I've been performing in concerts and music festivals like this for so many years and I can totally understand, imagine and feel what they're probably experiencing up on that stage, especially the technical ones, plus the fact that they were performing with an actual live band (a killer of a band, I might say), plus the cheers/screams coming from the audience, plus it being a big tent/outdoor event, it can definitely drown out the audio coming from their in-ears and it will also affect how you deliver out your voice. (unless you have heavy backtrack playing alongside you so you can easily put yourself back on the normal volume release and tone of your voice) And they're not even tone-deaf. Yes, there's some minor slip-ups in some notes but that's expected in these kinds of events, and that's okay and makes it natural, very human and raw as well, but still not to the point of being called tone-deaf or off-key. (which a lot of these haters and non-fans keep misusing, which totally frustrates me as a musician and singer) And again, the hype-singing, for the people who are NOT-well-versed in music performances especially in music festivals and outdoor concerts with this "shouting/screaming" that these girls were doing (as these "critics" have been saying), it's a stylistic approach in music in live concerts, hyping people up and changing the way you sing from the original way. Or sometimes, you do the second voice instead of the original. It's pretty normal, especially in music festivals like this where you hype up the crowd and interact and entertain the audience. Also, another reason is what I mentioned earlier, due to the loud noise left and right (outside noise), front and back (audience and the live full band), that drowns out your perception of your own voice's volume that it affects your modulation. Plus, Coachella is mostly a party vibe where you can dance or just sit or lie down and drink, etc, and not a "concert" like the usual in domes, etc. Sadly, today's generation (and mostly those that are just exposed in Kpop music programs only) wants performers to sound exactly like the CDs. (which makes it boring, imo) And the group was singing live and raw, only using very minimal backtrack as support to add extra voices and music and guide for their timings. And they're dancing with heavy choreography. The sad (and maybe funny) thing as well is that most of the people giving "constructive criticism" don't know anything about music at all. They're only listeners, but suddenly they've become "voice experts" or "Music Festival 101 masters", while lying down on a couch scrolling their phones and doing nothing or other stupid things and wasting their lives. They actually don't know the long, hard work and practice that go behind every little piece of music that artists put out, especially live. Those people just have demented minds, enjoying that feeling of criticizing others and sending hate, their kind of way of escape from their own miserable lives. And let's not forget the hive/herd mentality of these people, especially the ones sending hate to artists or any other person. Anyway, I actually applaud Le Sserafim for doing what they did. They really applied what an actual real, raw, live performance should be like and with a band that are actually, actually playing live that aren't done much in Kpop nowadays that have depended too much on backtracks (And no, I didn't say all of Kpop, before you all get triggered.) add to the fact that they were dancing all throughout for almost an hour, and in that LA heat and strong winds. You're either ignorant about music or in actually playing live music among a big crowd of people or just straight-up hater if you can't see those big merits that they have done in their performance. Or you're simply just toxic. Lastly, AND MOST IMPORTANT OF ALL, everyone in the venue actually enjoyed their performance and have been saying praises to the group, whether if they're a fan or not. Even the real critics, music journalists and actual musicians have praised them in their Coachella performance. The performance is for the Coachella live audience, the group adapted their performance for the event, and the group definitely, definitely delivered!! I can see Le Sserafim getting a lot BIGGER and BETTER after this, moving forward. The irony is, amidst all these hate, Le Sserafim gained tons of new fans! But the bigger you become, the hate will also add up. Why? Because more people will get to know you, whether they like you or not. More publicity. More chances that new people will discover them and their music, their art, and will actually appreciate them. And that's where we should focus on, instead of the haters or even non-fans or even those that have "left" the fandom. (Why are even non-fans bothering and trying to include themselves in this when they're not even, well, fans?) Just continue on working hard on your craft, improving and focusing on your own growth. It's better to see their journey as they continue to improve, becoming much better, especially in vocals. Performance-wise and stage presence and the fun they bring in their performances, they already excel in it. If they are already perfect, then that would be totally boring. The girls are definitely working hard and improving and improving and trying out many things, especially outside the norm of Kpop. While those haters giving "constructive criticism" and "voice experts" and forcing and harassing others to accept their opinions as the only correct one are just lying down, wasting their rotten life, and even if they do have a job or business or whatever, it just means that they're not happy in their life. Because if you are, then you definitely don't have time to bother wasting your own time hating these hardworking, talented and successful girls and is mature enough that you'd rather just focus on being successful in your own life and being happy (by that, I mean the right way. Coz if hating them is your way of being happy, then there's definitely something wrong with you). And if you get triggered and angered by this statement and sends more hate to them and to others, especially those that appreciate them and actually enjoyed their performance, then it says a lot more about your personality, attitude and immature, obsessive mindset. Shame on you. And as for new people curious about the issue, just use your own judgment with an open mind and w/o being hateful, while also considering the venue and the event itself, the whole context, and not be affected by all the haters backed by troll farms just to make these girls look bad while these toxic people are promoting their own favorite groups under the hate train. I mean, it's not helping their groups at all. It would just spread more hate. Anyway, YOU DID GREAT, LE SSERAFIM!! Keep the fire burning! I'm excited to see Le Sserafim continue to rise even higher in the future! And if you're a fan, keep on supporting them. That's what they need right now. (and to the people who have reading comprehension problems who would say you're babying them. No. I said, support the girls.)

Seriously you would really think did absolutely horrible with the amount of hate they're getting. Low to no backtracks, raw vocals, hard choreo. Sure they had slip ups which is completely normal and okay, but their entire set was good and fun.

I'm not a K-pop fan, but they seem incredibly cool. They have amazing vibes and passion. I listen to various types of music, but many artists, no matter how skilled they are, often lack the vibes and passion needed to really energize a festival crowd. They've undoubtedly got that.

This sounds better than the live feed I watched. Much more balanced between the band and their voices.

I went there with one of my friends a fearnot and to tell you their vocal is fine, they hit the highest notes and it understandable when voice is shaking because they are dancing. I think they are so cool, that I have watched their MV at home. Anyway, me and my friends went wild there. Their performance is just amazing. I don't understand why the hate though, people there had fun and that's what matters. Some are just online haters.

Sakura had an overwhelming confidence in her face. Performing is really her element. She may lack vocally, nobody tryna deny that, even herself. But she's showing her love and passion to entertain people here, and it translated to the audience.

I was there - it was so much fun and energetic. Even my friends who knew nothing of them loved it. Imagine working hard and actually putting on a great show, then getting all the negativity. Mainly unwarranted hate from ppl or basing off a few bad clips. Ppl are even reaching and questioning their work ethic... that's when you know it's ridiculous

I don’t stan le sserafim but i went to coachella and i don’t get the hate they sounded amazing yall hating for no reason

Okay so I’ve watched the whole thing and I’d like to know why Sakura was called tone deaf because she was totally in tune in every single line she had.

That’s why everybody in Coachella said lesserafim really good and they enjoy in their performance. I can totally feel the energy even just watch the video.

Im tearing up seeing Sakura is so so so confident and enjoy this stage. She did everything she could. She give it all. The energy. The power. The stage presence. As i follow her journey from produce 48. Im so proud of her. And nothing other people say that can make me feel other way

They literally sound good, they're feeling themselves, enjoying the stage, vibing with the crowd and overall having an amazing time, i love them

They did what most bands don't dare - dance their a**es off + sing fully live. They know very well how to sing, and they tore up the stage. Always be happy! I wish more artists had fun like that, it was contagious seeing them enjoy themselves made the crowd even more hyped! I am so moved to see them succeed like that. Well done ladies! Proud of you!

It's crazy how people hate for only some parts that were bad and we can clearly see here that most songs are so good, they nailed it and slayed so hard. Even the crowd was screaming loud for them

00:00 Fearless 1:50 the great mermaid 04:54 introduction 7:26 new song HOT N FUN 11:45 Unforgiven 14:50 Eve Psyche & Bluebeard Wife 19:50 perfect night 22:15 Smart 27:55 Easy 30:35 Fire in the Belly

Insane performance. They did so well and all the hate is literally making no sense. Most of the songs sound exactly like the original other than those few little slip ups Is their room for improvement? Yeah but isn’t there always??? They debuted 2 years ago, Eunchae is 17 and doing all this??? Like, the crowd had so much fun, the girls were so happy, PLEASE, just let them be happy I am proud of them always. Well done to our fimmies. FEARNOTS are always here for you!!

With no backtrack, only raw and live vocal they really slayed. Keep improve girls, we waiting for second week show 🧡

フェスにおいてアーティストは客を沸かせたら勝ち。それをちゃんと体現してた。ファンではないけどほんとにかっこいいと思った。

今話題のルセラフィムどれだけ酷いんだって観に来た人達がみんな｢別に言うほど酷くないしめっちゃ会場楽しそうやん｣って興味持ってくれてファンとしては本当に嬉しい。ありがとう

I'm speaking as someone who is American and from Los Angeles. The criticism about vocals is understandable but this has been overblown as for the overall performance. Everyone who attended said that they were amazing. People who didn't know who Le sserafim were mention the experience of being amazed by how entertaining the girls were. I understand that vocals were not the best, but why throw everything else away such as being passionate, entertaining, exciting, high energy and connecting so well with the crowd? Please remember that this is a festival, artist are there to entertain and bring joy to the audience first, not live streamers. Why not appreciate young Korean artist working hard overseas to be known as great entertainers?

Woah guys.. This isn't bad. Wait.. People wouldn't use short clips to try and paint a false narrative, right? Surely nobody would do that??

They slayys on this performance, i can feel the energy they put on this performance, sooo cool.. Such a concert vibes, fireeee🔥🔥🔥

I feel like slapping the mouth of the haters with this video, they perform incredibly, even omg their stamina is really amazing!!

Thank you for the video, I trust you who are there. They did it well ❤❤ I'm sure you enjoyed the performance of our girls

they killed it !! room for improvement which is fine!! their stage presence and overall energy as performers is amazing !! but they have already came a long way and you can see the hard work they put into this performance! these girlies are only getting better and better 💗

these band versions of their songs is just on another level of energy. I loove it so so much!!!

Thank you for the video I wish I were there! LE SSERAFIM Fighting!

コーチェラのマイナス意見があまりにも多いから観にきましたが、、そんな悪い？堂々としていて普通にかっこいいけどなぁ、、、 私の推しグルでも大事な授賞式で高音パート盛大に外してしまった事があったけど、その後ヘラヘラ笑ってしまう訳でもなくプロらしくカッコよく歌い切る、そういう姿がアイドルとしてのプライド且つオタクの私が思うオタクが求める姿だと思ってます。 叫んでる的な事に関しては、もちろん終盤にかけてキツくて苦しいのもあるだろうけど、彼女達自身アドレナリンが出て、お客さんを沸かせようと煽ったようにも見える。 こんなに大量の曲をバキバキに踊って生歌やったのは実際は初めてなのかもしれないが、それが彼女達にとって歌の事に関して前から言われていた事もあり、大きな挑戦だったのかもしれないですね。 でもネットより、現地の人！沸きまくってて楽しそうな人いっぱいいるって事は成功！

will be watching this fancam instead of the coachella replay. the live stream was so fckd up that made it worst for the girls and the comments here are so heartwarming and with open minded and understanding abt the problem of the stream. i saw a lot of comments from the people who ACTUALLY went to the festival and they said that they really enjoyed their performance. KPOP fans are scary, keyboard warriors :(

i am SO IMPRESSED by them!!! they improved so much. well done girls, love you

Thank you for uploaded. No matter how getting hate from jealousy, Lesserafim are getting more success and famous.

Chaewon was born to be on the stage omg

쇼츠보고 풀영상보는데 확실히 느낌이 다르네. 물론 부족한 부분도 있고 부족한 멤버도 있지만, 그 짧은 일부만 보고 전체를 판단하고 욕하는게 얼마나 오류가 많고 잘못된 일인지 알겠다. 심지어 김채원은 마지막에 한 번 음이탈 날뻔한거 딱 그거만 쇼츠에 가져왔네 ㅋㅋㅋ 진짜 요즘 인터넷은 이 코첼라무대든 한 사람의 인생이든 너무 일부만 보고 전체를 매도해버리려고 한다.

本当に素敵な良いステージだった！動画ありがとう。

Thanks for upload ,, 🎉 HOT AND FUN LE SSERAFIM ❤

하두 언론에서 뚜들겨 패길래...보러 왔더만 격한 안무와 생라이브 고려한다면 대부분 잘하구만..,,르세라핌 안무가 대부분 격하다...뒷부분에 약간 삐끗하긴 했지만 그정도 가지고 욕 먹을정도인가 싶다

Sakura improve so much, & her confidence is everything 😏💯🔥

Fans know that the last few songs were not good perfom, and everyone knows. But most forget that it's a music festival. its not competition. People who went to the there showed a performance that they would enjoy, but online people find and criticize only the bad parts. sad😂

Thank you! It's nice to see the performance from a different angle. I love it.

사쿠라만 월등히 달라진걸 느꼈고 실력을 떠나 무대에서 진짜 즐겼고 본인의 그 에너지를 관객에게 느끼게해주는게 유투브로 본거지만 느껴졌어요 한국분들이 기대하는 가창력이 부족했을뿐ㅠㅠ 가수니 실력을 떠나 평가하면 안되지만 정말 많이 늘은것은 맞고 어떤 생각으로 임하는지 느껴지는 그사람이 보이는 무대엿어요!

The performance was so good. People hating are haters who couldn't believe girlies performed at coachella within 2 years of debut

bro their vocals sound so much better in concert than the live stream, like this performance looks so fun (Edit: this comment is getting so many likes and replies and now some ppl are not understanding that I can in fact enjoy something and have an opinion)

They did very well, the voices were very good along with the choreographies, the dancers and the band, they really transmitted very good energy. It’s one of his best performances. LE SSERAFIM killed it!!!

보컬이 엄청난 건 아니지만 격하게 춤추면서 이정도면 나쁘지 않은 것 같음 못한 부분만 쇼츠로 올려서 심하게 욕먹으니 맘이 안 좋음...

라이브 망했다해서 구경왔는데, 춤추면서 저정도면 잘하는거 같은데;

I’m glad you shared this video, because alot of people just saw some shorts on tiktok and started attacking them ❤ thank you 🙏

The concert was amazing from what i watched. They song very well. There was a couple of slip up on vocals but that is natural in a concert live setting. They had amazing energy to sing 10 songs in 50 minutes. The audience loved them and were singing with them showing they were having fun. Haters are just going to show more hate to LSF because their favorites weren't there singing in Coachella. LSF stage presences is much better than BPs.

They don't sound bad at all. I'm not sure why this hate train started. They seem like they were having so much fun, too. Something that was supposed to be a career milestone and highlight has now been soured by the bitter chronically online general public that wasn't even there. Tragic. Leave these girls alone.

오 풀영상 감사합니다

何でこんなに叩かれてるの？ 会場にいる人たちがめちゃくちゃ盛り上がってて、本人も努力して楽しかったと言っていたのだから。 そして頑張ったと言っただけでもうこれ以上頑張らないとも頑張れないとも言ったわけじゃないのだから。 これだけ叩かれて聴くけどファンではない私だけどみんなの成長見守るのもファンではないの？ いつかライブで見返してやれ！頑張れLe Sserafim！

하도 까길래 와봤는데 이 정도면 잘하는데 ...? 보컬이 얼마나 컨디션을 타는데;; 노래 제대로 배운 사람이면 저런 말 못함. 비행기로 10시간 넘게 날아 갔을테고, 시차 적응도 제대로 안됐을텐데 그 와중에 격한 춤추면서 저 정도로 노래를 소화한다 ..? 매우 잘하는건데 ;; 남돌들도 무대 하나만 끝나도 숨차서 산소 스프레이 쓰고 실신하고 난리도 아닌데 대부분의 시간을 춤추고 노래하는데 저게 쉬운게 아님 절대 .. 물론 더 잘할 수 있었을테고 더 노력할 수 있겠지. 그런 부분은 꾸준히 노력해야하는 부분이라고 생각함. 그리고 좀 비난과 비판을 구분하고 했음 좋겠다 ... 무분별한 비난 하는 사람들은 그냥 못배운거티내는거임 ;

It's not bad ...for me it's too good ..they r dancing, they r singing,they r hyping crowd....lesserafim love u girls

hold awn this sounds better than almost everything else I've seen so far I feel so much better now 😭

thank you for the video! I hope I can watch them live soon! ♡

뭐야 항간에 떠돌던 쇼츠랑 영상은 다 악의적 편집인가? 완벽하다 할 순 없지만 그리 욕먹을정도는 아니고 + 코첼라라는 페스티벌 컨셉상 저렇게 밴드소리 두각되게 편곡해서 방방뛰고 노는 컨셉인데 저기 관중들도 술먹고 드러누워서 즐기는 이도 많고 한 만큼 음원과 똑같은 소리를 내주길 바라는 이도 없음. 저 정도면 뭐 나라망신 시켰다는 ㅈㄹ은 아니구만

this sound so amazing ! thanks for the proof that they ATE FOR THE REST 35 MINS not only 14 secs. they will have another Ate performance at week 2 Coachella stay tune guysss

THAT WAS AMAZING!!!! Thanks for uploading ❤

今ルセラのこと叩いてる人の何割がフルのパフォーマンス見てるんだろう、切り抜きだけで判断して叩いてる人多そうで残念😢観客も本人も楽しそうだし本当にかっこよかった‼︎

Sure, people criticize their singing, but let's not forget they gave it their all on stage! It's not easy, especially for a young group, with the youngest member only 17. Plus, they've got their whole lives ahead of them, plenty of opportunities to improve and shine even brighter.

サクラ凄く声が出るようになってる！ 大騒ぎして批判するほどのレベルでは無いと感じた。観客が盛り上がっているのがその証拠、これからもどんどん生歌にチャレンジしてほしい。

They did so well I actually love their performances and I’m proud of them I really don’t see why people are hating

THANK YOU SO MUCH ❤

그렇게 물어뜯을 정도는 아닌데?? 조회수 개튜버들 + 자기 팬덤 아니면 상대무조건 까는 애들 + 그냥 열등감 쩌는애들 + 걍 은채가 발언 실수로 싸잡아서 까는애들이 문제인듯

쇼츠로 까대는 영상 현장의 분위기는 전혀 고려 안 하고 조금 억까 수준 같네.. 풀버전을 보니 적당히 한 거 같구만

vocally a lot of work is needed but dance wise, they always kill it. their presence is undeniably incredible🌟

How are their vocals bad?? Literally everyone online is saying their vocals are bad. All their dances are already hard enough. Whenever they include parts and say theyre bad, its always the parts when theyre having fun with the crowd or the parts that are harder to be stable and never include the parts they literally eat up

OMGGGG this is just so amazing

Thank you so much for this❤

done watching. I was so curious about their performance because I saw a lot of clips saying that they performed so bad. But I’m so surprised it’s not so bad. I’m not a fan of them but I appreciate the dedication and hardwork they did for this performance. I really thought it’s really bad. I think it’s just expected that they have some crack voice or flat while singging and dancing. I see how energetic they are and dancing so hard. But It’s not all the time they have flats. Just my opinion and base on my observation while watching this.

라이브로 이정도면 잘하는구만, 왜들 그렇게 깍아내리는지.

THey did SO amazing i'm so proud of them all.

쇼츠로 봤을 때는 진짜 못하는 것처럼 보였는데 풀버전 보니까 또 막 엄청나게 못한 건 아니였네...실력이 부족한 건 맞지만 40분 정도를 계속 공연하면 진짜 힘들기는 할 듯 쇼츠에 나오는 부분들은 대부분 힘 다 빠진 후반 공연들이고

The people overly criticizing them have NOT watched the full performance because how can you insult their whole reputation as performers after seeing them? I literally forgot all about the hate being spewed at them from terrible people and just enjoyed their show ❤ such amazing PERFORMERS! If I was in that crowd I would be hyped up so much! Definitely seeing them in concert for their world tour!

KAZUHA SO STUNNING, I WILL ALWAYS SUPPORT YOU 💖💖

Loved this performance. It was great!

머야 풀버전으로 보니까 쇼츠로 안좋은 부분만 묶어서 본것보다 나쁘지 않은 무대같네요 르세라핌 노래 자체가 부르기 힘들기도 하고(노래방에서불러봄요) 춤도 많으니까 진짜 괜찮은거같은디…난 르세라핌응원한다 비판이 아닌 비난의 댓글도 많아서 속상

Congrats lesserafim.. you all did a great job

I loved this! Every song introduced, the audience knows it and screams!

Thank for your fancam

하도 못한다고 하길래 지금 봤는데, 그정도인가 싶네. 저정도 격한 퍼포먼스 감안하면 괜찮은 편 아닌가?

르세라핌 잘했다!!! 이번주 2회차 공연 기대할게!

kazuha improved a lot, she ate!

盛り上げ方すごく上手くなってる！！ 最高だ😭😭😭✨

動画ありがとう‼️ 公式のストリーミングよりも現地でどう聞こえていたかわかりやすかった❤ 最高のパフォーマンスでした🎉

全然ひどくない気がする 力強くてカッコいい 客も沸かせてるしフェスとしては大正解なのでは

뭐야 현장으로보면 생각보다 나쁘지 않은데?

나이 어린 한국팬들의 비난성 댓글이 같은 국민으로서 창피 할 따름이다. 갑자기 댓글들이 입을 맞추듯 나서서 라이브 보컬 능력을 들먹이며 좋은 곡들을 계속 발표하는 훌륭한 그룹을 비난하는 것은 정말 옳지 않습니다. 수준 이하의 행동을 모두 그만 두길 바랍니다.

Thank you for uploading this. Le Sserafim ate!

전체 공연을 보고 왔는데 이 라이브가 그렇게 욕먹을 라이브는 아니라고 본다. 과거 밴드 중에도 라이브 못하는 뮤지션들 많았는데, 한국 사람들이 특히나 실력에 미쳐있는 듯. 어느 부분이 그렇게 라이브가 별로라는건지..? 뭐 관객 잡음도 섞여서 그럴 수도 있지만. 약간은 과도한 공격인 듯. 라이브라는 게 신나면 오버할 수도 있고 음정 좀 나갈 수도 있는거임. 그게 싫으면 그냥 더 좋다고 생각하는걸 들으시길. 왜 자꾸 다른 그룹은 더 잘했네 어쩌네 하는 개소릴 하는거지?ㅋㅋ 비교질 작작하고 그냥 이 무대를 즐겨. 세계적 밴드인 radiohead 의 thom yorke나 mcr 등도 완벽한 라이브는 아니어도 다 그른가보다 하고 들었음.

They tore up that stage and they will do it again! 🔥🔥

They performed pretty well, I genuinely thought they did really badly with all the bad press they’re getting 😢

le sserafim always strive to be better and challenge themselves, it’s obvious they’re gonna be out of breath with the level of their choreos being this high, it was really bold to not have any backtrack they’re really cool

アップしてくれてありがとう

I’m so jealous of those who watched this live, face to face😭

They did a great job, nice performance! 😊👏

dude Sakura was killing it

SAKURA IS TOO BEAUTIFUL!!! 😍😍😍 AND HER VOICE SOUNDS SO GOOD!!! SHE'S FINALLY SURE OF HERSELF!!!!! I LOVE HER SO MUCH, I'M SO PROUD OF MY BIAS!!!!! 💘💘💘

Great job ❤

음…한국분들이 별것도아닌 코첼라에 기대치를 너무 높인거같아요 ㅋㅋ 다른 가수들 무대를본뒤 그나마 르세라핌이 잘했다고 느끼는바가있네요…😅 *케이팝 팬 아닙니다*

Do you know how HARD it is to DANCE like that and to sing at the same time?! What the f people dare to criticize anything about them? Go do it BETTER then. Their vocals are pretty good! They dance amazing! Their performance was really fine (way better than some other artists on stages). I have to say they gave everything and they did it pretty WELL!