We know they can sing!!! We did a test at 14:24 - and it's exactly the same as the studio track. 😩 it's just a short clip, but we tested the entire song😂. Anyways, you can watch Pharita sing Believer, her expressions change guys😂 - Anyways, we love BABYMONSTER and can't wait to see what's next!!!

babymonster is definitely that group who gets accused of lipsyncing cuz their voice is so good at live

Pharita is that singer who makes you doubt if she's lipsyncing just because her facial expression doesn't show anything even when she's belting. I doubted it before not until I rewatched her introduction video. That's when she sang while her vocal coach played the piano or looked at her laptop listening to Pharita. I was surprised because she was belting there but her face remained calm neither her shoulders nor her body moved like she needed to grasp some air to breathe deeper for that song. Pharita has mastered this technique!! You might want to rewatch that part. For Chiquita, you'd know she's singing live because you can feel the rawness of her voice. For the other girls, they have soft voices and it seems that it's part of their training not to move a lot? Most YG girls even the sunbaes are like this too. They just want to show emotions through their faces and you can feel there is soul when they sing ballad songs.

That's how great they are, it's almost difficult to believe it's live😂

Parita: A Voice Nurtured by Talent and Support Her passion for music was evident from a young age, as she tackled challenging vocal exercises with unwavering determination. Even before joining YG Entertainment, Parita's family played a crucial role in fostering her singing talent, providing unwavering encouragement and support every step of the way.

Wow, their mics cost US$12,000 each! Their tube microphones, Telefunken ELA M 251E, cost almost the same as a car each. That is why their live vocals are almost the same as the studio version. YG did spend a lot for this live stage performance.

So the point of the reaction is to prove the girls are lipsyncing? That's the impression i got.

Omg so you haven't seen Pharita face when she practiced "Believer" highnote. She didn't do that ugly faces & she just sat without expression. They all practice this for 6 years thats why they are so ready 😂

RAMI'S VOCAL TECHNIQUE IS EVERYTHING 😍😍😍 THAT'S WHY I LOVE HER ❤

you can clearly hear them breathing. you can't pre record the breathing and lipsync the breathing at that exact moment.

What the?? Pharita’s highnote is totally different. The first time I listened to the live stage one, I immediately noticed that it’s a bit shorter than the studio version. If you didn’t hear that then something is probably wrong with your ears. Even the comparison in the end sounds different.

One thing more, YG and these artist wont jeopardize themselves, they each know their capabilities, as you said you already know them and have watched their older videos then that should have convince you that their singing lives, you can literally see and hear them breathing, I have watched all your reactions to babymonster and you always doubt on pharita's high notes, you might have forgoten her video singing Believer With that high pitch of her while sitting and having a poker face as if shes singing it in a low tone haha

The microphones are hot. Which means they are on. What they do is lower the back up tape but leave the music and everything else on. The only way you can hear just the voice is if they sing it acapella and YG will never do that! These girls have been singing this song so much that it’s going to sound exactly like M/V every time! Even in concerts the back track will always be playing!

You same “it’s the same” I say they’re fricken CONSISTENT.

I guess yg need to release acapella version just to satisfy everyone. Hard to be a singer nowadays.

Why are you wondering if it sounds the same in the music video when, in the first place, the original singer is the one doing it? I guess there's nothing to be shocked about because it's them, nothing else.

They're so talented, you can't tell if they are singing live.

BRO!! ALL YG ARTIST IS SOUNDED LIKE ORIGINAL VERSION, YOU'RE EARS HAVE PROBLEM THEN!

Pity guys, Pharita face never gets ugly when she goes for high notes. You should study what you dare to critique. A bit checking out her performance from her past and you won’t humiliated yourself. Now You guys so fck! lol

You just didn't notice many of their articulations here and there, it's obvious that it's live 😮

It's live. Pharita's big note, the first part at least, was shorter than the MV and Special Stage. Don't be deceived by how effortless she makes it sound. The harmonies are on the backing track but the ad-libs are live. Why are you fixated on this. Why can't you just enjoy this beautiful song.

Why people think they have to do crazy faces for live vocals and high notes. Soon they´re gonna sing everywhere live.

u need to see pharita hitting the highnotes of "BELIEVER" then u can tell

That’s how good they are. Lol

Nah yg never lipsync...even when their idols are sick they would not lipsync..they put pride on singing real live cause they value the support they get from their fans...watch pharita inroduction again and you will see how effortlessly she sang that high note when she was with their vocal couch inside their practice room. And watch their behind the scene,they practice while fixing their make up and they sound exactly the same just raw.. Whenever i watch kpop sing i do not only focus on their voices but also on their mouth and their faces. Thats how i can tell if its live or not. I can easily tell if someone is faking everything. And this is live. Their facial movements,their mouth, the way they delivered theie notes...its live

go watch behind the scene , don’t talk much and don’t complain much . like wtf ? lipsync ?? 😂

This channel is so funny. You guys probably won't believe they ate CDs. Please reacts to their Live performance.😂😂😂

Actually Pharita's high note is shorter this time if you noticed. Maybe you should search the mr removed version 😅

Its live. Go back to their pre debut final evaluation. Of course there is a post production but its hard to believe they doin it love since they are soo goood😊

welcome to another episode of "is it liiive?" LMAO

these 2 are VCHA fanboys.. VCHA is not even near Babymonster skill/talent..that'ss why they are hating..

Havent you notice how YG is good in live shows and festivals compared when other artist attends festival? Aside from having undeniable stage pressence they are even better in singing and performing live

YOU ARE NOT EVEN PROFESSIONAL TO KNOW THAT

If you really want to check then you need to take the audio tracks and place them over each other. The one thing that I remember when working with audio is that our memories for it is deceiving. We think that we hear it one way when it really isn't the case. Studio recording they usually try to reduce the inhales. So in the live I would say that if you hear a inhale and it matches the mouth and the body then it is most likely to be live.The M/V and the Special Stage with Rami's flip after the key change is different where you can see her put emphasis on the low note in the Special Stage which is the reason that it stood out more in it. Also, the mix of the voices were better in the Special Stage. But yeah, sound is a difficult one since there is a lot of variables that can change the sound in our ears.

As the name of the video says, it's live stage And if you want to see the live stage You should go see them at a concert or music show 🙂😌

Lol, too good to be true??? Go watch them singing without mics, hahaha. Check them out for real. Funny to doubt pharita highnote, she's effortlessly hit the highnote just by practising with her vocal coach. I can not

U guys are delusional, it doesn’t sound the same like the original, i have perfect pitch and i know what am saying. These girls can sing exactly as the studio version, its their talent and yall have to accept it.

I hope you realise by now when Baby Monster sings live. It is live. Go watch It's live channel. They just performed Sheesh with a live band on a independent channel to show haters or deaf people there is no trickery in Baby Monsters singing. You can hear CD quality live vocals.

This performance was live, listen to both the special stage and there are vibratos place in different places especially in chiquitas parts

You might have forgoten when pharita was singing Believer she was siting as if she was just normally singing when the part she was singing was already high, her face is still normal kzfaq.info/get/bejne/hduRdJebvqupfIU.htmlsi=zCjBH-alwfJht0D8

You guys are hilarious 😂😂😂 Question every single thing to the brimmed rather then listening a solid beautiful piece performed live by 6 unique different vocalist blended harmony perfectly. Thanks for the questions more then reaction share..10/10 so so cool 😎

Hey bro, why are you talking so serious about topic live or not, just enjoy this girl's extraordinary vocals, music and performance. relax guys

Is it just me that I see this as HUGE COMPLIMENT??? hahaha

Watch the special stage of stuck in the middle just for u to stop doubting hahaha.

You can tell already at first, when chiquita sing that it's live.. Always remember YG artist are more sounds good in live..

Kita sudah tengok live performance mereka sebelum debut lagi. Ya, vocal live mereka tidak dapat dinafikan. Mereka yang tidak menonton live performance solo mereka mungkin berfikir yang live stage SITM seperti lipsync

I think i get what these guys are talking about. They know baemon can sing, they know they're singing live, but they just want to hear them differently (from the actual song). For them (as they are used to jyp idols) singing exactly as good as recording is not the big deal. They needed MORE, to push their vocal more than recording, like to give more spices to it while singing live. So it doesn't sound exactly the same. You know, like when some divas do parts of their song a bit extra and it sounded better? Like that. But again, with spices or no spices during live, baemon is still a genuine gem. Unbeatable vocal lines.

YG has been known for their live performances. This is YG. No one should be lipsync. That is their rule. Please click on the link below where the YG talent manager does not approve anybody who is doing lipsync. They sound exactly the same as the audio. That's why people always said, "YG artists ate CDs". Babymonster doesn't have the opportunity to go to concerts or music shows yet. Please watch their survival shows if you guys still wondering whether the girls sing live or not. They just sound the same. You can hear their breath while they are singing. Link: kzfaq.info/get/bejne/f5yebMKpuMXGl5s.html

Lol you just jumped on the hate train...yes they are that good live

Queen Pharita ❤❤❤

You guys are so funny 🤣🤣🤣 I bet if they sing right infront of you guys,you both still be questioning " are they singing live?" 😂😂😂 Thanks for sharing your personal own opinions,stay positive in life ❤❤❤

Dreamcatcher 🤩🤘🤘🎤🎵🎶🎸

the 3 versions are not the same. Most distinct is at the end of ASA's lines the way she pronounces " my love".

You are entitled to your opinions, even though you wear $50- $1500 headphones, if you don’t believe it’s live, you won’t believe at all, nobody will ever convince you even this singers will tell you, they cannot please everyone, next time request for an acapella, so you can judge them that they are out of tune. You will not win in social media.

I appreciate your investigation guys❤👌🏼☺. I Love the BabyMonster "THE PRINCESSES"❤👸. The Funny fact about BabyMonster since they are vocally talented and trained they are the group along the way of their career that many people will accuse them always that they lip singing when they sing their song in live performance😅.Because of their well sounded vocals.But I also pray that they do not do lip singing in the future and hopefully YG let BabyMonster be vulnerable for them to be strong and for them to learn how to face criticism of the public specially in this industry. Much love to your channel and God Bless to both of you❤🙏🏼.

It guess the reason why it seems debatable is because they followed the rehearsed melody instead of experimenting with the notes, possibly bc they are too young still. They are singing live, but there’s potential audio edits.

I think we need them to immediately debute n come to a lot of 3rd party channel such as it's live, dingomusic, 360° sound bomb etc, and singing this song 😂

Funfacts : If we look at Pharita's introduction video or their live performance at the last evaluation yesterday, when he takes a high note, his facial expression is not excessive, he really looks relaxed when he takes a high note.

top 2 weird pharse, 'sing same like studio version' and 'the mic is expensive'

Guys, go and take a look their special stage behind the scene, the answer is there, they’re singing live, I know is too good to believe. Actually from Chiquita part you will know is live, very obvious.

I want you guys to watch last evaluation and their introduction their vocals then you will get their vocals are crazy that you can't find any difference

Guys, I loved your earlier reactions on Babymonster, but not this one. During your early reactions when you don't know much about BM, I really enjoy to see your genuine enthusiasm and reactions. However, in this reaction, you have lost those emotions and become a critic - okay, but criticising using the negative comments written all over the internet and scripted it in this reaction is not okay. Probably you have reacted on too many mvs to come to the conclusion that live singing = out of tune singing. You become doubtful whether it is live or not when it sounded too good to be true. Well, I'm going to give another try on your next BM reaction. If you guys have truly lost that enthusiasm, sorry to say sayonara then. Until your next BM reaction .....

This is live, whats your problem in your ears bro, I'm not musician, but i know the different. The microphone is the answer

Not sure if you have listened to this without a bias view.... Seems that you don't know that Pharita can sing like that live. Here check out this striped down song with only vocals.... Link: kzfaq.info/get/bejne/rp-el9CctJnNkYU.htmlsi=55Ntw84QdnaAaex_ Anyway, I'll give the benefit of the doubt. They are just that stable, and constant. Yes the playback has some ad-libs, back vocals, but Rami does most of them here live too. Take care

How anybody can’t tell that this is live with post production is beyond comprehension.

listen to their MR. and you will know it's live.

THEY ARE THAT GOOD

You can tell it's live for sure because you can hear Ruka's cute lisp!

YG will never copy any label. Say what you want but if it ain’t broken don’t fix it! You want YG to change what makes them YG? YG would burn their business to the ground before changing The formula that has made them who they are!

I am not a professional and I can hear live vocals. About pharita expression, i watched their documentary and that was how she was singing with no expression (it was live practice with her teacher, now way it was auto tuned or edited or even lypsincing) I asked my professional friend who worked at studio. He said this is live, with added effect to them (backing vocal) not the orginal voice (you can hear the breath and all). The end part of the song is live live with harmony. That what he said. If you guys still dont catch that, i think you need to stop reacting to baby monster bcs it seems like you dont like what they or YG doing most of the time 😅

The way to get them to believe is by singing badly and hoarsely😅😅😅

Try to listen to their pre debut cover songs if they're lyp singing brooo especially to pharita

They can definitely sing, but this sounds like it was post-processed after they sung it live. I think most Korean companies that post live clips do it.

I think it's live, but we can't see their expressions in the live singing video because the camera shots are always changing and have been edited a lot. But for the voice and how they sing it is live.

Thanks for sharing your thoughts

Sesusah itu kalian mengakui bahwa mereka bernyanyi "live"? Comeon, !!!

Lol those telling its lipsyching were haters obviously. YGAs are known for LIVE SINGING, they are all CDs eating.

If you are looking for live then watch all of those individual evaluation videos then. lol

The problem is the post-production. They were probably singing live, but the audio is too perfect. You can hear some notes should have been out of tune, but they weren't. Also, they probably spent a day recording this several times and used the best "video" moments (which could have been lipsync) with the best "audio" moments, so the audio doesn't match the video completely. And since it has been edited later, especially volume and tunning, you get these "LIVE" videos that aren't really LIVE.

No wonder you have this observation with Parita. Because her face was very calm even though she used a very powerful voice. But if you follow and watch "Every tape, really." She really had a calm expression on her face from the first tape. She worked very hard and the result is that she has a very solid voice. There's a behind-the-scenes video from the MV shoot where everyone dresses up and practices singing without music. .The funny thing is that it sounds exactly like it did in the studio.

watch its live babymonster sheesh

This is the only reaction where I don't see reacting to Rami's vocal. I was watching many reactions.

I said the same on other vids about the “special stage” it just sounds like an edited version of the song. And when you look at them it doesn’t look like they are really singing. Love babymonster and love this song. But I think maybe they sing little bits here or there “live” the rest is just the original song with a few tweaks.

BM live sounds so perfect made people think it's not live....😂

DON'T EVER, EVER DOUBT YG ARTISTS' LIVE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

If you don't believe it, then DON'T. As simple as that. What's the point of going back and forth, questioning everything? 😂

Bro they sing live ❤❤

Dude, now you're trying to do censorious work rather than enjoy their singing performance. 😅 But, anyway, I still respect your thoughts and enjoy your reactions. 😊 Kind of brain stroming. 😂 I'm feeling sure that what the cooking stage you guys want will happen after mini album release. Be patience for a while. 😆😁 . RORA part before ASA coming, she was singing softer than audio/MV, and the backing harmony was a pre-recorded backing track. You can compare it with the first stage as well. But I have no idea about whose voice belong to the pre-recorded harmonies. I guess it was RORA and CHIQUITA together. PHARITA is one of the most stable singer of this group, apart from RAMI, and she can belt powerful high note without face change. Most of adlips with riffs and runs were sung by RAMI, and she is one of the best in voice control, apart from AHYEON and RORA. The comparison from spotify and YT version, Pharita's high note ending in live stage was differently tipping up a little, and a bit longer. . I personally noticed some imperfections in this show and believe YG won't do suicidal action by allow Babymonster perform a lying live performance, too. 😉

Exactly ! Let them sing SING !! They have no problem to sing in live for sure, they need a real stage and sing in front of their fans and stadium. Great video tho ! Good analysis by the Pro.

Its live, but its processed obviously. Pharita belting its in her comfortable range, thats why she is not making crazy faces, when the singer is making crazy faces and the veins are exploding on the neck, they are just forcing something without the proper technique. Pharita's belts here are not that high and is going down on notes plus seems high because its stylezed. The majority of harmonies are backing track, only Rami adlibs are live in that sense.

the reason why pharitas facial expression doesn’t change is because her vocal technique doesn’t strain, causing no facial articulation to show.

nobody can sing perfectly on LIVE STAGE. if its sound too similiar like recording its means 3, either too much pitch corretion, or they lipsync , or they just a robot not human. I really admire with their pre debut

They dont sound like studio version. The studio version sounded like THEM

You guys can hear live watch the behind the scene video its 100% live with no mics and backround music

Come on Guys! They're not singing to demonstrate you that they're singing live. If you want A capella song from them just paid for it in your personal concert and stop pausing every verse to ask yourselves It is live? Soo boring. By the way, this time I won't leave my like of support for your channel.

It is a 100% live. Check their MR removed version and then you will see their true live voices.

Pharita cn hit highnote without making faces lol especially when her vocal tone was made for that note

Its probably them singing live with studio version over top.

PRE-RECORDED ???

Pharita high note was a bot shorter than the recodrding she sang live she can do highnotes with little to no expressions if u saw when she sang believer