Hey everyone, I hadn't realized that this video got this many comments, so I never thought to check and answer haha Regarding some of the comments: I totally agree that Mizoguchi needs to be in that discussion. If I had more time, I'd certainly include him. This was a university project of mine that required a comparison between two artworks (hence, only two examples). Glad to hear you all liked it, and all the constructive feedback was awesome! I never thought to continue making videos like this, but your comments are definitely making me at least consider it.

Just seeing these last shots from Tokyo Story makes my eye water. What a beautiful beautiful cinematic masterpiece.

"Mizoguchi's greatness was that he would do anything to heighten the reality of every scene. He never made compromises… Of all Japanese directors, I have the greatest respect for him... With the death of Mizoguchi, Japanese film has lost its truest creator." - Akira Kurosawa

There are a lot of good ideas in this brilliantly edited video. The notion that the opposition between Kurosawa and Ozu is not between "Western" Kurosawa and "Japanese" Ozu, but rather between two kinds of "Japaneseness" is a view I endorse. One cavil: the author of this video claims that Kurosawa was not concerned with the individual and that Ozu was. For me, the opposite is closer to the truth. Kurosawa says explicitly in his autobiography that, after the war, he wanted to make films that asserted the value of the individual. Whereas Ozu, though he filmed stories about Japanese people of all ages and classes, invariably perceives and displays them as part of the larger unit of the family, and their actions and sufferings only make sense in that context, not as individuals per se. But otherwise, the Otoko vs. Onna dichotomy that the author presents here makes sense. I also thought the bibliography at the end was a nice (and useful) touch.

Kurosawa is the best director of all time. It saddens me that not many people know his name nowadays. Ozu is amazing as well, I loved Tokyo Story

Thanks so much for making & sharing this video. It's insightful. Those are beautiful movies (and directors).

Thank you for a wonderful video !

Nicely done! Two of film's best makers I can think of. Thank you for putting this together!

One of the best essay I ever saw ! congratulation

interesting analysis. simply amazing

Wonderful analysis. Thank you for sharing.

I really wish you'd continue making videos like this! Very interesting comparison between these two giants of cinema...

This is a great, informative video of two master filmmakers! As a former film student and now a working filmmaker, it's awesome to be reminded - through videos like yours - why we love film! Thanks a lot for that! :)

thank you for the insight. need to watch this!

Fantastic study on this, enlightened many unspoken thoughts I had about these filmmakers

Very nicely done. Insightful and compelling.

Beautifully and powerfully crafted!! Thank you so much!!

Well done! Enjoyed watching very much. Thank you!

Thank You! For this beautiful docu on these two masters ..

Well Done, Dimitri. I was mesmerized not just with the visuals of the masters, but also with your great analysis... make more such videos!!!

Truly insightful. Thank you. I feel incredible after watching this video.

This was very good, thank you.

Wonderfully done, Thank You..

All along, I was so moved not only by the movies (spevially Ozu's) but for your caring analyssis. Subbed

Wow!!!! Good job (Y) loved your analysis. Definitely want more of this please.

Mahalo! Great analysis and thoughts.

Excellent! Thank you.

Great analysis, just great.

Thanks for this knowledgeable and interesting video!

Excellent video of appreciation and understanding of two great masters

Great work my friend. Thanks for the effort

Outstanding analysis of a very old debate. Deserves a lot more views.

Very kind and thoughtful essay. Thank you for sharing

Thanks for making and sharing this, Dimitri. Greets from Argentina.

rational analyses which have various questions within curiosity that includes respectful approach.thanks mate.

Exquisite research and conclusion

This needs far more views, good stuff.

I love Rashomon! I am greatful you picked exactly this movie! and good video in general as well

Amazing video, love the depth of study and thought that went into this essay. Domo

I've watched several of the "greatest" Japanese films but for me none beats The Human Condition.

SO beautiful. It took me four nights to watch. I looked at some scenes or dialogue lines multiple times. As Ronald Richie wrote (paraphrasing): American films are about action, European films are about character, Japanese films are about ATMOSPHERE. It is certainly true of this masterpiece.

the amount of clarity you bring to this topic is amazing ..and doing so without using cliches like "perspectives" while describing rashomon ...pls review Ikiru...

Well done. Thank you.

What makes the two artists absolutely identical is the magic hug which softly surrounds the wiewer makeing him/her aware of it just when "the end" appears on the screen.

Great video! Your take on Rashomon was especially interesting. Thanks for sharing this with us man! Keep up the good work and God bless you :)

Excelente análisis. Muchas gracias!

This is beautiful.

Amazing presentation

Fantastic video

素晴らしい内容でした

This is great man.

I appreciate your insight into these two directors, and these two films, all of which I have held close now for many, many years. Your presentation here feels like we are having a conversation, a chat between two folks intimately familiar with the subjects, who rarely sit down with anyone else who understands. Thank you. I cannot recall from memory any Ozu film that "crosses over" from onna to otoko, but I have to wonder now if maybe Kurosawa did not cross over to onna when he created Ikuru. And if we allow that, then there perhaps are others as well, especially in the earlier days?

I like this. Thank you for your posting. But there's so much mercy in Rashomon, unmentionable mercies, and judgements too.

Very good scholarship. I'm glad you covered the "non-Japanese-ness" of Kurosawa and the humility (floor POV) and transience ("aware") of Ozu. Very good post! Thank you!

insightful article .. 10/10

I am an admirer of Ozu's films, Late Spring and Floating Weeds, being my favorites. I have never watched an original Kurosawa film and now it is time to explore his work.

Thank you so much

Loved it!👏👏👏

Really enjoyed watching this video......I am a fan of Ozu's films.....good luck for your future projects👍👏 🙂🙏

I dig the Max Richter piece! Great vid and analysis!

thank you!

Splendid video! Really wants me check out Tokyo Story! Thanks a lot.

Un placer ver tu video! Y muy buen análisis. Saludos desde Argentina!

Thank you, Dimitri!

Thank you!

Awesome video!! I really liked how you did a very complete research on japanese culture (: Also music and edition were beautiful

awesome video my dude

Brilliant..

Wow I liked this.

Thank u Yuri

Thank you, thank you. I have for years observed the masculine vs. feminine approaches of Kurosawa and Ozu and also seen it in relation to Western art and literature, as with Melville's _Moby Dick_ of action packed adventure upon the grand quest of conquering the ultimate truth vs. Jane Austin's _Pride and Prejudice_ (and other novels) with a Fitzwilliam Darcy character and the eligible daughter Elizabeth available for marriage, with all the action transpiring within the drawing room, yet a world of action and insight into the human condition occurs and unfolds on those pages.

I liked your video, although I only learnt about Tokyo Story from you having only seen Rashomon. Thank you. I am pondering on whether to watch Tokyo Story or not.

Really enjoyed this. I haven't checked out Ozu's work at all and only just heard of him yesterday. Looks like his work isn't available for streaming anywhere but it does seem like a lot of his movies have been uploaded to KZfaq so I'll have to check them out.

Really well done video. I'm surprised I haven't stumbled on this video essay before. I actually hadn't watched an Ozu movie before today and I honestly didn't enjoy iit in even an intellectual or spiritual sense. But your video was valuable. I hope you're still creating content.

Everyone whining that the video isn't an exhaustive history of all great Japanese directors. Ozu and Kurosawa really are the two greatest Japanese filmmakers. They're also polar opposites within the context of Japanese cinema, so it is worthwhile and good to compare them in particular.

*17 seconds in, subbed* don't care if it'll take 7 months until the next 20 minute film dissection, but it'll be worth it when it gets here

Hey, cool video. One caveat to keep in mind is that Ozu loved American films. Particularly Buster Keaton and D.W. Griffith. But he was constantly consuming western films and his visual style was informed by that. Wish you mentioned Mizoguchi as he was considered the most "Japanese" of the three. It's weird how Ozu is considered to be a textbook example of a "Japanese" director. Maybe he drew more attention to everyday mannerisms and customs that Kurosawa sometimes liked to brush by. Anyways, great job.

thanks

Akira Kurosawa was a real master, but i actually think Ozu is the greatest Japanese director of alle time. Mizoguchi is great too.

Well said.

Hi, thank you so much for uploading! Question: do you mind sharing some of these books that you mention in the video? Thanks.

You should espend more time producing this kind of video essays, please. Please. Please. Please.

Thank you. My ignorance is slightly less monumental due to your effort.

This threw perspective. Wish we could talk more in person on nuances of Japanese culture and films... do you have any idea of Shindo's movie "Oni Baba"?

And Kenji Mizoguchi?!!!!!!!! He is so great as Ozu and Kurosawa.

Nice.

However, for instance in Tokyo Story wabi-sabi is not exactly about the ephemeral in life in the Western sense of "memento mori" but instead about the fact that growing of life and decaying of life belong together as an eternally continuing circle of life and in that sense the gift of the mother's watch to the daughter in law with the wish to her to forget about her late husband and marry anew means the continuum of life and not the end of it;

Very interesting! One thing - I suggest you to use もの (hiragana) instead of 物 (kanji), for 物 tends to mean a solid object/thing and in this case もの can be a situation, feeling and so on. And you also can write もののあはれ, too, which is the old way of spelling but still popular and used.

3:30 "Kurosawa 'the least Japanese of Japanese film directors.' This makes me chuckle. When I was in college there was (allegedly) a Donald Ritchie quote: "Kurosawa was the most Japanese of Japanese film directors." A college professors said this more than a few times. Any of us who'd seen even one Ozu movie knew this couldn't possibly be the case and just figured that it was a simple mistake that got repeated by a lot of people who didn't know better . Kurosawa is of course Japanese, but he's also more universal. Keep in mind that in his youth, Kurosawa considered himself to be a Marxist, so he set out to express the universal condition of humans. I laughed when I read the non-Chinese scriptwriter of Crouching Tiger Hidden Dragon saying that asking him to work on this script was like someone not an American trying to make a Western... Well, what's the best Western? Yojimbo. Sergio Leone (still not an American) proved it again. Tampopo is what you'd get if you were Japanese and said, "I'd like to make a Western in Japan,' (and it's billed as the First Noodle Western") a terrific movie, but Yojimbo went a level deeper and told a Japanese story that was also an American Western. I don't know where you got the bit about people thinking Ozu's tatami level shots aggrandizing his characters. I've not once heard this. I've always heard it explained as 1. something Japanese viewers would understand and feel respected for, but technically 2 it's about the midpoint floor to ceiling, this is the best height to show an interior while keeping the verticals straight up and down. Even when we look up from the floor in a room we don't perceive the corners of rooms converging. As a photographer after many years, somethings that don't seem to bother anyone else can be constantly annoying. So Ozu by not bothering with dissolves, camera movement, different lenses... everything matches, there are no disruptive 'effects' that are common with wide angle lenses. (Every source I can find on the web says Ozu used a 50mm lens. I remember it as a 58mm lens.) btw the 'cherry blossom festival' in Onomichi in the Tokyo Story clip. This is the end of the cherry blossoms in bloom because the shot is the petals falling off the blossoms. I think an another way to look at this subject might be to compare Japanese filmmakers with Canadian. How hard have Canadians been trying for how long to 'double' Vancouver, Toronto and Montreal as New York or other US locations? I can't think of a single Japanese film that ever attempted this.

Great job. I need to see more of Ozu. Please, can you tell the name of teh song at the minute 13:00. Thanks.

this is not a cool video, its a intense video thanks for your efforts. loved it Akira is the best director of all times for me.

Fantastic research and point of view, great job sir. Also, what's the name of that beautiful music playing when you start talking about Kurosawa, starting when you see him at the Oscars on (3:30 mark). I've heard it before and always wanted to know what it was, thanks.

It seems unfair to talk about how Japanese cinema was without analyzing Kenji Mizoguchi. After all, he is known as the most "Japanese" filmmaker of the 3. Still, great video

It's actually a triumvirate with Mizoguchi also.

Sad and transient beauty. Yet a fulness in emergent moments Ineffable challenge of understanding the human heart through individual characters Feminine and Masculine stories: Interweaving of private affairs and public stage of action Personal and cultural imperfection in life yet a universal message at once

18:49 has the references

Interesting thesis--but if one chooses Ikiru rather than Rashomon is the distinction as clear? I don't know Ozu's work very well, so cannot comment on that side of it.

Why i cant add subtitles to this video? :(, i am from Colombia and my friends don´t speak english.

nice video ! also love its soundtrack . What is this song in 5:26 ?

What was the book(s) you acquired this information from? The one mentioned at the beginning.