Once you see something you cannot unsee. That is the triumph of science.
@mohsinafzaal7159 Жыл бұрын
So this has been our problem from the very beginning that we bring religion into everything…..Science is Science Politics is Politics and Religion is Religion please for God’s sake do NOT mix them together! Religion is everyone’s personal matter and keep that to yourself……🙏
@connectingthedots1309 Жыл бұрын
rookie you are wisdom you lack
@mohsinafzaal7159 Жыл бұрын
@@zayd8618 I wish I could…. only those countries have developed which could confined religion inside their homes!
@7xr1e20ln8 Жыл бұрын
@@connectingthedots1309 speak like Yoda you are.
@eknayisooch3288 Жыл бұрын
You are 101% incorrect... Islam is a religion which you guide about all the things... So politics, science and other things are not out of Islam.
@mohsinafzaal7159 Жыл бұрын
@@eknayisooch3288 it’s your opinion and you have the right to express your opinion just like I have the right to express my opinion! Let’s agree to disagree……😊
@MunawarAzaad2025 Жыл бұрын
Salute to the First Questioner for his daring to question such basic things which are hard to even speak in Pakistan. People are murdered and lynched on this.
@AbaniPattnaik Жыл бұрын
Questioning and analysis is very important for human being. If that is stopped then we stop progress.
@bushraa65276 ай бұрын
yes and it is compatible, but trying to stop death and whatnot is not compatible so you must accept and understand the science, they need to grow and develop drought and flood resistant crops
@marspalk761111 ай бұрын
Hoodbhoy is wrong is saying that threre was no science before 712 ad when Muhammad bin quasim came there was no science. There was science before islam and before quasim came to india. India had made advance in mathematics and astronomy. Well is not very well versed in indian history, he is heavily influended by western interpretation of indian history. Sad reality why pakistan is behind science.
@user-rz5ei8xl5eАй бұрын
May be he said that there is no science in Sindh region not all in India
@marspalk7611Ай бұрын
@user-rz5ei8xl5e wrong, sindh was good mathematic and science. They build civilization on Indus River, that requires science and technological advancement. Your comment show lack of knowledge and inferiority complex you have. This is typical of pakistani and specialy punjabi muslims.
@airyanemvaejah3221 Жыл бұрын
Ibn e Rushd was an Ex Muslim..Pervez Hoodbhoy knows this but he did not mention ExMuslim in the lecture otherwise he would have been declared a Gustakh in Pakistan
@utubetruthteller Жыл бұрын
yes only hypocrites can live in Pakistan
@9Rehankhan19 Жыл бұрын
Such things don’t happen in india? Just because it’s economically better doesn’t mean people with cheap mentally don’t live in india. Do you know Indians believe that everything in science was invented by Indians ? E.g aeroplane was not invented by wright brothers, but some Indian guy 😂😂
@utubetruthteller Жыл бұрын
@@9Rehankhan19 oh u r one of those who thinks all science exists in Quran 😆 🤣
@mariarauf3280 Жыл бұрын
Maybe, but there were many others too. In the modern times the nobel prize laureate Dr Abdus Salam, he was a practicing muslim
@utubetruthteller Жыл бұрын
@@mariarauf3280 and abdus salam was made to flee Pakistan right, he is not even consider a Muslim
@shameemqureshi2774 Жыл бұрын
Religion is based on Faith and Science is based on Reason. Asha’arites emphasised Faith and Mutallazites Reason. The two domains are mutually exclusive. I agree with Dr Sahib that this question will always remain unanswered. Wonderful examples of Sir Syed and Iqbal, one started from point A and ended up at Point B and the other just its opposite. I think the prevailing circumstances and individual’s psychology play a big role.
@mohsinafzaal7159 Жыл бұрын
Agreed 100%
@ramanv.r3422 Жыл бұрын
I wish that when questions are raised the individual gives his name and qualification. At 1:08:00 a young person asked a series of well thought out questions. He articulated his questions well. I am amazed. I wish the young gentleman all the best. And in a decade or two we are going to hear more about him
@ashjaymohsin5583 Жыл бұрын
Thankyou for your kind words 🙏
@ashjaymohsin5583 Жыл бұрын
kzfaq.info/get/bejne/p9uVoqma2JaldY0.html
@ashjaymohsin5583 Жыл бұрын
This is the link to a recent talk I gave. I think you might find it interesting.
@cocophonix11 ай бұрын
@@ashjaymohsin5583 no link attached
@anujay81 Жыл бұрын
It's not understood as to why Muslim invaders destroyed ancient libraries ? Centres of learning, like Taxila and Nalanda were destroyed.
@randeepjasrotia22622 ай бұрын
Because of their hatred of any knowledge contrary to the what is written in their holy book.
@loveearthly Жыл бұрын
1.05.30 The questioner puts a blasphemy trap. Possibly because it would not have been the first time, the Professor responds in the most simplest & safest yet sophisticated fashion and closes it with the clearest, stunning yet painless knock out punch. Leaving the questioner with the choice to regress and remain frozen in Mohammed’s time, or progress with time.
@inaya199711 ай бұрын
Science and islam are poles apart😂
@mukhayar11 күн бұрын
Wonderful teacher ❤
@VMRDY11 ай бұрын
The question should be: Is Islam compatible with science? Not the other way around.
@asif2002407711 ай бұрын
Why should this even be a question?
@VMRDY11 ай бұрын
@@asif20024077 Because Pakistan is a failure. Maybe hard questions like that will help Pakistan climb out the mess it is.
@ajitsuttatti7 ай бұрын
The title of the discussion itself is wrong. Science has been around forever. Islam is like a newborn child in front of science. The title should be - Is Islam compatible with SCIENCE.
@gautamghosh803711 ай бұрын
Hardly any audience. Still I salute Prof. Hudhbhoy's efforts
@krishanpalsinghmalik9812 Жыл бұрын
Faith and reasoning are poles apart
@spectrum_X Жыл бұрын
The title of the video should be exactly opposite. Is Islam compatible with Science ?
@waqasakhtarali4944 Жыл бұрын
Very nice lecture in the beginning ! Balanced speech !!
@taufeeqahmed5168 Жыл бұрын
Cause and happening, Illat and Maalool, that can be seen by the naked eye, but there are certain happening you don't see, that's where you start believing in the unseen world, or the prayers what we find in all religions of the world,
@appupappu6412 Жыл бұрын
@ Pervez Hoodbouy Please read what following physicists have said about Vedas and Bhagavad Gita : 1 Erwin Schrödinger 2.Werner Heisenberg, 3. Robert Oppenheimer, 4. Niels Bohr, 5. Carl Sagan, 6. NikolaTesla, 7 Albert Einstein If you want to know what exactly these physicists have said about vedas and Bhagavad Gita please let me know so that you can enlighten yourself and stop criticism of what you are completely ignorant about !
@unculturedmeat Жыл бұрын
I want to know what they said exactly. Please specify
@arifsaleem5467 Жыл бұрын
What did they say?
@RG-iw4c11 ай бұрын
Kisne kah diya Hinduism me 5000 khuda h mtlb kuch bhi Iswar ek hi h. Vo khooda nhi h Avtaar h Ise aap kuch had tk nbiyo se jod skte h To kya m ye kh du Ki islam me 1 lakh khooda h.
@attarehman603010 ай бұрын
Islam is not against science or local cultures and traditions; therefore this topic is just confusing the conversation. First need to understand what Islam is as it gives us guidance and moral values and science is totally different topic and is not unIslamic. In this discussion only hearsay Islam is being discussed but not real Islam
@AbaniPattnaik Жыл бұрын
In the context of Pakistan, the history of Science in the Indian Sub Continent in which one of the oldest civilization existed and the oldest documented science scriptures exists, Pakistan which happened to be a part of India until the last 75 years, why intellectuals in Pakistan shy away from accepting and discussing the legacy of India which they should also be proud of. Pakistan not being part of the Middle East should identify more as from India. I am not saying that Pakistan doesn't have its own identity, but should acknowledge it as the son from the same mother and so discuss the inheritances of the legacies of science and mathematics with its young minds and not disconnect with it due to differences in faith. I wish All the very Best.
@dharmikrakshak8340 Жыл бұрын
Christianism and Islamism can’t think outside if book 📖
@9Rehankhan19 Жыл бұрын
@@dharmikrakshak8340 most prominent scientists have been from Christianity faith. Very few from Hinduism and Islam. You people still live in ancient times that Hindus discovered and invented everything. Britishers stole scientistic discoveries from you. While as, the fact is Indian scientists were more prominent during British era. After independence, I hardly see any major inventions or discoveries from Indians.
@dharmikrakshak8340 Жыл бұрын
@@9Rehankhan19 first correct Christianism and Mohammedi (islamism is new term 30 to 40 year old ) Very few scientists are Christian ,all are belong to Protestant group like ahhmaddiya in you islamism . Dr abbas noble prize winner is ahhmaddiya. Ahhmaddiya firka are same as Protestant. Ask yourself question son of god appeared 2000 ago, messenger of good appeared 1400 year ago and DARK AGES started??? dark ages period end 500 year ago . 0 zero is invention of Hindu. can you make software without 0. your Quran use Hindu numbers. Sanskrit. Mother language of all language .PAKIS ,TURKMENI, AFGHANI, all have staan. It is Sanskrit word Grammar is created by Hindu.many more
@memyselfyo8844 Жыл бұрын
India and South Asia in general no longer host the same quality of universities and centres of learning they once possessed in times of old. Nalanda is a historical landmark, and within its dust encrusted walls sits the forgotten legacy of giants of maths and logic. I say this as a person born in Pakistan but a citizen of the world. The Arabs formulated algebra by borrowing extensively from the knowledge of ancient India, all those who have attended impartially to the evidence of history would know this fact. Having said that, it’s important to remember that contemporary scholars, especially scientists who attend the prestigious universities of the western world, are inevitably imbued with a western bias. The ancient Greeks were indeed exemplars of incredible scientific discovery and knowledge, ranging from Archimedes to Pythagoras. But they weren’t the only ancients who advanced science, as western intellectuals seem to think. The name of the first ever manned lunar mission was ‘Apollo’, the name of an Ancient Greek god. The name Cosmos, denoting the universe, is a Greek word meaning order, the opposite of chaos, ‘disaster’ is Greek for bad star etc. The entire western framework for scientific rationality leans heavily on the classical Greeks and their works, as I learned when I read Carl Sagans Cosmos. Pervez Hoodhboy, and other scholars like him, educated at elite western universities like MIT or Harvard, Stanford or Yale, would inevitably regurgitate much of that bias. Edit: this response was NOT written by chat gpt or any AI bot lol.
@mayankumar1312 Жыл бұрын
@@9Rehankhan19kuch bhi matlab kuch bhi….not every white from west was a christian…pakistan ko samajh nhi aata ki some people dont follow any religion…and regarding india…scientists and mathematicians pehle se hi the….
@aneesurrehman655711 ай бұрын
Dr sb hamesha mazhab ko os k origin k bjae 'mazhabi' logoN k farmudat, ihmaal ore history k lihaz se dekhtay haiN.
@robinshrivastav Жыл бұрын
number system including zero was invented in India and such other scientific knowledge went to Arab and from there to Europe then how it can be said that Indian knowledge to Arab was very less, even Aristotle had asked Alexander that when he reached India to enquire about the learned schoolers in India who were very famous in Yunan.
@shabbirahmeddar7765 Жыл бұрын
ھود بھائ صاحب کی کتاب مسلم اور سائنس بھی اس موضوع پر پر اثر کتاب ہے۔
@sajjadashraf324 Жыл бұрын
What I understand by the word compatibility means ability to co exist without conflict. To me the Quran doesn't challenge science. Rather it emphasis to think logically over the universe. Moreover the religion just gives broad guidelines on life and the universe and let it to the human to explore.
@brisingr12 Жыл бұрын
Islam does very explicitly reject evolution thouhj
@user-mk7qi6gc2m Жыл бұрын
theory of evolution??
@vikramaditya844 Жыл бұрын
All i can say is Pervez ji is not that knowledgeable as it is potrayed..... Books from Nalanda and Udantapuri were initially translated even before the Bagdad University was developed
@zainsepticeyeАй бұрын
There is no proof of that
@historicalfacts7609 Жыл бұрын
Psychology is the branch of science
@WorldAffairskannada5 ай бұрын
I hope he is still alive after this seminar.
@praveenmallikarjunaiah761311 ай бұрын
Root question for the pakistani muslims remains the same - how did Allah communicate with Nabi Musa ? If they can't give the simple answer then atleast they should treat good their fellow Hindus and christian and Sikh citizens well as the fellow humans.
@kuldeepvirk4591 Жыл бұрын
1:04:30 that's why pakistan is number one in the world.
@rpforyou Жыл бұрын
Karam sy bada dharam koi nahi hy
@skagraw2 Жыл бұрын
Aja tumhari tang todne ka karam karna h. 😀
@alamagoddystyle Жыл бұрын
Koi bhi dhandha chota nahi aor dharam say bhada koi dhandha nahi.
@vashishthmehra11 ай бұрын
@@alamagoddystyle han islam ek dharam nai dhanda hai , usko manNe walla ek bewkoof banda hai
@qaiseraqaisar83336 ай бұрын
Never ,Science enhance the understanding of Islam but it requires a lot of observations, research and understanding of science.
@sanjaychauhan1116 Жыл бұрын
Science and islam is opposite thing .Islam teaches u that earth is flat 😂😂. Instead read bhagawat Gita instead
@talashegumshuda5791 Жыл бұрын
Read Quran first meri jaan
@mianzarrar37967 ай бұрын
@Respectshorts_900where ?😂
@ajitsuttatti7 ай бұрын
Having heard some of the questions even Pervez Hoodbhoy realised that most of the audience is radicalised beyond repair 😢
@adityaguru66548 ай бұрын
I am a Vedantin (Hindu) but when I read the Buddhist and Jain version of creation if forced me to question everything. They asked a very logical question. They said that when you say that life and the World are too complex to not have been created by a God, then that God is even more complex how did it has no creator? How did that God created itself? Also, Jainism asks one more question that you say God existed before the creation of the World so where did He existed? In a certain space, that means even the space have an eternal existence so why can't the World be created by itself? Very deep.
@shyamnarayanmishra53638 ай бұрын
This is very interesting discussion. But one point to be raised here: if Quran tells every thing what now science is, i.e. Allah, means world only came into existence just 1400yrs. While human races came thousands year before. Quran came only 1400yrs as given by Allah!
@R.kandaswamy Жыл бұрын
To know about how life originated on this earth read about Miller-Urey experiment. Also about Cambrian Explosion.
@bachhus Жыл бұрын
The professor definitely needs to get a bit more educated on Hinduism. Hindu Vedas believe there is one intelligent force due to which creation came to being you may call it by one name or 5000 names of your choice. Just because you call him by 5000 different names it does not mean there are 5000 Gods. It is your spiritual democratic individual right to call him by the name you choose. " Ekam Sat, Vipraha bahuda Vadanthi" Sanskrit "Reality is one and knowledgeable ones call it by different names"
@aqeelqureshi4964 Жыл бұрын
First correct your religion name. Don't use nick name Hinduism for sanatana.
@aqeelqureshi4964 Жыл бұрын
There are four different copies of your vedas, which veda are you talking about? Which one is authentic and genuine?
@aqeelqureshi4964 Жыл бұрын
Copied from internet, *There are at least hundreds of millions of gods, according to the ancient Shastras of Sanatana Dharma such as the four Vedas, the Puranas, Ramayana, Mahabharata, etc. The Puranas especially give vast genealogies of the gods, including thousands of specific deities. There are major Gods, full forms/aspects of the ultimate reality Saguna Brahman, like Ganesha, Shakti, Parvati, Kali, Durga, Shiva, Vishnu, Lakshmi, Saraswati, Surya, Skanda, etc., ranging down to still great but non-absolute Gods like Brahma, Hanuman, Ganga, Samudra, Indra, Agni, Soma, Prithvi, Nandi, Manasa, etc. There are Avatars like Rama, Krishna, Narasingha, Parashurama, Buddha, Minakshi, and many more.* Hope this will help you understand your religion better.
@bachhus Жыл бұрын
@@aqeelqureshi4964 We dont need Guruji Aqeel to understand our religion. The four vedas are not different but branches of Knowledge of espousing Philosophy of God, Creation etc Agree the real name is sanathana Dharma but used the term Hinduism for understanding in common parlance.Thank you for that Your google guru's explanation of Hundreds of Gods( Perhaps loaded by a Christian missionary as I can make out from language) it is not the term God we use they are Called Deities by us Deities translation somewhat nearest equivalent can be Angels. We are proud of religion just like you are about your religion and there ends the matter. Ultimately all of us are trying to reach the supreme in our own way. The theory that this is the only way, the only book, Only name does not jell as sanatana Dharma is a democratic religion goading followers to seek the truth rather than believing in something
@ashutoshraj_iift97088 ай бұрын
Again you are assuming that similar to Koran there should be one book to follow in Santana but that is not case in santana@@aqeelqureshi4964
@parjanyashukla1768 ай бұрын
Islam's worldview and history and social issues are so radically different from Hindu-Buddhist-Jain-Sikh that it is no surprise that partition happened. But it doesn't mean that 2-nation theory as laid out in 1947 made any sense, as it is too simplistic.
@kuttapan900 Жыл бұрын
Science and religion are closely interconnected in the scientific study of religion, which can be traced back to seventeenth-century natural histories of religion. Natural historians attempted to provide naturalistic explanations for human behavior and culture, including religion and morality
@kanthlk2 ай бұрын
Does a book in Islam that says earth is flat?
@seshanm54 Жыл бұрын
To pose this question and then waffle, when a young man frames a clear question on Darwin's theory being in contradiction with the Quran, is literally damaging the minds of the young...
@AmitMishra-qt4yn11 ай бұрын
No use playing music to deaf but hats off to you for trying to remove their blindfold
@muhammadharees22258 ай бұрын
Once my teacher said "every scholar has a pitfall in which he once falls once a life", so do not be dependent upon a scholar in each sense. But I see Dr Hoodbhoy is remains always in pitfall and if he says something correctly, this is the exception of that status of being in a pitfall. So sad that this kind of great doctor is unaware of basic concepts of history of Muslims.
@bhanumungali6000 Жыл бұрын
South Asian Islam is unique. Let’s take the marriage ceremony- it’s 90% Hindu amongst Muslims. I have read Quran a few times (in my view Maulana Wahiduddin Khan’s translation is the best). I’ve stayed in Indonesia and nearly all gulf countries. Their Islam is so different from ours. South Asian Muslims are struggling with a religious identity. As for religion- to be in this era has nothing to do with religion.
@bhanumungali6000 Жыл бұрын
I wanted to say as for science
@zain1132 Жыл бұрын
There is no such thing as south asian Islam LOL. You just hate religion
@ufaqkaiypaar531810 ай бұрын
پرویز صاحب ۔ انسان کے دو پیراڈئم ہیں ، جن میں تبدیلی اُس کی عمر کے ساتھ ہوتی ہے ۔ ایک فزیکل پیرا ڈائم (جو حواسِ خمسہ ) جسے وہ کائینات میں ہونے والی تبدیلیوں کے ساتھ، وہ ساتھ تبدیل ہوتا ہے اور دوسرا سپرٹوئل پیرا ڈائم (الھام) جسے وہ اُس کے ماحول کےمطابق مثبت اور منفیت ترازو میں جانتا رہتا ہے ۔ جوکُلی طور پر کلیٹو کانشیئنس کے جھکاؤ پر منحصر ہے ۔ اگر کلیٹو کانشیئنسس مثبت ہے تو ثبوت کا پلڑا جھک جائے گا اور اگر کلیٹو کانشیئنسس منفی ہے تو انکار کا پلڑا جھک جائے گا ۔(خالد مہاجر زادہ)
@shiblysadiq8680 Жыл бұрын
Credit goes to the little girl who sat through the whole length of a high level science class. It is unmeaning to go for compatibility of science and religion. Religion is founded on belief which deals with material and moral world so far as those relate to humans. Whereas science is limited to exploration of truth about natural phenomena in our material world irrespective of humans, their values, belief, morality and life hereafter. In my view science also should be guided by morality and shouldn’t go for discoveries of things utterly destructive to humanity.
@lepetitprince21886 ай бұрын
What's the need of the lengthy talk? The obvious answer is No!😅
@user-vv2xs9qj3o5 ай бұрын
💀
@seshanm54 Жыл бұрын
The Prof doesn't seem to know that in Vedanta there is no duality. The thousands of God's he is referring to are deities representing different deities...whichever the form you choose to dwell on, no Hindu denies that all the varied forms all lead to the same ultimate Truth.
@taufeeqahmed5168 Жыл бұрын
Magic phrase is Peaceful co-existance could work but only through the sharing of Values, of all ideologies of all times
@manishkumar-ou4dt5 ай бұрын
Such a intelligent boy🎉
@archinsoni125411 ай бұрын
Ah people from this little Historically Converted society By Abrahamic Thought are fun to listen to.
@ZafarIqbal-qe2po6 ай бұрын
Following an unchanging philosophy in a changing world is idiotic and foolish. Let's move from religion to responsibility. Thank you
@himansusekhardas4526Ай бұрын
Islam and science are two poles of a magnet, South pole and north pole. Do not try to bring them together.
@seshanm54 Жыл бұрын
The nub of the matter is that all 'revealed' religions which require one to SIMPLY BELIEVE are helpful, if at all, in organizing and ordering our earthly existence. To reach out in the direction of ultimate truth are the experiential ways of the great Seers/Rishis, Vedanta...and now Science & Quantum Physics are finding REALITY to be eerily close to the descriptions of the Rishis and in Buddhism [read Tao Of Physics, for example]
@Tahirkhan-commissioner Жыл бұрын
Dear sir, you should have mentioned Al Mawardi who was a bridge between the orthodox Greek philosophy and Sharia unlike Farabi who was his cotemporary and a vital exponent of Greek philosophical thought especially Aristotle
@indiapakistanfriends745311 ай бұрын
Seeing the dumb questions by the audience, Pakistan has no hope.
@shekar7367 Жыл бұрын
Medieval Islam was probably more compatible with science than modern Islam which has become more fundamentalistic and inward looking !!.
@rpforyou Жыл бұрын
As per me Science is universal whereas religion is not universal.
@kuttapan900 Жыл бұрын
I never reckoned Darwin Theory but after seeing Atta Tarard I belive Darwin was right. 😄😄😄
@historicalfacts7609 Жыл бұрын
Biological psychology Physiological psychology
@tggamer0099 Жыл бұрын
What a great minds 😜🙂😜😜🙂
@sanupu Жыл бұрын
Sir ye bata pakistanio ke liye bata rahe hai, views aur comments mein Indians hote hai. Pakistani lage hai apne jihad mein.
@salimm786 Жыл бұрын
Religion Islam focus on one god, heaven, hell, day of judgement, sociology and some economics. It is responsibility of modern muslim world to prosper in modern world by education, learning, science, technology, economy and sociology etc. Problem is that muslims have stopped learning and expanding on knowledge and limited themselves to religion.
@ahmadhamza50 Жыл бұрын
Sir I have a question but it is not related to this topic.. May I ask?
@earth4782 Жыл бұрын
Yes
@randeepjasrotia22622 ай бұрын
Some communities remained Jahils over the centuries and still continue to be so.
@indiapakistanfriends745311 ай бұрын
A single book cannot have all the wisdom in the world. This fanatism led to huge genocides in history.
@asif2002407711 ай бұрын
Dr. Hoodboy had to waste 2hrs of his valuable time just because we don't accept the fact that its not religion's business to teach science to humanity and defenitely not Islam or quran's business to teach science to Muslims. The same reason why it is not science's business to prove existence of God/Gods or Allah. And why are we so insecure about Islam not being compatible with Science? Even if it is not compatible with science whats the big deal?
@historicalfacts7609 Жыл бұрын
BSC psychology with congonative neuroscience at University of Nottingham faculty of natural science
@reg40265 ай бұрын
Not at all.
@rohitkapil3605 Жыл бұрын
Why only few views
@user-fw6pr3zd2j11 ай бұрын
Sir, should this not be other way around ?
@taufeeqahmed5168 Жыл бұрын
Once our prophet Muhammad saws emerged from home to see two groups of people indulged in the debate of Qada w Qadr, thereupon prophet Muhammad saws showed his anger and said, Stop this silly discussion, if you don't you might continue till Doomsday,
@AnMi-ln5bf Жыл бұрын
whenever there is no mention or reference in Koran then one must find answer through science. e.g. if Koran is silent about using automobile, then you decide whether you want to use automobile.
@601gateway11 ай бұрын
Sorry to see that all questions are baseless. You follow a religion because you are born to parents who follow that religion. If you were shifted to a hindu parent or chrisian parent then you will follow their religion. It means religion has no control over your mind. However science is universal...... prove and this will be followed by everyone across the world.
@cyb-m Жыл бұрын
Short and simple answer: No.
@AbhishekSingh-cq4yo8 ай бұрын
science gives proof for any things but that asmaani kitaab is based on hypothetical evidence…
@taufeeqahmed5168 Жыл бұрын
Tehzibul Akhlaq by Sir Syed Ahmed Khan, but in today's time Mullaism remains the biggest challenge of Islam, Iqbal's booklet Iqbal Aur Mulla is the typical example of Mullaism explained by Iqbal,
@Ashujnct9 ай бұрын
Hindus haven't talked about sky book
@taufeeqahmed5168 Жыл бұрын
Averroes or Ibn Rushd Mutazzila has contributed to put the heads together of all the 3 religions of Abrahamic traditions,
@jangsherrao2454 Жыл бұрын
Did Baghdad city exist in 712 AD?
@civilizational_bridge11 ай бұрын
For Pakistan to make progress in Science or other fields, the country and the people need to embrace their Indian identity rather than claim some nonexistent arabic heritage. Indian heritage provides solid identity that gave Taxila university that was established in present day Pakistan. Your ancestors were not in the desert. They were in the fertile delta.
@ufaqkaiypaar531810 ай бұрын
ابراہمک مذہب کاتعلق ابراہیم کے انتخاب (اسلام ۔ دین ملت ابراہیم ) سے شروع ہوتا ہے ۔ جس کا مقابلہ بتوں کی پرستش سے شروع تو ہو سکتا ہے ۔ سائنس سے نہیں ۔
@qazwsx25321 Жыл бұрын
It's ok that. You. Want. To educate Pakistani. Society about. Science but speak truth with all your heart sir I know you also afraid to open up in Pakistan society
@ghazanhussain2070 Жыл бұрын
Chup kar kafir dozakh mai jalayga tu apni mata ke sath
@annasaheb96787 ай бұрын
Parvez Hoodbhoy don't defend your army, your koashish will never be recognized, because I am your student from India..!!
@DaRationalVoice4 ай бұрын
The reason for Pakistan’s current state of affairs can be summed up in the title of this discussion. The question should never be “Is Science compatible with religion, the question should be Is religion compatible with science”. The answer for most part will always be a resounding No. These books were written by people from that era and with their limited understanding of the world around them and it is clearly evident if you actually read the books. For a common man of that era, they were definitely advanced to some extent , but they cannot be compatible with our current understanding and expecting so is unfair as well. It is almost like expecting a first grader to have the same understanding of theoretical physics as a physicist with a PhD degree. We should aspire get lessons of morality, empathy and compassion from any of the religious books, but expecting them to solve science problems is utterly irrational. While we know that Life as we know it the most rarest thing in the universe, 80% of the world’s population is fighting over “whose invisible friend is better? And whose medieval books are the holiest?”. If we allocated even a portion this collective intellectual capital into science, imagine how advanced and rational our world would be. Instead of falling for rhetoric and brainwashing, everyone should think on their own and form opinions based on facts and objective understanding. I see divinity in the Hubble deep field picture, photograph of M81’s black hole, 20 billion transistors being printed on a 1 square inch of an apple’s M3 chip, the LHC and the JWST. Sit back and try to understand the universe around you and the awe it can inspire.
@RG-iw4c11 ай бұрын
Kya Pakistan jaljle or Turkey ke jaljle me jo log mre vo paapi the ya us area me paap bd gya tha Or allah ne un pr aejab laya.
@FoolsOnlyFollowBook Жыл бұрын
Throw Quran leave Islam then understand Vigyaan..If u want to know Science read or watch Science books or teacher if u Want to Understand Quran then Watch or listen ExMuslim..
@mianzarrar37967 ай бұрын
I have watched their debates, pooray nangay hogay.😢
@AM-xl9ik11 ай бұрын
Human science is empirical. It only believes in things that we can percieve through any of our five senses or the instruments that we have made to extend them. Yet Allah talks about the other creation like angels and jinn whose existance cannot be proved scientifically.
@indiapakistanfriends745311 ай бұрын
True religion is about how to live ethically here on earth and not primarily about what happens after death.
@taufeeqahmed5168 Жыл бұрын
In my opinion Dr Hoodbhoy has a shallow knowledge about Dr Iqbal's Reconstruction of religious thoughts in Islam, Iqbal knew very well about the negative impact of Greek philosophy,
@subodhsingh9533 Жыл бұрын
Thus, under the protection of westerners, he got rid off mullahs fear to act and think like his masters to prefix his name with SIR.
@rpforyou Жыл бұрын
OMG what a question
@saeedbaig4632 Жыл бұрын
راجہ رام موہن بنگال میں جدید رجحانات کا آغاز کر چکے تھے جس کے بعد دھلی کالج میں رام چندر نے اس کی پیروی کی۔
@brv3466 Жыл бұрын
Can Kafir ask some questions?
@attarehman603010 ай бұрын
If you admit that you’re kafir then yes you are kafir but there are no restrictions on asking questions and you can ask
@vikramkumar-ow6uq Жыл бұрын
Last line - Don't take them seriously.
@dkv120111 ай бұрын
I wish those parents had brought a book or comic or smartphone for the young girl child in the front row. Even this highly enriching talk must have been such a torture for the young one!!!