Key Thinkers: Graham Priest on Gottlob Frege (Part 1)

  Рет қаралды 8,509

The Monthly

The Monthly

11 жыл бұрын

Part 1 | Part 2In this Key Thinkers (University of Melbourne) lecture, Professor of Philosophy Graham Priest discusses the influence of Gottlob Frege. Friedrich Ludwig Gottlob...

Пікірлер: 10
@Cathari
@Cathari 10 жыл бұрын
very helpful and informative. thank you for this post.
@bobelschlager6906
@bobelschlager6906 4 жыл бұрын
Not many comments on this video, but that says nothing about the material. I found the two videos immensely helpful in putting into a larger framework of philosophy, logic, mathematics, and political history, my knowledge, observations, and a few ideas from going through parts of Frege's "Grundgesetze der Arithmetik." Truly, much thanks. It's too bad there is not more widely known some of the underlying ideas of mathematics and logic.
@drbonesshow1
@drbonesshow1 8 жыл бұрын
Everybody saw someone? Everybody was Kung-Fu fighting.
@jeffreysbrother
@jeffreysbrother 8 жыл бұрын
It's not clear to me why the two examples @23:02 express different notions. Is it agreed upon that reversing the order of the quantified variables conveys some different meaning, or did Priest merely mis-type? To be clear, I understand that the sentence "everyone saw somebody" has multiple (and distinct meanings), but do the translations into first-order logic really convey these two meanings? If so, why?
@MindForgedManacle
@MindForgedManacle 8 жыл бұрын
Yes, it's agreed that they convey those meanings, so far as I know. The order of the quantifiers change the scope, and so change how we interpret what's being said. To explain: "*∀x∃y xSy*" - The existential quantifier is in the scope of the universal quantifier, so this is translated as "For every x (every student), there is some y (some person which exists) such that each student saw some person". In other words, for each student, it is the case that they saw a person. Think of the "There is some Y" as extending FROM every student. The existential quantifier is bound to the universal quantifier here. "*∃y∀x xSy* - The universal quantifier is now within the scope of the existential quantifier, so this is translated as "There is some y (a singular person) such that every x saw that person y". In other words, think of the universal quantifier as extending FROM the existential quantifier, from a particular person, to being seen by every student. I hope that was helpful!
@scin3759
@scin3759 9 жыл бұрын
Nice lecture. Wish the speaker would spend more time explaining some of the ideas. Too happy just posting slides and rushing through the lecture without really giving examples and making real sense. Yes, Frege's work was decimated by Russel's Paradox, but Russel's work and some of Hilbert work was decimated by Godel's work. What goes around comes around.
@MindForgedManacle
@MindForgedManacle 8 жыл бұрын
Sure but Godel's work didn't, so far as I know, decimate the portions of Russell's work that Priest mentioned in the video. So its a bit besides the point, isn't it?
@MontyCantsin5
@MontyCantsin5 11 ай бұрын
How long do you want the lecture to be? 3 hours? To go into immense detail in the format of a lecture wouldn't be practical. Go back and read the mathematicians/philosophers work in question to gain the best understanding possible of the ideas hinted at in the talk.
Key Thinkers: Graham Priest on Gottlob Frege (Part 2)
24:32
The Monthly
Рет қаралды 3,5 М.
Playing hide and seek with my dog 🐶
00:25
Zach King
Рет қаралды 34 МЛН
Llegó al techo 😱
00:37
Juan De Dios Pantoja
Рет қаралды 56 МЛН
Dummett on Frege, Truth, Meaning & Realism (1997)
52:11
Philosophy Overdose
Рет қаралды 8 М.
Philosophy of Mathematics: Platonism
1:13:21
Kane B
Рет қаралды 67 М.
Gottlob Frege - On Sense and Reference
34:06
Jeffrey Kaplan
Рет қаралды 307 М.
Frege on Thought
49:26
Daniel Bonevac
Рет қаралды 24 М.
Duncan Pritchard: Wittgenstein on Faith and Reason (Royal Institute of Philosophy)
46:26
The Royal Institute of Philosophy
Рет қаралды 19 М.
Graham Priest - Frege
51:07
Emporium
Рет қаралды 21 М.
2014 Stephen Marich Lecture in Railway Engineering - Mr. Stephen Marich
1:03:59
Institute of Railway Technology-IRT
Рет қаралды 5 М.
Analytic Philosophy: Frege
50:35
Daniel Bonevac
Рет қаралды 87 М.
Graham Priest - "Everything and Nothing" (Robert Curtius Lecture of Excellence)
54:21
Internationales Zentrum für Philosophie NRW
Рет қаралды 13 М.
Playing hide and seek with my dog 🐶
00:25
Zach King
Рет қаралды 34 МЛН