Is Khums a Shia Invention? - Sayed Mohammed Baqer Al-Qazwini

Рет қаралды 6,237

Al-Rasoul Islamic Society

5 жыл бұрын

Al-Rasoul Islamic Society || Day 25 - The Month of Ramadan 2019

Пікірлер: 18

@Serviteur313 5 жыл бұрын

Mashallah, May Allah bless you

@farisalghofiqy7734 4 жыл бұрын

I Love You Muhammad and Ali Muhammad,/ peace blessing upon Him ang His Family, !

@majedalkafaji8592 Жыл бұрын

اللهم صل على محمد وال محمد احسنتم وطيب الله انفاسكم وحفظكم

@Arnold-hg8ng 4 жыл бұрын

Salam, I have one question on your explanation. Sura Infal is totally related to War & matters related thereto. This sura was revealed after Jang e Badr. According to this sura all the war booty belongs to Allah and later in ayat 41 explains its distribution. Certainly it is 1/5 th. No doubt about it but it’s only relating to maal ghanima , which is war booty. How have you interpreted that same khums is also applicable on savings remained unused for one year? I could not find any logic as sura is clearly related to war. Please share any sayings or qol by any of the Imams. Whenever I asked this question I was told about 20% and who has right but not on the logic on which wealth it applies. I sincerely want to learn but I am not willing to accept anything without proof. Please help me understand.

@atravellerindunya4433 4 жыл бұрын

+Arnold 1000 He will not be able to answer your question because you are right. Surah Anfal verse 41 which talks about khums (one fifth share kf Allahﷻ, his messenger ﷺ and his family) is also talking war booty. *But these people want to charge khums on Zakah to increase their own wealth.*

@freedomfighter695 3 жыл бұрын

Exactly Same question

@alireza8395 3 жыл бұрын

salam, did you even watch the video? from minute 9:00, he addresses your question and from minute 12:20 he goes on explaining. You just come in and give a question where he answers your question within his lecture, unbelievable. he gives his reasoning and if you don't find it reasonable make dua to allah to guide you, simple.

@adilakhtar676 3 жыл бұрын

I disagree that khums is on gains of any sort. Imam Jafar e Sadiq hadis says khums is only on maal e ganimat war booty. Man la yahzarul faqih hadis 1646.

@thepr1ntgnome430 Жыл бұрын

You're right, these mullah khums eaters have no clue about zakaat. they have nullified zakaat while they promote khums. We have at least 100 ayats about zakaat.

@jewalzn9523 5 жыл бұрын

Salams this question is for the sayed. Confusing topic. I still dont understand. clarification please. So the bloodline of the prophet (as) take the khums. Are you saying bani abbas doesn't exist today. Forget sunni shia.