춤을 춰본 사람은 알겠지만 윈터는 확신의 재능러임. 카리나가 동작이 시원시원해서 확실히 더 돋보이고 당연히 잘 추는 것도 맞는데, 윈터 느낌을 살리라고 하면 못 할걸 윈터는 반대가 가능할거고

노래랑 안무에 따라 달라보임 개인적으로 넥레나 세비지 같이 쫀득함이 어우러진 곡들은 윈터가 낫고 동작 크게 쓰는 블맘이나 스텝 많이 쓰는 스텝백 같은 곡은 카리나가 나은 것 같음

각자 다른 스타일로 완벽하게 소화하는거 넘 좋음 .. 카리나는 동작 크고 힘있어서 시원하고 윈터는 깔끔하고 절제된듯

같이 놓고 보니 윈터 쪽에 눈이 더 간다. 윈터는 뭔가 보는 사람으로 하여금 관전하기 편하게 춤을 춤. 매우 매끄러움. 카리나도 물론 잘 추지만... 너무 와일드해서 대학교 응원단 혹은 야구장 응원단 같이 무언가를 응원하기 위해 더 적합한 느낌

Personally I think Winter keeps her dancing very centered in her core that's why everything looks so clean, precise, and balanced all the time, whereas Karina kind of relies on her natural talents, which allows her to add more elements and freedom, and like they said, boldness to her moves. They're very similiar to EXO's dance line with Lay and Winter being similar vs Kai and Karina.

절제된 춤선을 좋아해서 윈터가 이쁘더라구요 직캠도 찾아보고~ 근데 전체로볼땐 아무래도 동작크게하는사람한테 눈길이가죠... 제 취향은 내적으로 절제하면서 추는 넘사벽인 사람을 좋아해서 둘이비교하는 영상보면 윈터만 보게되요ㅋ 이게 취향차이고 누굴좋아하냐 차인거같아요

무대 중심을 확실하게 잡아주는건 카리나 파워가 가장 쎔 튕기는 안무 같은거 무게 있는 안무나 먼가 쎈캐 느낌 줘야하는 안무나 제스쳐 잘함

카리나는 춤에 포인트 지점이 있어서 퍼포먼스 형식으로 어떻게 하면 더 좋은 모습을 보일 수 있을까를 생각하면서 춤을 추는 것 같음. 그래서 카리나가 포인트를 안잡은 부분엔 윈터가 동작을 날리지 않는 편이니까 윈터를 보면 됨

윈터는 자로 잰것처럼, 안무가 처럼 정확한 박자마다 춤이 정확하게 들어가는게 진짜 카타르시스... 잔움직임이 없어보임.

winter be really having one of the sharpest and most accurate angles ive seen in kpop, i know how people usually are attracted to dancers with big movements and strong energy, but theres something about the extreme control (ngl almost robotic) that winter has over her moves that makes it look so clean and satisfying to watch,, for eg the savage chorus movement and 2nd chorus,, i feel that winter would do AMAZING in tutting

I guess because winter of her clean simple moves many enjoy watching her fancams

Winter=clean,sharp,controls,has pops Karina=bold,bouncy,energetic

뭔가 춤도 성격이 드러난다고 해야되나? 윈터는 노래할때랑 춤추는거랑 똑같음 뭔가 똑부러져..

As a non dancer, Karina dance like rent due & its fun and Winter dance like this is what she's told to do, so she does it exact, no more no less.. both amazing to me tho

Winter's cover dance of boa's song at mama 2020 and Karina's cover of "bola rebola" at knowing bros personally my favorite clips of their dancing

winter is literally a perfect female idol her beauty her vocals and her dance😭❤💋

윈터는 진짜 메보인데 춤도 와우

They should watch Kai and Karina in beyond drive tucson 😇🙏🏻

Winter has move own dance and statisfying

남자 쪽 카리나 되게 좋아하는거 눈에 보임 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

my eyes always go to winter in group dances, she has a very precise, sharp way of executing moves thats so pleasing to the eyes.

윈터는 댄동출신에 춤으로 캐스팅 됐음~아무래도 프리스타일보다는 정석적인걸 추구함..그래서 잔동작까지 아주 정확하게 춤..기본기가 탄탄하다고 해야 하나??ㅎㅎ

I’ve always thought Winter’s dancing is so clean and precise. Personally I like her dancing style better but I understand why Karina is the main dancer

비전문가인 제가 정확히 표현주겠습니다...윈터님은 내면의 쫀득 쫀득한 춤선이고 카리나님은 외면의 시원 시원한 춤선이시네...

춤좀 추는사람들은 확실히 윈터한테 눈길 감 ㅋㅋ뚝딱 없이 간지가 나 영상에서 댄서라고 한 딱 그 느낌 잔 동작 팝핀 다 잡아주면서 쓸데없는 힘은 안씀

i love winters popping when she dances !!

춤좀 배워보고 춰본 사람은 알겠지만 카리나는 일반인도 열심히 배우면 가능한 춤의영역이라면 윈터는 아 저게 춤의 재능의영역이구나 단순히 배운다고해서 절대 나올 수 없는.. 평가하는 댄서들도 초반엔 살짝 그런 뉘앙스로 얘기하다 괜히 영상 올라가고 까일까봐 필터링으로 계속 걸러내서 자제해서 오히려 뒤로 갈수록 카리나에 대한 칭찬과 부연설명 구구절절 하는거.

'winter is the textbook of dance'😮❤

Karina is the best ace dancer in aespa

암만봐도 늘 윈터에 눈길감 춤선이 예쁘고 안정적이고 박자에 딱 맞춰서 모든 동작을 느낌도 살리면서 정확하게춤

에스파 직캠 2번보는 이유가 윈터 춤 때문이라고 웃으면서 말들 하던데 윈터 춤 언급 많고 잘추는데 보여줄 기회도 많았으면 좋겠다,,노래를 너무잘해서 상대적으로 춤 언급 적은데 정말 잘춤😭내적팝에 강약조절도 잘하는데 팔다리골반관절 아이솔레이션도 잘함

I love how Winter do her Cleans Mover, strong Vibes, Her own Style Dance and all dance moves she doing and perfect as Lead Dancer, and Karina and Winter is aespa best Dancer

There is a reason why karina is the center and MAIN DANCER. Her dance is BOLD AND UNRESTRAINED. The power each of her movement holds is amazing. She is always on point and she makes even the hardest of steps look easy. Winter is a good dancer. Her moves are clean and she executes the choregraphy well but KARINA takes the win here. There is a reason why she is the main dancer and GIRLS dance break is the proof.

여돌중 윈터 탑쓰리인 듯...춤 진짜 잘추는 것 같음

kpop stan twt always discredit aespa's dancing yet here we have PROFESSIONAL DANCERS praising aespa's dancing skills. I hope people won't believe anything your read on social media because everyone on the internet tries to be something they are not and judge people without respect. Only trust professionals when it comes to performances because their opinions are what we can consider constructive and valid. Anyways, stan aespa and let's wait together for their comeback :)

minjeong rlly caught my attention. her dancing r so clean and powerful without trying so hard. she's just calm but slaying

둘 다 다른 방식으로 잘 추는 거 같은데 팬덤에 갠팬이 많은지 누가 더 잘한다 이런 댓글이 많네

윈터님 생각보다 너무 잘추시고 귀여움ㅠㅠ♡ 진짜 저 쫀득쫀득한 춤선 좋아하는데 윈터님이 다 가지고있어..

I love Karina's way of dancing ✨

윈터님처럼 순간순간 깔끔하게 팝 넣으면서 추는거 겁나 어럽죠

Karina is the main dancer for a reason she's not only good in one style and focuses on all points when she dances, she knows how the attract the viewers attention

Karina best dancer in aespa 👍👍👍

i agree! winter has that kind of popping dance type(?) she would be good at hiphop dance please react to Seventeen new song Darl+ing. it's in english !

그냥 성향임.. 카리나는 열심히 동작을 크게 쓰면서 춤을 추고 윈터는 여유롭게 적당히 추는 느낌 그래서 같이 추면 카리나가 더 잘 보이는 느낌임.. 아무래도 같은 춤을 췄을 때 카리나가 더 힘듦것임.. 좀 더 파워를 실어서 추기 때문에.. 각각의 장단점은 카리나는 같이 출 때 더 잘 보이고 춤이 다이나믹하지만 라이브 할 때 숨이 찰 수 있음.. 원터는 카리나에 비해 튀진 않겠지만 라이브시 덜 힘들고 춤추면서 보컬을 안정적으로 구사하기 쉬워짐. 윈터는 춤추면서 고음과 다른 멤버에 비해 더 많이 불러야 하기에 저렇게 적당한 춤선을 가지게 된 걸 수 도 있음

I just love how big Karina's moves and how she puts her own flavor on her dance not just performing

I’m always in love with WINTER dancing style. Her moves are very clean and sharp. She is such an Ace.

Karina is seriously amazing

love watching karina perform, she always gives her hundred percent and her attention to detail is very impressive

karina famous girl

I have always loved Karina's way of dancing, she is very energetic when she dances, every time she always manages to attract my attention

윈터 춤이 뭔가 간지남 딱딱 잘춤

My eyes are always on winter. Her clean and very precise moves makes it so satisfying to watch like honestly i love it!!! 😳🌼 Whereas Karina!!! she is some natural moves based dancer, she has great flow and is a kind of bouncy dancer almost similar to kai? if you know what i mean. I love it they both are a dangerous duo💙

Karina footwork and body control are amazing while winter is sharp and powerful

Sm에서 각자에 어울리고 맞는 춤선과 방법대로 코치한거같네 윈이 카처럼 춘다고생각하면 시원시원하지않을거같고 카가 윈처럼추면 답답할거같음 아슬처럼 본인의 장점을 잘 살려서 추는거같음 더 맞는곡도 다르고~ 결론은 둘다 좋다!

춤도 사람 성격이 보이는 것 같음 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 특히 윈터가 군인아버지 밑에서 자라서 그런지 춤선도 절도있는..

karina puts in emotions into her dance, and she's diverse in dancing from contemporary, hip hop, popping and etc. she does all of them well and that's the reason why she was chosen as the main dancer, even tho she was a vocal trained rapper then become the best dancer in the group, an ace! SM is lucky to have her tbh

Karina ♡

I'm so mad every time I see international aespa haters called "aespa has no stage presence" or "aespa can't dance", are you blind? why can't you see how good Karina and Winter slay every dance moves and how clean they executions all their choreography, aespa's choreo has many hard details and iconic moves, AESPA jjang 👍 AESPA DANCE LINE "KARINA WINTER" JJANG 👍

I was happy to see such a video... Ignorant people were constantly criticizing Karina by commenting on the dance. I'm glad that professionals are talking about this. Unfortunately, I don't think aespa's choreography is good enough for Karina to stand out. If you look at the "Step Back" stage, you'll see that she is an amazing main dancer with powerful and detailed moves. Winter is pretty clear. I don't think the attractive thing about Winter is the way she dances, but Winter has a strange charm. Watching her fancams is so much fun. It's not because of the way you dance. You know. She's just Winter. Stop and watch her fancams for hours. You won't be bored. She is like textbook. I also want to talk about other members. After all, aespa has 4 a member. Ningning comes after Karina in stage dominance as well as being a good dancer in my opinion. Ningning is a really good dancer. I don't know how to describe her, but it is possible to say that she also has a special aura. As for Giselle. She received a lot of unnecessary criticism about her dancing. Giselle is not a bad dancer. I think she has style. She will smile at you in a sassy way and make casual gestures. She adapts the sharp movements to herself, making them a little softer but sassy. To me, the way aespa members dance is more like boy groups than SM's girl groups. They remind me of NCT and EXO.

i love winter's more cause she looks neat. Clean and doesnt look sloppy

I'm always impressed with Karina.She became my bias when I watched her performance with EXO Kai

If you have to trust something in Karina, it's footwork. She can never go wrong in her footwork.

I always like the extra pop from Winter

Aespa!! Yess 😭 Karina and Winter have different styles and I love them both! ❤️

There’s a reason why winter’s fancam always has the most viewed in every era.That’s because of her attractive dance that makes her stands out.People are acting like she’s the worst as a lead dancer but from dancers opinion they keep giving compliments for her and says that winter is not far from karina.Haters are just overreact

안녕하세요, Trainee A 의 춤에 반응해주실 수 있나요? 비디오 : kzfaq.info/get/bejne/npeFrN2Ksbm2lqM.html ( Freestyle dancing on LA street at night "Down Bad" ) 감사해요 🤍 죄송합니다 번역기를 사용하고 있습니다

Honestly I noticed the differences in their dance styles too. It's interesting how they said Karina stands out during performance alittle more because of her powerful execution and extra subtle addition in the choreography because that's exactly what lured me into checking her more during Black Mamba!

둘다 춤도 완벽하고 얼굴도 완벽해...☆

카리나 남돌 춤 추는 거 보고싶다.. 프로그램들 나오면서 조금씩 추던데..

I love Karina dancing style

머리 긴 여성분 표현력이 진짜 좋네요

그룹 내에 여러 스타일이 있으면 팬 입장에서는 환영이죠

Winter has less issues than Karina when dancing (hence why she does the moves cleaner and simpler) but Karina has a lot more strength in aspects such as her footwork (not perfect but quite decent still) which makes her still surpass Winter as a dancer imo.

I really enjoyed watching Karina dance, it just appeals to me. Of cos dancing and singing is all subjective, just personal preferences. Both have their own style and that’s good 👍

karina is so amazing! she's really one of the best dancers out there

Winter all rounder

one thing about karina is you will never see her slack off, since day 1 from black mamba to savage, her energy is consistently high. she owns the stage.

Karina's dance style is not kind of style for idols she has a big and powerful moves and she knows how to control her energy in the group that she will not overlap with the other members

Winter jjang

"karina goes extra miles" yep karina always the one that complete every moves every dances steps. Look at karina in DCT she's always the one doing the leg waves and popping!

I love this analysis. This is how you do it, no need to be super biased when commenting about how Karina and Winter dance. I've seen a lot of comments in other videos wherein they're dragging Winter down mostly and some peeps drag Karina but mostly Winter. Both girls are exceptional in their own ways, they have their own styles of dance and execution. We better support them as a whole and not drag the other one because they are a team, AESPA. For some moves, Karina executes it better than the three, and for some moves, Winter executes it better, some moves Ningning does it better. THERE'S A REASON WHY KARINA IS THE MAIN DANCER AND WINTER IS THE LEAD DANCER, SO WE BETTER NOT DISCREDIT THEM COZ THEY BOTH EXCEL IN THEIR OWN STYLES. We all know that Giselle is not a good dancer BUT SHE'S STILL GROWING AND LEARNING SO LET'S SUPPORT GISELLE ALSO!!! AGAIN I LOVE THIS ANALYSIS.

Karina is a main dancer not without a reason, love her fancams 💜🔥

i love karina's dance style, looks so powerfull and on point

I have always been obsessed with watching Karina's fancam ever since her debut. That black mamba fancam of hers were it all started, she just has this certain aura around her that makes her addicting to watch. And her dance moves are always so light and easy to watch too, I've never seen her slacked once be it a rehearsal or the actual performance. That's what i like about her, she has this consistency. Overall i think both are great dancers but i just prefer Karina's dancing style more.

노래에 따라 다르긴 한데 카리나가 메댄인 이유를 알 것 같음. 개인 직캠으로 보면 둘 다 각자의 매력으로 잘 추지만 전체로 봤을 때 더 눈에 띄고 눈길이 가는건 카리나인듯.

나는 암만봐도 카리나가 더 좋던데 힘이 더 들어가고 팝핀하는 느낌

As a dancer Karinas dance always impressed me… her moves are great, her isolation is so good, her footwork has become alot better shes so light kn her feet now and moves to the rythem better…

This is very insightful thank you for doing this!

I would say Karina has better basic skills but Winter has more distinguished vibe

Karina is an incredible dancer, her movements are precise and meticulous, she captures your attention with her charisma and talent on stage.

타고난 끼와 간지는 어쩔 수 없구나

윈터가 더 잘추는거 같음카리나는 동작을 크게 춤이 잘 보이게 춤 근데 허우적거리는 느낌 받을때가 있음 타고건 윈터 카리나는 노력을 엄청해서 능력치 최대로 끌어올린

I prefer Winter's dancing

They are both good n awesome their own way n style. Love both but really attracted to karina moves n presence

윈터가 춤을 스웩있게 맛깔나게 잘 춘다 정석으로 잘 춤 윈터 춤은 보는 맛이 있음 이런애가 어캐 노래까지 잘하지 완벽한 올라운더야

I am so incredibly happy to see this video right here comparing the moves and the dance pros of karina and winter--like i would love more for insight on these things! they're both wonderful dancers, but it's the intricacies that set them apart and as someone who isn't a professional dancer this insight is so useful for me, and esp those who like dance and want to appreciate it. But as always xD hahaha PLEASE REACT TO CHUNGHA! I WOULD REALLY LOVE TO SEE THEIR REACTION AND COMMENTS TO HER LIVE PERFORMANCES OR DANCE CHOREOS! and i know that she participates in making some of the moves as well which only makes me look forward to what the pro dancers have to say!!! or even just generally on her movement and dancing dynamics!

I just got into aespa like 3 weeks ago; they honestly lulled me back in after a LONG long break from kpop. First thing I noticed was Karinas "outward popping" as they put it during savage stages. I love her sharpness and power in all of those angled moves aespa has in a lot of their choreographies. winter also has a very distinct, laid back style. I love her control. great video!

Tôi thích cách nhảy của Winter, mượt mà và chính xác

Karina got power and winter has a good/natural pop style when she dance

I love both jiminjeong my bias is karina Karina powerfull dance i don't know why but i more like Karina but winter good