Verily it is a reality

Don’t use the internet, but subscribe to our channel. Makes a lot of sense.

​@@terencehank7206 Didn't u read what I said: I said it's become an essential part of our lives now. This was over 20 years ago. The internet was a new thing and it wasn't really necessary. In fact, this very Sheikh opened up his own website before he died.

While what you state is all correct, I would just like point out the fact, that such statements about a new technology by such scholars stops the whole ummah from becoming early adopters of the technologies and take advantage of it, which leads to the current situation of ummah. Muslims were the inventors and innovators during the golden era of the Islamic period and from there currently we are in such a state that any new technologies is always given the supposedly evil doing image by our elders. I know the scholars do study about Islam and then give out a statement but if such line of thought would be followed as described in the video, it would also mean, interest is banned in Islam, people give and take interest in currency system, although currency system is good and bad people have an option to get/receive interest if they use the currency system, so no one should use the currency system. It sounds absurd but it follows the same line of thinking. If some scholar doesn't understand the future implications, they should just say it outloud that they cannot judge, the famous example of imam Malik not passing a judgement on a topic for 20 years, because if someone stops the people from enjoying the resources that Allah has bestowed on them, such people will face Allah's wrath is mentioned in quran. Also last but not least I would like to point out that there is a certain sect in Islam whose only opinion , about each and every act that hasn't been performed by prophet is to be considered evil, harm, bad, etc is one of the contributing factors, not the only factor but one of the contributi g factor, for the Muslim ummah to remain backward in current era

Very well articulated thank you

May Allah reward you. Leaving social media really does increase productivity in deen and dunya related affairs.

hmmm..u r here commenting

Mash Allah pray for me brother

@@osamatsondoladen yes he said he accesses scholars here.

@@osamatsondoladen ahh here it is, classic one. Maybe you should read again.

Agree internet is controlling us

So stop using the internet then, nobody's stopping you. Whilst your at it, go to the countryside and live your life their with your family. And then consider building your own version of the internet which is better, rather than continuously whine about how the internet you refuse to give up, is so bad.

Illuminati is controlling internet

@@Ganstaz003 assalam u alaykum, brother. With all seriousness, would you help someone who want that

@Abdul Haqq I'm saying, to be part of the solution instead of the problem

Ameen

@@subulassalam6067 Assalam walaikum ...from your indian muslim brothers...

Aameen

ameen 🤲

امين

Just as general advice, thank Allah for have guiding you to this. It is only because of Him that this is your desire. If you were left to yourself you would be just like them. And don't compare yourself to them as this can lead to arrogance. Arrogance is a tremendous sin. Just remember that Allah is the One who has guided you to this goodness and be greatful to Him for that. And the best person to take as your rolemodel is the Best of Creation صلى الله عليه وسلم. Shaykh ibn Uthaymeen served the ummah and he is great, may Allah have mercy on him, but there is someone even greater to try to emulate.

@@Name-jz4fb Dear brother he wants to be like both of them Sallallahu alayhi wa salam alayhim. He want to be like the shaykh because the Shaykh was a great scholar, righteous and practicer of the sunnah.

Masha Allah ❤

@@abasbashir852 the prophet saww Mohammad is the greatest man ever created and the sheikh follows and try’s to be like prophet saww Mohammad so he should follow and his goal should be more like the prophet saww Mohammad not the sheikh.

@@Name-jz4fb we can never be equal to a prophet grow up

SubhanAllah Congratulations

May u find peace, Baraka Allah

Glad you did. ❤️

Allahu Akbar☝️ Welcome back brother 🙂

May Allah the magnificent save us from the terrible punishments of the grave and allow us to pass the exam of the grave and allow us to rectify our affairs between us n his majesty and any human's we harmed ameen, welcome to Islam my lovely brother with the warmest of hugs , be steadfast and patient and strithe!

Please write Allah's Name in capital letters. And please write 'Subhana-Hu wa T'aala'. As-Salaamu 'alaykum! :)))

You're literally using Social Media, telling Muslims to leave social media

@Untitled. For more Islamic knowledge YT memri tv- australian preacher, syrian cleric, kuwaiti cleric, saudi cleric, al azhar uni. prof.

@@IbrahimKhan-gv6cw why? Capital?

Did you have the inner peace and if so how did you quit.

No, we're trapped ,fooling ourselves won't save us

yes We need separate platforms I absolutely agrees with you.

*Yes* - *one of the founder of KZfaq is Muslim, He should contribute in creation of Another platform like KZfaq but with Restrictions on Immorality*

Real talk we definitely do. Mosques (at least in my home country UK) are sitting on so much donation money. They should all get together and make useful websites that have no haram and even better we should make our own network companies that block access to sites that contain haram.

القوقل و الینستاغرام ( سلام الله علیها)

wa iyyak

Aamiin

Agree

Please translate to bahasa indonesia. May allah reward you

Wallahi, the concluding statement from Sheikh is the truth and still very relevant today. May Allah bless him

Allahumma Amin ya Rabb

@@lacroquetalacroqueta6813 We captured some of the women as prisoners, and the long separation from our wives was pressing us hard and we wanted to release sperms outside of the women. We asked Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) (whether it was permissible). He said, "It is better for you to release sperms inside. No soul, (that which Allah has) destined to exist, up to the Day of Resurrection, but will definitely come, into existence." Sahih al-Bukhari 2542

​How did I ever know this?are you making it up?@@takiyaazrin7562

Ameen Suma Ameen

Hey kratos

Akhi stay away from these games of shirk

@@gigganigga690shut up

You can't just come to a conclusion by watching one eastern person. Calm down brother.

Please say 'Rohimahullah' as 'Rohimah-Ullah' to pay respect to Allah's name.

@Faysal. For more of eastern Islamic scholars go to YT memri tv-australian preacher, kuwaiti cleric, syrian cleric, saudi cleric, al azhar uni. prof.

As Muslims, we believe in the punishment of the grave. There are many narrations which verify its authenticity. One such narration is: The Messenger of Allaah (sallallaahu 'alaihi wa sallam) said, "Seek Allaah's protection from the Punishment of the Grave, since the Punishment of the Grave is a fact/true." (Saheeh: At-Tabraanee in 'al-Kabeer' from Umm Khaalid bint Khaalid ibn Sa'eed ibn al-'Aas.) Our righteous predecessors have mentioned many stories in this regard, some of which are as follows: Ibn Abi'd Dunya (rahimahullah) mentioned that one of his companions said, “My brother died and I saw him in a dream. I said, "How was it when you were placed in your grave?" He replied, "Someone brought me a fiery flame and if it had not been that someone else made supplication for me, I think he would have hit me with it.” ("The Soul journey after death" an abridgement of Ibn al-Qayyim's kitabar-ruh.) Bashar b. Ghalib (rahimahullah) said, “I saw Rabia, on whose behalf I make frequent supplication, in a dream. She said to me, "Bashar b. Ghalib! Your gifts have been brought to me on plates of light, covered in silken cloths." I asked, "How can that be?" She replied, "That is what the supplication of living believers is like. When they make supplication for a dead person, that supplication is answered for them on plates of light, veiled in silken cloths. Then they are brought to the dead person for whom the supplication was said and they are told, 'This is the gift of so-and-so to you.'” ” ("The Soul journey after death" an abridgement of Ibn al-Qayyim's kitabar-ruh.) Amr bin Dinar (rahimahullah) said “The sister of one of the men of Medina died and he buried her. When he came back from the burial, he remembered that he had left something in the grave. He asked one of his companions to help him. His companion related that they had dug up the grave and found what they were looking for. Then the man said, "Let us dig further and find out what has happened to my sister." He lifted up one of the stones covering the burial cavity and found the grave filled with fire. He replaced it and filled in the grave again. Then he returned to his mother and asked, "What was my sister really like?" She replied, "Why do you ask about her when she is dead?" He said, "Tell me." She said, "She used to delay the prayer and she also used to go to our neighbours' doors, put her ear to them, and then tell other people what they said." ("The Soul journey after death" an abridgement of Ibn al-Qayyim's kitabar-ruh.) One of the early Muslims said, "We passed by a watering-place on the way to Basra. We heard the braying of a donkey and asked the people there what the braying was. They replied that it was one of the men who used to be with them whose mother had asked him for something and he had told her to bray like a donkey. Since his death, this braying had been heard every night from his grave.” ("The Soul journey after death" an abridgement of Ibn al-Qayyim's kitabar-ruh.) The torment in the grave will vary according to the sins committed by the person in this world, whether he was a disbeliever or a disobedient Muslim. There are authentic narrations which describe this torment for the people who commit these sins. For example: 1 - Being struck with an iron hammer. It was narrated from Anas (may Allaah be pleased with him) that the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said:  “When a person is placed in his grave and his companions leave him, and he can no longer hear the sound of their sandals (footsteps), two angels come to him and make him sit up, and they ask him, ‘What did you say about this man Muhammad (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him)?’ He says, ‘I bear witness that he is the slave of Allaah and His Messenger.’ It is said, ‘Look at your place in Hell which Allaah has replaced for you with a place in Paradise.’” The Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said, “And he sees them both. But as for the kaafir or hypocrite, he says, ‘I do not know, I used to say what the people said.’ It is said, ‘You did not know and you did not follow those who knew.’ Then he is struck a blow with an iron hammer between his ears and he screams a scream which everything around him can hear apart from the two races (of mankind and the jinn).” (Narrated by al-Bukhaari, 1222.) 2 -7: Furnishings from Hell are prepared for him; he is clothed with fire; a door to Hell is opened for him; his grave is made narrow for him; he is struck with a great hammer which, if a mountain were to be struck with it, it would turn to dust; and he is given the tidings of torment in the Hereafter. Hence he will wish that the hour would never come. Ahmad (17803) and Abu Dawood (4753) narrated that al-Baraa’ ibn ‘Aazib said: "We went out with the Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) for the funeral of a man from among the Ansaar. We came to the grave and when (the deceased) was placed in the lahd, the Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) sat down and we sat around him, as if there were birds on our heads (i.e. quiet and still). In his hand he had a stick with which he was scratching the ground. Then he raised his head and said, “Seek refuge with Allaah from the torment of the grave,” two or three times. Then he mentioned the soul of the believer and how he is blessed in his grave. Then he said: “But when the disbelieving slave is about to depart this world and enter the Hereafter, there come down to him from heaven angels with black faces, bringing sackcloth, and they sit around him as far as the eye can see. Then the Angel of Death comes and sits by his head, and he says, ‘O evil soul, come forth to the wrath of Allaah and His anger.’ Then his soul disperses inside his body, then comes out cutting the veins and nerves, like a skewer passing through wet wool. When he seizes it, they do not leave it in his hand for an instant before they take it and put it in that sackcloth, and there comes from it a stench like the foulest stench of a dead body on the face of the earth. Then they ascend and they do not pass by any group of angels but they say, ‘Who is this evil soul?’ and they say, ‘It is so and so, the son of so and so, calling him by the worst names by which he was known in this world, until they reach the lowest heaven. They ask for it to be opened to them and it is not opened.” Then the Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) recited (interpretation of the meaning): “For them the gates of heaven will not be opened, and they will not enter Paradise until the camel goes through the eye of the needle.” [al-A’raaf, 7:40] He said: “Then Allaah says, ‘Record the book of My slave in Sijjeen in the lowest earth, and return him to the earth, for from it I created them, to it I will return them and from it I will bring them forth once again.’ So his soul is cast down.” Then the Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) recited the verse (interpretation of the meaning): “And whoever assigns partners to Allaah, it is as if he had fallen from the sky, and the birds had snatched him, or the wind had thrown him to a far off place.” [al-Hajj, 22:31] He said: “Then his soul is returned to his body, and there come to him two angels who make him sit up and they say to him, ‘Who is your Lord?’ He says, ‘Oh, oh, I don’t know.’ They say, ‘What is your religion?’ He says, ‘Oh, oh, I don’t know.’ Then a voice calls out from heaven, ‘Prepare for him a bed from Hell and clothe him from Hell, and open for him a gate to Hell.’ Then there comes to him some of its heat and hot winds, and his grave is constricted and compresses him until his ribs interlock. Then there comes to him a man with an ugly face and ugly clothes, and a foul stench, who says, ‘Receive the bad news, this is the day that you were promised.’ He says, ‘Who are you? Your face is a face which forebodes evil.’ He says, ‘I am your evil deeds.’ He says, ‘O Lord, do not let the Hour come, do not let the Hour come.’” (This hadeeth was classed as saheeh by Shaykh al-Albaani in Ahkaam al-Janaa’iz, p. 156) 8 - Being swallowed up by the earth. It was narrated from Ibn ‘Umar that the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: “Whilst a man was dragging his lower garment out of pride, the earth swallowed him up and he will continue sinking into the earth until the Day of Resurrection.” (Narrated by al-Bukhaari, 5345; Muslim, 3894) 9- The edge of the mouth being torn to the back of the head. 10- The head being smashed with a rock. 11- Being burnt in a tannoor oven 12- Swimming in a river of blood whilst being pelted with stones.

@@AlexMkd1984 so civilized wow, you can clearly tell who is the intelligent one here 🤣

Yeah, even a totally halal stuff will be bad if we do it excessively. Avoiding it isn't the key, our self-control is. Everything is halal except something Allah decides to forbid.

This is what the shaykh said in the last part of the video “quit internet completely if you fear to fall in haram” if you are strong enough to not fall in haram then you are ok to go

Me too

ameen

Aameen

Ameen

Social media was also available on msn and yahoo chat people were used to contacting each other on mails.

@epitome email is more identical to postal mail just faster. The MEDIA in the term social media sets it apart but many other things online are bad

Social Media was available in the 1990's

@@alexojideagu not as we know it today, the earliest form was MySpace. Besides, the Sheikhs points are valid regardless of social media

@Sam. You might as well say that to the blind, deaf and dumb. With due respect, at least the impaired have sign language to go by.

See pinned comment

Which is why he said “there’s good and evil” with the internet and of course this video was recorded on VHS 📼

and the irony of irony is if we don't use the internet, we wouldn't need to hear that either

Exactly what I was going to say,let's not forget this was 20 years a go i belive,now days knowing how necessary the Internet has become maybe he himself would have changed his minde.

I think he said, in the last sentence that one should not acquire the internet if they have fear that it will lead them stray .

Amin because I was noticing more sinister. Why is it when I think of something I see it come up on the internet. Invading my thoughts with technology, and am I giving these permissions by cookies ? Allahu Musta’an

That's not what he is saying. His opinion is that internet is haram COMPLETELY because, you can access to a lot of haram there, and there is rule in figh, which says that getting rid of harm is more important than increasing benefit. That is his opinion as a mujtaheed, but I believe there is no ijma among scholars about it.

@@user-pv2cx1lq7v Without the internet muslim scholars like Dr Naik will not be able to spread the word to an extent that eople watching him turn into muslims. He never said it is completely Haram.Stop putting words in his mouth sir.He even acknowledged some good in the internet. Without the internet we will not be able to communicate right now. Just watch the videos and tell me if he said there are some good in the internet? Just stop saying thing from your head. We not interested in yo opinion except what Ibn Uthaymin said ok?

@@user-pv2cx1lq7v you clearly didn’t listen to him properly and have a preconceived notion in your head. He literally said “one should avoid the internet if he feels like he will fall into haram”. You are twisting his words and intention. If the internet is haram, then that means going to a mall would be haram too. But it clearly isnt, it’s just disliked.

وإياكم

بارك الله فيكم

Wa feek

Radiation is never good

@@amjanwaters6142 the key is to intertwine the two. The internet can be used to remember Allah. Whether it by Islamic videos, Quran, Nasheed, Duaa, etc., remembrance of Allah can always be through the internet. The internet has many possibilities.

fake news spreads online too that decieves others

@@asaniwasabi the internet may be used for good as you have stated and to remember Allah Subhana wa Ta Ala. But let me kjndly teach you dear brother. Shaykh Ahamd al Najmi Rahimahuallah stated that Nasheeds are Haram to listen to and make. And that nowadays they are abundant with Sufis.

@@abasbashir852 even nasheeds with no music?

I'll make dua for you

Social media is mostly bad. Controlled by bad people and targeting teenagers. It's engineered to keep people addicted mostly kids. Tiktok, Instagram really, snap chat, others.

@@jameelali5457 thanks 😇

I convinced that the internet is a part of dajjal...

KZfaq is also Social Media

​@@alexojideagubut It does not like other social media

@Sani. Perhaps he saw the advent of those who tell the truth about Islam such as YT memri tv-australian preacher, kuwaiti cleric, syrian cleric, saudi cleric, al azhar uni. prof.

@Sabir The cat's curiosity was not backed by knowledge so it will surely perish 😊😊😊😊😊

I still believe that it's the worst thing ever created because the benefits of it does not exceed the 1% than the 99% which it contains that it is haram, so the chances of you falling into haram is actually 99% and please don't say that some people haven't because through observations this statement seems to be correct.

Just like the knife, can be used for good and evil.

Because people can relate it with themselves🙃

I think you missed the part -'as long as he fears he will fall into haram'

@@kittol6713 he did not missed the part. Sheikh said “avoid it completely because it has good and evil.” Plain and simple. Sheikh can be wrong. No problem. He must be right about a lot of different things.

@@wahabsid759 His statement wasnt wrong at all at that time and the fact it still hold a lot of truth is a proof of that. The difference is nowadays we're so dependent on internet that it's hard to quit it completely but we still should limit its usage to what we actually need.

@@yfrufeyfryd2129 akhi his statement was clear. He said “avoid it completely.” There is popular saying “don’t throw the baby out with the bath water.” This statement does that.

It is a tool the person can use for good or bad alllah is watching

These people would encourage people not to use electricity ⚡️ if they would listen.. and return to the Stone Age times.. it makes absolutely no sense living in a modern world 🌎..

@@jerusalem5646 I use to laugh when i heard about the Amish people living without electricity as they label it 'the devils system'. Now i'm starting to agree with them.

@@umeriqbal5406 so if you have a bad heart ❤️ and you need a machine to monitor it.. are you going to ignore technology.. wtf 😳🤦🏼‍♀️why would you be afraid of electricity ⚡️.. without electricity you would never be able to travel to live in the west… the plane ✈️ that your family migrated on needed to communicate with the aviation system on ground.. all this is running by electricity… the house 🏠 your family lives in is governed by electricity.. especially in winter 🥶 unless you choose to return to a third world 🌎 country in the mountains 🏔 and live in a cave 🤦🏼‍♀️like the Buddhist monks in Nepal 🇳🇵… why do you even have a phone 📱???? Electricity is good 👍🏼 it’s the evil 👿 in peoples that makes this earth 🌍 sad 😞.. shalom alykm

@@jerusalem5646 thats not the point man.

@@jerusalem5646 what are your beliefs ,creed

Sheikh Imran hosein Also tells this

@@mohamedriyas4527 I am familiar with Imran Hosein, but he goes to far and exceeds in the explanation and prediction of the matters of the end of time. That accodingly to himself, he is the only one that realy knows and understands this in the the best and in the correct way. And this is not correct and respectful to all the other repected schollars like Ibn Uthaimin and others. So that's why we can not take blindly everyting from him in what he teaches and claims. But the most people are not aware and have no knowledge of this and take out of ignorance everyting from him in what he says and claims.

@@alyunanie simply pls look the world This world moves to something strange. Max. Hadiths are muthashabihath.

@@mohamedriyas4527 I agree with the fact that we live in a time with great Fitnah in every matter and aspect in our lives at this time and place, and the end time is close. And i accept all the authentic Hadith that speaks about the end time and the things that will happen. But, to interpret and explain them in a sorten way that the Prophet Muhammad( Peace and blessings be on him) and the Sahabah(ra), and even the Tabi-ien(ra) did not do and teached. Then we have to be sceptical about everyting that wich a so called schollar brings where there is no hard proof for it in wat he claims. Some things are hidden(Ghaib) for us, and how and when it will be happen. Only Allah( the Exaled the Most High) knows it, nobody else. But the Muslim has to belief in the things that are hidden( Ghaib) for us. This is a part of our belief according to the Qur'an and the Sunnah.

I don't think he said anything about 30 minutes, but he indeed limited tech access in his house. Back then honestly it was not neccesary that much as today tho.

@@Calvin_M. you got choked up by the literal sense of what I said and comparing internet use to then and now? You totally missed the point of what was said. But if it makes you feel like you had insight I didn’t notice than by all means 👏🏽

Hé literally said it contains good and evil. The problem is that those who are in charge of controlling social media and data in general they know what they’re doing. They’re digging deep. It’s not difficult for them to conduct this industry and direct it to where they want it to be.

Well the time was different back then. Internet and all was not a necessity to live a full life, but we still can get few valuable points from his speech :)

@@Calvin_M. many valuable points not few. Don’t forget that he’s talking about having internet in households not companies and schools.

@@latusalihyasalim4872 you still need an internet in household unless you want to be isolated from the rest of the world.

@@Calvin_M. it’s not for everybody. Unless you’re an expert in a certain field or a researcher or something like that. which is not the case for the majority of people. and those who need internet from time to time to look for a specific thing they can find it in public cybercafe.

He said in the beginning that internet contains both the good and the evil things.

@@ASh-hj3it That's stating the obvious. Like the sky is blue or 1+1=2. How about tell us something we actually don't know, like how Muslims could create their own version of the internet which safer.

@@ASh-hj3it but the evil is a lot more accessible and out their compared to the good even if u intend to do good evil will find it’s way in

@@Ganstaz003 Önce bana ideolojinin ne olduğunu söyle, ancak o zaman seninle tartışmaya devam edebilirim. İslam karşıtı trolle tartışırken aptal görünmek istemiyorum. Sanırım sen Pakistanlı bir Hristiyansın, değil mi?

@@musa7176 Sen Müslüman mısın kardeşim? Bu şeyhi destekliyor musun yoksa onunla alay mı ediyorsun anlayamıyorum!

You cannot truly know about someone, you are not to judge

@@beckham231017 Allah Subhana wa Ta Ala will judge us on the day of judgement. But we judge people nowadays on what is apparent as Imam al Nawawi Rahimahuallah has stated.

you are right and he is also right

i was thinking the same but the man is right tho

@@itsVEED i agree with him. But not using internet these days, is impossible. Hes right about that there are many bad graphics on the internet but we have to control ourselves.

If you do not use the Internet, you do not need to watch this video

"..... as long as he fears he will fall into haram" Dude you obviously didn't watch the entire video

your attention span must be very low to watch a 2 minute video. what he's saying is the internet is a double-edge sword we should have self control and use it appropriately to achieve any task in according to islamic law.

yea, it reminds me of how they said chess and music and TV was haram and now they use TV for spreading their message

This was 20 years back when internet was not essential part of our daily lives.

"It depends on how you use them" that what he said tho. He said it's contains good and bad. Means conditionally could lead you to either depends on your nafs and iman. Avoid using it just his advice it's not absolute law in Islam. And lets be honest, avoding bad things in internet kinda hard even we don't have intention cuz we literally get any and even random information in milliseconds. So, his advise is still reasonable to protect you completely but unrealistic for someone who live in slightly modern or above place.

@@bakkah7733 If you closely look the subtitles, it says that he said to “Avoid it COMPLETELY” it means to avoid it at any cost and to never even go close to it.

@@ayeshanaseer3061 It doesn’t have to be essential btw. When giving fatwa while knowing there is also benefit like he says, then he shld be careful. He is lecturing normal people which could lead to misuses. May Allah guide us

See the pinned comment

Ok I will also use my knife moderately, go outside moderately and read moderately. Complete nonsense.

@@terencehank7206 What are you talking about. Everything needs to be done in moderation. You also lack the etiquette of Islamic knowledge. Even if u disagree with the Sheikh, and you think he is wrong, u should know that he is rewarded for his ijtihaad (striving to arrive at the correct view). The one that does ijtihaad and reaches the wrong conclusion, receives one reward. The one that does ijtihaad and reaches the right conclusion, receives two rewards. People of knowledge are know to respect each others views without insults like this.

This is not really about the Sheikh, it is about you and your channel. The Sheikh said don’t use the internet. You say (in a titillating and clickbaity way) ‘imagine what he would say today’ - what is that supposed to mean? You then go on to say using the internet is a necessity, but that everyone should it moderately. What is that supposed to mean? If I say it’s nonsense it’s because that’s what I believe. If you want respect to earn it and not demand it.

​@@terencehank7206 Stop twisting your own words. Look at your original comment. You were talking about the Sheikh's fatwa itself. I don't need your respect, but you need to respect the Sheikh and the rest of the scholars. My channel is only used to translate their speeches