next game with exciting football and 4 goals... Football chat is so emotional.... Thr back-line is injured... Arsenal was a terrible result, but we beat them twice with Moyes' signature style ⚒️⚒️⚒️

Football fans don't remember last season, last month or last week. It's always about NOW! Sad but true.😂😂😂

Let’s just keep in mind Moyes player spend over the last 5 years - over half a billion. The 240m is the clubs NET spend. They should be competing at 4th or 5th at that spending level. I can understand the fans frustrations completely and some of the games are dire. I’m sure they are grateful for the relegation save and the European trophy but agree to go after the season end.

Clichey is really good, wanna see more of him

Reminds me of Spurs. George Graham won them the League Cup, but it wasn't good enough due to the style of play "not being the Tottenham way". Spurs won nothing since. Everton fans wanted Moyes out after losing the FA Cup semi final to Liverpool - he went to Man Utd shortly after & in the years after Everton slowly worked there way down from competing for Europe every year, and back to where Moyes found them - fighting relegation every year and on the edge of being ruined by poor financial planning. Or first time he was at West Ham, when they thought they could do better & had to come crawling back when no other manager could get them out of relegation fights and up the league table on their kind of budget. Be careful what you wish for West Ham fans, not many managers out there can offer the kind of stability Moyes can. Before you force him out, you need a good replacement lined up. There needs to be a proper plan, not knee jerk nostalgia for a time you've never known. There's not many manager's around you can point to and say with confidence "he could take West Ham forward".

If we are a defensive team and we can’t even defend then what are we? 6 against aresnal 3 against Utd even 2 today

I'm a West ham fan and have been for 50 years. I would leave him in position until the end of the season. We won't be relegated, won't win anything and it's been like that for years. If we jump now we could easily end up with another Pellegrini.

Regarding the last section. From Moyes point of view only, and if it were you, if you were offered a contract to keep earning money, you'd take it. If it turns sour and toxic he/ you gets paid off, still earn your money. Interesting to think someone would just reject an extension on a job you think you're doing well in. Or else im wrong?

As always, who would replace Moyes? The usual names who have failed at other clubs, often several times. Whereas Burnley fans are standing behind Kompany, despite their results. West Ham have a short, bad spell, and fans want him out. Go figure.

3:04 West Ham's best manager, in the PL era? Short memories. Harry Redknapp got a 5th place finish. Slaven Bilic got the most points we've ever achieved, in a PL season. Neither won the Europa Conference, because it didn't exist back then. Not a single PL would take Moyes. Loyalty works both ways. West Ham gave him a shot, when after he'd failed at Man Utd, Real Sociedad and relegated Sunderland. With £500m spent, an aging squad and just 1 win in 2024, West Ham do expect more.

its funny that the game after this they put 4 past brentford. moyes brought them their first trophy in decades! what more do people want

Moyes should go but announce it after West Ham exit thos season's Europa league, whenever that is.

People commenting on this clearly don’t watch West Ham, fighting relegation last season. You wouldn’t accept it at your club, but we have too because we’re West Ham.

I think Will Still is the only manager West Ham should replace Moyes with but the sudden change in philosophy could harm them. Look at Southampton, got Nathan jones in (although hassenhutl was doing a fine job) and he was the worst manager the league has ever seen and got relegated. Moyes has done exceptional since he joined and deserves most respect from the fans tbh, West Ham were a yoyo side for the previous 10 years before he came in and he’s given them stability and introduced exceptional fan favourite players into the club.

I dont know how everyone missed this 7:50 😂😂

Hope he goes and WH get relegated.....the West Ham way 😂😂😂......that is the WH way just avoiding relegation. Moyes is a class act he don't need to be disrespected like this.

the damage hurting west Ham football come from 1-selling&loan players 2-west Ham gambling supporters calling sack moyes moyes have special history of west Ham football and wining top european finals and what we witness now against great D.moyes.

Guessing Carra can't wait for Moysegate to take over at Liverpool 😂😂😂😂😂

Won a trophy last year 8th in the table..so sick of hearing pundits talk about Moyes and ETH. Talk about Howe and Poch for a change...

So impatient give moyes to the end of the season see where we are then

They're level 7th in the league after losing Rice, having injuries to their best players and playing Bowen up front (out of position)

All these pragmatic managers lose their job in the prem but we’re stuck with southgate playing 7 defenders every game

More Gael please

I feel like if they got rid of Moyes another PL club would definitely benefit from his experience

I could seriously listen to Clichy say the word Methodology all night long. What a pundit btw sounds like he’d make a decent coach.

8th is good for Westham how can anyone complain just because he is having a bad run.

The grass isn't always greener West Ham fans...

Out of all of the sky sports pundits which one is better than any premier league manager😂?

West Ham had no chance of winning 3 out of the 8 matches. The other 5 matches. They should have had at least 1 win out of the 5. In the next match, West Ham have to win. Otherwise, they must understand the boss's job and transfer are coming to replace them. This summer.

They missed Kudus for Afcon and Paqueta was injured. Give him one more go, sign two CBs and a striker

Maybe if the fans got behind him theyd be playing better. Imagine being a player sitting where they are in the league and fans chanting "youll be sacked in the morning" to the gaffer. Hope West ham go down next year.

Won them a European trophy last season, 10 in the league currently and still in the Europa League Seriously what do West ham fans Expect? league title? Top 4? He's done a great job and is just going through a bad patch If you want to just survive every season and finish 14th then sack him and get someone worse. Careful what you wish for

I agree, West Ham doesn't deserve Moyes

I get the fans wanting to ask to sack their managers but pundits explicitly asking a manager to be sacked is a little too much

West Ham were awful last year in prem and were involved in a season long relegation battle !? Won a competition where they were the favourites, highest value, highest wage against mostly league one/championship/ low premier level clubs.

Keep Moyes UTFT

This is why Gael will never be a manager. West Ham won 4-2 after his comments

I don't think the squad is ready for the transition to another manager. Not without a proper striker anyway

Bit daft this as they won comfortably and are now joint 7th again and had it not been for that late equaliser they would be 7th and only 3 points off 6th, hardly a terrible time for a West Ham team. Yes the Arsenal game was bad but they have been scoring goals for fun so it was unlikely that they wouldn't have done so again even in a London Derby.

Carra gets it. If the non supporters watch us day in day out. We not doing what things we should be doing, he picks the 11, he picks the players, he got rid of players so there is no cover. We have the oldest and smallest squad. This is a recipe for disaster in the latter part of a long season.

Not every team can play “Tippy-Tappy” football … I can understand it’s what every team & fan wants .. but it’s not as easy as City makes it look ..

He or anyone, has taken West Ham as far as thry can go. He's a victim of his own success.

The board needs to go! The two David’s especially! Moses could hand an European trophy 2 seasons in a row.

jamie “for me” carragher

Who to west Ham actually think they are disgraceful

Awful run of form of late but this guy has always been behind the 8 ball. The fans have never taken to him even after their European success. Best for him to leave.

Pep fooled the world with that playing out the back, when his team is the best at doing it while simultaneously being the best at the press, give over........

Moyes will go at the end of the season and West Ham will struggle to achieve top 10 finish next season. West Ham fans will then regret getting rid of him.

Football would be pure bliss if Jose Mourinho managed West Ham…. pure bonkers

The comments here from non west ham fans just proves the point that unless you watch them every week or your club is in the same situation, you really don't understand

Sack Moyes and you aren’t doing any better I’m sorry, you’re 8th with 39 points, I don’t see what’s to complain about. You’re West Ham, everyone above you isn’t a shock they are above you. Could be said that it’s a surprise you’re top half. Any other expectations are beyond what anybody will achieve with that squad.

West Ham fans need to show more respect to Moyes. He’s by far the greatest manager in their history. Without him West Ham would be playing in the Championship

The media is awful david moyes has done a brilliant job with west ham expectations these day are crazy

Maybe carra and Neville should part ways with sky

They've won a European trophy. That alone should give Moyes a season to breathe, not to mention the fact that they sold their best player. Anywhere between 11th and 17th is good enough for this team. There's nobody in the top 10 they should be above and every position below that is a free for all. So barring relegation, Moyes should stay where he is.

Shameful that the fans are out for him. Not to go all Rafa '09, but look at the facts. Highest win % in the PL era. Highest league finish in the PL era. First manager to win silverware in decades. Currently sat 8th, above Chelsea and Newcastle. What more could he possibly achieve?! The 7 teams above him, bar Brighton, have 10x the budget. The fans don't like the football but the man gets results. Everybody outside West Ham knows that, if they sack him for a more fancied name, they'll end up between 12th and 18th next year and, judging by the way they're treating their most successful manager, the fans will deserve it.

Daniel krampah >WHU David Moyes out

Are these guys for real?? We have been in Europe 3 seasons in a row we've won a major trophy we are still in the Europa league we are top 10 and his job is in question 🤣🤣🤣🤣 What happened to winning?

Love what moyes has done but these top 6 fan boy pundits act like everyone else cant be ambitious

A mainstream channel encouraging a football club to sack their manager. Anyone who thinks this is the way forward is beyond repair 😂

Moyes also got Champions to out of top4. So pinch of salt yes?