Yeh, but has the scientist even published any scientific papers? Huh!? These kids are an embarrassment.

@@MajesticArtimus I think his wife's boyfriend is too!

Brilliant! 😂

I believe the engineers who threaten to resign when Brian tries to speak for their organizations. Deniers will want to keep that quiet so their suckers can blame censorship of him on the lizard people, when they're not too busy blaming wildfires on the space antifa space lasers from outer space.

Brian

Probably a vegan. They lack the nutrition for physical work.

Not an ounce of muscle on the guy

Bet his nickname is “soft hands”

He doesn't have to as daddy pays for everything.

Lose the beard and see his chin is the back of his head!

Mr Catt is not an expert on climate change. He is not trained as a climate scientist and has never had a scientific paper about the issue published in a scientific journal.

Yes it crediable and working in the industry is also.

Yep, ancient Egypt may have been warmer than Britain 2023 on average, literally due to latitude, but as the global average as a whole it's not possible to have been as hot as today at the time. No way in hell.

​@@lyrimetacurl0he literally said it was up to 2°C warmer at the time in the UK than it is now.

He has never published any papers. He's just an ignorant climate science denier.

he looks like a woman

the old guy battered him

@@paulrichards6894 Thats what happens when you actually put someone with knowledge against these clowns - something you will never see on the BBC. Thats why Greta got to spout here utter garbage without question because its so easily debunked.

A living example of the Dunning Kruger Effect!

Current state of majority of gen z: Impressionable and gullible. Also, a reflection of sorry state of our education indoctrination system.

It sounds like Shawn is nothing more than a megaphone for the two groups he sited. He seems he isn't willing to do his own research to discover whether what he believes is true or not. Major media here in the US are making a big deal of the recent100F plus temperatures in Phoenix AZ. Of course, they blame it on climate change. Fact is Phoenix has always had 100F plus temperatures during the summer. When I was 18 and lifeguarding at a public pool in the Phoenix area, it was 117F the entire week. So the panic talk by the lame stream media of 110F going on now is ridiculous.

Exactly, gbnews failing to do their job and get a balanced debate. Awful tabloid rubbish.

Indeed, I'd love that question bounced back at the childish numpty.

A Salary

And IGNORANCE!

They are also against hydrogen energy which I can make in my back yard to power my car (with modified injectors). It exhausts HO2, water. Japan is producing hydrogen run cars. Japan also used Ivermectin to combat covid very effectively. So, you do not have to plug in for hours using electricity 85% produced from coal. Oh, and China owns 80% of global pollution.

The globe was categorically NOT warmer during that time. 🤷‍♀️

The globe WAS categorically warmer during that time 🤷‍♀️

I daily a 4.2 V8 and my weekend toy does gallons per mile….I’m doing my bit 🤣

Me too (sorry shouldn't use that term). Me as well, and I make sure I waste as much petrol as possible rev'ing the nuts off it along the way.

Make sure to b careful if u "accidentally" run them over. Lol 🤣🤣😆😆

@@Mr_OoOsH 4.2 V8? I bet that makes a sound to warm the cockles of any petrol heads heart, poetry in motion! If I had the money I'd have a TVR Sagaris. I know the build quality is a bit "meh" but those looks, and the sound of it....yum, yum! As for dealing with the swivel eyed loons known as JSO I would favour a VERY large steam roller.

@@witsend236that’s not wasting, that’s enjoying it. I regularly do that with my GT4.

soy boy lol

He probably identifies as a unicorn.

And forced to live their days in caves especially now as I type this during severe winter weather.

😂😂😂😂😂

Yeah, but at least potatoes know how to SHUT UP.

😂😂😂😂😂😂

Now that's an insult to potatoes

Underrates comment

🤡 🎪 🛢

fry little piggy's fry

​@@President_NotSureI encourage you to be the first of the 8 billion to help towards depopulation. Just stop using all energy resources and food that comes from it.... duhhhhh

@@President_NotSure What device to you use to resort to insults ? What was used to manufacture it ... trees ? Haha

@@President_NotSure Gobshite

‘Their’

Spell check you maron... @@sicilianotoronto

Je hebt gelijk, je reactie bewijst het maar weer.

@@regenen Het is moeilijk voor een lege zak om rechtop te staan.

also he was saying (activist) : most of the scientists . bruh nice source what sort of scientist would be as dumb as that lol

@@kalashydra9016 "most of the scientists" is an appeal to authority. Also he's referring to the IPCC which is a political organisation. These activists don't understand science, they just repeat the dogma that everyone agrees with them, without actually looking at the data.

@@rutgerhoutdijk3547 exactly thats what i mean hes full of shit lol . lyterali no source to his claims

There needs to be another Munk type debate on climate alarmism. These alarmists are creating an alternative pseudo 'scientific ' world to make their case. This needs to be debunked in a public forum.

@@deryk2002au exactly this. One can't help but assume that the choice of opponent for Catt in this case was chosen for the sake of ratings and red hot television rather than to further a genuine scientific understanding of facts.

What did the JSO bloke say, specifically, that was "deranged nonsense"? Pick one of his points and argue against it factually.

@@andyknowles772 He didn't actually say anything besides appeal for authority. His strongest argument: "Do you disagree with IPCC and with X million scientists? How dare you?" He knows nothing about the subject, he has no plan to propose except some nonsense that won't work but talking about it makes him feel better, and that is really what JSO is all about

@@utility00 yes and it's ok to appeal to authority....what the 'scientist' did was even worse.... Oh the IEA, ISPCC, climate scientists....I quote...they don't know what they are talking about...and by this guy's own admission he has been in industry....he gave no argument either just appealed to his own authority by baselessly saying they didn't know what they are talking about...based on because he says so.... A paid shill at best, malignant narcissist at worst Imagine if a plumber came round your house and you started telling them how to do their job because they didn't know what they were talking about because you knew better because.....you worked in an unrelated industry....I mean come on....

@@andyknowles772 I think it's deranged to be so fanatical about a subject where you only can rely on other people's opinions. It's like a cult.

Ironically Shell invests more in renewable energy than the UK does.

Exactly what I thought his glasses likely his shoes watch etc ... another bellied who wants to be seen and heard regardless of the BS he spouts

add jewellery, l bet his t shirt is cotton not much cotton grown in the UK, a walking advert for the term hypocrite

He looks like a right turniphead. That head needs replanting in a field.

Correct I was thinking the exact same thing lol he needs to sit there in a hemp bag

I made a list too😂 such a pain to see these not wanting to work people truing to make a living out of protests and government that they claim should not exist

No. he didn't! He just made unfounded claims and waffled on. You're a scientist are you?

@@edeledeledel5490 no i'm an engineer and your in need of a elementary elementary science class. this time PASS!!!!!!!!

​@@sgtbrown4273are you really an engineer? Just looking at the latest IEA and LAZARD which this 'scientist' quotes and nuclear is no where near the cheapest as he 'claimed' it's actually the single most expensive. So he's just a flat out liar...surely an engineer in a relevant field who passed would know this???!

Another fact these fuels are not made from fossils, the Earth makes oil and gas continuously, calling it fossil implied finite and pushed the prices right up in the early days when they were not worth tuppence

@@sgtbrown4273 I have A-levels in Physics, Chemist and Maths, and a physics degree, and was a qualified engineer with 40 years experience, so I am not in need of two elementary science classes, thank you. You are need of some common sense. Why do you think you know more that most climate scientists and indeed most scientists in general. Are you a lathe operator; they often think they are engineers?

Solarpanels and windturbines + 🔋 bank... 😊

​@@mikafiltenborg7572LOL! Whatta load of 🐂💩!

​@@mikafiltenborg7572do you actually think this is an answer?

So you mean to tell us that at one point, when fossil fuels are depleted, we just devolve as a society and stop using electricity?

@@regenenwe have hundreds of years worth of oil for the whole planet, the day we run out of oil we would already have made the switch to using more nuclear

SPOILT BRATT MUMMY and DADDY'S have never said NO TO SEAN EVER👍👍

They're a Marxist outfit...the kind of people who would close your bank account (and your family's) if you show any dissent if they had the power. Gulags awaiting new customers! 🙂

"democratic" That would explain why there's no-one to vote for who DOESN'T support the green nonsense.

@terencegumbs2478 Now do government

Those who demand, don't get.

Yes his benefit claims forms, 😂 which will be paid for by taxes gained from those using fossil fuels. Just stop oil are HYPOCRITES .

He's more than likely on benefits.

no but i bet he reads the guardian

He printed off a few propaganda leaflets on his gaming p.c. , does that count ?

There he said it , " It's all made in models , not real " !! Jeez , thank God Ferguson isn't doing the modelling , we'd all be fried by Tuesday ??

Or brainwashed. Just like many others who do not protest.

@@MisterHowzat ... if they had even an average IQ they should be able to work out how ridiculous their claims are ... they live in a ideological fantasy world

@@pablorages1241 And then they'd point out that "97% of scientists agree that...."

​@@MisterHowzat Science isn't determined by polling. At one time 99% of scientists believed the sun rotated around the earth and the earth was flat. Also that poll just asked them if they believed in climate change nothing about anthropogenic global warming.

@@PHUCKyoutube689 You need to read all the comments above to get the flow of the logical progression. I was referring to the alarmists, that THEY, not I, would point out that 97% of scientists agree. I was being sarcastic, making my case against the alarmists.

Probably wasn’t breast fed I think.

Why are ALL of these "protestors" so odd and geeky looking?? I think they're just angry and jealous.

@@slartybartfast5368 He was, by his father.

I would love to know how these protesters get to and from the locations where they protest….. Car? Bus? Train? I bet it’s not bloody walking!!!!! How do they get their shopping? Drop their kids at school? Visit parents, friends or relations? all the things that they F@#£ UP for other people…. Do they use fossil fuels? Every day of their lives they do… double standard hypocrites, every bloody one of them.

Prime example of vegetarianism too.

And a dangerous one

Cult

Yes JSO have all the hallmarks of a cult. Minions repeating the same emotional rhetoric and a creepy old man at the top, pulling the strings

@@jackdeniston59 .... am thinking you made a "typo" there Jack??? Just askin'!

9 volt is a bit generous.

That's dropped to 8.5 volts.

dynamo i reckon. using a hamster....

How about a solar panel on a rainy day in October?

Love this

Almost the correct way is to withhold their allowance and make them get a job and learn some responsibility

No, I highly have to disagree on that. They want to live in a world where they have to grow their own food by hand in the fields with lots of physical laybor. No electricity, transportation, medicine or grocery stores etc.. Just make them live in their dream world!

@@uwejacobs6587 Well, we both know that is never going to happen... :) Behavioral science tells us that just like training an animal, you "ignore to extinguish" bad behaviors.

He advocates for more slavery in Africa to make new batteries for Europeans.

@@uwejacobs6587Did you see the arms on the activist? He’d struggle to open a bag of Doritos!

And his sandle n socks family 🙄

Sean the sheep 🐑

Destroyed in minutes, loved it :-)

What they do is say “since records began” which only goes back generally to the 1800s where global average temps could start to be recorded so it’s a massive play on words to fit their narrative.

Catt is a charlatan. He is clueless on climate science.

Watch how mainstream attack him now to discredit him.

A climate skeptic who represents the less than 1% of scientists who deny climate change. Finding someone like this to shill to an audience of gullible, ignorant fools is called confirmation bias.

@@dam8087 There are a foolish few people that totally deny climate change, it does change obviously as it always has but, I have never heard a scientist outright deny that change.I have heard 3% of the Worlds scientists shilling to an audience of gullible,ignorant fool's with confirmation bias that humans are the primary cause of that change while ignoring the fact that there was little human industrial activity when the weather was doing the same as it is now.

There are many, but from the beginning of this scam, they have been ignored and silenced by the charlatans who are making money out of this nonsense.

A butter knife 😂😂😂😂😂

Called useful idiots

We are still in the holocene and our temps should match the others. Its just that our holocene isnt lasting as long as the others did. We will be coming into a cold period soon enough when enough polar ice has melted. But im far more concerned about the magnetic pole shift which is picking up speed.

You misspelled most it is a l l

During the 70's and early 80's they were warning us about a new ice age

@@richardgutermuth2043Yup, and it was all “Game over” by 2000…..and yet….here we are and nothing has changed! Well at least the climate nutbags made “Prince” famous…”🎶 two thousand zero zero its party over were out of time…..so tonite im gonna party like its 1999🎶” 🤣😂🤣😂

They are a cult. Their mantra, which they repeat incessantly, is their entire preparation.

You can't teach pork!

Does anyone know where this "hottest" June day ever (since the last one) was actually recorded? I've yet to hear any facts about this claim , just anecdotal bolox.

This knob head has already been publicly kneecapped .. totally unprepared with no evidence or facts... 😂

No one has ever said `no` to these self entitled idiots.A good slap needed.

Aye, if they are going to preach and dictate to us "climate deniers", perhaps they should lead the way and stup using anything in society that is oil derived in any way shape or form...be fun to see how far they get.

Useful idiots for the WEF. Soros is probably paying him.

Do as they say not as they do ....😅

Their chauffeur drives them in mom and dad's McClaren

Perhaps they all travel to the protests on horse back🙄

@@janeboardman5289 but the horse farts ,will somebody do some thing about the horse farts ?🤣🤣🤣

If polled I suspect they all support unlimited immigration. No matter what country (1). Which logically increases the total energy usage. Plus puts extra strain on the water and waste services. Plus increases total food denands. Including distribution systems. 1) I live in the US and l am surprised we haven't seen our own home grown nutters doing this. But then they have other causes of the month or year to get excited about.

Yep if you’re gonna undermine someone at least come prepared and do your research on the person before the debate. I wouldn’t be surprised if Just Stop kick this guy out, they act like a cult anyway

Bet he speaks it Sean aswel completely wrong, anybody who spells there name Sean rather than shaun can't be trusted. 😂

"...a breath of fresh air." Well, THAT would be a welcome situation, Pete.

Why are you listening to a physicist handpicked by GB news over the thousands and thousands of climate scientists contradicting this guy?

He's talking nonesense. There is enough capacity in the national grid even if everyone transitioned to using electric cars. In fact, right now the percentage of the capacity we're using is well below that of a few decades ago. And the more people have solar panels and wind turbines on their houses, the more that's gonna reduce as well. Furthermore the vast majority of electric cars get charged overnight when nobody is using electricity anyway, so it's really not going to be a burden on the grid at all. I don't know what nonesense he was saying about digging up transformers in back gardens. Finally, you can quite comfortably power every country in Europe with about a thousand square miles of solar panels in the Sahara desert. So I don't know the nonesense he was talking about running out of renewable energy. It's just not true. What kind of physicist is he? He must have got some significant investment in the fossil fuel industries

There are actually loads like him. The ambassadors of science and many other scientists and proffesionals are requesting and open debtae with the man made climate change scientists, who refuse to accept.

@@marioluigi9599 Thank goodness....a sensible comment...where do all the idiots come from?....hope they haven't got kids.......

Nice to know that you know more about it than most of the thousands of climate scientists in the world. Good for you! You must be very smart and well-informed.

@@edeledeledel5490 You lose your argument when you resort to invective.

​@@edeledeledel5490Thousands of climate scientists? Gretha Tumberg? Just think for a second, all of these climate scientists.... Who funds them? Any vested interest in certain results? Bare in mind most of what you hear is from MSM reporting on global elites who have paid a group of Scientists make a report. These reports are never the same except for the fact we always have 5 to 10 years "left". There ate many Scientists whom haven't sold themselves and when they want to report, they get silenced. For example I bet you didn't know the Polar ice caps are growing not shrinking. Growing in the West, shrinking in the East but a net growth over all as the growth is bigger than the loss. Discovered recently but the elites don't seem keen to make it public knowledge. Had it have been shrinking, front page news everywhere for weeks, I'm sure. Place where temperatures are recorded (which is used to build computer models) are cherry picked. Some places on Earth are heating, others are cooling. Guess which are used. A scientist recently published his 20 years work recording temperatures across the globe using satellite. This meant he recorded everything, not just the parts he thought would yield the results he wanted. He found the Earth is warming up on the whole, but not at the rates we are being told they are. He published the work on his website and the website was blocked on Google for inaccurate climate science. 20 years. Satellites. Inaccurate lol. Anyway I'm rambling now, it's late and if my grammar is a mess I apologise but you should look this stuff up rather than just being told "Scientists say..."

​@@edeledeledel5490~ Okay then, please list the names of every single one of these so-called "majority of scientists" you speak of and who exactly they all work for. I'll be waiting thx. 🇨🇦

Just tell me where the glaciers went.

A GB News viewer talking about facts is hilarious

@@dam8087cope harder

​@@owendavies9141science denial is some sad shit boy

@@dam8087 Ignoring what the WEF,UN and WHO are aiming to do is much sadder.

@@dam8087 you should know! Off you pop now muffin

No he doesn't. His qualifications aren't relevant and he's wrong. Google him, he's been debunked before.

@@backfromcuba Ice core samples completely destroy the climate change scam, it's why you pedos ignore it. C02 is plant food and at the lowest levels ever.

Catt is a charlatan. Now wonder he is on GB "News".

@@TOM-TOM-TOM Precisely.

​@@backfromcubaby who?? Corrupt bought and paid for "fact checkers" or bought and paid for scientists??

Yep, then we could talk about the minerals used in ev cars, lithium batteries, solar panels, what wind turbines are made of - you can look at the entire process of 'green energy' and see what a joke it is but these people aren't told that and they are too stupid or ignorant to bother researching it.

You cannot make steel without coal.

​@@Leeds71agreed, friend. To evaluate if it's good or bad for the planet you need all of the facts. I'm fed up of these do gooders not taking the time to do due diligence research.

I suspect the UN dropped net Zero because they realised they could wipe out people even more efficiently by starting wars.

​@@michealmccannnot coal exactly it's coke and if you make every vehicle out of lithium ion battery do you know how much fresh and pure water is needed.if they really want to decrease CO2 emissions on planet only way to increase O2 levels is by maintaining Ocean's clean and healthy

Your pigeon analogy is excellent but incomplete, when you play chess with a pigeon he will knock all the pieces over, shit all over the board and then claim victory. You missed out the all important shit part.

​@@keithwilliams1243😂😂😂 nice.

I was waiting for someone to ask him that, but they didn't

Really, it did not need to be asked. He looked stupid anyway.

Probably as many as Catt has, ie zero.

Err none!

@@wundurra24 Catt said he has published papers

He probably threw a tantrum on his way out. No doubt mummy will be there to soothe her little soldier.

Imagine being this gullible

I completely agree . And then I'm sure that every eco/ climate activist has a cell phone, a washing machine , a PC , most of them have a car or a moto or the use public transportation ... their speech is full of pathos and their behaviour is simply patethic

​@@chadleywinnetsya imagine being so gullible and dumb that you think humans are responsible for the climate and must sacrifice basic needs and animals so government can "fix it" while also having no solution to replacing what you want removed.

Utter balderdash. Brian Catt is not an expert on climate change. He is not trained as a climate scientist and has never had a scientific paper about the issue published in a scientific journal. He has an upper second class Bachelor’s degree in Physics and a Master’s degree in Business Administration. It also indicates he is a Chartered Engineer and a Chartered Physicist (which is awarded by the Institute of Physics, an organisation that accepts the overwhelming evidence for anthropogenic climate change), but his CV does not list any formal experience or qualifications in climate science since he started his career in 1965. What Catt lacks in credentials he tries to make up for with strong opinions about climate change, a combination that apparently makes him an ideal interviewee for GB News and Talk TV.

Yes please but where do we have a space big enough to put them in

Well said!!

Sure. But, only if we bring back caning for those children who refuse to listen or do as their told.

@@silverfang6869 The ocean, help the sharks and it's plenty big!

Came here for this comment.

"ignorant upstarts with little or no credibility" - indeed, but why do these blighters have the ear of so many in positions of power, and influence of the decision-makers - it beggars belief! It is as though the medical profession were being asked to defer to witch-doctors.

Brian didn't even have to change out of first gear to show this twerp up.

yes

These types never debate in good faith. They tantrum and refuse to acknowledge the people who oppose them

How do the Stop Oil muppets get to the location of there protests????? I bet they don’t walk.

Mo, enough of this fake junk science. These activists need to be slapped, gitmo, and exq2ted.

Yea but they would not let the the people who know get a word in they would be shouting over the people of knowledge

@@davidc9171 Then they would be forced to shut up and listen.

The only 'crisis' is the one being self inflicted by the Western governments. None of this has anything to do with ' saving the planet ' The planet will do nicely on its own 😁

The IPCC are just another undemocratic NGO ( lackies of the biggest NGO, the UN. Their publications are NOT by scientists but are their interpretation of what some scientists say.

IPCC panel has 75% climate activists with no scientific qualifications relevant to climate. They are mostly mathematicians and psychologists. UN is similarly totally in awe of climate change. If you read in depth about climate change only about 18% of scientists are wholly in favour of this hysterical view regarding climate change and CO2, the vast majority are neither on one side or the other and have serious doubts. It was interesting to read that in a survey of scientists by IPCC it removed all those who expressed the view totally against climate change and included those that were undecided as a for vote. hence the fallacy that 97% of scientists agree with climate change. As someone else said, 97% is not a consensus it is dogma.

@@Goldenlion148 the scientific consensus is not 97%, it's 100%. Scientists round the world check each other's papers like the rest of us would spend our 'me time' keeping our wits sharp with a strategy game or a cross word. There's no good news, the 3% turned out to have one or more of the same few errors that became well known and easily spotted. As for the rest of what you've said, the IPCC is very big, it needs statisticians to correlate it. If psychologists are qualified statisticians then that's all well and good, the old school like Freud and Jung were too anecdotal and gave clients no protection against pseudo science with a lower recovery rate than no therapy at all. Your self-qualifying 'if you read in depth' cliché did make me laugh; it doesn't qualify a statistic and it was a prelude to a preposterous lie so I'm grateful for that even though your lies disgust me. It's a classic.

7 stone wet through, total whimp.

That's because it grows longer telling made up LIES 🤔🤔🤔🤔

What a great idea.Put Judith Curry in the mix too!

Sterilise them all

He isn't a Professor. His facts were mostly wrong or misleading. He is a strong supporter and member of "The Global Warming Policy Foundation" an organisation founded by Nigel Lawson, right-wing Tory, Chancellor under Margaret Thatcher. IT DOES NOT REVEAL ITS FUNDING SOURCES! I wonder which fossil fuel lobbyists provide the money!

What about compulsory Prof Catt videos in every school in Britain to even up the brain washing that our children are suffering from every day.

Absolutely correct they talk about Tipping points, stoping extraction of oil before we have real world solutions to power the world would be a un-recoverable Tipping Point.

Would most likely result in the end of the world as we know it

I think they know, but they HATE humanity, and to them a couple of billion people starving to death is nothing.

The loss of plastics alone would have a devastating impact on civilisation worldwide.

yeah, farmers should be making sure their vehicles can run on vegetable oils etc. Only half of humanity's food gets caught and foraged in the wild these days.