Bro, Clear sight and Darkstalker was such a dramatic and sad couple 😭 Edit: DANG, 100? Tysm! 🤗

I was so sad when Carnelian died honestly, I felt like she would of had an amazing character arc lol. Maybe be friends with Peril too

Aww Fathom and Indigo being placed right next to each other is even sweeter than Peril and Sky being placed right next to each other!

I think Turtle deserved S tier, I agree he wasn't the most heroic character for most of his book, but when the time came he wasn't afraid to sacrifice himself for the good of everyone else.

3:33 I think Pearl is overall pretty good at heart but was in a really very tough predicament. She had to become queen at a very young age completely out of nowhere due to being the only surviving heir in the Albatross massacre. She had to make herself regal really quickly in order to keep the kingdom intact which is a really heavy burden to carry. And then she has the matter of everyone fearing animus dragons to take care of. Making Fathom swear an oath and keeping him isolated from others really was the only way to calm down the kingdom other than simply killing Fathom herself. And it’s hard to choose against the cheers of her own subjects to get Indigo, the known famous animus slayer, to not go on the trip with Fathom. The only thing I think Pearl went too far on was telling Fathom and Indigo that the other doesn’t wanna see them anymore. And even so, that was very understandable too. Pearl had a huge mess to clean up and considering her circumstances, she did a really good job.

10:30 Cobra may be the very worst parent in Wings Of Fire, but she’s also a really interesting character with many epic moments

I remember reading WoF back in 2021, and absolutely ADORED Qibli. Now, I’m absolutely overjoyed that JMA and the WoF fan community love him just as much as I do, truly a great minds think alike moment.

Can't wait to watch this! It was posted like 14 seconds ago lol Edit: It's amazing how Indigo and Fathom were placed next to each other! Also (edit 2.)SSSSS+ for Qibli!!!!!!!!!

I’m guessing no one can beat qibli. You should add a tier that says, qibli. Also can’t wait for part 3! And I love the tier lists, I’m excited to see what you do next 🤗

I just LOVE Moon and Qibli so I'm happy they rightfully got put in massively high ranks :)

The fact that the music changed on Qibli shows that the editor --(erm idk his name lol-) has respect for Qibli and knows that JMA loves Qibli the best

I love how foeslayers picture is from the dumb ways to die video. “Ice spear keeps you frozen in place”

It’s really interesting to see what people think of your favorite (cough cough Winter) and non favorite dragons (cough cough Narwal)!

I really loved reading book nine. Turtle is one of my favorite characters

I'm very glad Turtle is in S tier. He's my fav character, I can relate so much with him. And in book 9 he had some really great moments by the end of the story.

I love how the music slowly transitions as soon as we get to Qibli, gets quiet again, and then the instrumentals come back with a BOOM

YESSS, I AGREE SO MUCH WITH THE TIER LIST, also I love Turtle, I'm so glad that he got S tier (and Moon too! Moon's amazing)also I agree with Qibli being S+

So happy that do you like Warrior cats and wings of fire too! And you’re a KZfaqr! Such greatness.

I swear I never cried when clearsight buried dark stalker but the Last LAST paragraph of of the epilogue of the same book is just soooooooo underrated and beautiful

Moon and qibli were such a good couple and I hape if arc 4 comes out we see more of them

That part in turtles book with darkstalker and the marble was heart wrenching I had read that and I was like ok wow tui thanks for ripping my heart out with that scene

Very well deserved Qibli rating. Thanks JMA and fellow WoF community :)

I think the image used for Listener was actually an image of Thoughtful (notice the glasses and lack of mind reader scales)

I love how qibli got his own tier

I verbally laughed when I saw "explaining darkstalker any% speedrun."

JMA! I just got a sticker and it looks so good! Thanks for being the best WoF creator! ❤❤

Awww that Indigo art is so cute. I love that her and Fathom are facing each other happily ❤

My boy Qibli getting his own tier, yes!! I love his character so much, its so charming and fun! Also this tier list is very well done and I totally agree with it! Can’t wait for tier 3! ( ps. Was that whirlpool at the end when it was pixelated :agony: )

Your tier lists are amazing! 👌

MOON GOT S TIER!! YEAAAAH! And Qibli Deserves S+ those good for eachother. And yeah... rip Carnelian. She had so much potential in the story, but unlike a sane dragon, she didn't jump behind a bookshelf.

Love the series I’m only on the very start of book 5 and I just love blaze and viper I don’t know why love your videos!

Hey JMA and everyone i love your videos and watch ALL of them keep it up👌

Yes part 2 great job

when Jma uploads its gonna be a good day

Feels illegal to see this so quick. Btw good tierlist!

I love this and I can’t wait to see part three I love your channel and qibli forever

I probably love these type of videos as much as you Ralph

Woo hoo! I’m happy to see that Moonwatcher got such a great score! I didn’t expect her to be rated this high but I definitely think she’s earned it! She’s not just a big part in the plot due to her powers. She’s also incredibly empathetic and wise after the events of Moon Rising and is able to touch the hearts of so many dragons around her to try to be better versions of themselves and make the right choices. Even all the way back at the beginning, she never lets her fears or doubts stop her from doing what she knows was right. There are so many examples of her words of wisdom and encouragement giving others the push they need: She lets Winter know that he’s more than just a prideful IceWing who turns his head away from other tribes, which helps push him into siding against his sister when she’s in the wrong. She tells Sunny that she has what it takes to unite Pyrrhia into a place of peace, which chases away her doubts regarding her idea of Jade Academy. She encourages Riptide to give things another shot with Tsunami when he’s having trouble deciding if she wants to see him again. She tells Peril that she can decide her own future, despite what the prophecy says about “beware the talons of fire”, which leads Peril into wanting to do the right thing more. She comforts Turtle about being a good brother for caring so much about his little sister, which ultimately guilts him more into risking his own safety to help Anemone later on. Plus, Moon’s father-daughter dynamic with Darkstalker was so captivating, between Darkstalker trying to make Moon genuinely trust and like him without brainwashing her while he’s secretly taking revenge on entire tribes and ruling the rest, and Moon trying to give Darkstalker a fair chance to avoid being unfairly hated like she was at first.

my favourite character was Joe Kiske as he said the iconic line 'I own a green jacket with internal pockets, which I use for storage.'

Haven't watched yet, however Qibli REALLY SHOULD get his own tier, anyways, there is no doubt in my mind that this is a great vid, keep it up! EDIT: Is it just me or at the part when he says someone got rated higher then Qibli, did he tease it to be a picture of Whirlpool? That's what the blurred image looked like. Also I'm pretty sure it's either Snudoo or Willow.

This is really good!!!

I waited 5 days just for this video, but I knew this video was gonna be amazing.

I’m so excited for part 3

6:45 I think Hailstorm went through the Diamond Trial as a sort of "I still have Pyrite in my head, so maybe this way I can be free" sort of deal when he wanted Winter to strike him down so Winter could go out without shame. Or to prevent his family from being plunged further in the rankings. Personally I saw him as still being selfless and trying to help Winter and his family in this regard. Of course then Winter had to be a genius and think that if he went out, nobody would know. And he got to be free to live his life with Scavengers. Hailstorm could've kept to the rules of the trial and struck him down as most Icewings probably would've done, but he risked his own ranking so that Winter could survive. If Winter was ever found, the whole Kingdom would know and Hailstorm would probably have gone to the bottom for ruining the sanctity of the trial. His methods weren't perfect, but he never seemed the brightest. He did have his friends and family close to heart, though, and I love that about him personally.

Where’s cliff.

At 8:33 Jade takes back everything he has said! THE DATA LIES?!?!!?!???!!?!

Yeey finally it's here!❤ I love your content JMA😊

me and my friend call Talons of Power (the book) Turtle Hiding and now i can barely remember the real name

Icicle is honestly interesting when it comes to how her character can be viewed, especially when it comes to how she views and interacts with her brother Winter. On the surface, Icicle has shown a resentment towards Winter for Hailstorm being captured as well as making attempts to belittle him by calling him weak/worthless. The latter of which becomes interesting when it comes to when Winter questions Icicle about why she didn't tell him about Hailstorm and her telling how he is worthless and didn't want waste time arguing with his sensitive more sensibilities; Something that Moonwatcher, no doubt reading Icicle's mind, rebuttals by saying quote: "She means she didn't want to be talked out of it. She knew you'd try, and maybe even succeed, because you're not worthless; You're smart and brave and capable of caring about other dragons". Dialogue that, when taken context for Icicle's actions, becomes pretty important to her character. Giving an idea of while she cares about Winter deep down, she does appear to make attempts to emotionally distance herself from her brother with the resentment she has for him; Something that becomes physically apparent when Icicle backs down from attacking Starflight when Winter attacks her, despite her being capable of taking him down to get to Starflight, as well as when Icicle's attempts to insult and shy away from Winter 's attempts to reach out her at the Old Nightwing island. Things get more interesting when taking into consideration of Icicle's latter thoughts considering Winter as smart and brave and capable of caring about other dragons, giving the possibility that Icicle may have seen Winter in some way as a dragon better than herself; Be it from dealing with Scarlet or living under the pressure of their parents, especially her mother Tundra looking to use her daughter to control the throne; Leaving Icicle to live her life with the thought of one day killing her Aunt Glacier. Getting back to Icicle one last time, if she did see Winter as a dragon better than herself that it would be kind of ironic considering Winter saw himself as not good enough to be an Icewing and saw Icicle as the perfect Icewing.

0:45 - 0:51 When he ACCIDENTALLY says that Clearsky is his most disliked character and you ACCIDENTALLY sign him up for the army 😅

12:07 I saw what you did there, Ralph 😈. And honestly, if *IT* does come true, then I wouldn't mind seeing Winter again through the eyes of irony.

I love your tier lists!😊

4:10 YESSSSSSSSS! AS A WHITEOUT FAN LIKE ABSOLUTELY LARGE FAN IM HAPPY FOR HER! (Ik she doesn’t exist but. She’s my entire favorite character) :) (edit: that picture of”listener” is actually thoughtful! You can tell because he has glasses. And no silver tear drop scale!)

I would move winter up qibli down but other than that I agree with that list

The data lies joke was really funny😂😂😂😂

32 seconds and 5 miliseconds new record for speed runing teh explination of darkstalker

Cliff was likely the dragonet who saved leaf in legends dragonslayer.

I love that you aren’t really spoiling anything at all. I love that because I haven’t read some of them🎉

We need a parents tier list

I love this!❤ (Albatross is Fathoms grandfather you said uncle a few times)😁 Also I’m SOOOO HAPPY TURTLE IS IN S TIER!!!! He’s my favorite character besides Moon Qibli and Whiteout!!!!❤❤❤

My headcanon for Chameleon is that he’s brachycephalic (short face, like a pug) because it can cause severe breathing issues and it just fits his innate derpiness

Haven't seen this yet, BUT IF QIBLI DOESN'T GET HIS OWN TEIR I WILL MAKE THE HEAT DEATH OF THE UNIVERSE COME EARLY. EDIT: ERM ACTUALLY, ALBATROSS IS FATHOMS GRANDFATHER, NOT UNCLE EDIT 2: *LONG HEAVY SIGH* Man Moon is overrated. Never thought that 2 of my leasst fac characters would get the top of S Teir. EDIT 3: WOOOO TURTLE FINALLY GETTING THE LOVE HE DESERVES! *Soccer Mom cheering sounds* EDIT 4: HOLY SH** I WAS RIGHT! GO QIBLI AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA EDIT 5: It's Sundew, Isn't it? She's the one that gets a super high ranking?

YESSSS! Qibli wins! And winter (by far one of my favorite characters) got relatively high! This was excellent jma. Thank you!

We need epic rap battles of Pantala I think Blue vs Cricket and Sundew vs willow would be cool

YESSSS!!! Whiteout supremacy!!!! I'm so happy she got recognized and given the rating she desrves. Whiteout is such an interesting character with how she sees things so differently. Other dragons tend to dismiss her as just being weird and talking nonsense, but if they actually took the time to really listen to her they would see that she is trying to tell us something, just in her own way. Behind that strangness, she's very wise and often knows something about others that they havent even realized yet. Also I'm just a sucker for neurospicy characters 😉

i want more lady scarab, ik she isnt in here, but i love grumpy old charectors so much...

Yay! Cant wait for part 3!

12:27 LETS GOOOOOOO MY BOY TURTLE MADE IT TO S TIER YEEEEEAAAAAAAHHHHHHHH

Im doing a Darkstalker VA And Im voicing Whiteout and my Bestie's voicing Clearsight and Lagoon. So m rlly happy to see Clearsight and Whiteout on the well deserved S Tier!

I really am excited for part 3

Qibli randomly in book 10 : *I need you to arrest my mother*

The reason some horrible characters got higher rankings than expected is, although they are terrible people, they are still interesting characters. Take Chameleon for example. His existence alone reveals a darker aspect of Rainwing culture; ostracising those that are deemed too different. His actions create considerable obstacles for the heroes and his ability to assume multiple personas allowed many twists in the plot. He's a villain I would like to see make a return if any more stories are written.

great video..........wait a sec where is cliff?!?!?!!??

JMA: Darkstalker also deeply cares for those he loves. (added "Also respects"). Qibli: Those gems are DEADLY LASERS

Omg the mystery character ww-wwwas..... WHIRLPOOL!!

As a speedrunner myself, I LOVE the whole speedrun blurb! Also, amazed that Turtle got S tier... But the data doesn't lie!

Great video

Honestly I kinda hoped albatross would be in at least b+

0:50 right there with you bro all my least fav warrior cat characters are leaders. Leopardstar and Blackstar because of Stone fur, but Clearsky is number one

As a whiteout fan I definitely approve of whiteout being S tier

I feel that in book 8 moon is to smug to peril & is nothing like the moon in books 6 & 7

I’m feel like I already know who is it now and I’m talking about the surprise 13:09

Lez go. CANT WAIT FOR PART 3!❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

2:49 Actually, Albatross is Fathom's grandpa, not his uncle. Whoopsie on JMA's part.

0:21 yeah Tui did her dirty.

Qibli supremacy!! Also glad winter got some credit!!

Thank you for answering my comment. I was winter who asked it, but my iPad screen broke so I am getting it fixed.

11:34 QUEEN GLACIERS NEPHEW!!!!!1!

yet another slamdunk of a video and i think its becuse of darkstalker that i made my mane oc character a nightwing lol

LETS GO JMA POSTED AGAIN！！！

Also if u put book 7 on the left of book 6 moon and winter look in the eye

My prediction is willow. Also yay good boi Qibli 💛💛💛

Hey JMA you did , its whirlpool

JMA, you forgot an important character, The Strawberry!!! It heroically sacrificed itself to take down Darkstalker #JusticeForTheBerry 🍓

Albatross was Fathom’s GRANDFATHER, thank you!

YUS MORE (ps, if you see this, may I animate some "JMA funny moments" or something? Ive seen a couple moments so far that would be absolutely hilarious and fun to work with, but i totally understand if not)

I completely didn’t know you read warriors- yes I know I commented but I wanna do it again lol

While reading the darkstalker books the only mystery was Fathom and Indigo luckily it happend

Why wasn’t I notified when this came out…

Heads up Albatross was Fathoms grandfather great video tho😀