No video

IRC RapidFire RapidFIRE Mode vs Legacy Mode + Low-Light Performance

  Рет қаралды 7,594

John E Fly

John E Fly

6 жыл бұрын

After the controversy in the last video regarding my claim that I was noticing latency when running the RapidFIRE module in RapidFIRE mode versus Legacy mode, I decided to do another round of testing and share that with you. Additionally I tested the performance in both modes in multiple lighting conditions this time to see how that played a role in my findings.
I hope you find this helpful, and please watch until the end.
RapidFire Module - bit.ly/2MG7QMF

Пікірлер: 64
@NJ-Tech
@NJ-Tech 6 жыл бұрын
It truly baffles me why people punish you for your honesty in some of the comments! It's important to highlight the nuance in these new products, regardless of whether we fully understand the issues at the time. Kudos to you, i will certainly bear in mind what i've seen here when my set arrive to review.
@DuckyRC
@DuckyRC 6 жыл бұрын
Thanks for your honest opinions and heads up on the lighting condition issues.
@bazathome2002
@bazathome2002 6 жыл бұрын
I've read another report on FB where it's great in bright light but then the colours go weird and the screen rolls at dusk!
@BMSWEB
@BMSWEB 6 жыл бұрын
Thanks for the followup testing John.
@JohnEFly
@JohnEFly 6 жыл бұрын
No Problem! I'm just trying to do my best to relay my findings for people that are interested.
@MrStevegibb
@MrStevegibb 6 жыл бұрын
Yeah i think your right the issue lies in my opinion with the fact that they are blending two signals together. With analogue electronics every little difference in the signal path can skew the signal which is fine if the whole picture is built from the same signal source but when you blend two different signals together the small differences can cause alignment issues and chromatic mismatching issues. This is probably exasperated by higher amounts of chromatic and luminescence noise in low light situations that will upset the analogue bandwidth saving methods they use in composite video.
@proximityfpv1722
@proximityfpv1722 5 жыл бұрын
Thanks for making this. I was looking for others backing your claims of latency and found this. Mines been working well but I was worried I wasn't really noticing the increased latency. No problems so far. Yeeee.
@mathieuf.2788
@mathieuf.2788 6 жыл бұрын
Was the difference in lap time significant between the modules, and if you are racing in good lighting conditions would you see a difference? I'm glad you gave us another testing round, I expect this video won't be the last on the RapidFIRE. Cheers.
@JohnEFly
@JohnEFly 6 жыл бұрын
There was no significant difference in lap times between the modules or the module modes (in the earlier testing). 11.3 wound up being my fastest at the end of the day with Legacy mode, but I was seeing 11.4 and 11.5 times with the True-D and RapidFIRE mode earlier.
@MsBotnik
@MsBotnik 6 жыл бұрын
The area he flew in wasn't bad rf environment, In a race with more people and more static I think he would appreciate Rapidfire more. The only thing bothered me was the saturated picture... I hope it will be fixed. Anyway, interesting points on the rapidfire module, when will it be available again? I have to get my hands on 1. A review dom V3 vs hdo would be lovely.
@ddfwaj
@ddfwaj 6 жыл бұрын
Another great video! Really appreciate you doing these vids for us. With that said I absolutely agree with your statement as I bet most of the race testing was done during daylight hours. I would be curious how this will affect the freestyle guys with multipath and indoor environments where lighting is also low?
@JohnEFly
@JohnEFly 6 жыл бұрын
I don't think it'll impact the freestyle guys much. They tend to fly very slowly around those environments compared to racing.
@ddfwaj
@ddfwaj 6 жыл бұрын
John E Fly I was thinking more of the multi path interference
@nkeney
@nkeney 6 жыл бұрын
Interesting, so lighting condition seems to cause different behavior on the Rapidfire mode for image processing.
@JohnEFly
@JohnEFly 6 жыл бұрын
I know, crazy right? I didn't see that one coming...
@danlatu209
@danlatu209 6 жыл бұрын
My hdo/rapidfire went nuts today. Image in the hdo appears to shake when flying and not. I also had a rolling screen. In a multigp race with 5 other quads all day. It was overcast and noticed shimmering effect.
@psychwardfpv4353
@psychwardfpv4353 5 жыл бұрын
Great video and thanks so much for this honest info. You just saved me 100 bux. I've been saving for a while for some HDO's + Rapid setup so I can focus more on flying than trying to focus my eyes in my lame box goggles. With the proximity that you flew in these last two videos I really don't see 100 dollars worth of difference. Bandos flying is probably where the rapid fire really shines but for normal gates in a park like i fly I'm probably going start with the true D or that new GE with the Quad finder first. At least until Immersion works out all the kinks.
@JohnEFly
@JohnEFly 5 жыл бұрын
For what it's worth I love my rapidfire now. Batch 1 has an issue with mode 1, but if you get batch 2 you should be good. It really does hold on to the signal better than a true d. That doesn't necessarily mean it's worth $100 to everyone though.
@mojokeeper8603
@mojokeeper8603 5 жыл бұрын
Awesome recap review,I did update and running rapid fire mode 2 it’s legit,I’m in same boat had same issues with black screen at first but no lag 🤷🏻‍♂️
@stecozz4907
@stecozz4907 6 жыл бұрын
Lighting conditions are down to the camera not the module surely. Ive come from using the Realacc 5808 module with Achilles firmware/Dom V3 goggles which were great,but my Rapidfire paired with the HDOs are on a whole new level. Rock solid through dense trees plus great range,cant fault it.
@JohnEFly
@JohnEFly 6 жыл бұрын
If you watch this video, I'm using the same quads with the same cameras through all of the testing. I never would have expected lighting conditions to matter either, yet there it is. Try flying the RapidFIRE in RapidFIRE mode just after the sun goes down at a high rate of speed. Then try it in Legacy mode. You may find the same thing I did...
@rdmanone
@rdmanone 6 жыл бұрын
No matter what you do there will always be haters. Keep up the good work and thanks for taking the time to share.
@ktmjay9920
@ktmjay9920 6 жыл бұрын
Super informative video as usual thanks for the Honest real world reviews. Really helps alot of people..
@mikec4032
@mikec4032 6 жыл бұрын
Hey John. Are you still getting any desyncs with the 2405 build? Man, I can't get mine working right (it's exactly the same build as yours). I've tried demag comp HIGH based upon your previous input ( thanks for that), but it still desyncs. Any help would be great. Thanks!!
@JohnEFly
@JohnEFly 6 жыл бұрын
I also run 48 khz pwm rate but I wouldn't expect that to matter. What min throttle are you running? I run 4. Perhaps yours is too low? You could also try auto timing. I've had no desyncs since going to demag high.
@dronetrooperfpv7810
@dronetrooperfpv7810 6 жыл бұрын
DETROIT!! Thanks for doing another video for the rapid fire. I have the HDOs and my Rapidfire should be shipping soon. I see your not using your pop-up gates. What are you using to stake these pvc gates into the ground.
@JohnEFly
@JohnEFly 6 жыл бұрын
If I have the time I like to use rebar and pvc. If I don't have the time I use quaddiction gates. The rebar is 2 ft x 1/2 in
@MCsCreations
@MCsCreations 6 жыл бұрын
That's really weird, man. Interesting how the light conditions change things! O.o And AMAZING flying, dude! Someday I get there too! 😀 (For now I'm training on Liftoff, but still can't fly that low...)
@pescaextrema
@pescaextrema 6 жыл бұрын
Great video. Thanks for sharing your info. That Frame do you uses and that Canopy? You print? Do you thing that rapidfire es much better than True-D?
@JohnEFly
@JohnEFly 6 жыл бұрын
I'm using 2 different frames. 1 is a prototype frame from Detroit Multirotor which will be available soon for sale (if it's not already), and the other is a Mode 2 Ghost. The Mode 2 Ghost frame is the one using the canopy. I did not print that one, it was ordered from Brain3D. I printed one in TPU before but it didn't protect my electronics well enough, this one is made from Nylon and is AWESOME. I would say the RapidFIRE is probably better than the True-D. I still like the look of the picture from the True-D more, but I do notice less breakup using the RapidFIRE instead of the True-D, even when running in legacy mode. The issues with blacking out still make me very nervous with the RapidFIRE, while the True-D has always been rock solid for me though. I think in a few firmware updates there will be no comparison between the two, the RapidFIRE will be significantly better, but for now the True-D may be the safer buy.
@youeladamas7840
@youeladamas7840 6 жыл бұрын
maybe from using other modules your connection socket is not getting the best contact. Do any of the pin legs on the modules look discolored ? i do see how it changes your style of flying for the image quality you might need to re adjust all your cam and your goggle settings. it does look like power issue in RF mode or maybe try changing channel for a test it might be something around you on the frequency it can see maybe in RF mode. The rapid switching could be making noise in the power thats not getting filtered right. if you can return for a new one but i know how shipping and waiting is if you dont have local might be a bad cap or lc/rc filter
@JohnEFly
@JohnEFly 6 жыл бұрын
I would be extremely surprised if there is an issue with the module socket. These HDO goggles are basically brand new. Before the RapidFIRE only a single module was ever put in there, the True-D. There is no discoloration on any of the pins. The quad in question actually has 2 caps. It has a large 1000uf on the main battery leads and then a smaller 330uf on the vbat/gnd pins of the FC where the VTX connects to (as recommended by Serge from Piroflip). If you look at the about screen of the RapidFIRE it shows 5V power and low-power mode is off. So I would be extremely surprised if anything like this is happening.
@youeladamas7840
@youeladamas7840 6 жыл бұрын
yeah i dont think its you kwad and i forgot you just got new goggles. try redoing firmware if you can maybe a few 1s and 0s got mixed up for the rapid fire program
@JohnEFly
@JohnEFly 6 жыл бұрын
Haha. There is no publicly available firmware yet btw. Your only option is what ships from the factory. I will say I'm very curious for more RapidFIRE customers to do this sort of testing. I know it's the sort of thing you're probably only going to notice at a very high speed with the quad, and that may not be relevant for a lot of pilots, but I really really don't like that I'm the only one that seems to see this so far... I'm sure there has to be others that will see it too...
@youeladamas7840
@youeladamas7840 6 жыл бұрын
yeah thats why i say you might need a new one everyone else seems to be happy with their unit. mass production can have the 5 in a 100 that get past cause they seem to pass test in house but after you can tell there is an issue. maybe reach out to a tester channel who has a rapid fire to see if they can get same situation.
@JohnEFly
@JohnEFly 6 жыл бұрын
yeah I need to reach out to some more people. But to be fair, have you seen many others flying at a very high rate of speed in relatively low light situations like this? I'm wondering if either people aren't going very fast, or they're flying with more light? I'm really curious now if it's just me...
@jonathansmith-bey6380
@jonathansmith-bey6380 6 жыл бұрын
Can you get a film/tint to put on your goggles? That'll help with the sun...
@Hexcidius
@Hexcidius 6 жыл бұрын
Thanks for the vid,,,
@vincentholm326
@vincentholm326 6 жыл бұрын
Well..both modules look good in my eyes😅 About those spedix 30a 3-6s esc's you once used on 6s, why dont you use them anymore? What does the aikon have that those didn't other than being a 4in1?
@JohnEFly
@JohnEFly 6 жыл бұрын
The biggest thing is that they are 4-1. Much lighter. Not awkwardly placed on arms. My racing frames are really optimized for 4-1 escs. The AK32 is also blheli32 while the es30 were blheliS
@theresjustnotellingfpv4822
@theresjustnotellingfpv4822 6 жыл бұрын
You changed the antenna!
@jaredmende3641
@jaredmende3641 5 жыл бұрын
Mine is Having The Same Problem.
@taggerung890
@taggerung890 6 жыл бұрын
What's your field charging setup? Was that orange case, on the left of the table, a power source?
@JohnEFly
@JohnEFly 6 жыл бұрын
Yeah, that's a portable UPS. Here's a link for it: amzn.to/2BG7m7D. Basically it's a lithium ion battery with 288Whr of capacity and it's also an inverter. I can charge about 10 6S packs from it and maybe 15 of my 4S packs. I mostly use it to power my laptop and timing system for a day out flying. In this video I was using it to power the timing system that was letting me know my lap times.
@taggerung890
@taggerung890 6 жыл бұрын
thanks!
@UAVfutures
@UAVfutures 6 жыл бұрын
nice video mate
@JohnEFly
@JohnEFly 6 жыл бұрын
Thanks Stu!
@jamesonkruger6989
@jamesonkruger6989 6 жыл бұрын
Was there a big humidity change from the first day?
@JohnEFly
@JohnEFly 6 жыл бұрын
No. No concernable difference
@DaytonaJim78
@DaytonaJim78 6 жыл бұрын
I will just keep my true d for now!
@ponyboyfpv3552
@ponyboyfpv3552 6 жыл бұрын
Low-light performance of a receiver module???? WOW that is something. GET A CLUE!!!
@deadmoo83
@deadmoo83 6 жыл бұрын
To be fair it is a receiver module that is combining the images from two receivers, so there is a possibility of there being issues depending on the algorithm used to combine the frames.
@JohnEFly
@JohnEFly 6 жыл бұрын
I'm just going to assume Ponyboy didn't watch the video... I never would have expected this to make a difference either, and why I didn't mention it at all in my first video.
@MrStevegibb
@MrStevegibb 6 жыл бұрын
If this was digital then yes it would be silly but your talking about combining signal from two very different signal paths. 1. linear patch 2. circular polarized pogoda. In analogue everything in the signal path changes the signal to some degree when you try to combine two signals with very different paths your bound to get problems.
@thomashannam2985
@thomashannam2985 4 жыл бұрын
why speed the video up lol ya melt.
@FabioPaulinhoView
@FabioPaulinhoView 6 жыл бұрын
You must be felling pressure from IRC to make such idiotic test.
@JohnEFly
@JohnEFly 6 жыл бұрын
No pressure at all, I must just be an idiot! Thanks for watching!
@FabioPaulinhoView
@FabioPaulinhoView 6 жыл бұрын
John E Fly You are not, but testing maybe 10 - 20ms diference in latency with a "i feel like" test is not a good idea.
@JohnEFly
@JohnEFly 6 жыл бұрын
I'll be honest, I don't care about 10-20ms. I care about getting the fastest lap times possible. If something makes me slower, that's what I want to know. In this testing the RapidFIRE was clearly making me slower, and I mistakenly assumed it was latency causing that to happen at first. I think this testing shows it's not latency, but under certain conditions there is still something which does make me slower. So oddly enough, I care more about the feel than the straight numbers for stuff like this.
@MrStevegibb
@MrStevegibb 6 жыл бұрын
Its not idiotic at all he noticed something with a hyped product that people don't want to believe hence the hate.
@FabioPaulinhoView
@FabioPaulinhoView 6 жыл бұрын
Stephen Gibb i was meaning the test method, to be precise. Ofcourse hyped products must be checked properly. How do you imagine to test latency with a lap times? Humans are not that consistant, to test this kind of issues.
What does Rapidfire Have That Other Modules Don't? How Good Is MCK Actually? - FPV Questions
8:15
ImmersionRC rapidFIRE - Overview & Setup
9:18
KremerFPV
Рет қаралды 44 М.
managed to catch #tiktok
00:16
Анастасия Тарасова
Рет қаралды 14 МЛН
Logo Matching Challenge with Alfredo Larin Family! 👍
00:36
BigSchool
Рет қаралды 7 МЛН
Rapid fire Mode 2!!!
10:28
Mr. Exaggeration
Рет қаралды 5 М.
Foxeer Wildfire vs ImmersionRC Rapidfire 🔥🔥🔥
12:49
Albert Kim
Рет қаралды 25 М.
Angle vs Acro Tiny Whoops In 2023
17:20
John E Fly
Рет қаралды 25 М.
First Look Inside Blue Origin's New Glenn Factory w/ Jeff Bezos!
1:12:59
Everyday Astronaut
Рет қаралды 723 М.
The Secret To Perfect GPS Rescue
47:33
Dshot
Рет қаралды 14 М.