#CourtTV What do YOU think? #VerdictWatch MORE HERE: www.courttv.com/tag/karen-read/?

The prosecutors closing argument in my opinion absolutely DOES NOT prove murder. He should be embarrassed.

So the McAlberts were allowed to sit there and stare down the jury. Yeah good one! 😏

People keep missing this main point that Jen McCabe’s husband texted in the group chat something to the effect of “the guy never came in the house” and Brian Albert replying “exactly”. Why text this if John never went inside? Why delete and upgrade your phones if you have nothing to hide? And why would anyone text this if he really wasn’t inside 34 Fairview?! *edited thanks to a wonderful reviewer who caught my mistake, thank you.

Not ever referring to him as “Officer O Keefe” is so disrespectful

You can not explain why home owners especially trained police officers would not run out of house with all the police cars and ambulance to find out what the heck is going on, even if someone already told me there’s a police officer down on lawn. No way. Never happen unless your hiding or already know what happened to him. Disgusting

Embarrassing and scary. I would pack my things up and leave that corrupt city asap

From what I can see and I’ve been following this for weeks. There is no evidence that she hit him with a car or anything else.

There’s just no way she would have left those voicemails if she knew she ran him over

Did this guy really just try to use shoes in a house as a way to show she knew she hit him? Wowzers.

Let me get this straight, because Karen did not take her shoes off when she entered into the house, it means she killed him? She knew she could wear shoes now because he would never know? How crazy. How about she is woman who is drunk and thinks her boyfriend is cheating on her and she just wants him to come home , so she doesn't care or even notice that her shoes are still on.

This actual closing statement is terrible. This guy should be fired along with Proctor

Wow ! He said use your common sense. Where is his ? If they use theirs then obviously Not Guilty ! 🙃

Reads lying how No ONE notices..1st she dropped HIM off watch him get to door..then later she left him at the Waterfall. Come on folks. A man is dead his family now with another loss. The kids had John now he's gone as were their parents. Sad as hell.

If I were Lally I would self exile out of embarrassment. This guy made an absolute joke out of himself. He’s truly a terrible attorney

Not a great prosecutor… His delivery was atrociously boring and unconvincing.

The medical examiner unable to confirm manner of death with the defense witnesses are a not guilty for me despite her angry calls.

I went from feeling sorry for this man for his sad incompetence to finding him just as reprehensible as the corrupt cops and seedy players in this unbelievable case. I hope they hire him to defend them in their federal trials! They ALL deserve one another

The worst closing argument to date.

He showed a video of a parked white van in the snow with doors open and a distraught GF yelling as she sees her dying BF. Then the texts of a GF left alone with her BFs kids while her BF continues to party. All this lines up correctly. We all agree 👍. But how did they explain the wounds on JO and how,when and where did Karen do this? With her SUV she hit the back of his head multiple times but only struck his arm????? Who believes this?

Absolute snooze fest of a closing

Lally just keeps repeating‘the broken tail light’. He did not connect the dots for the jurors.

The closing argument is clutching at straws. Nothing makes sense, no real facts except timestamps that prove zero. The jury must be fed up by now...

Not guilty. Too much doubt and honestly I question those folks in the house too many questions no answers. The only person who knows is Mr. O'Keefe. May he rest in peace.

Jackson is a actor that why she got him she told yanetti she hit him

Every time this man is about to tell a lie, he clears his throat

I feel like we should be throwing rotten tomatoes at this joker. He completely misinterpreted Jackson's words in closing. Jackson was telling the jury that the Commonwealth was hoping that everyone would just "look the other way" and just disregard the facts and evidence that proves that Karen DID NOT KILL JOHN. The voicemails are irrelevant. She may have been mad at him for whatever reason because they're both human beings and are not perfect, but that doesn't make her a murderer. Physical injuries do not add up to being hit by vehicle. I believe the FBI expert over the trooper. The FBI expert is more credible. Anything that is said by Proctor and his gang of his sick twisted troopers have absolutely no credibilty.

When she left in the am to find John both taillights still lit up red!! So that tail light was cracked but not missing those big pieces….YET

I'm so thankful to Lally for this closing statement. I've always had such a difficult time falling asleep at night, and thanks to Lally, I finally got a good nights sleep just by playing this video. I'm out like a light within 5 minutes! Thanks Lally!

This is the most boring closing argument I have ever seen! I'm going to sleep. Lally, go find another job.

So not GUILTY! Please FBI get justice for John and his family🙏🏼!! Find the real killers please!

Lolly makes me sick that his closing statement is so squed and not any facts

What a schlub. Even though he wasn't hit by a car and her car didn't hit a person, he wants them to convict her because she's not a nice person or for her panicked raving. And the hair was frozen to the bumper? Then why didn't it fall off in the nice warm sally port of the Canton PD (where Higgins and Chief Berkowitz hung around)? You'll never hear a good reason why two professional law enforcement officers (Albert and Higgins) destroyed their phones knowing there would be an investigation.

SO much reasonable doubt. Not guilty.

I cant wait to see the defence team for the Alberts and McCabes when they go under investigation after this case is complete with Karen Read going free with a NOT guilty. Wonder if proctor and trooper Paul will be their star witness for that trail. 😂😂😂😂. Good luck to them.

Four times?????? What a dope 🙄🙄🙄

Use your common sense? This coming from a prosecutor who isn't using his. Anyone who has watched this entire trial and has common sense clearly sees a plethora of reasonable doubt. The fact that this case moved forward should frighten everyone, you could be accused of a crime you did not commit. Maybe you feel she's not innocent, ok, but reasonable doubt exists therefore, not guilty. To those ready to convict her, i pray you are never on a jury or falsely accused.

Not guilty, not guilty, not guilty, not guilty

Listening to Lally is like reading "little red riding hood" to a non English speaking audience........waste of energy

Take a brave man to repeat what Jennifer McCabe said lol

A long drawn out closing argument mumbled and boring as all hell.

Thank you Lally! The jury must convict with this mountain of evidence!

This was sad at best. What a disgrace.

Look at the body language of the ppl in the background during this closing vs their body language during defense closing 😂😂😂

I didn’t know that the My Cousin Vinny Confession could really stand up in court. “I shot the clerk?”

If ambulance and police our outside of my house at 6am with lights and commotion you bet I am running outside my house to find out what’s going on…. I’m definitely not choosing to sit in house while all that is going on…. Unless I’m guilty

Nothing of what he says connstitutes evidence...its just words.

Embarrassing this even went to trial. This prosecutor literally put in closing arguments she kept her shoes on in the house as evidence of guilt. Epic fail.

You dont convict a person base on messages and calls.

Alberts related to Proctor such an injustice! What a horrible case! Then nothing in the house gets investigated! Alberts and Higgs get rid of their phones, the dog disappeared..... the floor gets made over, the house gets sold..... my my my. Oh and the tail light! Its only cracked until Proctor touches it! AND video is missing from salyport! Very shameful investigation. Just ask the FBI.

He did a fantastic job! I hope the jury follows the evidence.

Hear say hear say hear say hear say

Both KR & JO and their entire crew are heavy drinkers. None of these people, including several of the LEO’s, have shown much emotional maturity. Evidence has been disposed of. Evidence has not been collected (inside 34 Fairview). This group of people have circled the wagons & left KR to wear the entire thing. NONE of the people are like able at all. Text messages have been cherry-picked and shown without context. Vehicle evidence is weak. Autopsy is inconclusive. They clearly didn’t break up during the day since they went out that night. The ADA got a crappy case full of holes & he has no choice but to prosecute it. It’s his job & the higher-ups want this horrible episode closed. The defense attorney’s primary job is to test every piece of the prosecution’s case and expose its weaknesses. He illuminated enough reasonable doubt to drive a truck through.

"I bit him. I bit him. I bit him" Chloe

I don’t believe she said I hit him

This was by far the worst closing argument ive ever seen!!!!

I did not hit her I did not hit her The disaster artist

Lally robotically repeats himself, and blatantly asks jurors to disregard components of evidence presented, including omitting the fact of failure to secure crime scene, which taints entire investigation. Even the claims of her saying "oh my God I hit him' versus 'did I hit him?', such statements do not indicate any intention to kill him. Even dooosch-bagg proctor very clearly states he doesn't think he can prove intentional versus accidental impact, even if you believe her car did hit him. No basis to charge murder from any of that evidence. Him suggesting that how she showed grief is evidence of guilt "why did she act like that?" - throw Lally's comments down the crapper. He sounds like he's reciting from a court report, no suggestion that he strongly believes what he's saying. It's almost irrelevant if her car hit him; the evidence is suspect, there is exculpatory evidence to rebut, and mountain of reasonable doubt. Best Lally can hope for is a recalcitrant juror (maybe even a local with a vested interest) forcing a mistrial.

Kudos to an amazing defense team! That closing argument was epic! This momo ….what an embarrassment! Shoo

Not guilty. It was obviously that other guy that wanted to fight him.

she may have hit by accident and panicked.. but the prosecution has not proven its case beyond a reasonable doubt.

Apparently this guy runs out of time. How unprofessional

I’m sorry lunchbox, i think your just making excuses for a bunch of iffy humans.

I can't believe he opened closing arguments with here say

Reasonable Doubt. Not Guilty.

That is NOT what happened!

"If the shoes were on, she killed John" - Adam lally

Guilty obviously,,, but she'll walk,,, just like OJ did. Her celebrity like status and good looks will definately not hinder verdict.

When i see the people who believe she is guilty i am worried tor humanity. Genuinely.

Just wanted to see if anyone else looks at her face and sees that smug look and just can’t stand her by looking at her or is it just me

A cop with 28 years plus on the job has a man killed in his house and puts him out on his front lawn. I am frightened by the thinking of conspiracy theorists

Do you People really believe that EVERYONE at that party clammed up to aid in covering up a murder of a fellow officer An officer who everyone knew was raising his deceased sibling’s kids? Do You believe the wives and others at this party were all complicit and that everyone has kept their mouths shut for the duration of the investigation and even years since? Impossible This defense was brilliant in raising reasonable doubt but the reality is yeah, she hit him - and no, not every emt who says she said that is lying again, that’s just not a reasonable thing to believe

Must be painful to be the commonwealth right now.

What a joke

Lally is in WAY over his head

He followed Alan Jackson's masterpiece of a closing with this? How embarrassing.

Factually innocent.

'i hit him i hit him i hit him' she never said...he never said...witnesses never said 'by a car'. Lally wants you to believe it's a car

She kept saying ..did I hit him I hit him why didn't she say we're is John .. then she saids after she is ok ..I do not remember what happened .unreal

This prosecutor is horrible and should be as embarrassed as the police dept in Canton

None of what Lally included in his closing arguments explains those dog attack bites n scratches on John's arm..nor the utter lack of any bodily injuries below his neck

She just needs to give Johns family peace and let go and take her punishment. Blaming others like a child. Sad, grow up. Covered her bases by leaving voice mails, and getting ahold of turtle boy. So manipulative. Thinks like a child. All of her actions are of a guilty person.

Why would he even mention those awful texts and messages from Proctor? Just highlighted it for the jusy.

Why would she call him 53 times after murdering him accusing him of sleeping with another girl, or lying trying to bait him saying she left the children there alone and went back home? also, explain the fact that the triple expert doctor said there would 100 percent for sure be bruising after getting hit with an SUV. FOR SURE. explain that people who think shes guilty??

Even if she had hit him... how could this ever have been lethal, if there were no broken bones and no bruises? This question Lally does not want to answer "for some reason". I hope he will get some karma for his "performance"

Is he all over the place? His narrative has no order how does he expect the jury to make sense of what he's saying?

Yanetti knows she done this theatrical Jackson she pleaded guilty before

The flipped photo of the car tail light and the Vulgar words towards Karen are what turned the tables for me.

I love how Lally just rolls off the names of all the killers that were involved in the murder and cover up, just in case we should forget. 52:05 and 52:38

How come Court TV doesn't have a timer up fora verdict watch like they normally do?

Lally recited a snooze fest. He wouldn't know how to close a door much less a court case!

Ny don’t need any of those Massachusetts state troopers here!

GUILTY

Ask yourself why the CW spent over 100k to frame Kearney and have yet to look for the Ford Edge seen by the body location hours before it was found. Is anyone curious to why that car was blocking the body at 3 am?

46:28 Which frame is this from the original video, show the entire video, not just one cherrypicked frame that makes your argument look like an absolute. 🤡 Lally

GUILTY! Thinks she’s a rock star and a lawyer, sitting there all smug, rolling her eyes, she was pissed that John didn’t want her anymore. Bunny boiler!

“Mister Lally, such a continuous personal vendetta is hardly conducive to the dignity of your position as District Attorney. The commonwealth and its witnesses have made totally unsupported accusations against my name and John’s. If any of you have one authentic shred of evidence, just one, let them bring it forth! Otherwise, if one more word of this outrageous calumny reaches my ears, I shall sue! I shall take the commonwealth to the supreme court and I shall sue the Boston, Canton, and Massachusetts State Police! I will not stand quietly by and allow myself to be crucified by a deranged mob of sycophantic morons whose fetid frustration has overcome their judgment! If scandal is to your taste, Mr Lally, I shall give you a feast!“ Karen Reed ~ The Prime of Miss Karen Read

Hes a disgrace. And should be ashamed of himself.

Firefighter McLaughlin is friends with Kaitlin Albert though, and even lied about being friends with her, so her testimony holds no weight

How can Lally feel good about himself!!