The key objective of US India engagement is to disprove Chinese exceptionalism. If by 2047, India can bridge the 5x gap to say 2x gap, it will prove that US support played a critical part is rise of China. Indirectly proving US exceptionalism of providing growth opportunities.

US and EU cannot be telling the world that they are being immoral. It's like Laden giving a lesson on the importance of non-violence.

Interesting discussion, Uzair. Keep doing such a podcast .

Brilliant analysis on a range of subjects Dr Tanvi Madan ji! 🙏 🇮🇳

Sir do an episode on France -US relationship in indo pacific because France is a resident power and is advocating for strategic autonomy from US

Thank you for a riveting podcast. You might want to read, N C Bipindra's, 'Mapping Chinese Footprints & Influence Operations in India' that tells readers how China spent billions of dollars to buy support for itself from among India's entertainment industry, academia, think tanks, media, trade bodies, tech companies and political parties and twist public opinion within the country to destabilise it from within. Although, US-India relationship is predicated on notions that both countries are democracies and share common threat perceptions, the belief is suspect because the US, through non-state actors is believed to be abetting issues and fomenting unrest in the run-up to the general elections slated for 2024.

Superb talk!

Tanvi has explained the various scenarios with great insight. India, US relationships with China need to be defined in the context of circumstances of trade and military imperatives. The current trade is of such magnitude that it unwittingly underwrites China's growth in adventurism. India and US need to develop procedures manuals for trade and military cooperation vis a vis the Chinese behaviour.

Level headed lady, no nonsense but straight talk.

Ms Tanvi Madan's analysis is excellent and also the scenarios she could portray.

I used to admire and respect India. Its support of Russia and Genocide has shocked and disappointed me.

Let’s make it Indians are not South Asians. SAARC is dead and buried and so also the concept of ‘South Asia’ We are back to the Indian Sub-continent. Indians don’t want Pakistanis and Bangladeshis hiding behind Indians. We are not in the same league. It pulls us down

We American Indian will make relationships between two countries, no useless think thank buggers can harm it. I am gujju from California. Like UZAIRBHAI.

The cynicism towards Amazon in India is because WaPo, which is owned by Amazon, is decidedly anti-India in its editorial leanings. The minister was simply sending a message to Amazon thst two can play at a game. Don't think any policy decisions were taken that would be adverse to Amazon.

I don’t think India has any incentive to alleviate issues faced by countries because of Chinese Debt. Because let’s be honest it just means cheaper debt from the traditional lenders for India. And going by growth figures currently ₹1 spent in infrastructure in India is yielding growth that is more than ₹1 faster than ever. India is one of the fastest growing large economies.. if not the fastest. So more the Chinese drag their feet on renegotiating debts with other lenders involved more is the space for India to raise money cheaply and grow itself quicker. India should only focus on alleviating such concerns for its regional partners. Which it has successfully WRT Sri Lanka and Bangladesh.

Really appreciate the balanced views of Dr Tanvi.

great podcast :) thank you sir

Uzair did good to let her be descriptive & without any jutt ins. Tanvi did touch upon the various nuances even in the skepticism with which US is looked at in India. I would say Indians are (rightly) more skeptically admiring of the US.. than being admiringly skeptical. Tanvi was to the point, professional & her scholarship showed.. but she also comes across as an 'influencer' on US' part.. being careful with words if US had to be criticised & not so much if India was to be dismissed. We see her inputs as important insights, but not sufficient & definitely not a complete picture. The Indo-US "partnership" .. at least we see it that way from our side.. is gonna be unprecendentedly wide berthed & deep (if it maaterialises). However, US is working double shifts to ensure it does not have to sign commitments with the current regime in India.. & try & install a more pliable Congress regime in 2024. It'll be a cat & mouse game until then. Modi's impending visit, I don't think will produce more than a few defence equipment deals & probably one show piece item deal. The "partnership", if it happens, w/o only take shape post 2024. The partnership, if it materialises.. could become another US-Israel one (yeah, all other things considered) .. or, at minimum, a US-South Korea one. Forget about the politics Uzair .. Did anyone tell you you look like Shikhar Dhawan's twin .. & sound & talk exactly like him .. with exactly the same body language. Haridwar ke mele mein bichhade 2 bhai.. haha.

Fascinating discussion! Thank you for the enlightening conversation!

Tanvi Madan is a US sponsored India US relations expert. She always defend US

Very insightful conversations with Dr Tanvi Madan

Uzair keep up good work as always being PAkISTANi / American

We Indians take only 4 nation seriously usa,China,Japan and Germany. You are not even in our league 😂😂😂😂

Great conversation Uzair. Good luck to you

Grt job , anchor.keep up.

Pleasure to listen to Tanvi mam. 😇

the asian bonhomie 20 years ago between India and china was uneven relationship, china played a big boy role ... india is now open for business , infra and growth

Such a distinct take on these affairs....loved the discussion.

$10 trillion should be the goal . Need to reach that mark within 10 years.

One of the best podcasts out there

Nice discussion and agree with Tanvis pov. With our sovereignty being challenged by belligerent China, US is a compulsion not choice. Indians never liked the west as allies because of their never ending hypocrisy but china left India with no choice. If they want unipolar Asia we wouldn’t take it lying down

Great podcast 👏👏

Balanced and upto point view. Doin well Mr Younus. Keep at it. Cheers

Tanvi shud not be lecturing too much.....get on ground and understand what India is doing and how its thinking

Uzair you are underrated ❤❤❤

Tanvi Madan is basically batting for India's loss of strategic autonomy to America and actually saying it's good for India it's a necessity for India. She is also wondering what is wrong with that :O :O This is the level of her intellect. And by the way whatever you say of our governments and India's China problem but India isn't going to give up her independence and sovereignty. Also her assumption of India's coming for Taiwan's rescue(or US's side for Taiwan issue) is cute; a region which itself doesn't count herself as a country and call herself CHINA. :D :D

What a brillian analysis by Dr Tanvi Mam 🔥🔥

YAWWWWNNNNNn!

Sir ,always ask the book question.

It is very technical for Pakistani

Uzair Younus Can you make it bilingual ?

Ailaa, farast bhew! 😂😅

I have a question, what happened to the trade sanction imposed by President Trump on China and also India. Are they still in force against India? Are those sanction helping Pakistan and Bangladesh export to US?

Not related to pakistan

Anti-Americanism in India is a BIG problem for me. Not so much the anti-Americanism of many Indians, but the fact that Modi and the government of India does NOTHING to counter it. NO Indian official EVER says anti-American statements are wrong. NO Indian official EVER defends the United States. In fact, Indian officials will often pile on and make false and ignorant claims against the US. I have seen this for decades. Modi is no different from past governments. IMO, this will stop the US and India from being allies, or even being able to work meaningfully together.

Much of negative Indian public against USA is because of the US media especially NYT, Washington Post and WSJ anti-India bias The other is the fingering of India on religious freedom. Has a great impact on the anti-US views of the public

4, Garpar Rd Sreerampore

Good conversation, but needs to be less wordy.

Promo>SM 🎶

not your best work uzair. superficial talk.