I got to say, out of all of the videos I made for the past couple years, this is my favorite one to make yet. I hope you guys enjoyed watching it because if you do, I’ll gladly make more videos where I look into more old theories of Amphibia, and maybe other shows too.

I remember the Anne losing an arm, Sasha losing an eye, and Marcy becoming paralyzed theories

There was a theory that the person who took the calamity box was sprigs mom

I had a theory that Sasha would befriend Ivy, since Anne became friends with Sprig and Marcy befriended Maddie, and when the girls left Amphibia, the Calamity powers would be passed down to Sprig (Blue), Ivy (Red), and Maddie (Green).

I do fondly remember the Anne losing her arm theory too well. Because I ended up getting bombarded with discussions about it when I first got into Amphibia & the fandom. I figured it wouldn't happen, but then when Grime lost his arm I was like "Well. You were half right Amphibia fans."

I mean Anne's whole body disintegrated, so...in a way she DID lose an arm. It was along with everything else, but still...

Honestly, a lot of the theories on Marcy's personality DID end up being true, just not overtly so. Marcy is actually just as manipulative as Sasha, given the whole Calamity Box situation. She also genuinely seems to view others as like, NPCs in a video game or things she can use to make herself feel better. This doesn't make her a bad character, and she grows by the end, but the fandom tends to think of her as the one member of the trio that never did anything bad and that is FAR from the truth.

Actually if I'm not wrong the original plan for Marcy WAS to be worst then Sasha. Indeed her character in S1 looks like a total different person

Ahh, Ghost Marcy AU, those were the days… still could’ve given us more Sasharcy moments in some crazy way.

I hope Matt is working on a movie cause honestly I’d love to see the girls and wartwood reunited one last time

yes, sasha loosing an eye, anne loosing an arm, i was a firm believer of these 😂

Yeah I still freshly remember the whole Anne lose an arm and Sasha loses an eye theories.

All that theorycrafting was one of the most interesting parts of the fandom. I remember another two, one about short-haired Sasha in season 3b and another about Marcy's memories being deleted at the end of "The Core and the King". Also the theory about Anne losing her arm was technically true but we didn't expect for her lose not only the arm but her entire body...

Honestly surprised you didn't cover the theory of Hop Pop dying. That had a REALLY strong following during the show, too.

Back when I watched Reunion for the 1st time, I seriously thought Sasha might’ve died. Looking back, this made no sense for her character; but I remember being so relieved when we saw her again in season 2.

Here are a couple of theories I had for the finale prior to it airing:

I remember when the show first started when everyone online though that Grime was gonna be the show's main villan

Great video I remember them well.

Not much of a theory but a lot of people expected Sasha to cut her hair in season 3A! Sasha with really short hair is a big thing in Amphibia animatics and fanart from that time

A theory I remember hearing was also quite crazy in hindsight and was basically about how Grime was actually a zombie this whole time. This theory was around the time Maddie and Marcy came out, with the whole reviving spell thing. Basically, we know that Grime was a gladiator before becoming Chief of the Toad Army and it's possible that he lost his eye in a gladiator battle back then. Some people think that another time (or that same time) he also lost his life, until someone revived him with the spell, hence his green glowing eye, like we saw in Maddie and Marcy. Now, this theory was not confirmed, but considering that there might be a graphic novel it seems, maybe it might get confirmed there. If Valeriana being a ghost was confirmed in a Post-Hoot as a sneak peek of Marcy's Journal, then Grime being a zombie can be confirmed by outside media too