Damn she was in a mood!!! The Plaintiff handled himself very well 👏🏼

I admire the plaintiff’s patience 🙏🙌

Its weird that only Douglas is in the court room with 3 monitors 😂

idk considering how many times shes said "You only have to prove that it was more likely than not" you'd think the plaintiff would have been awarded for damages. considering that the place was so bad it was literally deemed uninhabitable, it wouldn't be a stretch to assume any mattresses in there would get damaged.

She kills me interrupting the litigants as they are trying to finish a sentence.

It irks me when she always ask them questions and then will rudely interrupt them and say please stop talking but gets mad when they start talking while she has interrupted them

I don’t agree with the way that JM seemed to be dismissing and diminishing the plaintiff’s experience. She keeps saying *”You got to live there rent-free”* but she’s ignoring the fact that the man says he had bedbugs, roaches, heating issues, water issues, etc. Would SHE consider living anywhere under those circumstances to be fully compensable by not paying rent, and therefore, she need not complain? Also, if the place was actually found to have bedbugs, then *of course* he would have gotten rid of some items…I know I would have, and since he didn’t have proof of the actual amount of loss, she should’ve done a bit of a that “rough justice”, and awarded him *something!* Preponderance of evidence? 🤷🏽‍♀️

JM was having a really bad day. Living in a place for 3 months with no heat and no cold water is ridiculous. He was willing to pay her as long as she fixed the issues. He wasn't getting over on anyone. And the judge should know plenty about bedbugs and how hard it is to get rid of them. I wouldn't have taken the furniture either. She was just upset about something else and showed her emotions through this case.

This was weird the judge was annoying. She kept cutting him off and was just so rude. Landlord was a slumlord

Smh 😔 so disappointed with the judge for the way he handle this. The guy had a video of the flees like wtf if the previous judge deemed it uninhabitable then how tf you don't think that his stuff will be ruined.

I'd bet anyone 100$ that Judge Milian wouldn't dare leave her mattress in that apartment overnight yet she said this plaintiff had no proof for damages lol.

Judge Milan is incredible rude and loud for no reason. I guess she thinks she's talking to her kids

The disgusting defendant literally had that man living in a rundown barely habitable shack because she knew it was what he could afford. She didn’t care about anything, and the judge clearly found the place uninhabitable. The Plaintiff should’ve got the security, but also the fees. Milian can be so tight on the People’s Court wallet sometimes. Also, they really need to get back into the courtroom. They can barely hear each other and the delay makes it hard for them to communicate without talking over each other. That’s getting annoying quickly, not just to them, but also to us watching them interrupt each other.

Why was she being so rude to the plaintiff. It seems like she just didn’t like him.

her first question to him " when did you stop paying rent" .. she's never asked that as a first question. she started off rude. I wonder why

Can’t wait for everyone to be back in the courtroom!

The judge is so disrespectful to the plaintiff, she accuses him of talking over her, but in fact she keeps shouting over him, and where does she get off accusing him of living there 'rent free' when the place was infested and considered 'uninhabitable by the courts. And it goes without saying that when a place is 'infested' you throw all bedding away, would the judge use her same bedding after it has been infested. I'm sure if the plaintiff had been a different colour she might have been more understanding and awarded him damages...

The judge was extra rude in this case.

I'll say this for every one of these COVID episodes......poor Douglas is all alone 🥺

These virtual shows are annoying. She acts like she doesn’t know there’s a lag and she doesn’t stop interrupting.

They really need to get back to doing the cases live. Trying to do them over video-conference creates a delay, and issues with communication. They’re talking over each other, not knowing when to stop, and not knowing when to answer because of the delay from the webcam and the fact that they aren’t in the same and can’t see other live. I mean it’s cool, but it’s kinda contributing to making the communication messy and more abrasive than it needs to be.

The plaintiff is a youth development specialist in Syracuse NY. He was on the show another time. I think it was regarding a used car sale. I remember him, but not the case. It will come to me. In this case, Marilyn was very rude to him. No surprise there.

Everyone is mad at the judge for not awarding the case to the Plaintiff; but he had no physical proof of the damages to his furniture Edit: and the judge explained all the way at the end that because the guy wasn't paying rent while still living in the gross apartment - THAT'S his compensation

Strange format 3 tv screens talking to each other in an empty room except for Douglas 😮

I see many comments slamming the judge for not letting the litigants finish sentences...come on now, the judge is asking direct questions and the litigants keep talking like they don't hear her....is it a technical issue or just both of them trying to lay out as much information even though the judge doesn't need to hear it?

Glad the plaintiff won !!!

She's constantly being rude and disrespectful to only certain people and it's just ridiculous! She cuts people off and does not listen! JM used to be a good Judge!🤦🏾‍♀️🤔

The defendant PURPOSELY tried to deceive the court but Milian had more smoke for the plaintiff. 😐

The plaintiff was so patient with the judge. She is so ridiculously rude

Plaintiff says that he had to have someone at his place 24/7 because there were no locks. Then he said the handyman felt uncomfortable working at his apartment when no one was there. What happened to whoever was sitting there in place of installing a lock?

Cannot stop laughing 😆😅🤣😂🤣🤣🤣this landlord-woman looks like she is wearing a hat with ears 🐰

That's why i always ask about bug's before moving in even if the place had bugs year's before but clean now i still wouldn't move in I have a huge phobia to roaches and don't take any chances once they're in those walls they're there forever no matter how many times you exterminate

If a judge asks what time is it, don't tell the judge how to fix a clock.

That house definitely ain't worth 1200 WTF

Since he didn't technically sue for his stuff he probably still can.

These zoom cases frustrate me. Not because of quality of the video or anything like that. Thank u for the uploads. Over the computer there can be a delay. So it may take the plantiff and defendant an extra second to even hear a question or hear that the judge started talking. Then she is telling them to stop talking. Then just a bunch of her yelling stop talking and them still talking

Unfortunately all too common too have flawed crazy and greedy landlords.Out of seven landlords lve had in my lifetime only two were decent people.

Never complained before about the judge being rude as I normally like her feistiness, but she wouldn't let the guy finish a sentence!!

He was so sweet, patient and respectful the judge must’ve been dealing with menopause that day she was rude as hell for no reason at all I mean damn

She can't shut off the Heat period! Whether he legitimately had rent in Escrow or was just not paying

JM wasn't "meaner" to the plaintiff any more than the defendant. She wasn't on her period, y'all. 🙄 She just hungry. Bet this case was right before lunch.

It's wild to me she states he was ordered out by a judge. He was *allowed* out because it was uninhabitable. They were both annoying with how they wanted to stick to their stories instead of just answering questions, but judge really didn't handle this properly imo. She was pretty rude. I don't understand why she wouldn't award him for his things, either. Bedbugs alone are a nightmare to get rid of, plus fleas?? Some people throw away all of their furniture after dealing with bedbugs for a while.

GREEDY LADY, TRYING TO SNEAK AND GET MONEY ANY WAY 😂😂😂😂

Why are the interviewer guys at the end always trying to throw shade? 😂

Neither one of these people could answer a straight question. Every answer he gave started off with "ok so" and then he proceeds to give her more background instead of answering. The defendant was no better, she kept just trying to get her story out as well instead of answering.

I thought he had to have someone there 24/7! So why would no one be there for the repair man?

Wow this was stressful

He literally could have moved with the rent he withheld he didn't have to stay in an infested unit.

So if an adult chooses to live somewhere that not habitable they don't have to pay what they agreed to?? That's not right. They should get 5 days to get out or pay rent.

Judge MM was very frustrated. BUT, I get it...Most times, either party will NOT answer the question asked. They give an entire dissertation without answering the question.

JM’s head bow 😂

Not me trying to figure out his Funko pops 😅

If it was infestation why wouldn’t he get damages for furniture sorry but JM was extremely rude to the plaintiff!

you can’t hold rent ransom for ANY reason.

I live for this show LOL

The uneven scale in AFTER THE VERDICT still annoys me!

I feel that the judge was racist in how she treated the plaintiff. No one else will say it but I will. She had no excuse repeatedly interrupting and yelling. In addition, she has done enough of these cases that even given she is privileged she should know by now that bed bugs ruin mattresses. Very disappointed in her.

JM is annoying I can’t with her, he should of went to Judge Mathis.

If the renter/court says a place is uninhabitable then the tenant should have to be out in 5 days. Not a month or more. If it was so bad why did he not move immediately???? No he didn't pay rent for 6 months and that's ok? No. She should have gotten rent since he stayed and lived there. Ridiculous tenants know what and how to play the system

They both are liars. One big hole in the plaintiff's testimony.... How did he testify first thing saying that the place had no locks and that he had to have someone there 24/7, then he used the excuse that the handyman was unable to fix anything because "he's a working man" and no one was there to let the handyman in everytime he came by..... uuuuhhhh, which one is it??

SRB you can't afford to live / that simple / here come a car

That shade of brown looks good on you Judge MILIAN 👍🏾

Then move out... I dislike people like the plaintiff; if it's that horrible then leave... She's not forcing you to stay!

the judge has been so rude lately .. it’s not fun to watch when she’s just being unnecessarily rude.

Is she wearing a Santa cap?

Not sure if it's the computers or the people, but they need a new format bc this is exhausting to watch.

Disorganized woman! Annoying tenant!

This guy is the problem he is the reason why he is the definition

I hate this new format!! It was already bad with the litigants on the screens but I got used to it. Now Milian is on the screen?? She broke her foot so wonder if that’s why

Now if he REALLY didn't have heat.....you'd think he'd let them in immediately... Since he lives in Syracuse

Wow this seemed so out of character for the judge she's usually right on

Can Douglas share his anti-aging secrets? 😀

Does defendant have a head wound or is that a fashion choice?

It maybe time for JM to retire. Her nerves are getting bad. I can’t watch the show hardly

He answered the picture issue 3 times.

Crazy door 99

Now he just said he has to have someone there 24 hours a day so strangers can’t get into the house but when the maintenance people came he was working lol What happened to the 24 hour person?

I don’t think they’re purposely talking over each other. There may be a delay because it’s all video

The place looked like a dump.

"that's a problem for you and that's why u lost your case." this shade is called "no shame shade." it's obvious and in yo face like a late 80s tyson uppercut.

He sounds like wah wah wah wah like Charlie brown teacher😴

dude learn to shut up. i hate people that have to keep talking. this is why i like in person court.

Yall forget roaches are common pests depending where you live, it doesnt make it inhabitable or slummy.. #1 , #2 bedbugs can legit come from anywhere places like NYC have them even in bougie hotels, too many damn buildings and ppl in one area i guess. So you can’t claim damages on that.

I don’t feel like she being rude JM is asking specific question and they information dump instead of answering the direct question at hand

Hex yeah zoom court!!!

When someone asks you a question, just give them the answer and ONLY the answer. The plaintiff tries to complain about something and then talks about 4 or 5 unrelated things. She's trying to drive the train in a straight line and doesn't need to be clouded with a bunch of useless information. She'll get to it when she gets to it

What is on the defendants head?

No biggie, she gets to keep his money and the show pays the judgement. TV justice!

This should be interesting 🧐

Crazy money 91

Why does she ask questions and interrupt answers within 2 seconds? If I wanted to watch this, I'd watch Judy (The best in the interruption biz).

🙄 The judge deemed he didn’t have to pay rent so why are you upset.

Good ruling for the plantiff. Justice was served in this case.

Oy! Another litigant who uses only pronouns. "On eleven nineteen he went to his house but he would not let him in." People don't seem to have names to such litigants.

Hmm well he's getting the 800 and I get she would've given him the 400 if he had photos or sum kind of proof of wat was damaged. Reading these comments fig it'd have been her going off on him but. Really just seemed like her being her and was trying to get to the point only time she really got upset was when he was over talking her. And she even said he kept his money he would've spent on rent so yeah I understand her judgement on that.

It’s SOOOOOOO annoying when people don’t listen to Judge Millian. Just shut up for a second and listen to her question 🤦🏻‍♂️🤦🏻‍♂️🤦🏻‍♂️

Gentle boy 73

The case of chatter box vs clueless

WOW! IF i ever stopped paying rent, i'd sure remember when i stopped paying it!! That vid was WAY too fast. I didn't see any fleas there! WOW! if i ended up in landlord tenant court, i'd sure remember THAT day as well

Топ