KS. Awesome video. Very informative and professional, your production is tops!. . Thanks for sticking with guns and no ranting. Again I am going to snivel a bit. I’m in california and can’t have the glock. I do have the non 2.0 shield and love it. I did some trigger clean up by minor polishing some rough surfaces..... keep up the good work

The best thing about this comparison is there is no bad choice.

LOVING my 43X right now. Yeah I wish the grip was a little shorter but I'll tell ya, being able to get that 3rd finger on the grip makes a big difference to me.

I appreciate your "if only" videos. They are very well done and very professional. Those 20 minutes just flew by.

Thank you KS for all the time, thought and effort you put into your “If I could only have one”... videos! What’s funny in my mind...sometimes I can’t have just one 😂! Have a great weekend 👍

Thanks KS , you just helped me break the tie on on my next CCW. I am looking at both of these pistols and have decided on the Shield. Really enjoy your videos. Keep ‘‘em coming.

I'm a new gun owner and I really enjoy your videos. Very informative. A bit difficult for me to follow everything because I'm just learning. But I was impressed, for sure! Keep up the good work.

Both are Great Firearms, I would like to have both, but couldn't do that. I chose the one with the Great Lifetime Warranty and The Great Customer Service, The Shield. Thank you for the good and very helpful uploads, they are always appreciated.

KSGunGuy........ I just watched this video. I love how you do a unbiased comparison and focused on the benefits of each.

5th review and now I know that I want the Shield. Thanks

Bought the Glock 43x earlier today to replace my old carry, my .45 S&W M&P which was too big for summer in my area. Found this video afterwards. Great choice on both!

I went with the 43x and the new Shield Arms S15 (15 rounds flush fit) for the glock. These mags are a game changer.

Great job on the reviews. Bought the shield 9mm for my wife and she absolutely loves it. Although my choice for carry is my Smith M&P 9c with double stack mag, but I do enjoy shooting her shield as well.

I just picked up the 43x for $439. It feels really good. I’ve only had it to the range once. I’m still preferring my M&P Shield, but I hope with more range time, the Glock will be my go to gun. Especially with the availability of the Shield Arms S15 magazines.

Good video! Watching your videos I have noticed that we perceive recoil very differently. I always have felt the heavier the slide, the more recoil I feel. It is interesting to see other people's perceptions. Thanks for more great insight!

You are so lucky in The US to be able to CCW. Happy New Year all the best from Australia 🇦🇺

Miss your reviews! Not Many honest and good comparison like you do. Hope your doing well! Have a merry Christmas!

Another great video. The Shield has been my edc for quite a while now and I tend to prefer the ergo's of the m&p series over the Glocks. However, the 43x does interest me for it's slightly larger capacity. The original 43 just felt like a afterthought from Glock to me. Think this firearm, along with the 48 fit a nice "between" size for capacity and comfort.

First video of yours that I have seen. I like the sportscaster voice approach and you are very thorough.👌🏻

Amidst a sea of biased gun reviewers, I really appreciate having found your channel! I am hoping for your comparison of the new Mossberg MC1 in the near future! Thank you!

Nice Review and Video KS . There both Great guns , can't go wrong with either one ... Have a Great and Blessed Weekend KS. 👍👋

I definitely agree!,hard to beat any 2.0 out of the box especially the prices

I was doing this exact comparison at the gun shop today. Both are great guns. I went with the G43x just because it felt better in my hand. No other reason.

I put my hands on the glock 48 a few days ago. And I gotta say I want that for summer.. that slim grip feels sooo much better than even my 19

The regular 43 would be a closer comparison. Loved the video!!

I have to go with the 43X with no thought process to it at all. Longer grip for big hands and better control over recoil because of the grip. I have heard that changing the trigger can mess with the guns function. Is this true?

Great info! Gotta ask though,. I've never seen a range target that spins. Whats the use for that?

Just got the 43x with the black slide from factory, that’s how they make them now, have the shield also , I like the feel and shoot ability of the Glock , the 15 round mag is a no brained for the ultimate appendix edc

I've owned the Shield 2.0 and currently own the 43X. Sold the Shield only because the Glock won me over with the capacity.

Do talengrips beef up the grip as well? I have a shield 2.0 and want the grip just a little wider

My 2.0 is upgraded almost exactly like he's, except, I install madgguts in both magazines to give me an extra round. I installed an Aluminum mag release button and Pinky extension base plate. and I still carry the 2.0. Love it!

Would you carry these with modified triggers? Thanks for you excellent video.

CZ P10c 😎 Out of these two I'd take the Shield all day...good stuff as always!

Holy shit bro, your videos are so informative! Had to subscribe!

Thanks for not blabbing off the point. Great vid

100% agree with you on this comparison. Well done.

I have the 1st gen Shield. It's a great gun in it's own right, and you did the 2.0 justice in this vid. The thing that made me look at the 43x was the wider and slightly more boxy grip, as well as capacity. I finally made the call to buy a 43x and took the chance to upgrade to the night sights. You're right, the stock ones are junk. Holding this gun, it has the feel I've always wanted. My pinky stays on, it fills the palm but not too much, and Shield Arms is releasing a flush fit 15 round magazine in the next month or two. A gun that feels better in my hand and DOUBLES the capacity of my Shield? Yeah, I'll keep the ol' S&W as a bug or deep conceal, but the 43x is my new EDC. Still a good vid, even and balanced comparison. Thanks!

Just subbed to your channel really enjoy your videos ! now which one to get the 365 43x or the shield ?

Dude, I always love your vids! Keep is going, bud!

The Shield is significantly cheaper, comes with good metal sights, has flexible capacity for deep concealment up to 10+1 with aftermarket extensions, better grip texture, better ergonomics, great aftermarket support, and great reliability. To me this isn't even really a competition. Shield all the way.

Great video. I have been looking at the shield for a while, but the issue I run into is frame length. I have big hands, and the Shield 9mm is just a hair too short. The .45 fits a lot better. It has that longer frame, which fits my hand better. But now it's more expensive to train. If it were 9mm vs 9mm - I'd buy the 43x.

Great video KS! What would you choose between G43x and CZP10s as a CCW? Would the shield still be a better option? Best regards!

Great job with the vid and comparison. Still torn, even as a Glock guy...but don’t think you could really go wrong here. 👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼

What was the trigger that you have on the 43x?

Thank you for your great work!

Great video. Thinking buying the Shield. Any thoughts is it best to buy with or without safety for carry? Also is that a good ammo capacity for a carry gun? Thanks!

Would the m&p shield 2.0 slide fit on the Glock 43 frame?

Nice comparison, thought I'm partial to the Glock, I've heard nothing but good things about the M&P Shield

Thanks KS, and if you could only have one and you need to decide between shield or 2.0 compact 3.6", which one have you choose ?

What trigger do you have on there?

G43X is on top. Bought it first week it came out, love it.

whats the link on the barrel and trigger kit for the s&w shield 2.0?

Great comparison video, KS! I like both pistols but I think the Sig P365 is better than both of the pistols with the 12 rd magazine. I love seeing more pistols come on the market because it gives us more options. Keep up the great work my friend! Carry on! 😎✌️

Great review! I switched from my shield to the 43x and couldn't be happier. Personally I just shoot glocks better. Question, what model ameriglo night sights did you upgrade to on the 43x? Link? Thx!

Hi, I own the S&W shield, and like some others I do wish we had the possibility to add more rounds without compromising our ability to conceal the firearm. The grip on my pisto has cost me a couple of shirts over time but is is great with staying on target. All in, and given the price, I would stick with my Shield. I found mine for less than $300, brand new, at a gun show. Let’s hope someone comes up with a magazine that adds capacity.

I am looking to purchase my first firearm. I owned a revolver when I was 17, but didn’t really use it. I just kept it for a couple years and got rid of it. This is my first personal purchase. I had few people recommend the p365, Glock 43x, or the s&w m&p shield. What is the best for carrying and for shooting. Mind you this will be for me and my fiancée, and she has no experience with guns whatsoever. I want a gun the is economical, but also consistent and reliable. Also one that she can learn discipline, aim, and form fairly easily with. I am open to suggestions if anyone has any. Thanks in advance!

Hey Ks great vid. I just ordered a shield gen 1. Got it new for 215.00. Do u think the new trigger on the 2 is worth the extra cash. Thanks. Watch 3 guys every week.

The 43x has aftermarket 15 round flush fit mags out

Did you add the duty kit or just swap out the trigger? Great comparison video!

I just traded in my OG m&P shield and Diamondback DB9 for the Glock 43x along with $130. Felt I got a good deal. Due to the guns being dated. A lot of great carry over the 12 years and 15 years respectively. Awesome video bud. Very informative

As always, good video brother. I love both of these pistols, but the 43x is the first Glock I have left the trigger alone on. I really like it. I added talons and hackathorn grips to it though. The 10+1 capacity beats my shield, even with mag guts on it. They are both good pistols and you cant go wrong with either. I have to select the 43x though.

I agree 100%. Thanks for a great review.

I have a PC Shield and think its decent although I never tried these up grades..........always good to hear you

I know this video was almost a year ago, but I don't see the Shield 2.0 in the same price range as the original Shield M&P, would there be a good reason to pay more for the 2.0?

Own and love them both, but my slight nod goes to the 43x simply due to the extra capacity. Nice, informative vid BTW.

I was looking at both pistols it was hard for me to decide but I agree with what you say about concealment and price is better and a Smith and Wesson just looks sexier thanks for helping me out with the decision 😄Helpful video thanks

Is that a l2d barrel on the shield ? Has it really improved the accuracy of the gun and is it worth the money?

I love my 43x. The 10 round magazine is great for CWP. It fits in my hand well and I personally love the slide color. I think the Glock looks better than the Smith but of course that is a personal choice. I respect your opinion and love these “if I could only have one “ videos. Keep them coming.

Where did you find the G43x sights? Can’t find them anywhere!

Once again nice comparison. I recently was looking to augment my current carry choice, the CZ P-01 has been my go to and I looked at all of the usuals: the Shield 2.0, Glock 43X, Sig P365, after careful consideration I really liked the the way the Shield 2.0 felt and looked, additionally like you I felt it was the most versatile, but at the end of the day I ended up with the Glock 19 Gen5 MOS, haha. Come this summer I will likely get The Shield 2.0. Nice series.

Very nice video, easy to understand.

Another great video; I do agree with the Shield for the overall package/value. The Shield is a very well proven platform. I do carry the 1.0 version & it's just hard to justify what it would cost to move to the Glock or Sig with holster, mags & etc. However any these are great choices!

great review as usual but you scared me for a sec. i think you some how got a picture of my safe and decided to go with every gun that I own. 😂😂😂😂😂 we have a lot same weapons 👍👍👍 keep up great work and less red bull cause your hands are shaking

So glad you got the tactical pontoon trigger I installed an agency arms flat trigger and it was garbage so I ordered the tactical pontoon haven't got it yet can't wait to get it this vid made my day awesome vid

As expected, outstanding perspective & great content thanks. I agree with conclusion. However, I have no experience with any G43 at all. Our household has 4 Shields as CC & PP. 3 are 45acp & 1 9mm 1.0. My expectation is that S&W will bring 9mm & 40 over into the 45 platform and get the increased capacity to compete/contend with the 43x. They will likely produce a longer barrel version (3.8 or 4.0) also to compete for the G48 market. Just looks very doable & it makes sense. Keep it up.

Have you ever tried the magguts spring in the shield that gives you 2 extra rounds? I would like to know what you think about it.

The Shield that guards the realms of men.

Is that a stock trigger on the 43x?

Confused...is the mag release ambi or not?

Love the video! I would choose the shield as well!

Do both of the firearms shown in the video have modified/upgraded triggers?

I just bought a G43x (Night Sight Version) - Shoots Great.....300 Rounds of Blazer Brass with no malfunctions and good tight groups. Grip feels good and the lighter weight makes it nice for CCW.

Great vid!! Thanks.

I can buy either gun. Both cost 549. Which would you get?

Guys do yourself a favor and go ahead and subsribe , the reviews on this channel are very in depth, well thought out and detailed, you’re not gonna get any better.

Great Review! Can you please tell me what trigger is on the 43x?

great review man! thanku:)

What trigger is n the 43x and were did u get it please i just got the 43x and the trigger is hard to pull ive got a 2.0 shield

Good video with pertinent info 👍🏼

Both look like quality ccw's, but both could use something from the other. If you put the grip texture of the 2.0 on the 43X you have a great ccw. Put a longer grip/mag capacity on the 2.0 and it's a homerun. I agree they both could use a better trigger which you've already addressed. I love the flat-faced triggers, and especially the one you have in the Glock. Great review as usual brother, Cheers!

What's your thoughts on the ss80 would you consider doing a video on it?

A well-tempered and seemingly unbiased approach and presentation is definitely welcome in the gun community. Subbed, keep it up man. I can't stand all these political youtube tough guys that think they're right because they're loud and obnoxious. Anyway, just bought a 43x and I'm very happy with it. I may have chosen something like P365 if I wasn't already trained with a glock and had to carry one at work every day, but the 43X is certainly a comfortable and quality firearm.

What is the trigger on his 43x?

where can i buy the sights and trigger for the shield?

On your comment on grip textures. I think that varies a little from gun to gun. We have 2 Springfield mod.2’s and one has excellent texture while the other is quite slippery. I put a talon grip on the slippery one. Just my observation 😀. As always great video!

well done! I came to the same conclusion. With Maguts I get one extra round in the 8 round mag and I've got 9+1.

Thx awesome review

I have both and love both .that had to be a hard choice.?

I had a shield and switched to a G26, now running the 43X. All are exceptional.

Hey KS. Great review and two great choices for sure. My EDC for over two years is a Shield 9 PC. Love my Shield. So off topic, I saw on CDDN Sports an EAA MC28SA (9mm w/reflex optic) for $369. That’s the first I’ve heard of this gun. I haven’t found a review on this model with the optic. $369 is unbelievable with the features it has. Was curious if you’ve heard or know anything about it? Thank you Sir.