Correct, Beethoven called it a sonata for piano and violin, piano 1st!

Except when it's Yuja Wang accompanying the sonata, then people go salivate to her video.

@@musical_lolu4811 She is just too powerful. I just wish Joshua Bell the same.

shut up lol we're here to hear how the violinist is gonna play the sonata, that's the main expression

@@cantkeepitin ñqññpp⁰⁰⁰⁰⁰⁰⁰⁰⁰0⁰⁰⁰⁰ñ1ññññ¹ñq¹11¹¹¹¹

Angelo Ortiz For me it's the opposite, classical music drove me to shigatsu wa kimi no uso...

I've seen it too haha, I like animes, but I wouldn't have watched SWKNU if I didn't love classical music

Same as a Classical Musician the music drove me to watch it. I appreciated every aspect of it to the beautifully played notes due to my own experience as a Violinist of 10 years started playing at the young age of 5. This piece in particular caught my attention and I plan to either play this (well part of it) or In regards to love Eros for my Final for Orchestra at the end of the year and play it in the fine arts days at my school.

I've been a fan of Classical Music since I watched FMAB and FMAB introduced me to Akira Senju, thus opening my ears to Orchestral Music and Epic Music. Afterwards, I watched Shigatsu Wa Kimi No Uso since I like violin and piano already. The anime widened my horizon to more Classical Music pieces.

Angelo Ortiz and the anime itself is a masterpiece people gotta open their minds

Agree and I'm currently watching it rn

lmao sameeee

s a m e

I was just a normal classical fan and then I started hearing about this anime about music

@@octave11thpianist58 literally same

Hello there

@@dylankwong1512 General Kenobi

@@generalkenobi8994 You are a bold one :)

The magician KZfaq brought me here and I´m enjoying

Two set violin brought me here!

+Nikhil Hogan Get this guy to the top, people. This some useful information

Nikhil Hogan

Definitely!!! Let's get you to the top bro!!

The first one sounds more like agitato than adagio to me though.

Thank you! :)

Both are hard. Try to be at the same volume as a piano beside you without being muffled.

Coming from a violinist… They’re both incredibly difficult…

It's true, the sonata really fits good with the anime. I love the sonata a lot and i remember that back when i heard it in the anime i was so happy that they put my at the time fav sonata in the anime :) The only unlogical thing abt it is that the girl is only 14 while playing this (at this level of skill).

As a fellow classical music nerd, thanks for posting this, im not into anime but an anime about a violinist where they use beautiful sonatas like this one just might get me

Yuh

I finished rewatching YLiA yesterday. I couldn't agree more.

Me too Kaori and Kousei brought me here

Kate Royall cool, but painful

Yes, seems like hell

anarchy0209 shoulder rest is actually optional and a lot of performers don’t use it

@@verybratsche9467 yeah I know a lot of people don't use them but she's really good at controlling her shifting, tone, vibrato, and keeping the violin up.

@@verybratsche9467 I know that, it was just that for me it always felt very uncomfortable ....

It's Tolstoy's words, really.

are this really true words by Beethoven? or just made up by the film makers?

How did beethoven replied while he was deaf srsly...

Özgür Doğan Arslan schindler wrote his words down on a notepad.

hyponoticism is a word anachronistic for both Beethoven and Tolstoy, ain't it?

ysaye 3

bach violin sonata 2 is the best. change my mind.

KZfaq Handel-Halvorsen - Passacaglia - Jascha Heifetz, Gregor Piatigorsky

Who wouldn't be impressed? Kreutzer. Hated it. Refused to play it.

It's a shame that the man for which this piece was originally named ,is not even thought of today . George Bridgetower, here's to you!

Here ✌️

Definitely

Here!! I'm not a musician but I love watchng their videos(twoset❤). Also a weeb

It's all about the fingering. Much of Beethoven's phrasing follows "hand positioning" rather than "finger sequences".

The piano is actually the featured instrument not the violin. Sad that people don’t get this.

​@@coralreef909there is not such thing as the "featured instrument", all people who played even one of Beethoven's violin sonatas know these are actually violin AND piano sonatas

Same here.

Same here

Same

ME TOO

I SWEAR!!

Kathreen Guiang nabakov brought me here

Mee too lol 😂

@@izhan6991 its a reference to something

me too

@@Aaron-tp4ke To the movie "Immortal Beloved" his frustration

pacdbz Well he did it quick

Right?? I feel like page turning is a skill in itself 😂

i memorize a whole piece because i hate turning pages and not talented in it 🧑🏻‍🦯

13:57 too

George Bridgetower (not Hightower)

Bridgewater. He made an unpleasant comment about a woman in Beethoven's presence and Beethoven was appalled, and removed the dedication there and then.

Ludwig van Beethoven! *You have failed this history!* (Or, at least someone has.)

@@cazc.8626 Ooooh, intersectionality strikes again! Who are you going to root for? The oppressive white (presumably) woman, or the sexist black man? The drama, the intrigue, the suspense!

@@lauraandrews1676 wtf? Shutup.

4:10

Thank you!!!!

🙋🏼‍♂️

Here. It's a fantastic piece.

Here

Yup

You are supposed to be practicing

usually only the soloist gets attention

Me too!

same here! :D

And also the readers with Tolstoi´s book..... I´m part of all.

Yeah, rewatching Your Lie In April imo d i d get pretty boring. It was pretty interesting when I watched the series for the first time but when rewatching it, I kinda found myself skipping through a bunch because it just wasn’t as interesting as I remember it to be. :/

;op 4 You must’ve missed what most people who’ve watched the series remember the most/made the largest impact

Straddllw agreed who doesn't love your lie in april

***** I find it interesting what paths lead people to a piece like this. Will check out Kimi no Uso.

Straddllw Shame on you.

Me too :(

+Celui qui s'intéresse Piano Sure, new people getting interested in classical pieces is such a bad thing....

Tostaky Panda Gamer me

Same

Agreed

actually kinda yes i always see people in comments saying how it brought them to anime so i was thinking i would give it a try too if there is so good music

I don't care where you came from, just appreciate it.

@@noakinn I also play piano and I was interested in classical and romantic music before the anime...but it doesn't matter if I like this or not, if I would be new to this kind of music it would be an amazing feat to just check it out based on the anime.

Nice, short story time ... my wish, I could play some pieces (like those from Your lie in April anime, but also others, like now from Carole and Tuesday) casually, brought me to begin learning the piano four weeks ago ... and learning the piano brought me to TwoSetViolin (their videos actually keep me from practicing), cos there is no way, to miss their videos, as soon, as you begin looking for playing classical instruments. But well, here I'm mostly, cos, as a fact, since I began learning the piano, my interest in classical music has grown. Even if this piece is, for someone, learning solo on the piano, not so interesting (at least not for playing and even less after 4 weeks learning ;)).

Who?

@@papikabron18 Two youtubers, check out their channel, TwoSetViolin

Now i am reading and listening :)

The alternating quiet, gentle and loud, passionate sections describe well their relationship in the story. Periods of love followed by periods of hate and anger.

Tolstoy's novella took me here too although I used to listen to this sonata a lot at one time.

EXACTLY!! ME TOO!! I'M SO EXCITED!!😍😍😍😍

Finally, a person of culture!!! Tolstoy’s short story wasn’t what brought me here (I’m a violinist, and this sonata is a staple of our repertoire), but the fact that you know it even exists and that you enjoy it makes me feel so happy!!! So often I find people who don’t even know who Leo Tolstoy is these days🤦🏻‍♂️

We’re 8 years later, did you manage to play it?

YES

your lie in April didn't compose this. don't thank them.

Ik

They mean, thank you for letting me know this exists.

Hahaha

Me too

Same, I've heard of this piece before but it was a different recording. This one is much better than the one I listened to.

Roma Balagtas i here because of whom Beethoven dedicated this piece to

Roma Balagtas too

For what and how much?

Same!

Me too

+Joseph Sonners Absolutely. The early editions of this work describe it as a "Sonata for piano-forte and obbligato Violin" and also use the title "Grand Sonata".

There's been a fair amount written about this great Mutter/Orkis collaboration in all their performances. Orkis is not too shabby for a man with working class roots!

There's a lot more like it; give yourself a break and seek it out.

That’s what I said 🤣🤣🤣

Hahah idk...maybe you watched a lot of America Got Talent videos lol jk

Clapping during the performance is unacceptable.

@@sun-wo9vp agreed 😌

I did, at home.

im dying

Dude same😂

So basically you have the power to kill nearby birds.

pigön

Salutes to you

Me too

Thank you... *sobs*

Same, this sonata is fascinating

Undoubtedly one of the most significant masterpieces of this genre.

Michael Billimoria are you kidding???? That's unbelievable

Hace mucho la escuche tomando LSD y e

Hace muuuucho lla escuche tomando LSD y de ttan hermosa no podia dejar d llorar

I'm so pleased you liked it.

Is it something I am supposed to understand?

Chan The Epic What do you mean? He's simply brilliant!

There are some obnoxious people who comment on Google.

ble

For five years in the mid nineties I lived and worked in New Haven CT, basically surrounded by the Yale Campus. Every day I walked through the buildings of the music school there, past, I believe Stoekel Hall, or sum-such. It was a small recital hall and there were (free) performances there every day that classes were in. One day I saw the Kreutzer Sonata posted on the board, to be done by two old members of the faculty. It was the only time I ever saw this done live. White haired men. The violinist broke a string in the first movement and compensated and continued to play brilliantly and with absolute passion.

Mark Orenchuk cool story bro

I think this is true onky for the 1st movement.

Why did you stop saying it? You were perfectly right. I say, however, and have said for a few months now, that Mendelssohn's Sextet is the greatest piece of music ever written in Western History. And I'm perfectly right. And will be until I encounter another favorite.

Then you should be PRACTICING

+James Haynes Tolstoy's Kreutzer Sonata is a must read.

+James Haynes I seriously doubt that Beethoven's thoughts regarding this powerful music were at all like those in the macabre imagination of Tolstoy.

I just finished the novella, and it's how I found the sontata. I find that this music does really weird things to me, especially in context of the story. I feel just like Pozdnyshev in his daze after listening to it.

"Dissonant"?

Bj Coch To wit: LACK of HUNT

Whom?

no dont be like that ill cry😢

Of course it did...

:3 Comment was on the spot

God damn.

I don't get it. There is plenty of emotion in the playing

I'm a classical musician and have just started watching it. And it's really good

Yeah, I began with Mozart, and brought me to Him, now I am here always

😂😂💗

Thanks