If those cameras weren’t there, he would have been charged and put in jail.

Dudes literally the most prepared person to ever walk on this show.

Anyone that file a false report should have to face the exact same punishment that the accused would receive

LOVE IT! Having spent the past 19 minutes with the plaintiff, I now understand why they broke up. She is a miserable, entitled liar, and I hope the defendant understands that he needs to be wary of dealing with her at ALL times, because if she lied once, she’ll lie again.

He needs to wear a GoPro everytime he has any interaction with her.

His defense attorney is probably the world’s nicest and sweetest lawyer. You can tell she cares about her clients.

I love it when liars get what they deserve. He clearly didn’t do what she claimed he did. She made it sound like he got her in a bear hug and slammed her down…at worst he nudged her out of the way. Glad she got nothing.

I can't believe this woman... the contrast between her leeching off of his kindness to let her store her stuff with him for FREE, THEN calling the police on him because he kinda tossed her... that was instant KARMA.

I bet she regrets filing that lawsuit - lol

She seems like such a bitter and miserable woman. Hope the guy moves on and has a peaceful life.

As a divorce attorney, I despise women like this, whether they're on the other side or my clients. The outcome of this case is beautiful!

He's not the idiot, she is. He was helping his baby's mother. She not only took advantage of that, but she tried to get him falsely prosecuted for violence. SHE should go to jail for that.

Why ask him to store your stuff after he “assaulted” you? Make it make sense 😕

He needs to make sure he records EVERY SINGLE INTERACTION with this woman: texts and /or video. She is so entitled and obviously has no moral problem lying to get her way.

I was in law enforcement for 12 years, and I’d have never done that to anyone because I knew the consequences. Thankfully, her ex-boyfriend was able to get that video to defend himself. I’m just shocked that the DA didn’t prosecute her for a false testimony.

This is absolutely one of my favorite cases! I'm glad she told the plaintiff how damaging her actions were and made her pay for his labor🎉

Did yall see the size of stack of paper on the defendant 's hands? Dude was prepared. Also, at some point the judge calls him stupid for storing his ex stuff after this incident, to which he replies: "we have a son together". Honestly, that was humbling, and this dude deserves to be recognized for that, instead of simply being called stupid. My dude, if you're seeing this: you have love in your heart, don't hide it, don't change, you'll be remembered for that, and more importantly, it will help your loved ones grow.

Dude wasn't playing brought his lawyer very smart.

the fact that he has a past to use the police to ruin a dude’s life. She’s a nightmare. Dude! Build nice houses and live your life. Keep seeing your son and move on!!!

At 10:18 the judge know exactly what she was doing. She asked "how many hands did he push you with?" the response "one hand, to move me out of the way" But in your initial complaint you said "two hands on the ribs". Well played. So glad this guy won his counterclaim!

Anyone else think the plaintiff has been practicing her "sad victim" look for years?

Dear Little Lawyer Momma we arent judging you. 🙃 We have been there

One of the best cases I’ve seen. That girl is a lying vicious ex who changed her story because she got caught red handed after realizing there was a video of what actually happened. She put that man through hell and back!!

So happy with this judgment! Thankfully they had the cameras to prove she lied!

Wow his lawyer let him renovate her kitchen to so he could pay add the 5k. She’s an angel

This guy seems like a very nice guy. I'm so glad he got a bit of justice. Hope he stays away from jail.

This case is amazing. So happy the defendant won his countersuit! He probably wouldn’t have even countersued her had she not had the audacity to sue him after he took care of her shit for 6 months.

Her: "the baby". Him: "My son". That's fairly telling. She seems a very cold and bitter woman.

I can tell he’s a good guy. Made some past mistakes but wouldn’t intentionally hurt someone. Shame on her for making his life harder then it needs to be

The way his lawyer nodded when the judge called him an idiot 🤣🤣 Poor guy, at least he won

She should be charged with at least a misdemeanor for false police report. It needs to be on her record

She lied. She risked him going back to jail. She is a very, very bad woman. Very bad. That poor kid.

She looks vindictive. It's all in her face.

The plaintiff should be ashamed of herself!! What an evil, manipulative and horrible person. Thank God the father (defendant) was street smart enough to get an attorney involved with his case. Maybe there's still hope for their child...I feel sorry for that kid having that selfish piece of crap as a mother.

Shocking how mean-spirited she is.

What type of person would lie to get the father of your child arrested after he’s been doing you a favor this whole time? Lucky there was video evidence or else he’ll be in jail. Wish they would prosecute her for making a false report.

Imagine going to court to sue and end up having to pay what you sued for 😫😫😫

Sweet effing justice! She is the epitome of everything I detest about scheming “baby mommas”. I hope for the baby’s sake that she grows TF up.

She will be pure evil now that she has been held accountable

Wow she’s extremely entitled & bitter. So glad things worked in his favor, seems like a good guy

Imagine how many fathers who are going through this! Bitter Betty!

I found this to be my top favorite case and it is really satisfying to witness someone who is so prepared and brings a lawyer, as well as the entire interaction between JM and his attorney. I'm delighted that he exposed the lies of his ex-girlfriend.

If I were him I would absolutely use this against her to get custody of the child

First time I've ever seen a litigant bring councel with them.

With no evidence that he touched her she should feel ashamed of herself because there was somebody somewhere across town being abused and could have used the police at that very moment to help them but instead they were there dealing with this woman's pettiness! 😤😡 I am very happy her behind lost the case has to pay him $5K! Yes sir get your coins! 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾

The plantiff is the reason why I don't automatically rush to defend women when they're abused. As a woman myself, I am ashamed she filed that police report. This makes it harder for women who've actually been abused to file!

The biggest mistake this guy made was having a baby with her. That's at least 18 years of this manipulative, evil and vindictive behavior towards him. With the baby caught in the middle of it all, of course. Shame on her!

Lololololol I thought that was the defendant’s new girlfriend, too 😂😂😂

The plaintiff made that blanket story up

The defendant may have made some mistakes in his life, but he does seem like an upstanding person who's gotten his life on track, has good employment, and does honest hard work. The plaintiff on the other hand is digging for gold when she doesn't own the mine anymore.

Wow! Justice was served and I hope the defendant does better!! He deserves it 🙏🏽🙏🏽 shame on the bitter plaintiff!

"He said six months, but if its longer its fine" what a liar the plaintiff is. Along with getting him arrested this really shows the entitlement she thinks she's owed

Bitter, bitter woman and the child will suffer for it the most.

This is one of the most satisfying judgements I've seen on this show, It's great that the Judge listens to both sides and that he had that video because w/out it he would've been charged & it would effect all future run-ins. She should've been chargered & held responsible for false report in the 1st. place! She took him to Court thinking she would stick it to him & get paid🤣🤣Happy the spiteful liar had to pay him and she not only got ZERO but she is seen by millions!

Imagine hating your ex more than you love your son. This woman is pure evil.

Yep the plaintiff is going to be a nightmare in his life.

He deserves to have full custody of his child. She should only have supervised visitation rights.

I love how all the Judges on these court shows act like the court system works right away...it's weeks, not a day or 2

Wow!!!! She is an awful person and apparently such a narcissist that she still doesn’t care or even get it!! I’d would record EVERY single interaction with her because she’s a liar! Also awesome to see an honest attorney with a kind heart!

Such a satisfying verdict! But let this man beware. For until their son is grown and independent of them both, this woman will never cease to furnish the defendant with aggressions big and small.

He should video EVERY time he's around his EX 🙏

Plaintiff is a liar, how pathetic And she should be charged with making a false report

I am so relieved the judge handed her her hat! That woman was an evil nasty B- word, and is probably a crappy mother with her anger!! I felt so sorry for the defendant, getting more and more upset for him and seeing that B word clearly lied. Nothing wrong than lying to get someone false imprisoned. I hope he spends some of that $5,000 on himself he needs a rest. Also, she better pay him, now he has a judgment against her, he should not let her out of her obligation, levy her paycheck if necessary! I love when the Judge sees things and gets upset just as I would!! Thank you Judge Millian, you give me hope!

She is going to be a thorn in his side for a long time. I hope a court sets up some rules for their child custody and she can't just keep claiming abuse.

I actually felt like standing and applauding. He got justice. Happy for him.

There are sooo many vindictive bitter woman out there ruining their child's fathers lives it's disgusting. Thank God this man had a video he would be in jail for months and a record! Do people understand how being so spiteful can literally ruin someone's entire life! God bless him I hope he can remain calm and keep record of every bs this woman tries to pull!

Love this case - mothers/exes who try to make the father out to be the bad guy when he is not irritate the hell out of me.

When you cry wolf, you make it harder for actual victims. It’s a shame this all even happened.

I hope Shane is doing well in life. Sure, he made a mistake before and went to jail before, but he seems like a stellar guy now

Her comments after she lost was another sign of dillusional entitlement. Shame shame shame on her. I pray a court gives him full custody of his son. She needs mental health care.

I wish and hope I never meet a woman like the plaintiff. Thank god the defendant had those cameras too. If not, he would’ve gone straight to jail.

She knew calling the cops on him was going to make trouble for him. She knew. And he knows that she's a handful so he does stuff like keeping her shit in storage to try and keep the peace. I think he should file for full custody of his kid and let her have visitation cause at this point it's obvious she's using the kid as some sort of "keep him around".

He’s in for more of a ride than he bargained for. I know feelings and bitterness is raging between the both of them but they really should keep calm heads for the sake of their son. This is embarrassing for her but justice prevailed.

The judge calling him an "idiot" was so uncalled for. They have a child together and he was trying to be nice. His nasty ex girlfriend is an entitle witch who falsely accused him of assault. She should have been arrest for filing a false police report. These toxic lying women who make up lies to retaliate against their ex's need to be legally punished. If there wasn't a video of showing what really happened he would have likely been sent to jail.

So glad how this one turned out. Getting tired of women who use the law to hurt others. It causes the women who really are hurt not to be believed.

In most states after 6 months it’s considered abandoned property and it can be discarded.

She was holding back tears at the end. She thought she had a winning case but he was well more prepared then she was. She took him for a ride and then tried to say he was violent to win custody....and I hate women who do that!

I'm at home clapping my hands after this verdict!

I am so disgusted by people who LIE to cause intentional harm to another human. These are the moments when you have to be so thankful for security cameras. Imagine if it wasn't around her LIES would have cost this man his freedom. Based on the video we can clearly see that he went around her and she moved of her volition. And if you notice at 13:22 -13:24 she shuts the door and says something to him but he just walks off. She tried to screw with the law but the law wasn't having it and she ended up screwing herself💯

Well-done!!👏🏽👏🏽 I sense a lot of entitlement and ungratefulness; in my opinion, the right person won the case.

OMG! I feel sorry for the man and the child! That women demented!

The plaintiff was a fool for filing this case. The defendant made a smart move by bringing his attorney. Thank God for the cameras. Unfortunately most men in this case would have had to plead guilty and take a plea deal bc they didn't have evidence like this to prove innocence. Not sure if its common for lawyers to let clients work off their bill however this lawyer was an absolute blessing to him! So happy with the verdict.

I love how he wanted to avoid mentioning his drug charge.

Good judgement!!!!! She should have been thrown in jail for lying!!!!!!!

The video saved him! 🙌🏽 his ex is wicked & evil. False imprisonment is awful

She’s definitely trying make his life living hell for no reason when he seems like a good dude cuz my bd would Neva 😩🤣

I LOVE that she lost, and has to pay him $5,000. She is so CLEARLY entitled.

Her: He did this. Him: YOU'VE ACTIVATED MY TRAP CARD!! This dude was so prepared. I love it.

This is why real victims find it hard to be believed. He needs to have every interaction with her on camera, never be alone with her.

He should never have any interaction with her without another person or video camera being present.

Omg Jessica Allmer literally tried to put him in prison for no reason. She should be ashamed ! She is absolutely gross ! I'm so happy he won ! Good for him !

He does the right things; helps her and she literally tries to destroy his life (life of her son’s father).

He's a good guy. This lady is manipulative and vindictive and the ruling was spot on. Bet she regrets bringing him to court :]

Totally agree with the judge.

He was spot on. That’s a gentleman. After she gets him locked up, he still offers to help with her stuff because they have a child…. That’s a great guy.

So cool to see a lawyer in the court room with Judge millian

She is a piece of work. I’m so happy the judge ruled in favor of him!! Hope that lie was worth 5k, princess!

I cannot stand women like this!!! I am so glad justice was served and hope she learns her lesson. A man being a friend and wanting to see his son is priceless in today's world. She needs to grow tf up!! Lady, your son can see this one day!!! Co-parent & do right by your son!!!

what a bitter woman, so glad this man got justice!

Imagine there was no video and he got the 4 years. She should face charges for the false accusation.