I'm SHOCKED by how accurate Gary was about the killer a month ago. Everything he says aligns with Bryan. Impressive analysis.

I just re-watched this since the arrest, and Dr. Brucato described what he believed would be the killer's personality, and Bryan Kohberger's personality, based on how people have described him, is spot on.

I really dislike statistics, because not everything falls into boxes. When my child went missing and I was given all of these stats repeatedly by LE and why he wasn’t missing ( our child was at University, his fiancé of 4 yrs had just graduated from University ) and LE kept telling us “oh he just went to LA with his buddies.” We knew he wouldn’t bug out on Valentine’s Day when he had a special gift made for his fiancé & a dinner planned. We talked to him at least 3x a week & helped with finances. Yet we had to fight LE to listen to us, bc LE kept repeating he would show up in 10 days, stats shows this. He showed up in 6 weeks. He was murdered. Young ppl, pls keep in touch with family, let them know your travel plans. They will fight for you when you need it the very most! Stay safe, vet your friends carefully! Parents support your children & love them. Each day you have with them is a true gift.

BTW this is the ONLY podcast / true crime my wife and I have been able to sit through actual adults who know what they're talking about ...so thank you so much

The guy on the bottom-right is a keeper. He's the only one who is not repeating what other talking heads have said already. He's got points that I haven't heard anywhere before.

This guy, Gary Brucato (sp.?), raised several salient points about the probable personality of this killer. Fresh points and highly plausible. Such a keeper.

How ON POINT was the psychological profile provided by Gary!!!! (if BK is proven the perpetrator)

Hats of to this lovely lady guest speaker. I have watched and read about her, and she is a icon in our lifetime in bringing crime facts to all of us.

Is it just me or when Dr Ann smiles 😊 I find myself Smiling 🙂 too . ❤ she seems so loving and kind

Love it when investigators keep an open mind instead of creating their own narrative.

Fantastic panel, I could listen to Dr Gary Brucato all day, I think he is spot on with his analysis.

I came here for Dr. Gary Brucato, but completely enjoyed all the guests. Great job!

Amazing peek inside these experts’ minds on the assailant’s profile. Thank you for carefully elaborating aspects of who the killer would be and what goes on in his mind for all of us to deeper understand. Helps a ton with lowering our risk level and staying aware of our surroundings and who we let in, period. Let this type of crime never happen again. Justice is coming. 🙏🏽🕊️🕯️

In hindsight, this panel (especially Dr Brucato) was spot on about the suspect (assuming the correct perpetrator is the person currently in custody). Phenomenal show and phenomenal guests.

This is a dream team panel. Please bring them back

I’ve never seen this show before. Very well done from all your guests of course. This guy Gary is super sharp! I’ve learned a ton from this. Very thought provoking. Great work!

this guy in the lower right corner has a lot of wisdom.....

Fantastic lineup of experts in there own field. I could listen to Gary for hours.

So satisfying to listen to articulate, informed, knowledgeable individuals Thank you

Ann Burgess is so knowledgeable, I could listen to her all day!

The third man saying the killer would be someone people would find odd, gave the best description of what the killer would be like around people.

This channel is quickly becoming my absolute favorite.....

This was very well done. Appreciate the input from you and your guests. Most all of us watching social media true crime have had many, if not all, these examples in our minds. I pray the murderer has or will make big mistakes and not remain elusive. In my young years, I have had stalkers, very strange guys that attached themselves to me for no reason, guys that were immediately angry with me for being out going, outspoken, and almost fearless. I trained and rode huge horses and they seemed to feel that made me a woman “being overpowering.” There was more than a few times I actually hid from some of them. It hit me that I was at the beginning of women’s lib. Yep. The guest stating it caused more hate crimes and DV, if you will, toward women being liberated was something I watched first hand. Even my mother felt I needed to realize that could happen and would get angry with me for expressing opinions and “no being lady-like.” When the videos hit YT showing the girls “putting themselves out there” I posted that while they were so very beautiful and could do that, it wasn’t the best/safest behavior, as I learned from experience. Thank you again for your content and allowing us a platform for a public comment/missive. 🙏🏻

Another group of amazing guests. Joel, your channel just gets better and better. I agree the Phd guest is invaluable. All three are so interesting, but he was fascinating.

This forum is probably the most informative and intelligent out of all the other videos! You guys are so interesting and insightful!

At around 24-26 minutes the man on the bottom right talks about envy and how the individual could be lashing out at those he perceives as accepted, desirable, loved, and socially relaxed. I like many others during adolescence have experienced this envy. It can be quite painful and I can remember the frustration, sadness, and sometimes anger at my own social difficulties and not being as accepted as I would have liked. Fortunately I worked through it like most people. We don’t know it it’s the motive but I can see how a disturbed individual could decide to project their inner turmoil onto others. The inability to tolerate and work through the anger and frustration can certainly be all it might take which is disturbing in and of itself.

Dr. Brucato is unbelievably intelligent! I’m a first time watcher and I’ll be back. Very thought provoking conversation…love Anne…long standing expert and I love hearing their perspective. With so little info, very interesting

First time watcher…what a phenomenal panel! Exactly what I’ve been looking for! This case is so sad 😭

Wow, what quality guests. Thank you all.

As I watch this show, I am riveted by the quality of thought. And the hosting job is really top drawer. totally informed on the info, but just directing the input from the guests. Worthy of 5 million views on a major network. Keep on truckin'!

This is a very knowledgeable panel of professionals. I appreciate their informed, dispassionate and rational analysis. Also appreciate the moderator's questions toward each guest to obtain each panelist's perspective and expertise. Thx so much.

Love this video. Better than any other I’ve seen this far. Really explains what’s possible. So scary. I can’t even look at a papercut…. Please keep following this case. These poor kids!

Joel, what a great panel!!!! This was so interesting; I was glued for the entire interview! 👏👏👏👏👏👏

Gary is an excellent guest, incredible insight given. Definitely want more from him. Less ads though, never watched a video with so many.

Excellent panel! I especially enjoyed Gary's input, but they all had intriguing perspectives. Thank you.

Wow what amazing guests! I agree with the Dr. Bracato on absolutely everything he said. Envy, meticulous planning, obsessing, rage, odd-duck-type, choice of intimate weapon, all resonate as accurate. Unless the police KNOW who the person is and it isn't as meticulous as they are letting on, but they don't have enough actual evidence for conviction.

Fantastic guests Joel! Love the different perspectives on the cases. Always something to learn.

Thank you so much for having these guests on! I have the book The New Evil and Dr Burgess contributed to that book too.

I've only been following true crime on KZfaq for about a year and a half. I just heard of your channel this morning. Glad I found it. Good show and panel. Thank you!

Fantastic panel. Absolutely Fantastic. Thank you for bringing to the public this information.

fantastic show and guests! Thank you for continuing to bring this quality programming

Easily the best info and account I’ve seen on this sad event. Theses folks know what they’re talking about loved the interview.

FABULOUS show with very professional guests who brought interesting areas of expertise to the table. Thank you!

This is an excellent and useful contribution to the ongoing analyses regarding the Idaho tragedy, and is a standard well above most, in my opinion! Thank you 😇

Well, officially I'm completely hooked on your show. This case is beyond heartbreaking 💔. This Evil Creature took the lives of four wonderful human beings who had bright futures. Thank You for mentioning the possibility of my theory I greatly appreciate it.

I love how Anne is smiling the whole time. Sweetheart

GREAT panel! The envy factor lovely Ann mentioned stuck out to me. All the victims are to be envied. And the perp must of had a real thrill in ending their great successful futures. Like, see, so much for your great lives, and I am the one who put an end to it.

Tremendous insight from all your guests, especially the PhD. This was wonderful program.

Please have Ann (legend!) and Gary (so insightful!) back on again. This was an excellent discussion. Thank you. Have subbed.

Thank you for the best minds I've seen/heard so far. Great job!

This is one of the best analysis of the Idaho murders that I’ve seen.

Excellent guests sharing their insightful expertise in a very professional way.

Wow! Fantastic guest. Very informative. First timer here. Thank you for adult conversation with such awesome professionals.

Your videos on this case, with these fascinating experts, are top notch! Keep them coming

This is great. To put a group of pros together, and work through this. Very insightful.

I think Gary nailed it. Fascinating.

This was interesting and worthwhile. Also, ordered both Ann and Gary’s books. Thank you. New subscriber.

I'm watching this on January 6, several days after the arrest of the alleged perpetrator because I wanted to see how accurate you would be. I'm extremely impressed by all four of you and I will definitely be looking each of you up in the future whenever I'm looking for answers that I can have confidence in. Thank you, you definitely have my respect. BTW, I would really like to hear your opinion of Israel Keyes, I think he could have cleared up many murders if that case had been handled better.

What a tremendous panel. Thank you!

And Kaylee was only there for the weekend, she was leaving Sun., she had already moved out. she was just visiting and I think the killer knew that and it was his last chance to get her.

This is 1 of my favorite channels🎉

Last comment… really great panel. Thanks for putting this together. Am enjoying your videos and look forward to more.☮️

I am totally fascinated by the insights of these four individuals- thank you so much for this. You can't get rid of me now...

Sometimes the questions I want to ask are so horrific to imagine that I rather not ask it. I think it's been asked and answered already. Terrible horrific tragedy.

Criminal Profiler Pat Brown here on KZfaq also said that she suspects this should be considered as an individual committing mass murder and more likely a one and done as the gentlemen in the bottom corner stated. Such a crazy case.

This was fascinating - please have this panel on again....thank you.

Great show! You are an excellent interviewer and your guests are top notch!! I'm hooked!

First in my option any time a knife is used, (when it is released) where the wounds were placed and what was done, you are going to feel this was indeed sexual rage. I think we will find out it was not just stab wounds. This was not a random kill, the person that did this was familiar with the weapon, and he knew these girls, and has been watching them and the house.

NEW TO THE CHANNEL.....GREAT PANEL HERE!!!! MAJOR SALUTE!! THIS IS SOOOOOOOO HEART BREAKING....WHOEVER IS RESPONSIBLE FOR THE MURDERS NEEDS TO BE BROUGHT TO JUSTICE!!!!!🙏🙏🙏🙏💜💙💜💙💔💔💔💔💔😨😨😩😩😩🙏🙏🙏🙏

Great show! LOVE hearing from the professionals!!!

Yesss. I’ve said this from the start. I believe this is somebody who feels rejected by society or feels rejected by this particular group of people. I’ve also said that right now he/she is probably watching their P’s and Q’s, however if this turns into a cold case, I think their ego is inflated to where they’ll be able to strike again. Maybe not in Idaho though. Overall it’s horrifying to think about this turning into a cold case. 4 victims who deserve justice. I know law enforcement is doing everything that they can ❤

Hi! I'm fascinated by the man in the lower right corner! He is a brilliant man! I wish he could be hired to work on the case. All of your guests are great. So glad I found you!

I am here on your Channel for the first time and I give a sub. So interesting and giving lot of information from the psychology and profiling point of view with great guests.To this trio of serial killers I would add BTK maybe

Great guest speakers, wonderful information. Thank you.

I’ve rewatched this, it is truly one of the BEST in depth analysis (pre arrest). Would you please schedule the panel when the trial starts. Thank you.

Hi to all, Anne and the FBI guy are just so great could listen to these 2 all day, the fbi guy just flows in conversation on this subject, knowledge is king, thank you all

"I don't think there's any chance this is not a male suspect" It's great when someone just says the truth without waffle.

Really fantastic video. Informative. I learned a lot from these experts and your not just talking your own points which are great but having these experts on who do work in the field of brutal murders is so informative. Thank you, the video is excellent.

TY Joel! As always, a great podcast!!🙋‍♀️

joel you have outdone yourself with this excellent piece

fantastic panel you put together here! I'm very impressed by their knowledge and way of explaining in an easily understandable way. Up until now I was leaning towards a stalker or someone being bullied by one ore several of the victims, as it's also being supported by the overkill on one of the victims. Actually it's a lot more scary to think the murderer didn't target anyone specifically or for a reason one could kind of 'understand'.

Great panel I think we all needed this so many people confused an misinformation out there. I think this will really help get some minds on the right track ..

Thank you Ann Burgess and Gary Brucato ! Heard way too much from Jeff Wood.

These special guests all had really good points to make about this killer in Idaho. From the lights being on or off / wounds on the victims / who was killed 1st. Male suspect without doubt. Great people to have on.

I have always thought it could be envy of the whole group by one person. The four were frequently sharing their shared experiences on Facebook and other social media and they seemed to have this "perfect "joy and happiness together. I think this was the specific characteristic of their group that could have promoted envy and profound hurt in others. It would be awful for any person who might have been or felt "rejected" by this particular group. I'm a group psychoanalyst, UK.

Very very enlightening video, thanks for sharing this information! Makes a lot of sense.

One of the best discussions on motive and possible profile over the past month..👍👍👍

Something I believe overlooked. The killer knew how drunk and passed out these vulnerable souls where. The killer had the upper hand and took advantage.

I love this phd guy. He is so interesting and full of knowledge. Get him back!!

This was all so good. Thank you.

Great panel! Thank you! Interesting info!

Wow! I had not even watched this yet and know it is going to be great!

Kaylee's family is in shock and her dad feels like he needs to do something besides wait for the cops to solve it. They have experienced severe trauma and also have no answers, so they are exhausting themselves trying to solve this crime.

The "I am nothing" and then "I am everything" section is so insightful!

I can personally speak to being absolutely, uncharacteristically, emotionless, hours after a very traumatic event - our son, passed, in a bedroom, only feet from me,with a police guard standing in front of his closed door. The mind does strange things to protect our sanity. I look back on this horrible day and cannot begin to understand how me and my husband were acting so ‘normal’, when we were far from it. Shock does this.

First, great discussion. All panel members had interesting perspectives. Regarding the 911 call, my understanding is one of the girls from the 1st floor came up and saw Ethen dead and ran out of the home and passed out and someone outside of the home walking by saw her, used her phone and called 911. So they were not referring to one of the deceased individuals when they said someone was unconscious.

If he's gotten familiar with the rooms previously I would think he would know about the basement bedroom*Gary's explanation towards the end as to the why with modern violent crime here in the US was absolutely spot on and fascinating imo

Great panel with real professionals... Great show...

Dr Brucato absolutely nailed the profile.

Stunning. Educational. Subscribed.