It is a great day for Indian democracy but it’s a dark day for West Bengal, Lal Salam from West Bengal.

BJP is still winning because of it's effective social delivery, it has created a network of schemes to reach out to the poorest though most of the schemes were made by congress but delivery was a big issue famously Rajiv Gandhi said if I sent 1 rupee for the poor they only get 20 paise which has nearly reached 80 to 90 paise in BJP government.

Dhruv was not compaigning for AAP. What I felt from his election compaigns is, first he stood for Indian democracy,. 2nd he advocates Hindu Muslim unity and third he mostly tilted towards Rahul Gandhi. And yes, at one time, when Kejriwal came under corruption charges and was arrested, Dhruv did mention him. Overall, Dhruv was anti-BJP and pro democracy and that worked.

In short, democracy is improving in India.

Congress party was never Socialist but Dictatorship of Gandhi's and this time again another Gandhi was going to be prime minister and that's a NO ... anybody but Gandhi's 😡

Love the democracy of India ❤❤❤......from.Pakistan..

Sir ji you briefly mentioned Anti secular forces of Pakistan. Got your point but plz tell ki Pakistan me secular forces kaun si hain?

This is not Modi winning again and again but Bharat being defeated again and again.... It's a lesson 😎

Indian elections have remained largely free and fair.Their EC showed its strength and timely published result of 640 million people. Our EC,despite tackling 60 million votes,delayed and manipulated results to achieve particular outcomes.This establishment has effectively laid our democracy to death.it's shame to vote in Pakistan

just so you know Taimoor dhruv rathee has nothing to do with AAP ffs

Dr.Taimur, in West Bengal almost all the cadre of CPI(M) shifted to TMC after 2005. So, TMC also has CPM but under TMC leader Mamta. Names changed. Essence & culture same!

But this isn't just the Global South that's going through such radical political phases, we're seeing the "Radicals" get popular all around the world. And it's credit for the most part (IMHO) goes to the social media where whoever can entertain the best gets popular, and who ever is popular gets the rule. So, do you think we could reverse this and get out of the psyche of 'Amusing ourselves to death'? Especially with the rise of AI, Virtual and Augmented reality.

Zero knowledge about.... Indian politics.... This is Pakistan libral problem.... They have no idea about policy of economic and security... This show their intellectual level of Pakistan about world politics

Anna Movement against corruption in 2013/ 14 gave two strands of leaders : 1. Fascist BJP under Modi and 2. Aurocratic AAP under Kejriwal (typical of Asiatic Mode of Production).

Sir, The Hindu says NDA won 286 seats, full and final, they have simple majority now.

Druv rathee He just a youtuber of German citizenship 😂

Electoral Bond Scheme ECB alone provided Rs.8500 crore fund in 2023 by donation from corporate houses to the BJP. ECB was thrown away by Supreme Court of India as UNCONSTITUTIONAL this year.

Left just got 8 seats

The best take on the elections so far, brilliant.

Comrade kindly make a video about 'what is a current ruling class' in india or modern world💯

Thank you sir, for a useful summary! A layman like me sometimes wonders what the next 10-20 years would look like ?

Thank you Dr Very detailed analysis

Who is Dhruv Rathee? Never heard of him

Ap jaysa koi vlog nai kar sakta❤

Taimur sir not nitpicking just fyi dmk me k ko kallagam pronounce karte hai , zh is pronounced as L

Sir Dhruv rathe nai AAP ko support nahe kiya tha ya kesi bhi party o support nahe kia apnay campaign mai. Thora research ki zarurat hai apko

National bourgeois project will eventually fail in sll these countries of our region for 2 reasons:- 1. Public awareness for broad equality and 2. State action like Chinese govt eventually implementing Mao's policy of taming capital and maiming money. Deng created money in 1980s and Xi Ping is now taming it when it outgrows. See e.g. corporate Chiang Ma or whatever. RSS Modi and other leaders surreptitious follow communist Xi Ping as his fans. Even Putin is their hero. For other political obvious reasons if not communism which Samir Amin said China's policy of riding in two boats simultaneously.

so dhruv rathee so much famous in Pakistan. Lol

Sir plzzzzzz make a video on E H Carr.. What is history.. It will be ur kindness.. I am a history student ,ur videos are so beneficial .. Watching u from kashmir

For Pakistan,there is no greater challenge than to have transparent elections and let all classes present their true aspirations.Only a free,genuine expression will allow us to take the next logical step towards advancement of our political goals directed towards welfare of all .

سر آپ کیا بول رہے ہیں سمجھ نہیں آ رہی 7:56 ، تھوڑا سادہ زبان استعمال کریں بسک کنسیپٹ بھی ساتھ ساتھ کلیئر ہونے چائیے 😊

Dr.Taimur you're partly right. Not fully. Celebratoon of capitalism is very limited. Only Ambani and Adani show off wealth like street smart urchins. They know inside how e.g. Mughals became paupers after 1857. Wipro donates 75% and Tata still donates 60% of uts wealth each year. Still as S.V. keeps accumulating but it's different issue. Ugly Corporate Opulence is limited in India. Our rich history (courtesy Muzammil reminding us all) from IVC in Pakustan keeps us tied to our roots :- humanism.

Thank Rahman Your analysis is straight forward hence worth watching, however you are not in India.

Great Analysis and Masha Allah nice hair style

Very nuanced analysis, thank you Professor, ❤ from India .👍

Love you sir 👏👏

Sir may you forgot the indian lpg reforms in 1991 which was introduce by congress

A good monarch keeps his options and choices open in every political set up. This is how monarchy everywhere including the British Monarchy plays the game of power

Modi also tried to keep good relations with Pakistan 🇵🇰, because he invited Pak PM for Oath ceremony, visited Navaj Sharif home at Lahore, things changed after Pathankot. 🙏

Brilliant Sir for this interesting perspective of IND election.

Will you consider that india has transformed itself into a developed capitalist state from an agrarian society? Or still an agrarian country?

Yes whole have majority NDA but not BJP. BJP have 240 seats only far from their claim of 350 to 400. JDU and RJD have 32 seats and they are not so loyal to bjp so both parties together are king makers. Even if they chose BJP its different government now BJP cant dictate every thing they used to do now Modi relies on allies. These allies are gonna ask something before forming the government.

Can i ask you one thing ? Do u believe in proletariat violent revolution to get in power??...

Thankyou sir ❤

Excellent Analysis

Paisa kamane me ma problem hai ? Mujhe bhi bahut paisa chahiye. Free Market Capitalism is the best.

Nice information 😊

Politics is very similar to a game of chess. Positions are on the board but real players are minds who move positions.

An impartial monologue by Dr Taimur Rahman ( who is Taimur_Laal??') NDA wins 291 , INDIA win 234 the rest are for the OTHERS . total 543. so NDA will form the next Govt. The Pakistani presstitutes are liable to write anything, celebration what for? Clowns at best. The most important take away from the Indian GE 2024 is that that country has gone way ahead , while PK still wallows in her own charlatanism. BJP you are right won 242 seats well short of simple majority ( 272) , while INC won a mere 99. The Indian voters are astute and definitely very unemotional and iconoclastic. Free trade and the new page of a shining with sheen India is very visible! National bourgeois class has been buried for good!! This country is no patch on India. Indian GE spanned over 40 days + and the population there is 1.5 billion; here the population is 20% theirs and yet the fracas let loose on Feb 8 has NOT subsided yet. Partition was a mea culpa!!

modi got trolled

9:11 -- From manufacturing capitalism it's the rebeginning of merchant capitalism under Modi. Backwards regression.

Bhai, pronunciation "bhaaratiya" hai not "bhratiya" nahin. Country ka naam hai "bhaarat"

lol Sara jehar ugal diya😂👏👏.

Pls make some more vlog society shift on " get rich quicke"

❤❤❤❤❤

❤

First One sir ❤

Whole Pakstani state is "anti secular". Whats this BS abt "anti secular forces in Pakstan". How many "secular forces" of pakstan want to turn Izlamic republic to secular reoublic ?

Dhruv rathi ko meine like karta hu magar aap ko nehi keu ke mein anti communist hu

if Pakistani elections were conducted fairly, PM would be Imran Khan

The British monarchy imposed war after war on the people of Pakistan using the Pakistan army and its establishment.

Big victory for NDA alliance ! 9th june oath taking ceremony.🎉🎉🎉😊

Hair style 😍

میری بھی رائے ہے کہ دھروو راٹھی کو بھی کچھ کریڈٹ دینا چاہئے. مگر مودی کی مقبولیت میں کمی یقیناً عوام کے مسائل کی وجہ سے ہوئی ہے. خالی نعروں سے عوام کب تک بے وقوف بنیں.

No dharna. No halka kolo. Dhandly

You are also wrong...... there are 100 India's within one India.....BJP lost because they were looking at India from their typical North Indian cow belt Hindu lens....... You are also looking at it from similar lens.... It is difficult to analyse societies which are diverse to the core..... only ways you have to come to the ground...

No you are wrong, the thing is in 2019 election modi get 36% vote and in 2024 modi get 36% vote exactly same number But last time the other party cut each other vote and bjp get benifit from that competition but this time opposition is United, so their vote is not cut and bjp didn't get benifit of that.

❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

Bhai thoda pakistani minority ki bhi baat krlo .

Bhai dhruv Rathee aam aadmi party ka nahi hai 😭😭😭😭😭

V good . So every one is up gorgeous sale so Ambani fanfare was part of it as earlier pointed out.

Pakistani fikar na kre india ek hindu rastra bnega at any cost Dusra jo muslim abdul kalam jesa ni bn skta h usse milna to chodo hath milana bhi mujhe pasand ni h

And we all hate capitalism..ye kisne kah diya aapse... kerosene ki line lagane walon ko time lagega..and major problem was sufficient flow of employment (which is just one of the issues... significant but not everything)

Dhruv Rathee ka fayda india alliance ko Bahu hua hai

Modi was making India like a Russian oligarchy not open capital market. Middle class was squeezed by his policies. An rich middle class is true backbone of a country. Not few rich capitalists. Get your economic point of view right.

Islamic republic of Pakistan .....ka communist 🤣🤣🤣

Its hilarious when you say dhruv rathee had impact on Indian election. My dear friend most of his viewers resides in urban India and most of the urban indians voted for BJP. Its rural India where BJP could not repete its performance. If dhruv rathee had any impact, Urban India wouldn't had voted BJP. So I pity you and your analysis. But its okay what can be expected from a Pakistani who have never in his lifetime seen a true election.

Perhaps you are not aware that the Congress party is the most cunning and true representative of the Indian bourgeoisie. It was created by a British man called A. O. Hume

Corporate to achcha hai na???

Druv❤

Strong opposition necessary for any country and so is bjp for development of country. INDIA forming government will be disastrous for india

*secularism is rising in India*

I think you are overstating the change that happened with Modi in 2014. Ever since the liberalization in 1991, we have moved towards a free economy with full force. Many critics of Modi in India argue that he has slowed down the pace with his bad economic policy.

Why is this person not understanding that the corporate sector/industry players are getting money because there is demand for their services which was simply not their during the stupid inspector raj era, and there is a demand solely because they can spend to avail those services, so their is a need from the market/from the people to drive the very growth of rhe industry. That's what is needed which was not their during the so called 'nation building era' which you kept on mentioning,which was not even able to give them proper basic roads, tap water let alone economic growth which they deserved. I think those who called you an economist should slap themselves atleast once.

Any Indian? Are you satisfied with these results? Any rigging in indian elections? And what about the AAP defeat, I mean this defeat is good or bad for the indian public. Answer me honestly 🙏

Agar aapne👆 kuch aapke "Establishment" etc etc ke bande LOAN pe Rahul G ko diye, to "INDIA" mai "democracy" AUR MAZBOOT ho jayega - HAMESA ke liye - under yur dost/bhai Rahul G... (aur "Dabbu" Fawad as Ambassador/Viceroy for Life) 😁

"Sabka sath sabka vikas" ka nara Modi jee ko le duba..... Ek bhi muslim vote Modi jee ko nahi mila.... Example:: UP village "Rampur". In a polling booth of a village in Rampur Uttar Pradesh where 100% voters are muslim, total 2322 votes were casted. 532 house were given under PM Awas Yojana in this village. BJP got ZERO vote from this polling booth. This election must open eyes of BJP that no matter how much good u do for Muslims,still they won't vote for u bcos they hate hindus and they see Modi as icon of hindus. Time has come to say things bluntly & we are just borrowing time & have next 10 yrs. Hope BJP Govt take bold step & reduce their nos just like its neighbour countries do.

Dhruv Rathee wasnt running a campaign for AAP but against a fascist government please do not fall for false propaganda.

Marx ko vi talwa chatne ki problem tha, Jewish minority ki ahi problem HOTA hai, bad me iska reaction hai rebel ban Jana...sycophant ka opposit rebel HOTA hai...

Bla bla bla bla bla - vomiting oversimplified nonsense

Magar iqbal keu talwa nehi chati? O vi western university me para tha? Baat ye hai uska mind setup hossain azad o hali o dag dehlovi and mathew arnold lahore me hi fix kia tha...o 1905 me gaya cambidge jab unka age 30 tha, us umar silhane ki hai, kisi talwa chat neki khwaeyes nehi rehta

Hope Dhruv Rathi soon campaigns for Pak politicians.

seems like u r communist😅 what's future of communist in pakisatn?

Dhruv rathee factually correct HOTA hai magar aap nehi...aisa keu? Dhruv rathee western university me Kisi ka talwa nehi chati, magar aap Jo philosophy aap discuss karte ho western sycophant ka talwa chata kaha jayee keu ke moral compass drurv rathee ka bahat Strong hai...foran pakar leta hai : Kon sa truth Konsa jhut hai jo aap jeisa western sycophant pakar nehi sakte

Your Understanding is veru shallow and superficial . far from reality

Only Modi ji will come 🇳🇪🛑🇳🇪

India is secular due to Hindu Majority even if it becomes Hindu Rashtra it will remain secular in nature. Hindu itself cannot be pinpointed to one sect.

Bro u dont have enough knowledge about indian political parties😅thats not naxal party and yes nda(jdu ljp tdp)is forming govt again with bjp as largest party

First time watching pakistani little bit literate person .

Dont talk foolish by comparing right wing populism of both countries. Right wing emerged after persistent appeasment of muslims even after their negative acts like terrorism, underworld. crimes etc. can you say the same about hindus in pakisthan? how many riots have been started by hindus in pakisthan for right wing to emerge and become popular? In India right wing came in defensive action and in Pakisthan it was an offensive action. compare apple with apple.