In life, dance like nobody's watching, text like they will all be read out in court someday 😂

"He's Chip. He's Bear...." He's a liar extraordinaire....

The fact that Lally on re-direct implied "You sent those messages because she was guilty right?" shows me he also has no integrity. They are prosecuting a woman because she shamed all of them. They thought she would just roll over.

Can I listen to 4 more hours after Emily's 7 hour stream earlier today? You bet I can. Let's goooo lol

Bit rich of him to joke about someone's "balloon knot" when his name is pretty much the word/prefix referring to that very same anatomy. Yo, Procto! Yer fecked.

Would have loved to see Yannetti do the cross, but look at him. He's practically seething. Good call for this to be Jackson.

3:41:32. Ms Read is nearly laughing. When the Defendant is smiling and enjoying herself at the Prosecution witness's answers you know the witness is having a seriously shitty day.

I think he kept his phone because he didn’t think he was implicated by the initial crime, Higgins the Alberts and Macabes knew they were implicated so they got rid of theirs.

THIS will be spicy! IMO, Proctor has no reason to be that indignant about being called out by Yanetti. Not after we've listened to all the texts. No previous sanctions does not mean that this is new behaviour. Also, will add timestamps later. 00:00:00 Intro 00:04:50 Today will be allll about Trooper Proctor. (also, demonetization) 01:05:40 The definition of integrity 01:21:30 Nope, Proctor does not know the McCabes, and does not have a relationship with the Alberts! WTF! 02:01:30 Not asking for a gift … or at least not for himself🙄 02:26:20 Motive, means and opportunity 02:40:20 The autopsy report - and more texts 03:04:00 Canton PD and Kevin Albert (whom Trooper Proctor did absolutely not know!) Also, more opinions from me: People with Crohns or other IBS-diseases will react HARD. As a woman with heavy periods, I have bled through my clothes, and I am not unique, so the effect on at least some of the 10 women on the jury? Whoee! Listening to Proctor making fun of such humiliating experiences? Makes me furious. Female jurors may not realise WHY they have a visceral reaction, but they probably will have one. (that’s what they call inherent bias, isn’t it?)

Procter lied in saying that he wasn't referring to the ME as a whack job. He said whack job right when they were talking about the ME not following what they wanted. Direct lie

Proctor got everything he earned from Jackson.

Yanettis reaction to Proctors answers were amazing. He definitely would be too hot to do the cross. Jackson did pretty good. And I loved the "shame on you" at the end 🤌

I am glad this is being televised and he is being exposed. Police have all the power and people are defenseless when in custody. How dare you Mr. Proctor? Your wife and children will see this. Way to make them proud.

I was hit by a car going about 25 miles an hour (I think, I’m not 100% sure how fast. It was 10 years ago) and I can tell you, I was a walking bruise from head to toe for about 3 weeks. Even a small bump to the body like they are claiming, would be a massive bruise. I actually was lucky because the women hit the back tire of bike I was on first. So some of the force was actually absorbed by the bike before it went to me. So one could argue I was hit with even less force than 25MPH and I was still a walking mood changing ring for basically a whole month. I literally did a full 360 degree flip in the air and somehow landed on my feet. The woman in front of the driver who hit me stopped and the first thing she said to me when she ran up was, “oh my god I thought you were dead. You got clobbered” the cop who showed up on scene was flabbergasted I didn’t have any broken bones.

He keeps talking about all the evidence they have. Too bad that seems to be secret or invisible evidence since we haven`t heard it in 23 days of trial. I have no idea what happened. Did she accidentally hit him? Did someone else? Was he beat up? No clue. But there`s so much reasonable doubt and zero proof that she did anything at all. For drunk driving charges, probably guilty but so are all the other people involved including he cops

Oh they definitely made her the only suspect, even if the Alberts/mcabes didn’t do it they def decided to take the heat off by making sure KR was going down for it by day one.

I am living for Karen's expressions today.

I have officially lost my ability, at least for this trial, to accept anything said by the prosecution's witnesses (civilian and most police) as accurate and relevant. I would contemplate a law suit against the CW for damages, but since I live in the CW (NOT Canton) such a lawsuit would be detrimental to my income.

"The mating call of the honest cop" 🤣🤣🤣 That floored me

"I don't recall either of us being intoxicated" That bad, huh?

Your dementia comment is particularly funny to me. I work with a lot of individuals that have neurological conditions and this trial has been a great way to engage them. Especially if they used to live in MA.

'I did not have relations with that woman' blast from the past if you know you know.

Just imagine how much simpler this case would be if all the cops were wearing BODYCAMS at the scene, and while handling evidence (like taking her car into custody), and each time they returned to the scene to look for - and find - the tail light pieces etc. There'd be a hell of a lot fewer questions we have to ask and never know the truth about.

I don't know if every single one of the convictions where he was the lead investigator get questioned they may have to let him go or force him out of the field because they just can't use him as a witness after this

As a neuroscientist, I NEED a brain worm hoodie! 😂

Hiya Ian, Your commentary is spot on. I was taking a sip of tea when you said the "...his hair had more integrity than himself..." made me chuckle and a much needed in this horrific travesty of a clown show. Ta very much.🙋🏼‍♀️

I would have liked the lawyer to ask " You always make so many jokes about the deaths you investigate?"

Proctor: I never french kissed the Alberts.

Something seems off when police officers do not record formal interviews in this day and age.

Rewatch here: from Massachusetts and I am ashamed these MSP represent my state.

At the start of this whole thing, I was liking Yanetti's performance more than Jackson's, but that's changed - Jackson is an absolutely **fantastic** actor.

Looks like Karen Reed isn't the only one with a leaky balloon knot. Except in Michael Proctor's case, it's located much higher on his persons than his rear.

My son is a Marine and I have an extra Christmas tree that I decorate with just lights and crayons. He thinks it funny.

He always said we had in absolute proof she was guilty but he never said why. Just that there were tail light pieces found where he was. And by what the Albert's said. Incontrovertible truth??

Know vs relationship reminds me of Amber Heard pledge vs donate

Watching Proctor is like watching a slow motion train wreck.

These guys are definitely a young old boys club. Bet they still wear their varsity letter jackets

A work colleague’s parents decided to call their son Richard Head. Well he changed his first name to Peter ‘cos we all know what Richard can be shortened to. 😂

Honestly, the while situation with Higgins and the defendent, the select extracted text messages, and the disposal of the phone seem to point to more concerns there than towards Karen.

The one circumstance in which I would not choose the bear

4:13:24. "Shame on you sir". Judge "disregard" Look at the girl front row in the pattern top. She is nodding her head to the lawyer's comment. If that is close to what the Jury is feeling, the Prosecution's case is toast.

How many times did I watch the end of this cross so I could see the reaction of every visible person in the gallery? Yes

"bird, Whitey, and Doc." sound like a gang Snow White would form.

Lololol, I’m usually able to just listen while getting ready but today the super chats are offering so many funny comments I keep stopping to read the screen. From people’s funny initials to what Runkle’s name might mean in other languages, etc. This case has been rough so I really appreciate the humor. ❤

Thanks for all your coverage! It has been amazing. Totally enjoyed you on STS National!!!

3:48:00. The girl in the pattern top is giving the witness some serious side eye and foot taps. She is not happy.

Campaigning for a "brainworms" graphic with a 'Tremors' style image! It's a must!

3:30:06 I fell asleep with the show. Not because it’s boring but because I’m old. And this morning I found part to be better than coffee 🤣🤣🤣 well done Runkle!

I'm so programmed, like one of Pavlov's dogs, to hear "absolutely not" and immediately make a mental note they're lying. Lol. Not sure if it's a local colloquialism... but this trial alone makes me hear it as lies. 😅

“Awww…muffin.” 😅😂

❤ In the Courtroom: people on the left side are Karen Read family and friends, straight forward are John O'Keefe family and friends except for the top row, its the journalists, first row seats, to the right side are his brother and far left his mother and some times his father, brother and father have had a change of body expression since the first week, when they looked angry at Karen, now not so much ❤

I love listening to your analysis.

3:19:53 Living for this binder. It's very pleasing to see, and I'm glad they brought one for Bev, too.

Replay crew - I will probably comment a million times. But firsts, I absolutely LOVE every time you say aw muffin 🤣☠️🤣

I've been waiting to hear from you on this trial day. ❤

"I don't care for yanneti" aged like milk 😂

I had to watch this again to hear your insight

I was looking for this yesterday!

Ooooh description says extra spicy. Can't wait!

"The mating call of an honest cop." This is my Quote of the Year!

Gotta love how Jackson "proctored Proctor." I wonder if the proctoring of Proctor produced any polyps for biopsy.

Jen McCabe said she asked if she could delete stuff and they said she could 😂

Am I the only one who thinks TP looks a bit like Voldemort?

Cheers Runkle, your humour cracks me up 😂😂😂

yeah, I found all the plastic and white over 18 days after it had been all blown away first of all with the air blowers nothing was showing then they come back days later with rakes and shovels said they got everything and then your detective comes up three different times after those other teams of detectives watch shoulder to shoulder with shovels and rakes, digging all the way down to the groundto find more pieces of plastic. Who are they trying to throw under the bus the entire team that went before them or him for lying and planting pieces that he obtained through that he deleted from the ring camera

QUESTION: How in the hell do you have a vehicular homicide where all the damage is to the head, especially when both the victim and the accused were said to be drunk? I'm calling bullshit on that.

Totally objectionable, and, absolutely epic.

I think Proctor is a ‘company guy’. He’s myopic. He sees what he’s told to see. Doesn’t ask questions.

Greetings from South Korea!!!

As a pedestrian in a low-speed collision, I had bruising, a dislocated hip, and my knee was jacked up too. I'd be VERY interested in the ME's report. Also worth noting that the cops told me there was no point in filing a report since it wasn't on camera and I didn't get the plate.

The admission by Proctor that the video was inverted after he got his hands on it is INSANE to me. That was kinda glossed over but that means that it was specifically tampered with before being brought to trial. DISGUSTING malfeasance.

By the way, rumor has it that people beaten up by Brian Albert always have a certain look. "That's what I initially thought, but then I saw the guy" means he recognized Brian Albert's calling card. Albert is a trained MMA fighter, and people in the town are terrified of him. He knows what really happened.

Why can't we do FOIA to find the individuals who he has incarcerated? That needs full investigation

53:22 I'm genuinely surprised Runkle thinks this of juries. If I was a juror the last thing I'd want after a court day is to see anything more about the case. And according to other lawyers in lawtube they have said jurors usually take their oath seriously and can be tattletails and will tell court if another juror has done something. Accidentally seeing it? Maybe. But my parents nor siblings saw anything substantial about depp v heard, most of them knew the case existed but that was it. I don't think people realize how off-line other people can be. Maybe I'm optimistic but I believe juries follow their oath and just ignore whatever headline might pop up now and then.

On the hiccups, that's usually a core strength issue. Swing a kettlebell that's heavy enough to make you pay attention a couple times a week and you'll fix that right up

Alan Jackson ‘is the goat’ as my teenager would say 😂

1:36:10 "I've got a lawyer who is literally dead in my phone" Oh my God, how does he fit???

it’s also noted that not only did they delete the time when she arrived home. I bet they also deleted when they went in there and picked up the pieces of her tail light so they could disperse them little by little you know so he has a few times to show what a good detective he is finding them in the snow, after other peoples already went through it with leaf blowers and rakes

aaaaaaahahaha! Ian, your snark is priceless!

Funny, both you and EDB used two different Clinton quotes during proctor’s cross!

I think he’ll have a lengthy career as a federal prison laundry worker.

42:23 "discovered tail light pieces at the scene" - remind me again cos I'm lost in the chronology of the tail light pieces... did they find any ON the night? I didn't think they did? But Proctor is saying it as though they had, which is why he's blaming Karen 16 hours later in the texts... I'm confused.

If she had hit him while drunk and didn't realize there is vehicular homicide. I feel in Massachusetts. I remember someone being charged with that here in Massachusetts.

They had to delete a video that didn’t matter so they could SAY the video of them looking at the taillight is missing! Didn’t Carrie say they looked at it in her driveway? Jen is the guru. What she said was gospel!

1:56:32 Marine spouse here. Excellent crayon joke, sir. 😂

2:32:50 "Most people wouldn't have that equipment ..." Well to be fair they were apparently screenshots from his own phone. The only equipment you actually need for that type of "extraction" is the phone itself, a stock standard computer, with free or commercially available software, and a printer... (This to me made that part of Higgins' story of having to be shown how to do this at an FBI facility and actually using federal govt resources to do so that much more bizarre to me) Exactly how Higgins made the extraction, theoretically wouldn't have been obviously questionable on that basis at that time.

1:15:24 I had the same thing happen to me but it was the oil cap and it seized the engine and they had to rebuild the entire engine!!! It was not a newer car and I stilled owed on it!! I got very lucky!!

Replay Crew!

Physicists like to abbreviate charge/parity violations (a kind of asymmetry in nature) which is so unfortunate

Funny enough, I have a friend who used to go to strip clubs and not look at the dancers. When he was in college he discovered that a nearby strip club had a really cheap steak available at odd times. Something like 2-4pm Mon-Thurs. So he'd go in and get a table and a cheap steak. The dancers were all irritated that he largely ignored them. Which I entirely believe.

It's the chip and Bear dancers.

Re-play for the beginning I missed because sleeping. I hope Ian gets to sleep especially good when he does

I didn't think about the initial thing 😅 I was gone by CTP but if I didn't put my middle initial...

I think they said the jury didn’t show up on time so they had to switch him out because court starts on courts time

Inhawser laid ropes , where three strands are twisted together, the groves between the strands are in nautical terms called “C***Lines”

he kept saying it was newsworthy well if something is newsworthy, then it should be posted in the news. That means all of their text should be posted in the news, so it can be notified to the local residence of the professionalism of the officers that are protecting them

Ooof. Richard Head got totally shafted in the name department. 😅🙈 1:44:10

That is Karen's brother you pointed out 😊

The judge does not deal with this as hearsay. It shows she is unqualified because she doesn’t make anyone state their objections so therefore she must.

I watched an interesting video by Attorney Melanie Little here on KZfaq. She had a police dog trainer on to look at the arm wounds and explain dog bites. Very informative and he shows how dogs bite and shows actual confirmed bite marks. Matches the ones on his body.