💥 And the memory feature of the visor when flipping up and down the chin bar. Nice review

The chin curtain in the Neotec 2 is removable, just have to pop the 2 corners on the chin spoiler and it slides right out, then pop the chin spoiler back in place.

Thanks for the comparison. I've been looking at both of these helmets. New Sub

Good review of points not mentioned in other reviews. 👍

Thank you it helped me much to decide and what things to look at when at the shop :)

Nice review. Very good observations. I haven't tried the C5, but I've been using the Neotec2 for quite a while now and can confirm all your observations. One other thing I have observed is that the bottom edge of the shield on the Noetec2 is kind of thick and does interfere with the vision if I keep it one notch open - which is the typical way I ride in the summers to get sufficient venting. This is at least compared to other helmets (Nolans, AGV, Schuberth) I have owned before. The Schuberth S2 I used to own had the sun visor come completely lose while I was riding, giving me almost a heart-attack. So I've stayed clear of them for a while now, but I may give a chance to the new E2 (which is a C5 with a beak).

Great informative video. Thanks Ms Melissa.

Helpful, thanks. You pointed out many interesting things which will make me take a 2nd look at the C5 before being set on buying the Neotec II.

I have the Neotec II and have been very happy with. But I agree that the chin strap is too close to my neck.

Very helpful video vs those that get too deep in the weeds with information that won't affect your decision. I already have a Harley branded modular but may upgrade to a premium helmet in the future.

Been riding with the C5 for a year now, very nice helmet, quiet. Visor and screen tend to loosen up a bit during usage, not always bad, but sometimes i wish they would be a bit sturdier. Things tend to move inadvertently from time to time. It is a pretty quiet helmet, but I still put some nice Alpine earplugs for extra noise reduction.

I have the C5, you didn’t mention the extra vent in the chin bar is brilliant, as it gives extra air flow for fresh air when breathing and helps with defogging glasses. Looks so cool in the blue and white version on this video, that’s the one I have.

I thought I was going to do a "gotcha" on you when you mentioned the chin straps in relation to your "Adam's Apple". I Googled and sure enough gals do have an apple but it is normally much less pronounced than the guys. Excellent helmet comparison and timely for me because I am in the market for a flip up modular which will be my first after 50 years of riding. Thanks.

Stumbled upon your great video and also chose the C5. After trying both helmets on multiple visits to several retailers I came to the conclusion that my head is better suited for the shape of the C5 than the Neotec. I rode with the C5 for the first time this past weekend for a few hours and enjoyed every minute of it. They are both fine helmets.

I purchased the Schuberth C5 a few months ago and love it ! I’ve been wearing Arai helmets for decades and have no complaints but the C5 is different in so many ways. Extremely comfortable, outstanding vision field looks great and it’s like 2 helmets in one. I highly recommend 👍

nice review, I'm definitley in the market for a new modular but I'm waiting for the HJC RPHA 91 second gen to make it stateside before I decide, that helmet looks like a game changer

I have the Shoei Neotec 2. I was also torn between these two helmets. The Shoei is in stores whithin 70 miles from me. The Schuberth, forget about it! Can't find it anywhere! I was told that the Schuberth is not like other helmet fits. The Shoei fit great so I got it. Sweet helmet but I wish the manufacturers would not fixate on one brand of coms. I hear from a lot of riders that the Cardo is a better system. Thanks for posting this Melissa!

Thanks for the review of these two helmets. I own both. In relation to some of your comments my findings personally are : - the chinstrap angle is different but in my case - as is the case for some of the people that ride with it - this does not chafe or irritate the neck or throat area; - fair point on cracking open the visor, and the Schoei is a little tougher, but my Schuberth would open violently at times when doing a shoulder check; - the slider to open/close the sun visor is a little harder to find on the Schoei in the beginning but on the Schuberth it broke fairly quickly and couldn't be fixed; - the pins holding the padding around the base on the Schuberth also broke; - I find the Schoei is quieter; - I dislike Sena ... a lot and am still looking for a better and more affordable system. Keep up the good work and stay safe out there.

I have a Neotec from 2017 that still has the D-rings. Tried the Schubert E2 which is essentially a C5 and had the same issue with the chin strap and my throat. With the Neotech 3 coming out soon in the US, retailers are slashing the prices on the 2s (about 200 bucks). I’m tempted to get another 2, but I’m concerned about the chin/throat issue. My current 2 has been great. Maybe I’ll just get some new pads and hold on for another season or two. Thanks for the review.

Great review. The ratchet strap and strap placement on the Neotec 2 made it unusable due to the pressure on my throat and adam's apple. I very much appreciate your insight.

One thing you didn't mention is that both helmets have exchangeable inner linings of different thicknesses to help get a perfect fit. The Schuberth ones come at an additional cost but here in the UK there is at least one retailer (Motolegends in Guildford) that doesn't charge for these when fitting them to a new helmet. Also the Schuberth is tested to the newer and more rigorous ECE 22.06 standard while the Shoei is 22.05 - but the standards are different in the USA. It was that, and the fact that the Schuberth is available with a peak as the E2, that swung the decision for me; the difference having that shade makes when riding into a low sun is incredible. Might look weird on a sportsbike or a retro, though!

I had been a loyal fan of Scorpion Helmets for quite a while with my last one being an R320. Earlier this year I decided to treat myself and went and bought a Shoei Neotec2. The guy at the store I went to was not a big fan of the Schuberth and I had not heard a lot about them so I went with what I know. I agree with you on the chin strap padding, sometimes it feels as if it's to far down on my throat. Other than that, I love my Shoei. It's exceptionally comfortable, lightweight and has decent airflow. I don't, however, like how far back I have to mount my Cardo, but that is a problem on most helmets today. Thanks for the great information, I might just get a second modular, and go with a Schuberth.

Shoei had great color, that helped me to decide

Amazing review ..!

Thanks for a very informative video! I'm in the market for a new modular helmet, and I know the Shoei fits me well. Time to try on a Schuberth, I think. Plus, thanks for letting me know about the lack of phone calling support on the Sena 2 comm in the Shoei. That's important to me.

A little tip for closing the modular w/boom mic, just put the mic between your lips, close the helmet then push the mic out with your tongue or reach in with your finger. I like to push out with my tongue then the mic is lined up for sure voice pick up. Just a thought.

- Huh Joey, women don't have Adam's apples - ... - ... - You guys are messing with me, right? - ... YEAH, YEAH, of course.

Very useful real world review thanks for posting 😎

I actually agree with you! I tried a few helmets but, all in all the Schuberth is simply the best one! Enjoy the ride!

I have had the C5 for a few months. The visor was finicky to close tightly(one side would latch only) The fix is a little bit of silicone spray on a q tip and lubricate two little ramps near hinge area that are the latch close on visor. Same silicone application on sun visor slide makes both as smooth as you would expect. Helmet is quiet One con for me is the detention that holds visor open could be stronger as wind will knock it closed. (Not chin bar). After 5000miles I am still happy with purchase

I am about to buy a new helmet, have the C3 now and this one needs replacement.. gonna try the Shoei Neotec 3 Grasp TC-10 (really like the color since i drive a GS adv)but i think i will end with the C5 the same color(orange white @ 8:10) you have.. i think Shoei improved some things on the neotec 3 but i will have to find out.. keep you updated ad thanks for the nice and clear vid Gr from Holland

Great review.

Flip-up-helmets are called “sausage-eater-helmet” (“Korvätarhjälm”) here in Sweden :-) Will get a C5 next time….

Shoei the wind coming in on the front bottom right side of the visor is insane.

Shoei has a removable chin curtain, and a summer or winter curtain if you choose...

Very nice review here.

Good Choice for You - I will go for the Shoei this time

The chin curtain on the Shoei is removable and they have a cool and a cold version. In all honesty… fit is more important than most features.

Of course the manufacturers want you to "replace" your helmet every 5 years... lol Shoei makes a VERY high quality and supremely comfortable Helmet and at $700.00 for my Neotec II I think I will be hanging on to mine for probably 10 years if of course I don't drop it on to a hard surface like concrete or asphalt! I will probably also wash and or replace the inner pads at some point too.

Actually there is a Scorpion that comes with built in comm. I think it was the 930. Also modular helmet. I went to a store and tried it, but it's not for my head shape, unfortunately, even though I currently run a different Scorpion, that fits me.

C5 is the better one for sure. Heck, just the visor memory alone is sooooooo good.

I’m not a fan of the built-in com system because I can’t make built in speakers work for me. Sometimes I have found that the speaker pockets are not directly over my ears. I have found that I like a universal com (Packtalk) with earbuds or in-ear monitors because the in-ear monitors act as earplugs and I can keep the volume down and still hear. I can also move it to another helmet is necessary.

I dream to get moto like u have

I have the C5.. Like it with the exception that I think for the price the Visor is Weak... closes on its own at about 75mph.

the pre prepped C5 which is easier to plug and play for the SENA system is also a lot cheaper then the coms system for neotec helmet which you have to dismantle to connect everything.

I know it preference, but im not sure why some people prefer integrated comms. They are usually subpar and more expensive, and you cant move them among different helmets. I have a touring helmet, ADV, and a retro helmet.

As a female rider it's so great to see a woman doing these, thank you! Great comparison on the helmets, I have a Neotec 2 and I'll be looking to replace it soon. Can you please say what the noise is like with the C5?

I have the neotec. It is loud to me. C5 looks nice.

The C5 is also quieter (IMO considerably) than the Shoei. At speeds above about 50 mph the Shoei is *_loud_*

I just bought C5 pretty close call between these two but schubert wan because it is a bit less noisy...

Very good comparison video. I was close to pulling the trigger on a C5 but what changed my mind was the many reviews that others said about the visor falling down on its own while riding. Have you experienced this? Thanks

Thank you for your comparison review! Did you eventually install the com unit for your C5? If so, how do you like it? Any tips to keep the boom mic connected and positioned well?

thanks for the review i to am after a c5 or the neotec 2 cant make my mind up...the c5 has the latest test cert the neotec is still on the last test (25) c5 (26) the neotec will probably be updated shortly. can you tell me which of these two helmets gives you the best (largest ) view through the visor thanks

I Cardo system will I be able to install on the Schuberth ...?

i've had a cheaper helmet for a while. now that I know what I want I am willing to spend some dough for a long lasting helmet. hopefully the schuberth c5 will fit my big noggin. thanks for the look.

The Shoei is in a different league to the Schuberth on many levels. To begin with the Shoei wont come open if you chin the ground, the Schuberth's opening mech is extremely vulnerable. The opening mech should work by pulling down, as on the Shoei. It should not be possible to open the chin bar with a mere stab of the finger. The P/J switch on the C5 is tiny, stiff, and very sharp, a glove ripper in fact. With the Shoei, no messing around, you just push the chin bar up one notch. The strap fastener on the Shoei is tucked away where it can not be caught by a twig as you slide through a hedge, the C5's hangs lower and is again vulnerable. As if that is not enough they then fit a lasso to the mech release to improve its chances of catching something. Overall the Schuberth, fit notwithstanding, is a poor second.

I’m currently looking for a new helmet since my Shoei Neotec now hurts the top of my head and really puts pressure on my ears. I’ve tried the Neotec ll and same concern with where the ratchet straps pushes against my neck. Just curious what size you wear in your Schuberth C5 and no bobble head feeling with only two shell sizes?

Loved the content, but I do have some feedback I'd love to give you. 1) You've got a great vibe, and a great diction / voice. 2) Your thoughts are really well organized, and the dialog feels very genuine. 3) You could use more B roll, more stock video (Story blocks might be an investment if you're looking to make this a long time project). 4) Visually although you're lovely, the camera becomes a bit boring fast trying new angles, different shots, and B roll might help retention. I really think you've got what's needed to start a successful motorcycle channel on KZfaq, I'll subscribe because this was really great.

Please do your review after riding with the helmet on , you will be surprised that the C5 is a terrible one, the visior closes just when you reach 40 km/hr and sound level higher than it's competitor

How about the price difference?

Great review. Have you worked out how we know you haven’t used the coms yet? 07:45 😉

6:47 how's the fit for people who wear glasses?

😍

I own a Neotec 2 for 3 years now. Worn a lot of other brands but nothing compares. The Chin curtain should not catch your chin. Maybe you have a shape of head or lower jaw which is not suited for the Neotec 2. There are multiple chin curtains for sale for if you would like more breathability. Also the chinstrap is very comfortable for most people. I know a lot of people who own a Neotec 2 and none of them have a problem with the chinstrap position. Most of the other complaints you have about the Neotec are just related to the fact you arent used to the helmet. When wearing it for a while you get used to the positioning of sunvisor etc. When wearing it for longer then 5 days you know how to open and shut it without catching the microphone with the chinguard. Also the helmet does click when it closes its just caused by your speed at which you close it. If you close something so slow ofcourse it doesnt click as hard. The minimal latch on the Neotec actually works really well. Just unlatch the visor from the locked position and ventilation improves in such a way that there is no need for ‘cracking the visor open’ as all these desktop testers complain about. Actually when you have placed the noseguard (which you haven’t) and you open the front vent it blows the visor clear all the time. Also when you shut the helmet and the visor stays up like the C5 it means you now have to close it twice to close it in case of entering a cloud of dust or rain up ahead. Please have fun with the schuberth but just don’t act like you tested stuff or advise people to buy one or the other while you havent even unboxed it or rode around in it for a while.

I have a C5. A couple of things : 1. I thought the visor position retention when opening and closing the flip front was a gimmick, but it is actually very nice. I prefer it that way. 2. The visor has a tiny gap in the very last step before completely closed, this is a very nice feature. A big plus for me in colder and even not so cold weather 3. The flip mechanism works very well, open and close. but .... 1. Like with my BMW system 7 (which is also a schuberth below the skin) the helmet shakes a little side to side if the visor is cracked open slightly, from about 70kph and up. Very annoying. The shaking stops the moment you completely shut the visor. My old helmet does not do this. (A plus though - with the system 7 the shaking increased with speed and became intolerable by about 100kph. The C5 does not - shaking remains about the same all the way up to 120kph, so that's a big improvement. I am slowly getting used to it, pity I have to though) 2. The pinlock insert is not as effective as my last helmet - it fogs up a bit on out breaths at slow speed if the visor is closed. I think this is partly because the helmet seals very well, so a plus and a minus. 3. Closing the visor is not always easy. Sometimes it closes ok, sometimes I have to support the bottom of the helmet with my shoulder and press really hard for the visor to fully close. Slightly annoying but not a big deal I guess. (I have seen several complaints about closing the C5 visor) Overall I am happy with the C5. Would I buy it again? tough call. I think so. In the end more plusses than minuses.

Good review, thank you. Just as an FYI, women to not have an adams apple.

I wish they would come without the com system, I ride by myself and don't want to spend the money and want the weight. Get rid of the horrible gutar noise.

Neotec2 any day.....

In my opinion the Schubert is a much better looking helmet from outside appearance than the Shoei. Both of these helmets unfortunately are greatly overpriced for what they are made of. It’s sad these two helmets are considered top quality. I expect much better with my money for these helmets than what you receive.

I have same helmet too a Scorpion exo t1200 touring But stop making it because of noise!

Don't leave your gloves in your helmet. If there's moisture on them, you'll start growing stuff in your helmet that you won't like, and has a distinctive odor.

You can fix easy the sun visitor ….

Good pick on the helmet, ride safe. Ps.: Ladies not supposed to have Adam's apple:)