Her and Carrie Underwood

Thomas DeAngelo, We wondered the same thing. With her voice and presence, she should have won.

I thought Constantine had a better voice than Bo Bice sometimes it is song selection on a particular night, sometimes I don't know, just whatever taste of viewers on a particular night were I guess.

She was also amazing on Waitress, both on Broadway and London.

@@hydrolito Bo Bice was so good, he didn't ever need a microphone. We were disappointed Carrie Underwood beat him. But things worked out for her.

This was when the Country voters started tuning in and messing up the votes, that's how u get Taylor Hicks to win. I'm not a Country music hater I love some country songs it's just it's a known fact that the Country audience has a big pull when it comes to votes on these singing shows compared to the other genre of music ppl out there.

Kenneth locley

Ditto for me!!

Do A comparison and Google Carly Rose Sonneclar singing Over the Rainbow, I like this one the best......its that good!

Gary Howard I’ve already seen Carly Rose Sonnenclar. It doesn’t come anywhere close to Katharine’s version.

@@benzmusiczone Well when you say "It doesn't come anywhere close to Kathern's version".....what that tells me as a professional musician of 55 years is that you simply are not a good judge. Because no matter who you might like as having the best version...They are in the same class period. Sorry, just saying!

Gary Howard How on earth are they in the same class when one (Katharine’s) is vocally and overall more superior than the other (Carly’s)?

@@benzmusiczone let me put this in perspective for you: Carly is overall superior because her range takes her from pop to blues and Jazz, Kathern cannot cannot do that... I doubt that you have ever seen or heard Carly in another musical setting and one of the judges on AGT, the black gentleman was heard to say about Carly that she had "Insane Talent" Try to be more open. Carly never married the conductor.

Dion Corderd I loved her and I always will, she is pure talent, until she married that David what’s his face. You know, you David Yolanda Hadid.

WHAT WHO WON

Gross

He said she was “really fat”

and too good for an old man too.. 😀😀

I don't understand how "too good" only finishes in 2nd place?!

Catharine McPhee in 2021 where is she.

@@suzannecurran6009 Where is she? In the mist of a Global pandemic, 10 months of Pregnancy and just delivering a child less than a week ago. On every minor and major newspaper, television, Social Media platforms in the free world. I have no freaking idea where she is. Do you?

@@donaldholderdoc2910 Check her out on Netflix. New show "Country Comfort".

Mariah Carey married Tommy Mottolla who was in a similar situation..People are so judgemental these days(.Look what happened to their marriage.) lol.

@Michael Martin young men might have the stamina but us older guys know tricks they will probably never know. Viagra might keep it up longer but it doesn't come with a manual on what to do. That is called experience. There is a massive difference between just fucking and making love

@Michael Martin oooor immature boys playing to be men but lacking manners, wisdom and courtship!

@@michaeldeane9029 love your words of wisdom!

@Michael Martin She’s been with several men near her age. I think by now she’s experienced enough to make a decision on whether she wants to be with someone she loves and has so much in common with, or someone she meets on a TV set. And that’s not me knocking her. She sees through his age is what I’m trying to say.

Song Mozart that’s what I said too. She had her plans to catch her rich man back then.

He’s 70 years old and a prolific pop song writer for decades...something tells me she didn’t marry him for their “connection” 🙄

She met him on idol. He mentored them

Yeah me too.

Walter x Paige

I agree she should've won that season. Better voice and stage presence

I totally agree! She should have won hands down, no question!

Popularity

Katherine should have won!!

CRAZY SHIT.....ROBERT.

Votes

bc women are the majority of the vote and yeah....that's about it. she SHOULD have won.

But we all know now that winning AI isn’t that important. Once you’re on the show, your career can blossom irregardless of winning.

@@kosmosbjm So? It's about having a fair competition, they railroaded her from the second she stepped on that stage.

@@mr.balloffur Fine, I’m not the one you should fight against. I’m on her side, and was just commenting that winning the show doesn’t mean that much as far as a future career, that if you are extremely talented, you will prevail, even if they did not judge you fairly.

Who won this season? I forgot.

@@HannahNoelle2158 Taylor Hicks

Except Adam Lambert! She has a beautiful voice , but, Adam has the power and stamina in his voice that makes his voice magnificent!! IMHO!!

I don't agree but that doesn't negate from the fact that she's amazing! I love how much color she has to her voice

Definitely one of the best

Her and Candace Glover...agreed!

Carrie Underwood? Chris Daughtry? Jordin Sparks? Mandisa? Pia Toscano?

@@dawnsilver2271 Candace Glover is one of the most underrated winners of Idol!

You'll find the way

Don’t compare yourself to others, compare yourself to who YOU were yesterday. ❤️

You can do it too! Just love & believe in yourself! Follow your gut!