my bias is so good, i love him more than everything!! his parts are best, and on this concert he looks so fantastic... shinees concerts are always so amazing, its the only one group whouse art makes me feel so shocked!!!

This song still rocks after 12yrs it still rock shinee you guys still rock ❤❤

SHINee、、、、👏👏👏👏👏👏 格好いいですね～ 痺れます上手で🎗️💚💛🍀💚💛🍀

I miss the old days... Lay with shinee was gold was His first experience. Shinee is gold.. I miss them

2:39 Lay on the big screen. Daebak! He nailed it. This era were Exo not yet exist and then he had given the chance to dance with Shinee! 👏👏👏 I hope in the mere future, when Shinee performs Ring Ding Dong again, YooGeun is there and performing with them. I miss the Shinee era. 😭

So glad concert camera work has improved since these days.

Entah knp jd suka bgt sm boy band shinee stlh ntn trs berita jhonghyun..

Stage, sound, chereo, voice, lights all fantastic so far the feeling is bam whaam magnetnitude...no one start concert such this power as SHINee.....the best❤️

난 저기에 있었고 dvd도 있고 링딩동+루시퍼 리믹스는 레전드고 여전히 샤이니를 사랑하고 오늘도 샤뽕이 차오른다

RIP Jonghyun :(

I never knew it was Lay before. But I always remember watching this and every time, I was like 'that back up dancer is pretty cute. he's really good too....' and I found myself watching him a lot even though it's a SHINee vid.

it's funny how Jonghyun appears suddenly

The best kpop live vocals.. Shinee .. waiting for them in Manila .. hopefully soon!

I got shocked when realized it's already 10 years ago since i've hyped up by this performance. Kinda miss the old era..

This is the best performance of ring ding dong X Lucifer I've ever scene in their first concert

My all-time favorite version of Lucifer!!! EVER!!!

JOUGHYUNNNNNNNNNN❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

ONE OF THE BEST PERFORMANCES BY SHINEE

Wow Shinee is awesome if you look at their pants it looks really tight and their dancing to some pretty hard choreography. Either their super comfortable or they are way skinnier than we think.

when im feeling unhappy i just come in to these 2 songs and put it on repeat

To think that this performance was more than 10 years ago... And to think how much has changed since then. Lay has grown so much as a performer & artist, and I still miss Jonghyun every time I listen to SHINee. I still can't believe he's gone sometimes.

Jonghyun i miss u 😭

The boy that dance with them is very handsome😊💜💜

Año 2023 sigo pensando que el es el mejor de SHINee ,le llevaba años luz a los demas ,me imagino si hubiera estado en este tiempo con toda la tecnología que hay ,lo que seria ,mejor no pensar porque te enojas ,Jonghyun que desasertado que estuviste bay cariño donde quieras que estes .🌟🌟🌟🇾🇹🇩🇪 .

This live performance was just pure gold. No questions asked

We are SHINee SHINee we are not going to let you down… 😭

the ocean is so beautiful breathtaking really if i was up there i would just my heart would stop

Esto es de 11 años atras ,y la voz de Jonghyun sobresalía de los demas ,ya se sabia que hiva a ser unos de los mejores ,de todos ellos ,y lo demostró a través de los años ,en voz en bailé compositor escritor no le faltaba nada ,hoy endia no a salido nadie como el en el K-Pop nadie que cante como el ,si en esta epoca hubiera estado seria mas que asombroso hera muy inteligente ,fue una pérdida terrible por eso es inolvidable, John todo lo hiciste bien menos hirte .Forever cariño sigo pensando el porqué te estraño cielo .👏❤️🌟🤔🇾🇹🇩🇪 .

This performance AWESOME !!!! Jongyhuns vocals never fails..the best..I so miss him

The visual attack at 3:44😮❤💎😇

That guy dancing with them is so cute. :)

Time goes by and the good ones remain 4ever. I love them❤🇧🇷

この曲、ダンス 大、大好き💕 リズム感凄く切れ SHINeeだわ～💜 嬉しくなります スカッとさます 最高のSHINee🎵

Светлана, музыка отличная, спец эффекты, супер, ведь они выступали 12 лет назад, но все ещё слушаю их,❤

They did a really good job of covering for Jonghyun, though. It's nice to hear them singing different parts.

love jonghyun rip for you

OMG. FIRST THE WOLVERINE THEN THEY START FLYING. OMG SHINEE. I LOVE YOU AND YOUR IDEAS

Lay here has more screentime than he has in exo 😂

He danced for Jonghyun since he couldn't. Lay is now a member of EXO.

Jonghyuns had to be first in lucifer, so he got hooked up to be lifted up and while he was singing the others were getting hooked up. This performance was great, especially the new part they added to lucifer. 👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍

Kim jonghyun is my prince

one word to describe them amazing

RIP Jonghyun na..

We are the shining shinee never going to let you down.

Most of my favorite song

Gente guapa , cada ser tiene su perfección

SHINEE the best❤the best❤the best❤the best❤the best❤the best❤FOREVER

imagine doing a concert like this at 17 years old, thats Taemin's life.

shinee at their best!

Graciiias por la buena calidad del video!!!! Shinee se mira fenomenal!!! :3

Lay is so cute! It's funny seeing people from years ago asking who the cute guy dancing with Shinee is. Surely, they know who he is now.

I miss them so much 💔😭

what a show

Exo Lay doing such a good job with how little time to learn Shinee choreography? Daebak.

Shinee antes de bts.....las mejores voces en vivo una actuacion genial

I love mấy anh nhóm SHINEE đẹp trai nhảy hay quá đi àh ❤❤❤❤❤❤😻😻😻😻😻😻😻😘😘😘😘😘 em rất hâm mộ các anh

SHINee♥LAY♥

אהבתי🥰🥰🥰

wowwwwwwww bj adore ma musique 💗💗💗💗💞💞💞💞💕💕💕💕💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋

샤이니 ! 사랑해요 온 힘다해 청춘을 불살으는 모습 멋져요 ❤

샤이니 !! 정말 최고!!❤

Yes SHINee fighting!!

THEY ARE SO COOL

i luv Kpop bcuz of them

LUCIFER WAS SO DARN PERFECT OMGGG

I am Brazilian and I am a big fan of them , they sing a lot and the songs very contagious .

❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤se ra mon groupe préferer ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

Shinee,i love you

❤❤❤❤

love shinee

Best song

Excellent🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

Perfect 🥰

GOOSEBUMPS.

Minho shinee I love you 😍😍😍😍😍😍😍

Super I love it

온유.종현이 너무 그립구 보고프다

when I first watched this in October: OH JESUS SHINee PERFECTION SHAWOL FEELS MY OVARIES GONE when I'm watching this in June: OH JESUS LAY FEELS SO PREDEBUT CUTE AND HANDSOME OH YIXING FEELS DEAD add them together and I'm just A VERY, VERY HAPPY FANGIRL ♥

Taemin cute😘

🌻🌻🌻

My friends and family: why are you so willing to spend half your income in a year to go see these group? What do they do? Do they fly or wth??? Me: well... Actually....

Que espetáculo ❤🇧🇷💯🙌

رائعه

I spy lay:)

DAebak! Pretty awesome. ! Key ♥

Did anyone notice that Yixing from EXO was on stage with them. Lol I watched a video of him backstage at this concert with SHINee.

Es perfecto:'"3❤️❤️

Love this song..energic..iconic💎💎Shinee it's Legend💞

7:21 Very clear. Good dancing

Love the fact that way sound even better live. Shawols and Taemints Attention!! Taemins Album Ace is nominated for the golden disk award, so let's Vote for him!! The App you can vote with is called Wefan. Ahh,by the way one person was asking me how it can be that everyday the results for the golden disk award go back to zero! That's because the golden disk award voting is closing at January the 11th.Till than you can vote 20 times a day:

~Complicated Girl~.....

Omg 😱😍🔥

Cool😎😎😎

Minho❤❤

אהבתי

I was told his ankle was hurt.

i couldn't freaking tell why lay was there until this video when i did jonghyun is there but unable to dance. i was so confused omf

Lindos 😍😍😍😍

9:00 wow came back here after MMTG gosh i vaguely rmb this but not this part omg legendd

Lay wasn’t take part in singing but I love how they give him screen time and not to mention he almost made in to main dancer in the group not backup dancer he’s daebak