Kirby vs. Miele

  Рет қаралды 34,418

polarisman800

polarisman800

12 жыл бұрын

Kirby vs Miele test

Пікірлер: 94
@rickrude6301
@rickrude6301 10 жыл бұрын
Test is not fair. The Miele does not have its full suction because of the full smelly bag and an old clogged HEPA filter. The sales guy even said so. Any near full vacuum bag will emit a bad smell. The HEPA filter traps micro particles but is not designed to stop odors. The Kirby may have more suction on carpets but for bare floors and dusting, you don't need super suction. I don't like upright vacuums, I prefer canisters with hoses, they are lighter and more versatile
@WhiteKitta
@WhiteKitta 7 жыл бұрын
actually the Miele here did not have full suction manly because they had the suction nub set to the lowest setting!! LOL....look at the video again!....so either they did not read the instruction for the Miele or they did it un propose the help the Kirby win
@mportklr
@mportklr 11 жыл бұрын
Any vacuum will always pick up dirt after another vacuum goes first. There is another youtube video that shows they dyson picking up dirt after the kirby went first. Then the dyson went first and the kirby picked up dirt after the dyson. So in conclusion, the vacuum that goes last wins.
@kg5vacuums205
@kg5vacuums205 7 жыл бұрын
another goes down to the kirby and just remember the dirt meter is just a little of the ture power of the kirby vacuum
@nightwish487
@nightwish487 10 жыл бұрын
What everyone fails to say is the dirt meter is practically no distance from the motor to the meter. How much loss is caused just by hooking up the bag? We need a new way to compare the cleaning power. Not to mention all those attachments that more than likely get lost before you get to use them.
@StrongEnough78
@StrongEnough78 11 жыл бұрын
You're very right young Jedi lol, sorry I couldn't resist. I used to sell Kirbys. What he's using is called the "glass bag" and from what I remember, with the smaller chamber of the glass bag, the Kirby isn't even operating at full power. We've even put a stack of those filter pads on at one time and still had great suction. The pads are the same thickness as the actual bag. If you put the full bag on the Kirby, it will be that much stronger and pick up even more dust and dirt.
@stockjonebills
@stockjonebills 12 жыл бұрын
Miele's are the quietest vacuums of them all. Just quiet and powerful
@ARon82
@ARon82 11 жыл бұрын
They spent more money on those vacuums than their 6mo. rent contract
@Definitive400
@Definitive400 12 жыл бұрын
Don't forget the Royal Everlast...it's a metal, direct-air machine with a metal housing, motor-casing and most importantly...a metal fan. It too cleans carpets very effectively...perhaps the best...and is a fraction of the cost of a Kirby (~$600).
@HelloKittyFanMan.
@HelloKittyFanMan. 10 жыл бұрын
Uhuh. She who vacuums last wins. I saw that debunking on another video.
@krantz55
@krantz55 10 жыл бұрын
They have the suction turned all the way down. These people obviously work for Kirby and are doing a completely unfair comparison and faking the coughing and sneezing.
@scifirobb
@scifirobb 11 жыл бұрын
How long had she had the Miele? What was she using before? A fair test would be for the Miele to be used everyday for 30 days, and then see what the Kirby pulls up. The first vacuum cleaner by Scott and Fetzer to bear the Kirby name was produced in 1935. The 1914 Grasshopper was not designed by Jim Kirby, and was prior to the incorporation of Scott&Fetzer. The Kirby is heavy to move from floor to floor. To use the attachments on the second floor requires two trips up and two trips down.
@Davegvg3576
@Davegvg3576 11 жыл бұрын
Yeah.. Miele has been around 114 years. He who vacuums last always wins the "remaining dirt test." Any vacuum shop will show you this. I used a laser particle counter on a kirby today and it went off the scale, the thing puts so much dust out you might as well shake your rugs out in the living room. Go do any dirt test yourself at any vacuum store then try it with a Miele machine all the Miele places have a Kirby there. I just sold my 10 year old unit for 2/3 what the S8 I bought today cost.
@cmpmeridian1
@cmpmeridian1 7 жыл бұрын
The carpet is so filthy you can do this demo with any vacuum and it will pull dirt.
@linksmith1057
@linksmith1057 4 жыл бұрын
Okay, so I'm a fan of Kirby vacuums, they are my personal favorite because I love how versatile they are. But Miele makes a fantastic vacuum and I doubt I would trade one for a Kirby.
@dvspot
@dvspot 10 жыл бұрын
Even though I like Miele vacs, you cannot beat a direct suction head design vacuum, like Royal metal and kirby. The guy clearly showed the design flaw in the Miele vacuum, " bypass motor ".
@ryanlogan7632
@ryanlogan7632 10 жыл бұрын
Delegend81 untrue. That statement had been debunked. The Miele although a decent vacuum couldn't possibly be better because it has inferior airflow to the Kirby or Royal. I have two Kirby's and a Riccar. I would keep my Riccar over a Miele because in all honesty there isn't much of a difference.
@Frefind
@Frefind 11 жыл бұрын
miele is less expensive and the 2. vacuum always gets a little bit more out than the 1st so if there would be such a test available for mile, it would also gat out things, the kirby would not get.
@tinafrancis927
@tinafrancis927 4 жыл бұрын
Fake sneezes? Really Kirby? Great representation...
@rickrude6301
@rickrude6301 10 жыл бұрын
Which one filters out down to 0.3 micron particles better? I have a MIele S5 canister, it is supposed to be totally sealed so all air goes through the HEPA filter after the bag. I have seen KZfaq videos showing the Meile passing the 0.3 micron test. on laser particle counters. I would like to see the Kirby and Miele compared in such a test.
@williamkinkade2105
@williamkinkade2105 7 жыл бұрын
It would be a tie. Kirbys have HEPA bags and Mieles have HEPA filters. They both do pretty much the same thing.
@steeltag
@steeltag 5 жыл бұрын
William kinkade. do same thing. perform the same? not so much...Kirby has a much larger bag therefore surface area to catch dirt longer
@jdog20012001
@jdog20012001 9 жыл бұрын
If you only spend $800 on a vacuum, it probably won't work very well.
@williamkinkade2105
@williamkinkade2105 7 жыл бұрын
.....you do know Kirbys are only worth about $800, right? If you pay more than 900 for a vacuum, you're getting ripped off.
@scifirobb
@scifirobb 11 жыл бұрын
I manage a vacuum shop. The best vacuum is one you will USE! That is the first and foremost criteria. I have a basement full of Kirby trade-ins. I give 50.00 trade as a courtesy to the customer. The local Kirby distributor does not want them. If someone wants a used Kirby I rebuild one and sell it for $250.00 shampooer and all. I do not display or advertise Kirbys and the distributor sells me all his trade-ins cheap. People sweep their floors more than they spray paint. $2000.00? Ludicrous!
@tomp999
@tomp999 10 жыл бұрын
I think if you do the kirby test twice, put a new circle test filter on there and go over the same carpet area again, and show how it doesnt pick up much the 2nd time because it got it the first time, your points will be better proven. there is that "he who vacuums last wins" video out on youtube that is causing the disbelief i think. thanks for posting your video!
@steeltag
@steeltag 5 жыл бұрын
tomp999. yes It will...2nd and 3ed time. b/c of the limited size of the 'bag' aka the small dirt meter cloth...a full bag will have more surface area to catch more dirt..... its merely a surface area/sq/ft property. I have a meter, have tried it myself on my own carpet. Its a quick revealing test
@lizard944
@lizard944 9 жыл бұрын
Which pixel is the vacuum cleaner? By the way, you forgot to stop sniffling when you were running your precious Kirby.
@MrRogerslarry56
@MrRogerslarry56 10 жыл бұрын
This test was not fair to begin with. 1. OP did not show whether the HEPA and and bag were replaced prior to the Miele test (dirty smell clearly indicates a full or almost full bag), but they were and shown to be new on the Kirby test so you didn't get to see how much the Miele picked up. Also, turning on the vacuum for 2 seconds proves nothing but there was residual dirt in the lines. The settings for the Miele were not shown either (it has multiple suction settings for each different type of surface), which could mean that it was set to the wrong setting which prevents it from sucking up nearly as much as it would if set correctly. Plus you are comparing a 499.00 vacuum cleaner ( Amazon.com) to a 1500-2500 vacuum cleaner. Sorry I have a Eureka at home which does perform better then the Kirby we picked up for 50 bucks at an estate sale. Last note, the Kirby and Miele are of the same design the only difference is the whole for the suction is bigger on the Kirby but essentially they operate the same way except the Miele has 2 motors one for the suction and one for the brush while the Kirby only has 1 for both.
@nathanielaranda8407
@nathanielaranda8407 8 жыл бұрын
direct air will always be the best kirbys are heavy but if you are lifting a lot day after day you will get use to it . when my shark navigator DLX goes I am going for a refurbished Kirby . they are rated top in reliability from consumer reports . and I vacuum a lot
@williamkinkade2105
@williamkinkade2105 7 жыл бұрын
That Shark is probably gonna last several more years. Why not get the Kirby now and use the Shark as a backup?
@nathanielaranda8407
@nathanielaranda8407 7 жыл бұрын
that's what I have decided to do already :)
@mintsiez
@mintsiez 5 жыл бұрын
I could've done with out the fake sneezing and sniffles i would've sent him on his way as soon as he stared pulling that shit. also of course there is going to be more dirt you did not vacuum the whole carpet as soon as he steps on the carpet it would've moved more dirt over
@carlbaum2265
@carlbaum2265 10 жыл бұрын
First off lets get some good lighting and a better camera.I will put my Miele up against any vacuum on the market being in the flooring business for over 20 years I can tell you its one of the best I give you one thing direct drive vacuums are the most power,I have an Electrolux Santini contractor series that i use on job sites its one of the most powerful Direct drive vacuum I've ever used,but people like using attachments and having them readily available also direct drive vacuums aren't good on real thick carpets or hardwood. That's where the Miele S7steps in its an all around great powerfulI vacuum with great agitation!! Check out the reviews
@WhiteKitta
@WhiteKitta 7 жыл бұрын
I think in general both vacuums are very powerful vacuums, both are high quality and are made to last (my mom has had her Miele over 14 years now) but its Interesting how most people don't agree with this video (with so many thumps down)......hummm.....I have a Miele U1 Cat and Dog, so I know how this vacuum works, ......I can clearly see that the Miele in this video has had its suction power nub set to the lowest (aka weakest) setting......so it seems you either did not read the instruction for the Miele or you did it on propose the help the Kirby win.I was once interested in buying a Kirby myself, but after having my Friends Kirby for over 3 weeks while she was on Vacation, I totally changed my mind......because #1 I then already had my Miele and did not notice it being any better then my Miele in cleaning the carpets, # 2 when cleaning the kitchen floors the Kirby didn't do a very good job, because it actually sprayed thing around and my Miele never does that and has no problem at all getting every crumb and dust particle with ease # 3 the Kirby is way too freaken loud (I literally got the urge to wear ear plugs), # 4 lots of the dirt the Kirby picks up gets back into the air, it just isn't very hygienic unfortunately, and that is another very important thing to me personally, I can’t stand smelling wet dog in the air after or during vacuuming, # 5 to clean with the attachments with a Kirby is the biggest ass hassle ever!.........So for me and my personal needs a Kirby will just not cut it.
@alessaray7721
@alessaray7721 7 жыл бұрын
why didn't that owner just clean and service her current vac and could have saved buying a new one I don't have either vacs but when she zoomed into the red vac that thing was disgusting lady looked like half a mattress was stuffed in that thing common sense right there just clean it!
@terryb492
@terryb492 9 жыл бұрын
It takes 1 filter to clogged and lower the performance kirby has 1 filter and that's all it needs not 3 or 4 filters if u want something more powerful than a kirby buy a royal ry8300 metal or a riccar raidiance
@jlmor6487
@jlmor6487 10 жыл бұрын
Kirby is the BOSS of all vacuum..... 100 YEARS and still going strong !! This vacuum Miele is made of plastic and will not be here for 100 years ! Well maybe not as a vacuum . Lets do our part in recycling ....... Sorry Miele .
@MrRogerslarry56
@MrRogerslarry56 10 жыл бұрын
Kirby was started in 1914, Miele has been selling high end appliances since 1888. Just because it is a 1500-2500 dollar vacuum does not mean its better and this video is biased and the OP are both probably Kirby salesmen
@jlmor6487
@jlmor6487 10 жыл бұрын
Larry Rogers The first Kirby vacuums were designed by Jim Kirby (1885-1971) for George Scott and Carl Fetzer after World War I, although the Kirby name was not used on a vacuum cleaner until the 1930s.[3] James Kirby invented the "vacuette" circa 1920.[2] The Vacuette Electric, introduced in 1925 with its removable floor nozzle and handle, became the forerunner of today's multi-attachment Kirby vacuum models. In 1935, the company introduced the Kirby Model C, the first product to carry Jim Kirby's name.[4] From 1935 through the 1960s, continuous improvements and refinements were made to the Kirby home care system. The last model of this first generation, the Dual Sanitronic 80, was produced in 1967 and still resembled the original.[4] In 1970, input from Kirby distributors, dealers, management and customers guided Kirby engineers in developing the Kirby Classic. The model was an instant success, with soaring sales, forcing the company to expand its manufacturing facilities outside of Cleveland for the first time. In 1972, Kirby West began operations in Andrews, Texas. The facility doubled the company's manufacturing capabilities.[4] Berkshire Hathaway bought Kirby parent Scott Fetzer in 1986 for $315 million.[2] Two years prior, Ivan Boesky had offered to buy Scott Fetzer for $60 a share, or $420 million.[5] Warren Buffett has singled out Scott Fetzer to Berkshire's shareholders as the "prototype" for the "kind of company-and acquisition-he was interested in."[6] According to Berkshire managers, "absolutely no changes were made to the existing Scott Fetzer business or management, and the entire business (and its jet) was preserved."[7] Beginning in the 1990s, the Generation series - starting with the Generation 3, ushered in a new platform for the cleaner. The addition of TechDrive variable power assist eliminated 90% of the effort required to move the unit back and forth.[4] As of 2003, Kirby is the largest source of revenue and profit for Scott Fetzer, with approximately 500,000 sales per year, about a third of which are outside the United States.[8] In 2003, Scott Fetzer sold the vacuums to about 835 factory distributors, who in turn sell the vacuums door to door .
@lyndon8488
@lyndon8488 10 жыл бұрын
hahah
@Nycholas1998
@Nycholas1998 12 жыл бұрын
one who vacuums last wins
@duncandistortion
@duncandistortion 8 жыл бұрын
miele for me,technology moves foward,the kirby is a dinosaur & the headlight bulbs don't last long.
@williamkinkade2105
@williamkinkade2105 7 жыл бұрын
Really? Then explain to me why I've seen Kirbys from the 80s that still have their stock bulbs. "Moving forward" doesn't really matter when they pretty much have it perfected. Kirbys can't get much better than they are.
@duncandistortion
@duncandistortion 7 жыл бұрын
sorry if you've a kirby collection but,they're shite!.
@williamkinkade2105
@williamkinkade2105 7 жыл бұрын
WC HEAD.​​​ You seem to be a brand elitest, calling a brand shite, likely without ever using one of their products. Kirbys are one of the best vacuums out there. Am I saying they're the best? No. Am I saying they're better than Mieles? No.
@duncandistortion
@duncandistortion 7 жыл бұрын
well you are definitely not the person who bought my g5 off me.
@williamkinkade2105
@williamkinkade2105 7 жыл бұрын
WC HEAD. ....and what does that mean?
@vincenzomastrovincenzo9492
@vincenzomastrovincenzo9492 10 жыл бұрын
it's bound you don't know Vorwerk's vacuum cleaners :)
@vacuumcleanercollectorfixe1499
@vacuumcleanercollectorfixe1499 9 жыл бұрын
I have a vorwerk vacuum from 1930s
@tinafrancis927
@tinafrancis927 4 жыл бұрын
Not enough cfm on those and who wants to carry a bulky upright on their shoulder to use attachments
@johnboudreau7212
@johnboudreau7212 10 жыл бұрын
Common door to door Sales scam ! You can do the same thing to the Kirby if you follow it with the Miele ! I use to do it after Kirby Sales man did the Salt test and I was demoing for electrolux and pulled up more salt behind the Kirby ! If you have been using a inferior vacuum for years, you will have a huge build up of dirt in your carpet and any vacuum will fail this test followed by any vacuum that is better than the one previously used by the home owner. Door to door vacuums are good high end vacuums but they are up to 3 or 4 x what they should cost. You can get vacuums just as good if not better and in Kirbys case a hell of a lot easier to use at a reputable local Vacuum Dealer. Better brands include Miele,Riccar,Simplicity,BK Air Tec,Lindhaus and many more .You wont find any of these at the Box Stores or the like. Don't be scammed by parlor tricks or high cost, do your research and if you buy a door to door vac negotiate a fair price which can vary by as much as $1500.00 + or -.
@williamkinkade2105
@williamkinkade2105 7 жыл бұрын
Kirbys are great machines, but the sales tactics are disgusting
@Ramcharger18
@Ramcharger18 5 жыл бұрын
There is no way in hell a Miele can clean as good as Kirby! The Kirby has double the amount of cfm as the Miele and way better agitation! The two most important things to clean carpet! I’d love to know the vacuum that u think is on par with the cleaning ability of a Kirby or any direct air machine.
@jimwalker3359
@jimwalker3359 10 жыл бұрын
There is physically no way that miele can clean better than Kirby. Personally I would not even waste time comparing them. The suction knob makes no difference, it's in the design of the vacuum. You can turn it all the way up and I still would not waste time comparing it to a Kirby. I know nothing about Miele, I just know the design. All vacuums with that design have very little suction at the head.
@kctyphoon
@kctyphoon 9 жыл бұрын
you have NO fucking idea what you are talking about - the only good statement you made was "i know nothing"
@jimwalker3359
@jimwalker3359 9 жыл бұрын
That kinda describes you. There is no way unless you have much larger motors and/or fans that a hose vacuum can have more suctions than a direct contact vacuum. Comparing an equal size hose vacuum to a Kirby, the Kirby will win everytime. I'd be happy to prove that to you anytime.
@kctyphoon
@kctyphoon 9 жыл бұрын
please do, i own both models in this video - and btw, when it comes to carpets, the beater brush is more important than suction, which is why suction it used as a marketing tool for every vacuum on tv, cause dumbass like you believe it.. lmao
@jimwalker3359
@jimwalker3359 9 жыл бұрын
You are cute :) Clueless, but cute....
@kctyphoon
@kctyphoon 9 жыл бұрын
the kirby has remained basically unchanged since 1950 - in the way they do just about everything.. yes- im clueless,, but my carpets are cleaner than yours, and so is the air in my home :) the only dust my kirby sees now is whats collecting on it in my attic.. take care..
@maryoassyrian2007
@maryoassyrian2007 12 жыл бұрын
Miele is better and more conveniant. Miele has the best filtration, the best tools and the best sound.
@williamkinkade2105
@williamkinkade2105 7 жыл бұрын
Miele has the best filtration. You do realize that HEPA means the same thing no matter what machine it's on, right?
@fjon4060
@fjon4060 7 жыл бұрын
I don't believe this. I own a Kirby and all it does is blow dust all over the house. As far as the Kirby destroying pennies, nails and rocks.... BS!
@harryrose69
@harryrose69 10 жыл бұрын
This video is too dark. Kirby make great cleaners BUT the have THE MOST UNETHICAL SELLING METHODS I HAVE EVERY SEEN. I would never buy a new one because of the way they are sold! AND THE MOST CRAZY PRICE! Only worth about 1/4 of what you pay for a new one.
@580678
@580678 12 жыл бұрын
not a far test
@dvspot
@dvspot 10 жыл бұрын
Because kirby is the boss.
@lyndon8488
@lyndon8488 10 жыл бұрын
i am the boss
@therischow
@therischow 8 жыл бұрын
Fuck both of u. I'm the boss
@therischow
@therischow 8 жыл бұрын
Lyndon What?!? Haha your such a tool. Mom jokes? Man your just a confused transgender teen who's upset cuz you can't pee next to little girls.
@lyndon8488
@lyndon8488 8 жыл бұрын
therischow you suck tools. cool have fun with that. stick a kirby up ur ass fool
@xw4
@xw4 10 жыл бұрын
Fake! What's making that guy sneeze is the smell of his own lies! Miele is bay far a better cleaner, lighter and quieter than the Kirby. I have owned a Miele red velvet for over seven years. Its still going strong. Had to clean the gunk out of the power head recently. Used a dryer vent brush to do that. It's a canister, but still the best vacuum I have ever used. And I have been through a lot of vacuums. Kirby, hoover, dyson, dirt devil, Eureka and rainbow. Miele is the only vacuum I will own.
@kalv1nk
@kalv1nk 9 жыл бұрын
Lol, learn how to say Miele before you make a video comparing it to another brand. Everyone knows the last to vacuum always wins.
@krantz55
@krantz55 10 жыл бұрын
That Miele is in poor poor shape. That is why the Kirby did better. Kirby is overrated. Wouldn't buy either one. FilterQueen is what I would choose. But that's just me.
@williamkinkade2105
@williamkinkade2105 7 жыл бұрын
Ha. Filter Queen. What a piece of shit vacuum. You have to replace a filter every time you vacuum, they start losing suction as soon as you start cleaning, and they fall apart after not even a year worth of use. I will never own another Filter Queen.
@katylady1981
@katylady1981 7 жыл бұрын
I've been in the vacuum business for 6 years. I can tell you that if you were to do a fair demo of these (clean both of them, put new bags in both and HEPA filter in the Miele, do a particle test of the exhaust) you'd find that the Miele, pronounced MEE-la, would decimate the Kirby on all levels. I've had my Miele Cat and Dog for a year and have never gotten an odor out of it, despite having dogs and a cat in my home. The swivel function, suction control, sealed system (Miele is basically doubling as a portable air cleaner when equipped with a HEPA filter) and you have your tools right on hand without having to disassemble the vacuum to connect a hose that then has to be stored separate from the unit. Also, it's been proven over and over that no vacuum can get 100% of particles from carpet, so if you had done the same test with the Miele AFTER the Kirby, it would have gotten that was left behind. oh, and your suction setting was wrong, just saying. Good attempt though.
Vacuums That Are Better Than Dyson or Shark
18:34
Performance Reviews
Рет қаралды 139 М.
EVOLUTION OF ICE CREAM 😱 #shorts
00:11
Savage Vlogs
Рет қаралды 7 МЛН
Little girl's dream of a giant teddy bear is about to come true #shorts
00:32
Llegó al techo 😱
00:37
Juan De Dios Pantoja
Рет қаралды 56 МЛН
55 cfm vs 121 cfm (Dyson vs Kirby)
1:57
Vacuumtests
Рет қаралды 13 М.
Kirby Sentria Vacuum
2:38
matthewtshaver
Рет қаралды 119 М.
Was 3D TV actually poo?
21:26
Linus Tech Tips
Рет қаралды 2,9 МЛН
Best Vacuum Cleaner of All Time - 5 Vacuum Experts polled
3:17
Vacuum Wars
Рет қаралды 79 М.
You Said I Was a Fool - Panasonic 4K Blu-ray Player
12:14
Linus Tech Tips
Рет қаралды 2,1 МЛН
EVOLUTION OF ICE CREAM 😱 #shorts
00:11
Savage Vlogs
Рет қаралды 7 МЛН