Yes please do the side by side!!

Oh man, I was trying to ignore this one but I knew it would be good. Looks like I may have to buy myself a Father’s Day present…

Yes, please do a side by side of the 4 Offerman! I’m sure a lot of your subscribers would appreciate it. Cheers

Would love to see a comparison of all the Offerman additions. Haven’t seen the original here in Texas for a while but the Guinness and Charred Oak are still floating around.

This one is a beauty. I didn't love the Offerman Guinness but the rest were spectacular. The charred is my favourite. I was amazing this expression 'just suddenly showed up' in the liquor stores but it has here and am I ever thrilled. This didn't happen with the other Offerman editions. Offerman is a true Lagavulin lover! I don't know if he has a lot of involvement but it wouldn't surprise me. I didn't doubt this would be delicious - not when it's Lagavulin - I have only been disappointed twice - Tequila cask - Lag 12 - Guinness Offerman. I think for what we get the price is good. I get a lot of smoke, salt air, brine, lots of oysters, charred lemon - fabulous. I dislike sweet scotch - especially Islay scotch - but this one is a beauty! I can't tell if you love it or not. I adore this beauty! I didn't want to get a huge hit of rum and I didn't - which for me is good! I wanted just a hint and smoke and I get it in a delicious way! $90 for the 16? I'd buy a case. It's a lot more here. Yikes. This is worth the cost for me and so is this one! It's $119 plus tax here. Oh wow you liked the Guinness? Interesting! Hey we all have different palettes! I'd love to see a side by side! I bought a case of this so I definitely wanted more than one bottle! I get that I enjoy this one more than you. I am an Islay nut for sure and Lagavulin is bliss!! I'm prepared to splurge - it's a treat and these days the price for this bottle isn't actually that much compared to other Islay expressions. We pay more now for sure! Cheers Bill!

I did realy like the Glenfiddich Fire & Cane which put the unusually peated whiskey in a rum cask. Maybe the peat is the key to making the rum finish work, a bit of bitter to offset the sweet, kind of like the mar that accentuates the beauty.

I love this bottle. I got lucky and found it at Costco for $75. This combines sweet and smoke. I would love to see a comparison. Appreciate the review

7:18 *Offerman Editions. Different from the distillers editions which are also amazing

I enjoyed this one, got a back up when it hit total wine in hartford at 64$. I was happy to see the first one for 75$ in costco in MA. Diageo seems to be putting things on sale these days...

I was pleasantly surprised by this one. I got similar notes, I’m enjoying it. I agree with you, Tullamore Dew Rum Cask really does nothing for Irish Whiskey or for Rum. Killowen Rum and Raisin is the best rum finished whiskey in my opinion.

Haven’t seen this, but the Ardnamurchan Rum Cask is amazing, so maybe peat and rum is a thing 😊

The only one I didn’t have was the first one. I think they all, lump the GoT edition in there too, with I’m glad I bought it and drank it pretty quickly, but didn’t want a second bottle.

I'll look for this I'm a big fan of the 16. Great review.

Bill, we definitely learn a lot about you mostly about your Caribbean trips)))))) Great review! Definitely going to pick it up next time $75 in the Costco, local small stores from 80 to 100. And one more thing, I truly love graphics on this video. Beautiful job!

I'd love to see a side by side comparison all four of the Offerman Editions. I'll have to pick up the Carribean Cask when I get paid. I loved the Charred Oak cask. I was curious about the rum cask before and after watching your review, I think I'll really like it.

Nice! Just bought it this week, still have to open the bottle though.

This Caribbean Cask is only the 2nd Offerman Edition I’ve tried. However, I’m on my 3rd bottle of “Charred Oak Cask”, (having purchased the last two at Costco for $80 each), so I had some expectations for the new release. I’ve only had a couple drams, but I’m enjoying the Caribbean Cask. Hopefully it shows up at my local Costco for a reasonable price too. Cheers.

I love Lagavulin, I've bought all the Offerman Editions except this one, mostly because I haven't seen it yet. I would love to see a taste test of all of them, especially if it's blind. Cheers!

I'll have to keep an eye out. I've liked the 2nd and 3rd releases, never had the first.

I’ll have to grab a bottle after your review. Would love to see a comparison…..

Been waiting for this one!

FWIW I say absolutely do a four-way side-by-side of the Offermans.

This is the only Diageo bottle I routinely buy, so when i saw it for $82 it was a no-brainer. I wouldn't pay 100 off the bat, but then the good reviews started coming and I knew the shop that doesn't gauge prices would be getting it soon. I'm still working on the Guineas so I'm on eof those collector types that will Happily taste vicariously thru you

Please do a side by side comparison 😊

I'd like to know where you can find the Guinness cask one, without spending 4x orig cost

I love this bottle and plan to grab at least two more of them.

I'd love a side by side. I have tried them all, but it was before I really really got into whisky. I know where to find the III, I need to try to track down the other 2 that are older. I just want them all in my collection. I actually like the char one a lot, but thats also just my taste.

I recently bought this edition and am really digging in. Would love to see you do the Offerman comparison video! Especially if you can get Nick to co-host with you. 👀

Wait, are you thinking about doing an Offerman Off?

👍

🥃-🥃-🥃-🥃 Make it happen captain

I live in a control state where the prices are $90 for this and $105 for the 16 year. Interesting that yours was reversed

I noticed you had an ice cube in your glass at the beginning of the video, is it your preferred way of enjoying this Lagavulin Offerman Edition ?? Btw yes for sure I’d like an Offerman editions tasting/comparison!