JD has been a mentor and a hitting coach to several Mets hitters, and has helped Vientos for one,figure things out. A player like that is invaluable.

Maybe yanks should trade Soto too then since he's a rental

With this newfound OMG theme, and the Grimace thing, there's magic in the air at Citifield. Believe me, I wrote this team off back in May, and wanted to trade everyone. They came back from 11 games under, and got to .500 in under a month's time. The team earned a shot at it this year, and Stearns would be foolish to trade big pieces away now. The whole lineups clicking, and if you remove 1 piece, they'll be back to the same ol Mets again. McNeil is the only one I can see them moving for bullpen help. Jeff isn't hitting, but he's still one of their best defensive players.

You only trade JD if it’s for an offer you can’t refuse. Most likely no team is gonna do that because he’s 36 so you keep him and ride it out

JD MARTINEZ has brought in much needed leadership and character to this ballclub.

The cue ball on the left has no clue.

He's delusional. They only started hitting when JD gave hitting advice.

JD Martinez is the best hitting coach in baseball. They need to keep him

Sean is effin’ nuts. I want JD to stay until he retires, cuz he offers too much. I don’t think we’d be in this sitch if the umps (pushed by the Cohen-hating MLB front office?), if they hadn’t taken Diaz away from us!! JD will help through any transition to ‘25… why NOT want to keep his leadership and consistency?

JD Martinez is the kind of player a team on the cusp of playoff contention brings in at the deadline. Contrary to some opinions here, trading him is not going to bring back more than a mid-level contract at best. He is an aging expiring contract and as well as he has played here, on paper he does not have much value in return. If the next 3 weeks exposes this team and they struggle, they cut bait, but what he brings will help keep fannies in Steve Cohen's team and that is what matters in September.

In the playoffs, you can move Butto, Megill, and Peterson to the bullpen. You go with Severino, Senga, Manaea, and Quintana as your starters. The bullpen looks a lot better with those 3 guys to go along with Garrett, Hauser, Ottavino, Diaz etc.

Why the fuck would they sign alex bregman? Have you seen the Mets third baseman?

Just think of the DH fiasco the Mets have gone through for years. Bring back JD Davis instead of Martinez? The worst position on the Mets until this year was DH. We don't have one anywhere.

Get Trevor and put in his contract one mess up and he's done.To much talent there not to give him a try

Unless there is some kind of disagreement on JD's contract for next season they can't get past, why wouldn't they resign him? Clearly he is more then an DH for this team having a positive impact since joining the team, with things like offers great batting strategies, has great knowledge of the game, doesn't have to be on the field with his aging bones playing defense and hits for power and is clutch; JD is also a natural leader to make things happen too. He has helped Lindor settle into a leadership roll the right way, he also has lifted Nimmo and Alonso to be better leaders of the team and improved hitters; JDs professionalism has impacted every player on that team in some positive way, including our younger players too. IMO he is the best signing preseason we have had since Max as he had a great impact on the guys too. I want JD back! Bader and Menaea too. These are guys that are gelling really well with our players that remained starting this season and they are guys that love the game, come up big in big moments and a great guys/players.

Love when a Yankees fan wants the Mets to sell lol

Let's go mets

The Mets needs bullpen help. Stop being so negative

There will be no run to anything unless pitching improves dramatically.

Keep JD Martinez..

I’m a Mets fan and I think Shaun is correct. We could get a very nice return for JD and I want to build a consistent winner

What drugs is this dude on? Trade JD lol. No matter where he goes, he has to resign at the end of the year. So what, he thinks a team is going to throw the kitchen sink at the Mets for JD?! No. At best, Mets get some prospects. Which is hit or miss long term gamble. Does nothing to help their bullpen this year. The only way this makes sense is if the Mets are out of the picture and sellers.

Always like to hear from Shaun. (Sean?)

WFAN who is that screwball on the left?

Fools gold!!! 100%

Trading JD is the dumbest shit I've heard in year's

how the guy on the left on this show bro he doesn't know sports at alllllll

Mets have too many holes to fill at the deadline Everybody knows this isn’t their year Sell high and keep it moving

#stros crushed #Mets 2 out of 3 games.

Trade jd for a relief pitcher? Lol what an awful take

Rotation stinks!!!

Id rather trade alonso than jd

They should be sellers. This run won't last, you watch they'll be in the wild card race, then 30 games out they'll go 10-20 and choke like they did in 07 just before the end of the season, and spent money and lost the opportunity to trade alonso for this smoke & mirrors ''run''.

Rage bait

Get Trevor Bauer!!! There is one pitcher

Tiki always has a stupid smirk on his face

Mendoza threw away the possible win when SEVERINO pitched. He could have pitched one more inning. PETERSON could also have piched one more inning.

You’re hinging all your hopes on a McDonald’s character. Of course it’s fool’s gold. This entire franchise is fool’s gold.

tiki 90 degrees and you are wearing a hoodie? as far as the Mets, they do not have what it takes to get to the playoffs...will come down to earth before the Olympics. So you Mets fans can watch the Olympics instead of the Mets losing games, this team is a joke

It's the Mets, so just a blip

It’s so funny seeing Mets fans squirm over whether they should do the smart thing and rebuild properly or push for a playoff appearance at any costs. Go ahead Mets. Buy at the deadline. I’m sure this is all very real and won’t backfire horrifically like always.

Trade Martinez?🫵🤡 these guys forgot Fujimoto...add him & senga & 1 arm in the deadline and the Mets should be fine

Fool's Gold. Definitely! The Mets will end up winning or losing 82-85 games.