this theory just ages better with every passing day lmfao

I definately can imagine that alastor works for lilith. We see how Charlie calls her in the pilot and just seconds later alastor shows up at the hotel. It could be purely a coincidence but I don't think it is, considering how well the story is curated.

I def think that Alastor and Lillith are connected in some way. It would make sense, but Rosie being Lillith doesn't make to much sense, but I do believe Lillith was in hiding with Alastor. Eve being Roo would be awesome!

Personally, I don’t think Lilith is an enemy. My take on her card on why she has the shh sign is the fact she’s doing behind the scenes work in order to help her daughter. That’s the reason why she sent Alastor to the hotel. Also, I think she’s going to make a last minute appearance that will result in the death of that exterminator (and why Adams face turned from angry to happy since he’s still not over her). Roo being Eve makes the most sense, because little do she and Adam know by destroying Hell also destroys Heaven since one realm can’t exist without the other. Much like how light and dark can’t exist without the other. That might be the reason why Heaven is having its own issue that mirrors the overpopulation crisis: what happens in one realm affects the other.

I thought that maybe Eve and Lilith would have been working together to bring down Adam. Given what we know, it’s reasonable to assume that Adam managed to dodge Original Sin by becoming leader of the Exorcists, whilst Eve became Roo because she ate from the apple. So here’s my theory. 1. Eve become Roo from eating the apple and is cast down with Lucifer and Lilith, unbeknownst to both of them. 2. Roo finds Lilith and convinces her to go after Adam. 3. Maybe they get into contact with Alastor to get him to steer Charlie into inciting a war between Heaven and Hell 4. Slate is wiped clean for them to rebuild upon.

The fact that lilith. The queen of hell. Is missing is honesty lowkey scary. I cant wait to see what happens in the show

The ROOT of EVE-il ???

Viv said in the Q&A that came with the early access that all the theories that say this character is secretly this character are wrong so Lilith probably isn’t Rosie. However I do love the theory about Eve and Roo

I actually noticed in the Finale, when we saw Lute telling Lilith to stop Charlie, you can look closer and you can notice that she's not wearing that pearl necklace we saw in the portraits of her at Lucifer's workshop and at the hotel in the series and pilot. That necklace she's wearing could be Eve disguising as Lilith and possibly tricked Lute and Adam. And I also agree about Eve turning to Roo or Root of Evil after she ate the forbidden fruit since we saw roots in the apple and it started covering Earth a little.

Me and others have the theory that Alastor may be working for Eve (the first sinner and the root of all evil). Lilith is locked up somewhere thanks to them maybe. Eve has a vadetta against Lilith and Lucifer for tricking her. Having Alastor indeed turn against Charlie in the end would be spicy.

I do agree with everything else, but viz in the newest Q&A did mention that no two characters are one person. She stated “if you see them as two separate characters they probably are.” But nonetheless it’s definitely interesting but I do think Rosie & Lilith are not the same person

Those are some very interesting and dark theories about Lilith and why she is missing for 7 years. I especially like the fact she left Adam so she'll be with Lucifer.😮

To be fair Adam never actually ate the fruit, or at least wasn't shown eating it, so I don't think he actually committed a sin which is why he's in heaven. Also Lilith disappearing 7 years ago is definitely connected to Alastor's reappearance. Maybe like mentioned in the video, they had a connection together, and when Eve went to replace Lilith, she threatened her, making her and Alastor resign to the shadows. Alastor is too proud of himself to put on a disguise which explains why he stuck to the shadows but Lilith might not be as proud, or cares more about gaining power/eventually stopping Eve, so she disguised as Rosie. I don't know if I agree with the theory that Lilith is Rosie but it is interesting how Rosie never died because technically Lilith never did either. But Eve definitely is Lilith, the pose she's doing on her card is secretive and she's doing the shh motion with her finger, indicative of her having a secret she's keeping. I feel like Eve has an inferiority complex with Lilith, she was the second woman, Adam's second wife, inferior to him and she blames Lilith for it. Maybe she's jealous that Lilith was the first woman and not her? Or maybe she blames Lucifer and Lilith for making her eat the fruit, blaming them for her being in hell. This is why she goes after Lilith, because she's the one who empowered hell so she wants to get rid of her to destroy it. I think it would be super interesting though if like said in this video, that Eve is secretly working for Adam to infiltrate hell. Eve may have even been forgiven for eating the fruit and got sent to heaven and infiltrated hell.

It’s interesting also to think that alastor returns on the seventh year. 7 is considered a heavenly number like how 666 is considered the devil’s, so maybe Alastor is helping Lilith (who is disguised as Rosie) rebel against heaven??

Rosie being Lilith seems a bit far fetched, we know that hellborns often represent the sins they came from so it makes sense some might resemble Lilith.

Anyone think they’re might be a major reveal with Lilith and the fact she hasn’t seen Charlie for 7 years

I wonder if Alastor made a deal with Lilith for power. If Lilith is Rosie (that's what makes sense to me) maybe Al wanted her power & sold his soul to her. Just like Husk & Nifty sold their souls to Al. Which would also explain why in the (old) pilot he looked at the picture of the Morningstar's. He was sent there to help because he is in Lilith's service.

Is it just me or does Lilith's secret trading card look a LOT like the cutout of eve when she has a grin while holding the Apple? The throne she's sitting upon also looks somewhat angelic. Not even angelic, but it doesn't look demonic in any way like Lucifer's throne.

I can just imagine a scene of adam pleading to heaven's court or something convincing them that its all eve's fault and only she should be punished😂

I personally think it’s possible that Alastor worked or still works for Lilith, but I think eve is a separate person and Lilith is just gone on her own terms. I don’t understand why everyone thinks that Lilith is somehow tied in with every mysterious character. They are probably just hiding her information so we can get a big reveal. And Rosie probably has a lot of info because she is a main supporting character. I like this theory, but no…in my opinion, just no

I really like this theory, as it's more entertaining than just having Lilith be a villain as it instead makes Lilith a secret force fighting to prevent the imposter from doing something really bad. This could also makes Alastor more interesting as I could see him teaming up with said imposter to just cause chaos. If he doesn't know that the imposter is posing as Lilith, then it shows how dangerous the imposter really is if it can fool Alastor of all people. This would also help with the recent reveal from episode 5 spoilers) of Lucifer and Lilith being divorced. Lilith could have feared the imposter hurting Lucifer and Charlie so even though it hurt her, she sacrificed her marriage as a way to protect them. Maybe Lucifer knew/eventually figured this out and it hurts that he can't do anything right now and more so has to keep lying to Charlie about what is really going on, great if the writer want to bring more drama/explore their relationship some more. Luckily once the imposter is revealed, I could see Lucifer and Lilith getting remarried which could lead to a fun wedding episode, especially if Charlie is in charge of planning it :D

Vivz has said out of all the theories, the “these characters are the same person” are the least likely

That would be an interesting twist. But I personally think the exterminator was killed by Adam himself and made it look like it was a sinner's doing. The angel, Emily, is the angel of redemption according to the bible. I think Adam intentionally killed the exterminator to make it look like sinners were getting stronger and to break the deal illegally. Because the deal is heaven only shows up once a year for extermination. The problem is technically Adam is breaking that deal. I think Adam doesn't want Emily to know what's going on because if Emily found out about Charlie's plans, Emily would've sided with Charlie immediately.

Eve could be Lilith, it would make sense because Adam became an angel and Lilith is also an angel and has similar shape to eve, maybe she changed her name like most sinners do after they die.

I think Vivzi addressed this in a Q and A saying pretty much all the characters are exactly who they present them to be, more or less. In response to these kinds of theories.

The pieces are falling together! In the following episodes it was revealed that both Allastor and Lilith disappeared 7 years ago...

I really do think this theory could be true for one Rosie is tall and slim with curves and has a specific body shape similar to Charlie's mom ender skin tone is kind of a similar shade but Rosie's is a lighter if Rosie really is her then she will try to hide the fact that she is Lilith and if you look at an old concept of Rosie she looks completely identical to Lilith although I think I'm reading too much into it

I remember first seeing the Lilith trading card and thinking that it is Eve 💀 maybe I wasn't so wrong after all. I did sort of get a feeling like these two are too similar to each other

Didn’t viv confirm in the QnA that’s the theories about one character being another character aren’t true

Why would Lilith be called Lilith Morningstar? That's a big assumption to make, the fact she's just Lilith seems completely normal to me. Same reason as to why neither Eve nor Adam have last names

It would be fun having Lilith and Eve be the same person at the end because it would play with the idea that some Christian religions believe Lilith never existed in the same place and Adam only had 1 wife. Most versions of the Bible or other Jewish Tales (which Hazbin takes inspiration on) never really say what was the outcome of Adam and Eve at the end of their lives, for example I am a Protestant Christian and we are always joking about not knowing if Adam and Eve will be in heaven, because we really don’t know much of what they did after being expelled from the garden, we only knew they had children. Hazbin already showed that Adam is purely evil but somehow is an Angel, while Eve is unknown. Eve is always “blamed” for being the one who introduced sin to the human world so Adam might’ve been redeemed while Eve didn’t, she adopted the identity of Lilith and invented that story to Charlie so Charlie would think her parents were wrongly punished. If this theory is true, Eve might be against the hotel as she was the first sinner and never redeemed herself so she wouldn’t support other people being redeemed, specially with Adam being an Angel and not her.

Okay yeah I do believe this theory could be true what is Rosie really is Lilith disguised as a new overlord if this does turn out to be true in the show then I imagine that Rosie might might give Charlie a big hug meeting her for the first time as if she hadn't seen her in years is it that were her own daughter

One thing that I also noticed is the specific mention of her voice. In light of episode 5 where we learn about Alastor trapping voices in the radio waves, I wouldn't be surprised if these also go hand in hand.

I fucking adore the alastor theory, I love chaotic characters that have emotion like that. Like 'I am going to destroy this hell because this hell was made by eve, and I'm doing so I'll help my best friend lilih return, in the meantime, I will protect her daughter with my life'

Remember these are the first 2 episodes, this is a buildup to what could be bigger explaination. Still can't wait for the 19th for more!

This theory is really, really good- Like I haven’t seen a theory I was so on board with in awhile!

She was standing in the background when we saw her in the beginning of the first episode, I don't think they're the same person BUT I do believe they may be twins

In some forms of Christianity, Lilith and Eve are one and the same, so this theory definitely holds water, if a little predictable because the fact it’s fairly well known. Also everyone is pointing out the similarity to the card, but I feel like no one points out the similarity to the angelic possibly female character we get a shot of in the trailer. They wear a crown and are smiling the same way.

I absolutely pray this is canon because this is super interesting and I would LOVE to have that in the show

I think Alastor appearing after the call could be a coincidence, he saw Charlie singing about the hotel a bit earlier and got interested.

I think Lilith and Alastor's disappearances are connected, the fact they both been gone is 7 years can't be a confidence. I wonder if Charlie searched for Lilith during those 7 years. Or if Lucifer knows where she is.

The stuff involving Lucifer is definitely going to be my favourite part of this show. I'll just crank up some Sympathy for the Devil by the Rolling Stones and watch how it all plays out.

This makes more sense when you remember the pilot when Alastor sees the family portrait Alastor eye contact looks like he looks at Lilth

I just realized there maybe more truth to Eve bein Roo, Because Lilith and Lucifer gave her the apple, but never got confirmation that Adam took a bite. Which would explain why hes in heaven and Eve is nowhere to be found

4:36 so what’s the point of razzle and dazzle then? Seems like almost EVERYONE just forgot about them ;-;

I am surprised you showed scenes we haven’t seen before!!

Oooooh! Interesting theory! I'm excited to see how season 1 goes! 😁😁😁😁

This is definitely a good theory,with all the supporting facts,I’m starting to wonder if this is true.Good video as always :DDD ❤️❤️❤️❤️

It's hard for me to pin Alastor at this point. He can go anywhere right now. 1. He works for Lilith for some master plan. 2. He has locked away Lilith for some master plan to go against Lucifer. 3. He works for Eve whom I think might become the big bad.

i remember playing for honor on Xbox with you and now you're a 300k subbed hazbin hotel youtuber that's wild

the fact that alastor is a radio demon and lilith supports hell with her voice... lol

Interesting theory there @Ayy lmao.

out of all the theories this is def the most researched i think

Wait the Lilith and rosie theory it kinda makes sense think abt it, when Charlie was trying to get the cannibals to help her with the exterimantaors and it wasnt working at first Rosie told her to sing to them! Omg this makes so much sense now 😆💀

I have a theory to this - Alastor wanted to make a deal with Charlie so she would do him a favor of asking Lilith to change the terms of Alastor's and Lilith's deal

It's certainly an interesting theory that could be true. I did find it curious during the overlord meeting that Rosie never said anything, not that we've ever known lilith's voice, but still. I was also wondering what Alastor was going to do with the information of an overlord killing an angel. It didn't make much sense to tell Charlie, though I guess he could hold it over the overlord in question as he didn't seem to like her all that much in the meeting. Maybe if Rosie is Lilith, he'd end up mentioning, but until we know the truth...

I'm glad Someone else Thought the same thing That smile Eve did I don't think it was a "Kindly" smile =o

Its creative and I respect it but I don't know where I stand on it yet. I will keep this in mind as I watch more.

im so excited for the hazbin hotel trading cards! i just bought them yesterday!

I can’t wait for Lilith to appear in the show.

Today is hell day, so at 7 pm, i can watch hazbin Hotel!

Haven’t seen the first two episodes yet but I’m very curious. I can’t help but watch.

Honestly I’d totally dig a kinda evil couple but they love each other kinda relationship between Adam and Eve lmfao

I personally think that eve disguised as lilith for revenge , she might’ve ended at hell since eating the apple was a big sin , she could’ve pretended to be lilith for years as the lilith you see has wavy long and pulled up hair , eve has side bangs and really straight hair , and when “lilith” takes Charlie she didn’t look like lilith on the photos at all.

I like the idea of a Queen Chrysalis and Cadence style idea for Hazbin Hotel Season 2 where it's revealed it's Eve who kidnapped attacked ambushed and impersonated Charlie's mother and trapped her somewhere in Hell when Charlie was still a child.

Hello I wanted to know if you can do a video explaining all of the Q&A that visaje has revealed please❤

My prediction has been ageing like fine wine. Alastor hides his potential and gained power and the writers do the same. He’s actually very strong due to a deal with Lilith. And his fp is completely unknown

If this theory turns out to be true Ayy you will prob have the ultimate back story video to this whole sistuation in the future I like it

She looks like Eris from Sinbad: Legend of the Seven Seas (2003)

I think and it’s only a theroy not real evidence but I think that Lilith and Eve are the same person. After watching a video from another KZfaqr who talks about their origins Lilith came from what was seen as the dark side of Eve that she got from the serpent making them the same but also different person.

Ohhh i like this theory. I like this theory a lot.

Don't know, I picture Eve talking to Lilith 7 years ago and she's tired of her eternity with the F-boy Adam killing her descendants for years on end. Eve might know the best way to smuggle angelic weapons into hell and Lilith the best way to hide them and build up an arsenal to take down the angels.

Love you channel so piecefull

on the imbd website there is a image of charlie,alator and rosie in a shop setting with some of the items on the selves having rosies name on it

Alastor and Rosie have some kind of relationship

well how far back do we think Eve replaced Lilith? could Charlie be Eve’s kid and not Lilith’s? Charlie is obviously very young in the scene where Lilith’s face is not shown, Lucifer doesn’t seem to see anything wrong with the LOHL… could Eve and Lilith be the same person? Lilith handing Eve the apple might have caused something to combine them…

The theory about Roo and Eve is very interesting, perhaps there is some truth in it. Regarding Rosie - Lilith, I think this is not so. Rosie is a separate independent character with her own story and other overlords will also be revealed later, I think.

OMG I LOVE THIS THEORY ESPECIALLY WHEN LILLITH SENT ALASTOR TO BE CHARLIE'S GUARDIAN. I CANT WAIT FOR THIS SHOW AGHHHHH❤❤❤

Fir me it was just eve being a villian as well for Lucifer giving her the apple but I love this thoery more

HELL YEAH YOU DID THE THING I TOLD YOU ABOUT

with all my heart i think this theory will be close if not true

This theory might actually be true

I'm not saying I am leaning towards any particular theory but I will point one thing out. Lilith:lily Rosie: Rose

It makes sense for Lilith and Alastor to be close because radio would've been one of the easiest ways to broadcast her voice across hell (radio came before TV and we know Alastor is much older the three V's because they show the previous overlords which he would've killed to make way for new ones).

5:32 Binding of Isaac music spotted!

Glad I wasn't the only one that thought that plus it makes sense as both are Adam's wives at some point or another even if they didn't end up together on the end

Team excited for Hazbin Hotel 👇🏻

Eve being rue makes so much sense and her being a villain reminds me of Adam since eves is made from adams ribs or something like that so maybe she resembles him a lot because of that idk i belive it to make crazy sense

Another possible piece of evidence of Rosie being associated with creation origins is her scaly neck that I think we’ve only seen on the angel exterminators.

That might work for lilith to protect her husband and daughter

I can't wait for Roo to show up, maybe in second season.

great theory

Easter Egg to add about Alastor: The song he & Vox sings in EP 2 has the same tune as the song “Insane” that Paranoid DJ made for/about him about a year or 2 ago. 🤩 . PERHAPS, this means the actual song will come up later & mayybe it’s being sung to Rosie? I know that the Rosie bit is a stretch but, in the original song, he mentions he knows whomever he is singing to & that they had so much fun together in life - and that this person was taken far too soon. . Not sure which vid would be best to post this so I’m sorry for the duplication.

Now that explains something

I saw this theory in the ntsg server a few days ago

In my opinion, what happened was that before Lilith went into hiding with Alastor, he sold his soul to her and was given power but absolute servitude to her. I believe that Alastor and Lilith went into hiding as Franklin and Rosie respectively, and after the most recent extermination, she faked Franklin(Alastor)'s death because she knew her daughter needed help and sent Alastor to help her. Just a theory. A GAME THEORY! Thanks for watching.

It makes alot of sense that alastor would have a connection with Lilith, after all as the radio demon he'd be able to help broadcast Liliths music and songs. Which raises the question, if his fight with vox was the cause for the secen year hiatus, how deeply involved are the Vs in this? Did they unintentionally helped Roo and reaped the benefits after or was Vox given orders to take away influence from Alastor or try to have him join the group under Roo?

No drama video today??? That’s a first.

I would not really use the expression as proof. Vivzie has a super bad habit of making all characters do the “crazy smile” and effectively uses very limited types of expression in her characters to the point where you can make slide cards that can apply to all of them. The best example of this I can think of from other shows is how my little pony will take the same body plan and repaint it, but it’s anatomically the same pony. Honestly It’s one of the things that bothers me about her stuff, as much as I love her ideas, the way she uses preset expression currently robs the characters of more individualistic types of expression that could be unique to their characters. To compare; One piece is a fantastic example of unique individual expression. The way vivzie is doing it now, if everyone and their dog is making the crazy smile, it’s not going to have the same weight when she needs it to. And Lilith being Eve because they both make the same smile is effectively just an artistic limitation she’s created instead of proof. Sounds mean to call it that but where’s the lie.

[4:20] Maybe the Theory with Alastor as a bodyguard could fit, since in the last episode (episode 5) while lucifer visited Charlie and her Hazbin hotel, Husk complained about being chained by Alastor. Husk also said something like "well I'm not the only one who's been chained" and Alastor reacted really absurd about it, which might proves that it might has something to do with lilith. Maybe lilith is in control of Alastor and found out about Charlie's plan, so she send him out to help and protect her and might helps to lead into a war with heaven to get revenge on what happend in the past. Well that's what I think