Good to see ex United player and ex liverpool player fighting over Arsenal.

Carragher's voice and accent always cracks me up man

Looks like Neville learned a lot in Valencia about what not to do as a coach.

Nev. "Jamie's power point here is lovely" Carra. "You should have took it with you to Valencia" 🤣🤣🤣 savage..

Gary Neville is an amazing pundit, really interesting to listen to him

Gary Neville and Jamie Carragher, a better love story than Twilight.

Arsenal fan but love Neville, such a good pundit

Neville is a genius, as an Arsenal fan I completely agree with him. I think Carragher was being misunderstood though, Jamie is just insisting that Emery adjust mid game to avoid dropping points. They both made good points here, love them together.

Mr. Neville is completely right..... we can 't forget they played city and chelsea.... that's not bournemouth and West ham.... can give unay much more time

Gary Neville is right in my opinion

4:35 “Should’ve took it to Valencia” Yooooooo lmao go on Jamie

10 wins straight on October. Neville was right

Gary Neville is a brilliant pundit!!!!

Hate to say it as a Liverpool fan but Gary Neville is a quality pundit who’s understanding of football is brilliant

The pitch of their voices went higher as things got more heated.. This is *hilarious* and both make valid points but I side more with what *Neville* said over *Carragher*

No one: My KZfaq recommendations: Jamie Carragher and Gary Neville have HEATED debate over Unai Emery’s Arse

100% with Gary. The players at utd dont respect Jose Mourinho. Thats why they are playing poor football. The amount of respect City players have for Pep is shown on the pitch. The way they push themselves on being the best everytime they step on the pitch. It’s about respect and fear of losing. The Arsenal players had a “softie” for all those years playing under Wenger. They dont know how to fear their manager. It is Emery’s job to get them to that point now!

The most important sentence in this debate: 3:47 "Guardiola, Klopp and Pochettino don't have a Plan B, they make Plan A better" which could be translated into "I fear not the team that has practiced several styles of football once, but I fear the team that has practiced one style of football 10,000 times."

1 month later and arsenal have won 9 consecutive games

"Unai Emery isn't trying to get 8 points from 5 games to avoid relegation." Absolutely roasting Sam Allardyce lmfao

Gary Neville is so right. Unai Emery is building a team, squad, for long term, not this season. He has a philosophy of how he wants to play. If the current players can't play from the back, he will bring in players that can. Like Pep Guardiola did at Man City. He's giving Ozil a chance, but he won't be there if he don't deliver. Ozil is quality, but he doesn't show it consistantly. The Arsenal defenders aren't up to the task, even some he brought in. The midfield and forwards are decent. Bernd Leno will be first choice soon, as he wasn't brought in to sit on the bench. I think Arsenal will get it right long term, but this season will be a learning curve, as the manager looks at what he has and strives to improve them or ship them out. Only next season will the team, squad reflect the manager.

We all know how good Neville was as a player but I think he's an even better pundit, He really knows his stuff.

If you close your eyes you`ll hear two old ladies

“This is a 3 year project” 😂

I don't even know how this is an argument after seeing Klopp transform liverpool from has-beens to champions league challengers. He did not adapt - he stuck to his methods and weeded out the players that couldn't hack it, bringing in new ones that could. Emery should be given 3 years minimum to build the side he wants to build. That's what he was brought in for. Anyone can just 'adapt' but that will only get you so far

Have to agree with G. Nev, give him time. They were stuck with the same manager for ages, you get a new gaffer and expect him to deliver the title off a not so good team? This is football not ping pong. Glad to have this duo back on the screens too. Always nice listening to the both of them.

Gary Neville is lucky Jamie didn’t spit on him...LOL

The thing is they're both arguing for two different things. Carra was arguing that Emery should adapt to the game or the opposition, while Nev was arguing that Emery should not adapt to the players' comfort zone. Both of which is not wrong.

The more passionate they speak in the debate the higher the voices go 😂

Neville: football knowledge.

Not often I agree with Gary Neville, but completely respect his opinion here and agree with him 100%.

How about now Carragher? Arsenal are now 21 unbeaten! Neville was on point!

4:35 Jamie: "You should've taken it to Valencia" Haha Carrabanter is back

when Bayern played Real Madrid in the 2014 champions league semi-final the players told Guardiola to let the team have control over the tactics. Guardiola complied and they went on to lose 0-4. I agree with Neville here. the players have to adapt to the manager's philosophy and not the other way round. the team then has to gain trust towards their manager in order to execute it properly, but all of this needs time. I couldn't care less about Arsenal, but Emery is a top manager and he should be given enough time to implement his philosophy.

The pragmatic (Carragher) vs the Dogmatic (Neville). Interesting debate but I agree with Neville. The beautiful game, ideas and tactic are better than getting results no matter what.

Neville's such a knob... 0:17 "It's ignorant to suggest he (Emery) has to adapt" and 0:35 "the players have to adapt to him" six minutes later... 6:40 "We have to adapt as coaches, not the players"

Neville is right 100%. Just look at Chelsea under their first year with Conte. The first games they played a back 4 as Conte "adapted" to their style. They struggled in the first games and their lost to Arsenal was when Conte said "We are doing it my way" with a back 3. They won the league at the end of the season

This debate was better than the champions league final.

Neville talks sense and methodically, whereas Carragher’s punditry style is that of an armchair occasional footy spectator at best! Love listening to Neville and this is coming from a Liverpool supporter.

Gary Neville is right. But he has the 90's/2000's mindset. Basketball, Football, Baseball. Players sign short contracts and managers get released. There is no loyalty like back then. Perform pr get cut.

Someone should remind Carragher that the entire Country used to bash and critisice Pep for playing it out from the back and dropping Hart. He allmost missed out on a top 4 finish in his first Season and won 0 trophies. It took Pep 3 Transfer Windows before his Team started to dominate so how do People expect Emery to Change Things for the better after 6 weeks when you consider his low Budget that he had and the fact that he has to rebuild an unbalanced squad that he inherited? Chelsea have spent more on a Goalkeeper than what Arsenal did to rebuild the entire squad eventhough Chelsea allready had the better Team before the Transfer window opened. I am a Coach as well (Ameteur Football) but Garry is absolutly spot on, you have to stick to your philosophy and be rutheless otherwise the Players will feel it and jump all over you

Gotta say as a Man City fan Gary Neville is easily the most open minded and best football pundit out there

Watching this now Arsenal have won 10 in a row playing Emery ball. Neville was clearly right.

Well said Gary, one of the few articulate player turned pundits out there, don't really know what Carra's on about here, surely the first year Emery should be given the time to implement and instill his ideas. The last thing you want is him to adapt and start playing long balls. Leave that to big sam

Damn those high pitched voices so hilarious

These two together are bloody brilliant.

Carragher making the most sense in this exchange, although Neville's point about keeping a consistent message is right. The message shouldn't be 'we stick with the system regardless though' it should be 'I as manager will pick the players capable of playing the best system to win against the opposition team this week'. Trying to make players play to a system they are incapable of achieving just means losing a lot. The system should make the most of what you actually have available at that time.

Unfortunate where the caption cut off

More tension then a family gathering

gary is completely correct, as ian wright said; wenger’s influence is all over the club, you can’t expect emery to come in and reform the club the way he wants in 5-6 weeks

Arsenal were the wrong club for Emery, Aston Villa is perfect for him.

Jeez, what happened before they went on?

Gary Neville is speaking sense,Jamie carragher is just confused

I'm surprised Carragher didn't spit at Neville

Looks like carra was right. You got to get results.

I swear carra's voice gets higher as he continues to be triggered by gaz😂😂..

That's why I love Gary. He's talk about football. Not bullshit. Great views from him.

I've waited for this since yesterday. Thanks!

Great debate from former great players , RESPECT for both of them !!!

Gotta love rewatching these years later

I agree with Gary!

Give the man a chance I'm backing Emery 100%.

Did anyone notice how Neville bodied Sam allardyce ? Wow.

Just got into fotball a few years ago after a life long watch of my best friend's love for Liverpool. These to gentlemen are fantastic. The dynamics and mutual respect combined with the banter is pure gold.

Finally someone telling the truth about big Sam 😂😂😂 oh Gary used to hate you but now love you lad.👍🏼

It's time for Jamie to manage a pub team

They both make good points, but Neville's arguments just edge it for me.

You are a very good analyst Garry Neville. After 10 wins in a row I came back to this video . 24 Oct 2018 . You are good and agreed with you regarding Emery he shouldn't change. Cheers

Ferguson done something similar to what gary neville said and it worked

The thing is none of them are wrong, they are just talking about different facets of coaching. What Jamie means is Emery should ADAPT his GAME-PLAN to teams he plays, use personnel accordingly and delegate instructions and roles accordingly *TO WHAT HE HAS DECIDED, NOT WHAT THE PLAYERS DECIDE OR BENDING HIS WILL TO PLAYERS* What Gary means is Emery should not ADAPT his PHILOSOPHY/MASTER PLAN to the players because certain players REFUSE/MOAN or aren't cut out to play the way he wishes. Gary believes the moment he starts compromising his philosophy for PLAYERS (Different from tuning your base philosophy to suit game-day opposition), *YOU HAVE LOST THE PLOT* Frankly, i think these two guys just like to argue cause its fun or "juicy". They are on the same team but both of them are colour blind.

Nevile predicted what unai would go through and as at now, Nevile stands to be right in all front. just the difference between a coach and a pundit.

The title in your recommendations😂

Emery is a great appointment. I don’t necessarily think some of these players are sound enough to fit Emery’s style, but that’s where Neville has it right! He’ll try to coach the players into it, if they can’t hack it, then they go elsewhere.

4:36 "should have taken it to Valencia" 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

Carra turned out to be right here. Arteta came in and made this team park the bus and won and FA cup. Started the clear out after to implement his own style.

I wonder if there are going to be some sort of update after the game v Liverpool has been played.

Gary Neville is a brilliant pundit... Always makes very valid points....

Gary is absolutely right here. Managers in big teams should never change their core strategies. The players should adapt to the manager and if they can't, the club must bring in new players who can.

As usual, Gary sounds the most convincing during the debate. But, as usual, Carra tends to be right in the end.

How this opinion has aged, here’s Arteta at Arsenal who did the same thing Gary was asking for them to give Emery the change to get

Have you ever seen Tottenham win the league

To be honest G.NEV IS TOTALLY RIGHT DON'T UNDERSTAND WHAT CARRA IS THINKING

Well this aged well

I love these two 😂😂. Gary Neville's analysis is so bang on point in this case and Arsenal is reaping the fruits on Emery's tactics

I'd agree with Jamie maybe a few years back but after watching football for years, I think having a philosophy is of utmost importance. It doesn't only shape the club on the pitch but off the pitch as well, that includes the structure, the youth team, the PR people etc. Having no identity is dangerous. Maybe Emery could have got a draw or a narrow win if he put 11 behind the ball but then he'd be undoing all the work Wenger has done. Many coaches have won trophies but only the elite ones build empires and change the club.

Brilliant from Gary..

So Gary was right arsenal is lit atm

Who else is here after Emery was sacked and Arteta was appointed?

Thank god for Gary Neville, all other football pundits are absolute muppets.

Carragher lost the plot

love these debates

How to win an argument in the rest of world: Present valid arguments In Britain: Do your best impression of Mickey Mouse

Both Carra and Nev are right in their own way. Neville says that each team must have a set philosophy, which is coached by the manager. But Carra makes a good point when he says, a coach should be able to manage his team depending on the opposition. For example: if Man City go head to head with Liverpool they might get absolutely destroyed (which already happened once last year), but if they park the bus ,they might have a prayer. This is called managing a particular match based on the opposition. Mourinho is arguably one of the best at this.

Gary has realized through managing a team himself that being a football manager is an extremely difficult job especially at a club where the expectations are high.....U are dealing with big egos everyday so the coach must implement his ideas or else he will lose the dressing room....Give it time...the football will be beautiful at Arsenal again

Heated debate between Neville & Carragher. 2-3 weeks ago, when i listened to Carragher's opinion on "Managers have to adapt" I thought "in what way". Listening to neville, I sided with nevile's opinion though I hate to admit it. Today I re-watched this heated exchange between them & realized Jamie was correct in his explanation. Jamie voiced that top managers "must adapt" which nevile & many of the viewers myself included thought "managers must shift from football principle they believed in and start new football principles". No. Jamie meant "while managers stick with their principles, they must combine the said principles with some new tactics/techniques". Jamie never suggested that managers should abandon their principles. He suggested they must combine with some elements of football philosophies adopted by some managers. Nevile and many of the viewers who thought jamies was wrong were proved to be on the wrong side. Take for example, Pep Quardiola adapted his principle to avoid Liverpool's gegenpressing and end up with 3-0 4-0 within 30 minutes as it has happened to him in the champions and epl both last season at anfield. Liverpool ran riot in both occassions. In his documentary "All but nothing" he displayed his fear of liverpool's front three. This season at anfield, he adapted, instilled into his players some tactics to avoid liverpool running riot again. He almost won the game at anfield had Mahrez scored the 85th penalty. In this match, PEP never abandon his principles but came with adaptation plan to avoid loosing at anfield. That is what Jamie Carrager meant "managers must adapt" Second example, Jurgen Klopp adapted too. This season liverpool's gegenpressing dropped well below last season. Jurgen acknowledged issues related to hurrying & pressing for full 90 minutes. He maintained some sort of pressing instead of continued pressing. He too adapted. Klopp gave instruction to his players to which they adapted to and implemented. Nevile said "if managers adapt, it is dangerous and they will loose the dressing room with the introduction of new principles" referencing to his days as valencia manager when he tried to adapt. I agree with nevile that if manager adapts and turns 360 degree from his philosophy to a new philosophy as nevile did at Valencia, then managers are in dangerous situation. Nevile believes that players must adapt. If they can, managers made them to adapt. Jamie is 100% right that managers must adapt while sticking to their principles but combining with new tactics/philosophies to win matches and trophies. Now, as PEP & KLOPP have evolved while maintaining their footballing philosophies most managers must adapt unlike mourinho who still believes in dirty non-entertaining football "park the bus". Jamie is correct. Managers must adapt

If you're on mobile...the title doesn't fit without pressing the down arrow...Just read it

Gnev wiv the realness

It is entertaining to watch these two. They are both great and they know what they talk about usually. But this is actually funny, because each is talking about a different thing. Jamie talks about adapting and changing during a game. Gary talks about not changing the long term system... listen to each other :D

I love that as the argument intensifies, their voices goes up to match it.

It's July 2020. I'm having fun watching this.