The biggest issue I see is that most of EN never finish the MC projects they start and then they end up playing so infrequently that they get intimidated by it and start comparing themselves to the other branches. Fauna has her tree, but doesn't seem to have a clear vision for it and doesn't look at other builds or guides despite being the one to make a bunch of farms, none of her homes are complete either. Kronii had the bunkeronii and now has her castle, but she rarely plays and built it in a place that is making it a lot more work. Mumei, has her treehouse from a guide and her owl but admits to being overwhelmed. Bae, has a couple dirt houses and a creeper farm, her "new" house on the EN server has made no progress. IRyS really seems to lack the drive to build and prefers to just mine. Ame has put in a bunch of work and built a lot but she only really plays in bursts, needing to be particularly inspired to play. Calli refused to play for like an entire year or more but seems a bit more open if it is a collab. Ina can build if she can get herself together on a day she's not exhausted and focus but that has been difficult. Gura, also has flashes of inspiration but is often followed by poor health and overwork. I think they just need guides to follow to build up confidence and actually complete projects and if more people play the others will often want to join in.

Untuk JP sport fes gila sih, kualitas makin meningkat dari tahun ke tahun, untuk ID jg banyak improvement tahun ini

karna branch JP dan ID punya tradisi masing2 utk merayakan lomba di event tertentu. JP basicnya adalah sport fes antar murid sekolah aka undokai yg lumrah bgt di jepang sana. sedangkan ID sudah jelas 17 agustusan makanya keduanya bisa rayain sport fes dgn dasarnya masing2. nah, EN ini yg susah. kendala mereka itu penyebaran tiap member yg ujung2nya berurusan dgn time zone. sama menurutku ditambah budayanya yg blm tentu sama tiap member jadi utk merayakan sport fes tidak ada dasarnya utk merayakan apa (well, alasan ini mungkin terkesan ngasal dan ga logis. tpi menurutku ini bisa jadi pertimbangan). lalu masalah utama: NIAT

berharap semoga kelak EN juga punya event mereka sendiri.. biar event di hololive makin beragam dan seru

I think Holo EN never make big project, maybe because they are not in the same country and have different timezone, so it's a bit difficult to collab for making event together. It's not like JP or ID with same timezone they are more easy to collab, even ID is more easy to IRL Collab.

EN server has to hold a big event. The most important thing is just the concept. For everything about resources, manpower, technical engineers, I'm sure the members of JP and ID will be happy to help if EN feels lacking. Because for events like sports festivals, in the end what we are looking for is the collab moment of Hololive members. And it was very memorable and fun for the members and the viewers.

en group minecraft stream falls under these categories: 1) fish and zatsudan, 2) adventure, goes around in boat and not building anything, 3) want to build something huge project after seeing other branch's build, but realize it will take time, effort and planning and give it up immediately. I think they just got intimidated by long term project and don't know where to start. And plus they don't like to research thing and plan before hand. Which is understanderable, give most member have a tight schedule doing other more important project. So en group member tend to avoid research heavy or project that require prior planning. Probably need to start with smaller and less ambitious build to build their confidence and understand it;s okay for thing to take time and not everything has to finish immediately. MC stream is effectively a zatsudan stream with activity on the side and some time spontaneous off collab. But some time en folks just dislike minecraft, which is fine.

I hope one day EN Minecraft server would held a big event too. It doesn't have to be sport's event, it could be just like festival or something like that.

I saw a lot of KFP start to mention in the chat for EN to make Hunger Games like arena (by hiring modder ofc), and I personally like that idea 👍.

I understand how kiara thought of that, but now EN have Shiorin and Nerissa which used play minecraft creative (based on kaela story about chat with them) so maybe EN can caught up in the future😊

Man, imagine, just imagine if they added Create Mod to their servers.... All the possibilities. The JP girls would probably build complex traps and war machines, the ID girls would surely advance their server to 3000 years in the future, and the EN girls would finally learn how to open a coconut.

Bikin event di Minecraft itu sebenernya rumit dan butuh banyak waktu, apalagi kalo banyak mod begini. Dari planning, building, meng-invite/kontak2 member yg mau ikut, dll. Beberapa member HoloID kadang "ngeluh"/curhat kalo mereka punya banyak PR di bulan Agustus, salah satunya karena event Minecraft mereka. Saat membuat venue event nya kadang mereka juga agak malas gimana gitu. Jadi mungkin ini salah satu penyebab kenapa EN ga pernah ngadain event mereka sendiri, selain ga ada pendorong budaya dan time zone yg beda-beda. Mereka tau siapin event Minecraft ribet butuh waktu panjang dan effort besar, apalagi kalo member2nya jarang main Minecraft dan belum terlalu paham Minecraft (kecuali Fauna).

I do like how ID started integrating Mods into their Minecraft Servers

Well this is hololive man.. I think EN capable to do some event too, even if they must be helped by any other branch.. See the holomatsuri fest in minecraft, its not only the JP branch who build many games inside the event.. Even many from other branch also participate to build some show/games inside the fest..i think ID branch who expert on minecraft like Moona, Kaela, Olie will gladly to help the EN branch if they ask for some help to held any festivals..

EN is more in individual culturaly while ID is more communal culturaly. Because of this their relation with fans also different, EN between talent with fans is basicaly entertainer and her fans, while in ID between talent with fans is more like community that is why person like Yuba or Arkana exist can exist in ID. Because the different culture is also impacted the member differently, in EN it will be hard to have a leader since every member strong in their own individualist idea, while in ID is more easy as long as they have common purpose/goal or interest because it much more easy for the member to put their ego individualistic aside for greater good of community. They just simply coming from different culture at the first place, one coming from West that emphasized individuality and other from Indonesia that emphasized more family oriented in real life.

I hope Holo Advent will bring a new fresh air to EN server

Mumpung ada olympic 2024 siapa tau mau bikin vanue jg EN branch, ada lagi event olahraga 😂

EN really needs a dedicated MC player in their lineup if they want to improve the condition of the EN server. Someone on the level of popular servers like HC or Empires, because it is gonna be a huge task to get everyone of them motivated.

Where there is a will, there is a way. Nothing is impossible for a willing heart. Improvise. Adapt. Overcome. It's not just for MC, it needs not to be MC, it can be anything, everything.

Jp:anime and game Japan Id:Budaya,Lokal,Fantasy

2:56 thats an Briliant Idea, caveman sport. Just if they really need to make it real event. Imagine Caveman sport being survival sport like run from dinosaur, or like indiana jones survival. I really love that FR FR

I disagree. I think EN has the potential to build really amazing stuff and can rival JP and ID. Its just that EN chat during the girls’ early days in Minecraft tended to have some hardcore Minecraft players who spammed the girls on how they were building things wrong. And then there was the conflicting info from chat between Bedrock and Java mechanics that confused and frustrated the girls further. Then when EN and JP servers were connected, the girls were spammed to just farm in JP server and ignore their own builds. That kind of kills any motivation the EN girls would have to continue making their own builds since JP is better according to chat, hence the long Minecraft hiatus after the EN - JP server connect. If EN chat could be a bit more encouraging and turn the building sessions of the EN girls into more relaxed enjoyable chatting streams and stop indirectly comparing them with others by telling them to use this or that farm, perhaps they can be encouraged to start building more. Thank God for Kaela though, her patience for collabing with EN in Minecraft and her understanding of how little their experience is with the game and patiently teaching them, is slowly drawing the girls back, also collabs helps to prevent the girls from reading discouraging comments in chat and helps to keep their motivation up. Can anyone else see why most of EN prefers collabing in Minecraft rather than solo stream? Let’s be real, why play a game where every stream you are called a noob and caveman and this or that person’s build is better than yours?

EN making the sports festival would be so funny to see though! It would be chaotic lol

EN, JP, ID Past, present, future

id very surprising 😂

My suggestion: EN can make fireworks festival 🎉🎉 I know that sounds too simple but, if EN can make somekind of special letters fireworks, that would be awesome 😮 some helps from ID n JP to amplify the project would be nice ✌️

Make a royale battle, its simple, but with different terrain

Kalau emang niat, EN sebenarnya bisa bisa aja buat event minecraft sendiri, minta uang ke yagoo untuk hire outsourcing untuk masalah teknis kayak bikin mod mod seperti event ID, nanti untuk tema dan konsepnya biarin EN yang buat 😅😅😅

caveman sport www....that's might be interesting festival tho ww

EN has Fauna! The mother nature who building civilization and economic. We can count on her. The 3rd gen has potential also. I'm sure they will evolve to next level.

Emang nih Phoenix gk sungkan dan ragu" buat bikin statement, bahkan untuk branch nya sendiri :v Salah satu sifat yg ane suka darinya, cuma emang rada riskan aja. Kalo viewers menanggapi nya, secara baperan wkwk

as far as i know, the one constantly doing minecraft in EN branch is fauna, kronii, ame, was ina does MC often?

JP server: Great individual projects, but no coherent theme. Most just stands on a flat plane. ID server: Amazing builds plus thematic consistency. Complete world building. EN server: It pays more attention to theme and terrain than JP, but not as much as ID. But most of all it just has WAY fewer playing hours invested than JP or ID. Really the core to get a server "big" is to have a devoted group of friends that just likes to hang out in MC. EN had it a little while with Myth and then with Council, but it was never as intense as ID and they have fewer members and shorter streams than JP back in the great Kenzetsu days.

Kalo mau mah EN PAS HARI PERGANTIAN TAHUN

Cavemen sports seems fun ngl ~ lol

EN sports festival is just seeing who can survive the longest on Hardcore mode with health regeneration turned off

nonono, I would like to see this caveman sport festival tbh

All the hololive members can do a Friendly match every month for soccer in MC , please

it's not like all id girls are that enthusiastic or great at mc either, you can prob count them on one hand, Moona, Ollie, Reine, Kaela, just four out of nine

enaknya JP sama ID mereka masih satu daerah semuah. sedangkan EN mencar ada yang di amerika ada yang australia, ada yang di austria,dll

I heard holo EN gen 3 has amazing minecraft builder

Bisa minta tolong 2 npc holoid si buat bantu2 build, tinggal ngonsep aja, terus kerjain kalo butuh bantuan ya tinggal minta tolong id or jp,

because our (Indonesia) nenek. moyang need to build Candi for wedding proposal

EN could make superbowl and rugby mod. They could hire ID too wether material/build, like sana's tower. Hopely advent could bring fresh air on EN mc server. Welp, it's up to them. No pressure

I think EN can make a WORLD CUP, like a PON in Indonesia. But player time and resource in EN it's a problem. I hope EN can make the Minecraft Event In the future.

Itu NPC 2 wth 😂

Komentar nya berbobot semua. Semoga aja member EN melihatnya untuk menjadikan komentar ini sebagai saran dan ucapan dukungan

yg bikin macam tarik tambang, badminton itu staffnya ato member id?

EN Kekurangan pemain Minecraft yang Pro, Bang Yagoo tolong di Scout 😆

Ya, the Flintstones fest

cavemen sports festival could be funny

Just get one dedicated minecraft youtuber on the team

actually... cavemen sports sounds plausible LOL why do you need over the top events when two branches already have them? One branch should brace that cavemen-ship and be proud of it too LOL. It's okay 👌🏽 I believe in EN ability too!

Honestly, I prefer to watch the MC content of the JP branch, the girls always find some way to entertain.. instead EN. It's like they're not very interested in MC... at first they were seen trying to play but once they were consolidated they let us see that they didn't like MC very much

I'm going to disagree with Kiara that EN could never host an EN Holo Cup. I think it's a good group project for EN to do by hosting an EN Holo Cup. I trust Fauna, Ame, and Ina could host an EN Holo Cup because they could come up with great ideas. In Minecraft, they're all excellent builders by experience. The rest of the EN and Holo staffs could help them too.

The problem with the way Hololive did the minecraft servers is that they threw EN to the wolves so to speak by putting them on their own server right off the bat. No one in EN had a lot of experience, if any, with minecraft when they were given their server. Sure, Ina and Ame are good enough gamers to figure it out and learn on their own, but you really need to be taught by someone who really loves the game enough to pass along the passion for it. Like Moona had with Pekora because ID started on the JP server. Moona then passed her passion on to the rest of ID, especially when they got their own server. EN never had anyone who really loved the game enough to inspire anyone else to play a lot. Ame builds solo. Ina is mostly solo when building, except for the Onsen (Cali) and fishing hut (Reine). Gura has the interest but not the attention span or knowledge. Kiara's mom had a lot to teach Kiara, but she would spend those collabs with the zoomies and wouldn't pay attention (kinda like reading). Council had Sana and Kronii who didn't have much experience, but again, were able to figure things out yet mostly built solo. Fauna had, by far, the most experience coming in to the game, but she was a speed runner, not a builder. Finally they started to let everyone visit each other's servers and it's like the EN rednecks showing the big city folk their collection of sheds. Now they are a bit intimidated by all the talent and knowledge in the other branches. What they really need are some folks from the other branches to take their hands and make them do some Minecraft collabs. (the reason I say "make" is because they are going to be too shy to do so on their own and if EN decides what to build, it will be too modest for them to really learn anything. But I would really hate for them to feel forced. I just don't know how to word it better). I think IRyS and Kaela would make a good collab as IRyS likes the mining and they do tend to overlap steam times more often than not. Gura did promise both Moona and Kaela minecraft collabs at some point, but Gura has been crazy busy since then.

man I kinda hate that they are keep feels this inferiority in minecraft or any other game. I mean the pokemon unite event proved that they can do it well if they try to improve themselves. I got it this is more complex since they need somekind of work map idea and pretty much whole EN comes from diverse nationality and tradition around the world, but if they planned this at least a year before the event they want to make then I'm pretty sure it will be as fantastic as JP and ID event

Things like Minecraft sports is too much for EN...like time wise and all that...then there's the EN Curse too... knowing them the girls are just gonna stress themselves out if what they want didn't go as plan so yeah I'm fine if they dont held a competition like other branch...or they can do other games that's not Minecraft 🙏

Ada fans ID ngeledek EN malas buat event, dia bilang gitu karena ada fans EN bilang permainan Tag Of War terlalu membosankan waktu member holo lagi latihan dan emang kelamaan sih game Tag Of War pas latihan tapi bgitu pertandingan dimulai ga terlalu lama karena team vs team. Nah masalahnya ini fans ID bilang HoloEN malas buat event festival padahal mereka bingung mau buat event apa, orang tiap member EN berasal dr negara yg berbeda...

i agree but also disagree with kiara, i honestly do think EN COULD do a big Event like this & ARE ABLE to do this, but, aside from Timezones being an issue & everything being spontaneous like previous MC streams (& introverted lol), the problem is most of ENs interests in MC is not there, members like calli & kiara, & kiara called out calli for it, are just too busy to sit there, build & plan it, especially since it takes calli a month to play MC again so she has to relearn MC every time she does play, even if calli's track record on builds and projects is pretty good on MC, then kiara, she just hates building, she finds it boring as a stream and to herself, maybe if its a collab but even then she won't, she would want something like an adventure to add to it, make it worth a stream, so she's not getting far on that project, ame and gura can barely finish their own projects let alone stay focus to play MC for that long to plan a big event, remember ame's fun house, gura's hunted house, or even ame saying she will blow up PPP cuz their are other & better farms, then with ina, she just burned herself out on MC & she's pretty much done with it, she did everything she wanted, then councilrys only has fauna, aside from bunkeronii, none of them play mc that much, if not, at all, nor has gotten far to do anything big, even the new advent girls don't play MC as much either from what i heard, nerissa likes building in MC but other then that, she doesn't care for the whole game, she's a Terraria girl mostly from what i know

One simple solutions for EN member that can bring them back to play minecraft again: Allow them to use 'Creative Mode' in their server. (just like Nijisanji EN) So that they can build anything they want so easily and fast without spending much time on grinding the materials.(especially when they has no time or busy) And make it optional for other ID and JP if they want to use Creative mode or not. The thing is.. i dont know if Mane chan would allow them to use creative mode in their minecraft server. 😞

The problem with EN branch was, they have no interest, will / intention to achieve a common goal. Their individualistic is too strong attributed to their different timezones and cultures. JP have the same timezone and culture, so they able to achieve a common goal. ID also pretty much in the same timezone and pretty much have same culture in a way so they also able to achieve a common goal. in ID side, Anya rarely play MC, even she practiced for only 4 days before joining the grand opening server to build ID's server landmark in MC. Iofi has motion sickness and cant stand playing MC for too long, but under the same interest to achieve the same goal, they can work together. EN doesnt have this mentality. just remember the matter about Faufau explaining things, other member simply pretend to listen or even dont listen at all. Faufau has reached the point that she doesnt even care anymore. so yeah, EN will never achieve something as long as this kind of mentality with strong individualistic never change.

I genuinely wonder how much all the cavemEN jokes and constant negative comparison contributes to keeping EN away from minecraft. Like everyone rightfully understands that comparing things like viewers or subscribers is a bad thing to do but somehow nobody ever questions if constantly going "haha look at how stupid and pathetic the ENs are their builds are so worthless and pointless compared to the IDs or JPs" might be a bit of a dick move. Even the idea of them trying to do something is kind of treated like "look the monkey picked up a hammer he thinks he's people"