Check out KEEGAN’S channel here 😊✌🏼 - kzfaq.info/get/bejne/d9SbZLJ5s6y2Z6c.html

Keegan’s provided more context and had more cohesion. Both were visually interesting. Kyle’s works better as a teaser. I could see it as a pre-movie commercial or at a film festival where everyone is getting a freebies! 🍫

I personally prefer Keegan’s. But both were incredibly done! Edit: tysm for all the likes!❤️

Keegan's was better for a few reasons. The music and text worked smoother with the edits and we had a much better idea about what we were watching as an audience.

The one Keegan made looked really epic. Honestly, the colors and the little details that he focused onto looked really cool in the final edit. Gotta give em' props dude 👏👏👏

Kyle has some nice shots and parts, like the same font as Mr.Beast uses and his outro song. All the soundeffect with this wild music and awesome shots make it overwheling however. The one of Keegan feels more thought through and more complete. It is better fit to the music and simpler and therefore conveys a clearer message.

Keegan's was the best one, IMO. Kudos on the creativity on such a low budget and limited time frame, guys!

Both edits were amazing but Keegan’s looked like a legit commercial while Kyle’s looked more like a 5 second promo

I cannot decide because both were incredible. You both got such an amazing talent! Props to both

The beat sync made Keegan's edit stand out a little more than Kyle's

Both were good, but second commercial was the better of the two. Well done guys. Awesome work!

Love your guy’s projects and trailers

LET’S GET THAT BRUNCH! 🔥🔥

The final product was amazing, but the story telling of filming how they filmed it was even better while sharing on technical knowledge on making different perspective come to life. Amazing! Thanks for sharing!

They are both so good!!

I liked Keegan's cut better. Now I want to buy a bar! You both did great and it was difficult to make a choice. You guys make a great creative team!

Amazing work! 👏🏼

this shows how much effort it takes from a 3 second shot and how you can do this out of anything

Both of them were SO good!!!!

Both edits were my favorite! Good job guys!

Both were very impressive!! I prefer Keegan’s advertising, but Kyle added in the nice touch of the Mr.Beast music!!

Kyle's was really good but too fast I think in my opinion, so the ultimate one would probably be Keegan's with the Mr. Beast theme played at the end and with the text from Kyle's

You both did incredible!

That's really good for that timeline 👏

Love your hard works ❤ Both edits are cool!

The raw shots alone were amazing! You guys are so creative! But I personally prefer Keegan's. Both were good but Keegan's had more of a commercial feel to it

love this behind the scene footage! XD

KEEGAN'S!!! the informative shots were slower and smoother and the use of the notes made more sense because of the text provided. Kylie's shots were a little rushed, considering that it's an ad but still cool

Considering the time and work that goes into these sets, I would love to see some behind the scenes clips of the creation process. The designs of these are truly next level.

You both did an incredible shot. Bravo. Kyle has that special style's input that wraps up his shot and that i personally like more particular. But i love your both shot. Thank you

The second one was wow, both did a good job

food photography is so interesting

The second one was definitely the best. Did't feel overwhelming and rushed. Too bad though they were vertical video's :(

This is genuinely awsome to watch! Thanks for inspiring us all 😁

2nd edit was undoubtedly the BEST

You guys did great. I like Keegan's edit more as a commercial, the text effect and all. But the edit lacked sound effects (breaking the chocolate bar and chocolate splash). Great work guys.👍🏾

I prefer the messaging in the second one more, as it has that marketing info that consumers want to know... But the clips for the second one is more aesthetically pleasing which I enjoyed watching

kyle's edit was smoother (exported at higher fps) and more satisfyhing, but keegan's edit ultimately advertises the product better

Keegans is the full advert, could show it in tv or something. Kyles is the short ad you see before a vid on youtube or scrolling tiktok. Both are great. I cant choose one over the other since they can both be used.

OMG!! BOTH EDITS ARE SUPER GOOD 😭❤

Personally I prefer Keegan’s cut, but as some others have said, I can see kyles as a clip you show to the funding companies. As a 12 year old interested in this kind of stuff, I find this video quite remarkable. 👏😁

The second ad was the best for me. Much easier to follow what’s being sold and it was really full of energy

kylie shots and fonts and keegan music choice good work both of you

Both were incredible good

I always love seeing how that stuff works behind the scenes.

Both did an AMAZING works! But Keegan's beat sync looks pretty cool😍

I've never been more interested at watching an advertisement

2nd one was DOPE!

I actually liked Kyle's a lot... the transition from one bar to another was so smooth and I loved it!

Keegan’s video looked like a real commercial.

like the first one tbh cause it showed most of the product and it had the og music

The second one was chefs kiss👌🏻

That was incredible! That must of taken lots of time and hard work! Couldn't decide because both were amazing masterpieces!!!

I like Keegan’s more because the message was so clear and it’s a fine way to introduce a new brand of chocolate. Anyway, you both did an awesome job on the shots 😊

2nd edit was fabulous 🥳🥳

I love both of them

They both did an amazing job, but i think that I liked Keegan’s more, the shots were EPIC!

Both were so good oh my God - Good job guys!

2nd one is a clear winner

Both are awesome ☺️

This channel is underrated, I prefer long videos more

I think Keegan's final cut was a little bit better, the shots were perfectly merged with the music... But both were awesome...

Keegans was amazing

I like both of them

Yep I definitely like Keegan's more. It flowed more smoothly and the music fits nicely with the shots

Both were amazing but the second trailer flowed with the music beat nicer… id probably put original first before the flavored almond and quinoa but thats just personal preferance.. but the raw footage is amazing!!!

I really like the second one. It looks like a professional ad

Both of them r equally good

Keegan's edit was pretty much bold and looking really awesome ....And Kyle's was also good , both are awesome 😊

Incredible. This video inspires me to do what you guys are doing, I don't know what it's called I think it's photography? Anyway, I hope I can learn what you guys are doing when I grow up, looks fun!

you both are super awesome no words to say anyways

The chocolate splashing nicely with the beat was nice in keegan's edit

The thing is, you guys create commercials that are much much much better than ones of companies

Wow you guys made it awesome !!!.. Hope mr beast sees this

I love the ending of Kyle’s edit, it adds a nice touch to it, however Keagan’s edit is fire overall and his messaging is superb

This is awesome! 😀😀

Both were well done, I could see them both being used a different type of promo. Kyle's edit would fit best as a short youtube ad. The edit brings more attention to the competition and the prize than the candy, so I think it would be better suited as a promo for the contest than Keegan's. Keegan's edit focuses more on the candy. It makes the candy slightly more appealing, and gives a few more seconds of footage to focus on the difference between the types of bars and the content within each type. I think Keegan's edit is better suited for a 30 second TV spot or a mid video sponsor message/promo. Overall each edit has a different focus, and both succeed at presenting their theme better than the other. If I was promoting the product, I'd choose Keegan. If I was promoting the competition, I'd choose Kyle.

To be honest. None of the edits where actually good

Keegan. That was Awesome

Keegan’s cut is so cool

I preferred Keegan’s edit. Great video you two!!! 👏 Hope you do more of stuff his stuff in the future!

Both of the commercials are good but I think Kyle's commercial is slightly better.

That looks really fun

Loved the second edit. Sorry. They both were amazing. Fun to watch!! Great tips and tricks!

I prefer Keegan's one, it was slower and easier to 'digest'. Also it promoted the product as something decadent and delicious with hints of potential to win $$$. Keegan 10/10 Well done Kyle as well. Your one was 9/10

Can you publish those footages. So that we can make a fan made edit out of this 🙏

Keegan nailed it

I love how it ends with the Beast outro music, very nostalgic ❤

Keegan had more details as of what was happening on each shot, very informative glad you 2 worked on this and provide feedback on each other great job to both of you!

I personally prefer Keegan's, but in the last scene i prefer kyle's

KEEGAN FINAL EDITING WAS INCREDIBLE

You always throw stuff upward or sprinkle something down ✨

great job guys!! both clips just rock! ... in our opinion: a combination would nail it. put the beauty of 5:16 in the second one and you are perfect ... what a blast & what a pitty to find you that late. great work! really. keep it up!

Kyle's cut is a teaser Keegan's cut is a social media commercial Both well done!

Keegans for SURE lol

Keegans commercial is insane I love it!

I have to choose Kyle. Keegan did an amazing job though.

both are great but id prefer keegan's edit abit more

now i want to try this chocolet out .... sounds yummm to me ! oh yummmm

Both edits were solid, the one at the end seemed especially badass! Raza :)