I think f(x) is the most elegant gg in their time and also now.

스타일리스트 누굴까.. 진짜 대단하다 의상 지금당장 음방에 여돌이 입고나와도 어색하지않을 듯.. 시대를 앞서간다는게 진짜 이런 거구나

이 날 정수정 진짜 ㄹㅈㄷ 저 바지 저때는 이상하다 생각했는데 지금 보니까 너무 찰떡임

진짜 이렇게 세련된 노래도 드물어.... 앨범커버, 컨셉, 스타일, 안무, 노래 싹 다 세련...;;

에스엠의 정체성을 완벽하게 보여준 두 곡 에프엑스 4 walls, 샤이니 View 이 두 그룹이야 말로 에스엠이 주장하는 세계관의 완벽 표본 아니냐구..

i miss fx so much. lets be honest there will never be anther gg like them, with their concept and aesthetics and overall vibe. krystal just has something that can't be replicated

아직도 기억 나는 게 저 당시때 나팔바지 보고 충격 먹었었는데,, 지금 보니까 스타일링 엄청 고급지고 예쁨,,,,, 크리스탈은 진짜 레전드네,,

4walls 당시에는 스타일링이 과하다고 생각했는데 지금 보면 너무 세련됐다 요즘 유행한 파스텔 톤 매치, 허쉬컷 웨이브, 발목만 넓은 와이드팬츠

Who's watching 2024? They're really ahead of their time

지금 스엠 미국시장 노리는데 스엠은 에펙으로 미국시장을 진출 했어야 했어 소녀시대도 외국에서 러브콜 많이 왔는데 스엠이 쳐내고

4 walls 가 민희진대표 작품이라는데… 이때가 뉴진스 컨셉의 초기작품이라고 해도 맞지않을까? EDM기반 이지리스닝 + 몽환적인 사운드&발성 + 세련된 스타일링 등… 짱좋음

nowadays, MeU miss them so fckn' much.

Victoria slays both the performances

애들 행복해보인다.. 같이 무대 좀 오래하게 해주지 아오...ㅠ

포월즈무대중에 이 무대가 최고인듯. 의상 색감부터 너무 이쁘고 고급진 느낌

2020 and still f(x) is my number one girl group in my heart among hundreds of gg out there

몇년이 지난 지금 크리스탈을보면 아직도 여신이라는 생각이 들어 🙉🙈

you know f(x) is ahead of their time that their backup dancers were wearing masks

they are all so hot... fx and wonder girls have the best visuals tbh, but their all so talented at the same time

is it only me, or f(x)'s music has changed? i mean the beat and the flow is different than the previous songs. but then it's good tho, different vibes. heehee

샤이니 뷰랑 이노래는 5년이 지난 지금 들어도 너무 좋음...♡♡♡♡♡

8年前とは思えない、ビジュも楽曲も今年でも通用する…

다같이 이런 활동 또 할 생각 없니 . ... 그리워

그땐 몰랐는데 지금 보니까 의상 디테일 장난 아니다 멤버 캐해도 거의 엑소 럽라 급

에쎔 걸그룹들 중 f(x)가 제일 스엠 정체성이랑 찰떡이라고 생각함.. 제발 이수만씨가 알아주길

이렇게 독보적인 그룹 또 없습니다.... 보고싶다 함수니들 ㅠㅠ 여전히 많이 많이 사랑해 💜

4walls 음악이랑 안무 지금 봐도 진짜 좋다.. 의상도

그 매니악한 하우스 장르를 가지고 이런곡 뽑아낸거 자체가 걍 미친거임

에프엑스 진짜 다시 보고 싶다. 개인적으로 좋아하는 노래라서 더 그렇지만 진짜 명곡들 많은데.

이 영상 아쉬운점.. 스엠 공계에 2년전쯤에 이미 이 무대 영상 1000만뷰 찍었었는데 삭제됨.. 조회수가 증명해주는 명작이었는데 ㅜ 더 조명받길

2:35 4walls리듬감에 의상까지 완벽하다,, 노래는 진짜 역대급이야

루나 저날 헤어 착장 메컵 너무 예쁨..각자 다 잘어울리는 컬러가 있었는데 저날 분홍은 개인적으로 루나가 제일 잘 어울렸음

팀 색깔 자체가 독특하고 현대적이었는데 그 팀의 색과 너무나 찰떡이었던 곡인 것 같음...

언제도 유행할 것 같지 않은 독보적 컨셉으로, 그러나 언제 보아도 세련됨을 간직한.

such beautiful concept, choreography and lyrics, iconic, you will be remembered fx, miss second generation groups, so sad SM didn't give them the world tour they deserve for how unique and amazing they're, I guess we can honor these timeless masterpieces by viewing.

방금 4walls 데모버전 듣고 왔는데 진짜 음악 활동은 예술인듯.... 데뷔 한번 하려면 티저만들고 홍보하고 앨범만들고 힘들게 연습한 아이돌들이 노래와 춤을 익히고 안무가가 춤을 만들고 작사가와 작곡가의 노력으로 노래가 만들어지고...

이무대는 몇년이 지난 지금까지도 계속 생각나서 보러옴...코디랑 메이크업 모든게 지금 봐도 하나도 안어색해ㅜㅜ 특히 크리스탈 착장 너어어어무 이쁨 관심도 없던 핑크에 빠지게 만든 무대 ㅇㅇ그립다 에펙스...

Watching f(x)’s performances has became my hobby now lol.

Am I the only one gaping at Krystal's body ? Like ...😍

I miss f(x) so much that's why I am still here in 2023.

This song never gets old

포월스 노래도 좋은데 스타일링 진짜 미쳤다,,,

f(x) is simply unique, I'm so proud of what they achieved before and now, they're doing it so well ~

전설의 영상..지금 봐도 세련됐다 특히 4 walls 앨범자켓이 진짜 개간지남

Vic's soooooooooo beautiful, from every single hair!!!

This is an eternal masterpiece. f(x) is an eternal masterpiece.

이렇게 네명이서도 빛나는데..무대에서 다시 보고싶다..

"A deep house Snog" Nice typo KBS World

당시 상황이 여러모로 힘들었을텐데 묵묵히 견딘 멤버들이 대단하게 느껴지네요... 서로의 선택을 존중해주고, 그저 주어진 선택지에 최선을 다한 이들에게 박수를 보내고 싶어요... 그래서 아직도 기억에 남나봐요 떠나간 이도 남은 이들도 늘 평온하고 행복한 삶만 가득하길 바랍니다.

I loved their comeback album so much. It's perfect.

Their live vocals are immaculate! They said the mic is ON! SM and their vocals! WOW!

Why does f(x) have to suffer so much... They're the best, though :)

Amber looks so skinny with tight pants.

It's 2021 and I still can't get enough of F(x)! I miss them so much :( I hate sm for abandoning this amazing talent!

아니 여기 한국어 미숙한 외국인 멤버도 진짜 이질감없이 한국어 잘들려서 너무 좋은것같다

에프엑스 컴백 언제해....ㅜㅜㅜ 크리스탈 대존예ㅠㅠ

진짜 포월즈도 좋지만 다야몬드도 진심 넘 완벽하고 좋음 엠버 언니 파트 매력있고 넘 좋음 👑

Here after watching Irene and Seulgi's Naughty. They remind me very much of f(x). I miss f(x) so muuuch ~

이 때 크리스탈 22살이었다는데,, 믿기지 않아 방송국에 개인 직캠도 없던 시절인데 지금 들어도 세련됐다

이 정도면 아이돌 무대를 떠나서 행위예술이지

f(x) will remain superior. I mean- who can top this?????

this choreography and them singing LIVE. Gen 4 could never I think

This comeback was beyond just another song.. it was literal art 💜

무대는 오랜만에 보는데 왜 눈물이 나지 ㅠㅠ안무까지 넘 우아하고 고급지다

하 어디 내놔도 자랑스러울 곡ㅜㅜ 내가 외국인이고 가사 하나도 몰라도 짱좋을듯

Now tell me what other group has the incredible concept that f(x) had. I need to know

빅토리아 언니 존예 포스 노래도 ㄷㄷ

Crying so hard right now. I miss them but I know some how I have to get over this because they aren't coming back.

이 앨범에 버릴 곡 단언컨대 한 곡도 없어요 다 들어봐주세요 흑흑

Fx is so amazing especially 4Walls is sooo Aesthetic and Beautiful love what they are wearing.✨

I miss f(x) 😢

i miss f(x)

there's no one like f(x) out there! i missed my girls already

Iconic song, iconic flare pants

에프엑스는 진짜 고생 많았다 스엠아 이 아이들을 좀 챙기지 그랬니

레전드 노래

The only differences I see in Luna is that she's older (from 16 to 22, yeah you change over the years) and the she lost a LOT of weight. Considering she was in puberty, she obviously went through changes and the lost weight make it even more noticable. Go check their first MV, all of them changed a lot. Sulli too went from cute bubbly kid to full grown woman. For me she didn't do anything else.

음색봐 저 앨범 자전거 탈때 맨날 들었는데 귀로 들어도 너무 좋은 앨범이었다

Didn't think I would remember the whole choreo since it doesn't show in the music video, but Hangami did a great job & this peformance is the sole reason I still remember it. Everything on point! ❤

루나 넘나 예쁜것...ㅠㅠ

이 노래 너무 좋다 ㅠㅠ

이게 6년전이라고?... 지금 들어도 노래 퀄리티 지린다

loving amber's singing voice and rap

I miss them so much 🥺 damn SM for not handling them well

praise to their backup dancers 🙌🏻 dancing in blindfold is really difficult ngl

f(x) is the first gg I stan, miss them so much

Amber Liu. Since your birthday is around the corner, I found it to be the perfect time to prepare for the celebration. The first time I ever saw you, it was through my older sister who was, and still is, absolutely obsessed with FX. I have been a K-Pop fan for about a decade now, but at the time, at least 5 years ago, I wasn’t acquainted with many groups. I saw the absolute glow in my sister’s eyes as she showed me endless FX music videos and talked about each member with such love and inspiration woven into each of her words. Since then, I have been a huge supporter and fan of FX, and I have grown alongside you during your most difficult and triumphant times. I know that you have been through a lot, and even saying that doesn’t even come to close to what you must have been feeling for the past several years. I know you have been in the business and making music for a very long time now, and I know you have experienced extreme tragedy as well as glorifying victories. I have never seen someone respond to any obstacles in the mature and hopeful manner that you have. That, as I’ve gotten to know more about you over the years, might be what I appreciated the most about you. I am so aware why so many people, including my sister who introduced me to you, are so inspired by you and desperate to follow in your footsteps. Amidst all of the pain you have felt, sacrifice you have made, and challenges you have faced, you continue to make barrier-breaking music and share your voice with the world through that music. Your response to the problems in the world is so wholesome, genuine and confident; and you have taught many around the world how to effectively recover from any pain they may have felt. It can be understood that you have gone through what many have not, and yet you have not given up on living out your dreams and encouraging others to follow in your footsteps. What has always stood out to me is that you have always been confident, and done what has been best for you, rather than listen to others. You always came off as so comfortable in your own skin, and that makes you such an iconic performer and musician. Your powerful and bold rapping, combined with your soulful, smooth, and energetic voice makes you an incredibly compassionate performer who is so connected to her audience and music on stage. You are an unbelievably beautiful dancer and have such a demanding stage presence that has been such a privilege for me to watch over these years. I know that your fans love you in a way that’s stronger than anybody else ever could. You have given them a reason not to give up trying when the worst happens to them, and there is no higher form of inspiration than that. I am proud to be one of these fans, and I know my sister is as well. Similarly, your members love you and have such an unbreakable bond with you that I have seen firsthand without even knowing any of you personally. I know that you have all relied on each other in such a way that most people can’t say they know or understood, and I can’t even speak on how unique your relationship is with one another. I can’t even thank you enough for coming into my life and showing me confidence, strength, and reliance on my passion, friends, and family in the darkest times in my life. You are an inspiration like no other, and I know all of the fans, and even those outside of them can recognize as such a once-in-a-lifetime authentic musician. On behalf of your friends, fans, members, and most importantly, your loving and adoring family, I wish you the most blessed birthday ever Amber. I hope nothing but love surrounds you and those close to you always and forever. Please stay safe, and I pray that you continue to live your life in such bliss as you do now and have always tried to. I absolutely love you so, so much, and happy early birthday! I hope you have as much fun as you possibly can!

I miss them Soo much

크리스탈언니 의상 이쁘다 내가좋아하는 핑크라서 눈에 띔! ㅎㅎ

the CAMERAMAN IS SO CRAZY LIKE I CANT EVEN WATCH THESE BEAUTIFUL GIRLS

Aaaaah i miss this moment so much. Love f(x)..

My fav GG I miss them so much, their music is always so underrate. I wish they would perform together again one day.

Always ahead of time! ♡

I love this comeback, it's my favorite. I miss them so much. 🛐💜

민희진님 유퀴즈에 나온 거 보고 또 생각나서 왔음! 무대에 서는 함수니들 너무 보고싶구나!

의상진짜 너무 이쁘고 에펙스가 소화 느므 잘하고

의상 지금봐도 존예

i love how krystal improvise her moves on 3:56. it adds ✨depth✨

6년전 영상이라는게 믿기지않을정도로 트렌디하고 감각적이다,,

Forever the number 1 gg in my heart. Literally lost interest in K-pop for the longest time after they stopped promoting…