Madam if you just follow what I have said it will be simpler for you to understand.

Thank you sir for your prompt reply.

How to take minutes I use astrosage app there planets are in degree and end in minutes I don't understand plz tell?

@@theironman1903 yes, for example my saturn is 10°27', means 10 degree and 27 minutes. While my mars is 12°04'. If i took minutes, then saturn will be the highest than mars, eventho mars have the highest degree, but here we are took minutes instead. So saturn > mars.

Shubham sir said that minute method is correct , just like a 2500 year old Sanskrit puzzle got solved last month by an Indian student studying in Cambridge similarly today we are learning the correct method of calculating charkaraka by Shubham sir , which was wrongly interpreted until now . This is revolutionary sir your Jaimini course was brilliant.

Why do you care what Sanjay Rath is saying? As far as I know, the actual Jaimini text/classic says "minutes". Myself I've checked the Atmakaraka of people I know using both methods and the minute method clearly does work, while the degree method clearly does NOT work. As far as I'm concerned, Sanjay Rath should stop teaching the incorrect method and should apologise to people.

0n basis of degree all senior teachers are advocating. It has 0ne advantage :: ayanamsa Issue it would duly taken care of if we use degrees! Right now:: 18:35 IST 25-12-22 Saturn in AK and Mercury in DK (If Dr B.V.Raman's ayanamsa is used) (But if we use lahari ayanamsa) :: Mercury is the AK & Jupiter is the DK. But if we use minutes :: Ak will be Mercury :: Dk will be Venus But even in the minutes system:: If we use Chandra Hari's 0r Raman's 0r even pushya pakshya ayanamsa :: we will again get different sets of Karkas ! 》》so 0ne needs sufficient experience & insights in prediction !

Minutes kaise Lena hai I use astrosage i don't know anything else plz someone tell?

Both

@@ShubhamAlock thank you sir.

Hey, Did you find the answer??. I have my lahnalord as DK and 7th lord moon as aatmakaraka

Oh, it never struck me. Looks like I need to learn more 😂

How many minutes is 15Degree 12 minutes

I use Chandrahari ayanamsa for all my calculations.

@@ShubhamAlock NC Lahiri is commonly agreed to be the by far most accurate system of equinoxes. Why'd you use Chandrahari system instead of that?

​@@ShubhamAlock Subham sir , as per lahiri ayamsa , Sun is my atmakaraka where as it's Venus as per Chandra lahari you use ... But I relate more closely to Sun amk with typical sun traits like self esteem etc and I am leo asc too with moon in utraphalguni Sun nakshtra While with Venus amk ... my asc nakshtra is purva phalguni ...but I can not relate that closely .. I am materialistic to an extent like many others commonly but not excess also I do not like expensive luxurious things .. have no such obession ... Also I have checked on people around me lahiri one in many cases give more accurate relations Please consider using lahari too to see the results of they are accurate

@@wolverine6117 Your Father is very rich and you are born in well to do family where you don’t have to think about your future but have a huge fortune to inherit?

@@ShubhamAlock I would not say I am born very rich ... i would say was born in a fairly middle class family... grandfather a retired headmaster , father lawyer district court ...as per local standard family would be called well off I think being rich is relative to place ... big metro different meaning of rich.. joint family uncle successive businesses been financially well off for most part not now because all of them have closed.. never had like monetary crisis in our family but also not like huge money too like say engage in luxurious expenditure and not caring if money go waste..not that rich About inheritance we do have significant fertile farm land in our village but in monetary value they would not fetch as per big cities obviously. The key point i am making is the atmakaraka would mostly ,, The key point I am making is the concept of atamakaraka should mostly tell out nature and characteristics not material condition .. i think not all Sun amk people would be very rich and have huge inheritance .. I am sure there would be many people around me in my neighbour with sun amk and less well than us .. there are many people in one single family may be born with different amk one of them could be sun amk yet the material conditions for all them being due to being from same family is same, Just like in my case as per chandra Lahiri I am venus amk and my eldest sister Sun amk .. so we can not relate concept of Sun amk univeraally with material richness... the concept make more sense if we relate palnets nature to people nature and characteristics as that would be universal just like all virgo moon people would have similar nature .

Who told you this? Is it your own conclusion?

@@ShubhamAlock I did month of research behind it because I didn't want to believe it. Denial can be a big roadblock with a huge wall. I had to humbled myself to progress. Don't believe me or anyone else, just look into it. Parasara has a chapter Arudha and Argala.

An answer to this will be revealing a lot of secrets, should it be done to strangers?

@@ShubhamAlock The secrets of jyotish, are keeping jyotish a hostage as a pseudo science when it is a true science.

Who said it is a pseudo science and who is holding it, just following what sages have said regarding sharing of knowledge. By the way, in which Purana, Chapter and Shloka Number, the relationship between Parashara and Vyasa and Vyasa and Jaimini is given, let’s see if you can answer it without searching internet?

Listen to the video, carefully, again!

@@ShubhamAlock hindi me apka channel link bhejiye